CS Paper Radar

When Does Predictor-Based RL Align with Human Perception? A Study of Subjective Rewards in Codec-Based Speech Language Models

Joonyong Park, Jerry Li

cs.CL cs.SDeess.AS ·submitted 2026-08-31 16:14 UTC · v1

Abstract

Codec-based text-to-speech (TTS) models make language-model post-training applicable to speech generation, but it remains unclear when learned perceptual predictors can serve as reinforcement learning rewards without losing alignment with human listeners. We study this question with Group Relative Policy Optimization (GRPO) using learned rewards for anime-like speaking style, naturalness, likability, and arousal. To prevent perceptual rewards from being optimized through transcript drift, we introduce a character error rate (CER) zone constraint and compare policy optimization with Best-of-$N$ reranking under the same reward gate. Across single-reward runs, each reward primarily improves its own target metric, showing that subjective predictors are not interchangeable quality surrogates. Multi-rater A/B tests further show uneven human transfer, while a reward-gap analysis separates average transfer from within-axis calibration: signed reward gaps significantly predict listener choices in the pooled analysis, whereas residual CER gaps do not, but per-axis calibration remains heterogeneous. Best-of-8 is a strong human-level baseline and is not clearly worse than GRPO perceptually, suggesting that GRPO should be viewed as amortizing reward-selected behavior into the policy rather than uniformly outperforming reranking. These results support analyzing subjective speech rewards as predictor-axis-base tuples and provide practical diagnostics for selecting rewards before multi-reward speech post-training.

Comment
Submitted to EMNLP 2026

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Pronunciation-Oriented Reinforcement Learning for Japanese Text-to-Speech with Kana-Domain ASR Rewards

cs.SD eess.AS ·2026-10-06 ·Shiao Zhu, Lianbo Liu, Kai Washizaki, Koki Nikaido, Yui Sudo
similarity 0.69
Abstract

Character error rate (CER) computed by automatic speech recognition (ASR) is widely used as an intelligibility reward for reinforcement learning (RL) post-training of text-to-speech (TTS) systems. For Japanese, however, orthographic CER introduces a representation mismatch for pronunciation-oriented optimization: distinct kanji readings may collapse to the same orthographic representation, while equivalent pronunciations may admit different orthographic forms. We instead compute CER in the kana domain using a kana-transcribing ASR model and reference readings (Kana-CER). Under matched group relative policy optimization (GRPO) conditions, Kana-CER reduces target-kanji reading error by approximately 26% relative to the orthographic CER reward, while maintaining comparable orthographic CER and similar speaker similarity and objective speech quality. It also reaches its best validation performance in substantially fewer optimization steps (4k vs. 18k). We further observe severe output elongation under unregularized Kana-CER optimization, which is substantially suppressed by KL regularization.

0.25

LoCA: Local Credit Assignment for Reinforcement Learning of Autoregressive Flow-Matching TTS

cs.SD ·2026-10-20 ·Jie Liu, Junyu Zhou, Junhao Zhong, WeiSen Tang, Rukai Cai +3 more
similarity 0.68
Abstract

Reinforcement learning can improve text-to-speech synthesis through feedback on generated speech. However, sentence-level rewards do not identify local errors, while signed regression updates can lead to excessive fitting or repulsion of sampled outputs. We propose LoCA (Local Credit Assignment) for autoregressive flow-matching text-to-speech. LoCA uses ASR-based text alignment to locate content errors in generated speech and redistribute sentence-level advantages across acoustic frames. To improve training stability, we introduce reference-relative positive and negative thresholds that limit continued fitting and repulsion. Experiments on VoxCPM2 show that LoCA reduces sample-weighted content error on a multilingual CV3 evaluation subset by 20.5% and 14.3% relative to the pretrained backbone and GROW, respectively, while improving speaker similarity. LoCA also improves content accuracy on the Seed-TTS-Eval hard subset. Ablation results support the contributions of local credit and threshold-based regression control.

0.10

Grounded in Sound: Reinforcement Learning with a Frozen Acoustic Judge to Curb ASR Insertion Hallucinations

cs.SD cs.MMeess.AS ·2026-09-13 ·Tingzhen Xiong, Rilin Chen, Weiwei Li, Wentao Zhang, Qicong Xie
similarity 0.67
Abstract · Accepted to IEEE Spoken Language Technology Workshop (SLT) 2026

When reinforcement learning (RL) is used for post-training automatic speech recognition (ASR), the reward almost always lives in the text space: it compares a hypothesis with the reference and never checks whether the hypothesis is supported by the audio. On highly regular speech this licenses a shortcut - guessing from a strong language prior rather than listening. Once the acoustics degrade, the shortcut runs unchecked and emits fluent but ungrounded words, i.e., insertion errors. We propose an acoustic-fidelity reward: a GRPO reward augmented with a separately pretrained, permanently frozen, non-autoregressive character-level wav2vec2-CTC acoustic judge, used strictly at training and absent at inference, where a single model decodes greedily. Trained on LibriSpeech and evaluated across a six-tier difficulty gradient including real AMI meeting speech (33,282 utterance-condition instances), the method reduces insertion errors by 28.3% on close-talking AMI-IHM and 22.3% on far-field AMI-SDM, while lowering WER on AMI-SDM from 35.89% to 34.71% and showing no detectable WER difference on the other five tiers, against a schedule-matched WER-GRPO baseline. The insertion reduction holds under a meeting-level clustered bootstrap. Four prespecified analyses support content-conditioned insertion calibration: output collapses 85-90% on unintelligible audio that preserves energy and voice activity; the gain is not recovered by the evaluated 32-best CTC rescoring configuration, yet RL internalizes it into a single greedy decoding run; and policy-only confidence yields lower insertion-AURC in all four evaluated settings. We frame this as a mechanism paper, demonstrated in one instantiation: a 7B speech LLM with a 0.3B CTC judge.

0.56

Beyond Speech Captions: Speech-Rewarded Style Planning for Conversational Text-to-Speech

cs.SD cs.CLeess.AS ·2026-10-08 ·Shiao Zhu, Lianbo Liu, Sizhen Lyu, Yuzhe Wang, Sheng Li +1 more
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Natural-language style descriptions provide an interpretable interface between large language models (LLMs) and controllable text-to-speech (TTS). However, using descriptions as pseudo-labels compresses target acoustics into text, and descriptive fidelity need not imply effective control of a particular synthesizer. We empirically show that speech-text alignment only weakly predicts downstream acoustic similarity among candidate instructions for the same utterance. We therefore propose Speech-Rewarded Style Planning (SRSP), which trains a text-based style planner through a frozen downstream TTS model. Given dialogue history and response text, the planner generates candidate instructions and is optimized with group-relative policy optimization (GRPO), using the teacher-forced likelihood of target speech tokens as the reward. On an English subset of the ISCSLP 2026 CoT-TTS corpus, SRSP achieves higher speech-style and emotion similarity to target speech and lower mel-cepstral distortion than the Base LLM and target-audio-informed captioning baselines. LLM-based expressive speech evaluation further shows gains over all baselines in contextual appropriateness and reference consistency.

0.08

EmphTTS: an emphasis-control TTS with reinforcement learning

eess.AS cs.CL ·2026-09-23 ·Zirui Li, Rech Silas, Lauri Juvela, Tom Backstrom, Mikko Kurimo
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 5 pages. Submitted to ICASSP 2027

Generating controllable and human-like emphasis remains an open challenge in text-to-speech, even when explicit emphasis control signals are provided in the text input, limiting the communicative accuracy of synthetic speech in real-world applications. Reinforcement learning has recently shown promise for post-training TTS systems to align with human preference, yet existing methods have not been applied to word-level prosodic control. We present EmphTTS, a non-autoregressive TTS system that applies Group Relative Policy Optimization (GRPO) to the duration predictor with an emphasis localization reward, enabling direct optimization for word-level emphasis. Evaluations show that EmphTTS achieves the best emphasis controllability and performs the best in emphasis objective evaluation. In subjective preference tests, EmphTTS is significantly preferred over synthetic groundtruth and most baselines. Ablation studies show that GRPO improves emphasis realization beyond supervised-finetuning-based duration modeling and simple speaking-rate adjustment, while alleviating the mismatch between the independently trained duration predictor and TTS model.

0.32

Group Relative Policy Optimisation Improves Multilingual Speech Recognition in Low-Resource Languages

cs.AI cs.CL ·2026-10-22 ·Tim Wenjie Hu, Evelyn Nafula Ouma, Benjamin Akera, John A. Quinn
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 5 pages, 3 figures, submitted to ICASSP 2027

Autoregressive encoder-decoder speech recognition models trained with teacher forcing can suffer from exposure bias, limiting their ability to recover from their own prediction errors at inference time. Recent work has shown that reinforcement learning with Group Relative Policy Optimisation (GRPO) improves speech recognition in major languages with LLM-based models. We extend this line of work to smaller, non-LLM encoder-decoder ASR models, using Whisper-large-v3 as a case study across 51 African languages. The benefits of this approach are most pronounced when training data is scarce or when input audio is noisy or degraded. Our resulting model, SunflowerASR, achieves the best published macro-averaged WER on the AfriVox-v2 (0.227) and SimbaBench (0.372) benchmarks, and is publicly available.

0.19

Transcribe, Translate, and Optimize: Joint Reward Learning for Speech Translation

cs.CL eess.AS ·2026-09-22 ·Yanghe Dong, Wanting Huang, Weiran Wang
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 5 pages

In LLM-based speech translation, transcription-based chain-of-thought (CoT) suffers from a mismatch between reference transcripts used in supervised fine-tuning (SFT) and model-generated transcripts at inference. To address this, we propose joint recognition and translation fine-tuning via group relative policy optimization (GRPO). We score both transcripts and translations, with translation conditioned on model-generated transcripts, and compare three token advantage strategies. Using Qwen2.5-Omni-3B across four languages, we evaluate CoT against direct speech translation (Direct ST) under SFT and GRPO, training on CoVoST 2 and testing on CoVoST 2 and FLEURS. CoT GRPO outperforms Direct ST GRPO by 1.77 and 0.83 average BLEU points on CoVoST 2 and FLEURS. Compared to CoT SFT, GRPO boosts BLEU by 0.82 and 0.67 points and reduces word error rate (WER) by 8.8% and 7.2% relatively. These results highlight reinforcement fine-tuning as an effective method to mitigate the training-inference mismatch, jointly improving recognition and translation.

0.18

Pseudo-Labels as Rewards, Not Targets: Group-Relative Policy Optimization for Semi-Supervised ASR

cs.CL eess.AS ·2026-10-23 ·Shashi Kumar, Yanis Labrak, Sergio Burdisso, Esaú Villatoro-Tello, Petr Motlicek +2 more
similarity 0.65
Abstract · submitted to ICASSP 2027

Adapting ASR to a domain with only untranscribed audio typically relies on pseudo-labeling, a strong teacher transcribes the audio and a student is fine-tuned on it. Because supervised fine-tuning (SFT) treats every pseudo-label token as a target, the student inherits the teacher's errors. We show that using the same pseudo-labels as a reward reference for Group Relative Policy Optimization (GRPO) is more robust to label noise. In the banking domain, GRPO yields 29.3% to 56.2% relative WER improvements over SFT on Whisper-generated labels, and the advantage holds across four Whisper sizes, four teacher families, three domains and four languages. While SFT reproduces almost 100% of teacher errors verbatim, GRPO passes through only 27%. Rollout statistics explain why, erroneous pseudo-label words rarely appear in on-policy rollouts, so group-relative advantages stay aligned with the clean transcript, whereas SFT forces them into the policy's support and collapses the reward variance GRPO relies on.

0.21