CS Paper Radar

You Cannot Photograph the Same Street Twice: Reliability Limits in Vision-Language Measurement of Urban Change

Kaizhen Tan

cs.CV ·submitted 2026-09-01 03:25 UTC · v2

Abstract

Vision-language models (VLMs) are increasingly used to measure urban change from repeated street-level imagery, and the results are often mapped for individual sample points. Such maps assume that a perception score changes only if the street does. We test this assumption with repeated Google Street View captures of unchanged streets in five US cities and with controlled experiments that hold the photograph, scene or camera fixed. Re-photographing an unchanged street shifts its perception score by two-thirds of the average difference between two streets in the same city. Much of this shift arises in the scoring and averages out over question orders; the rest comes from the photographs and is not predicted by image statistics of weather and light. A single image measures a place moderately well, but the change at one location barely separates redeveloped from unchanged streets. All models tested score degraded images as worse-looking streets, and in crowdsourced imagery camera differences cause false reports of physical change unless both images are rendered through a common virtual camera. After aggregation, redeveloped streets are scored as wealthier and better maintained, with more enclosure and less greenery. Streets photographed in the same capture campaign share part of their error, which averaging within a district does not remove. For urban research and planning, VLM perception scores can support comparisons between groups of streets, such as redeveloped and unchanged streets photographed in the same campaigns, but not the identification of individual streets that improved or declined.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Seeing the City or Recognizing the Place? What Street-View Imagery Adds Beyond Existing Urban Data in VLM-Based Urban Sensing

cs.CV ·2026-09-02 ·Kaizhen Tan
similarity 0.73
Abstract

Street-view imagery is increasingly analysed with vision-language models (VLMs) to infer urban attributes, but predictive accuracy alone does not show how much a photograph contributes beyond data already available for the same place. Using three VLMs, we compare image-based predictions with existing urban data for seven attributes drawn from five public resources. Each urban unit is evaluated with imagery, with location or text context, and against non-image predictions from nearby observations or public records. We also replace images and add conflicting records to test which source the predictions follow. Nearby observations or public records matched or exceeded image-only predictions for road damage, curb ramps, population, and house price. Images were more informative for building type, building function, and the floor count of low-rise buildings. For floor count, the advantage of images over nearby OpenStreetMap labels increased by 5.7 percentage points per doubling of distance to the nearest labelled building and declined for tall buildings whose rooflines often fell outside the frame. When images and records disagreed, predictions usually moved towards the supplied record. Released OpenFACADES floor annotations, generated with OpenStreetMap floor values as input, showed the same dependence: their agreement with the reference increased with building height, whereas that of image-only reruns decreased. The value of street-view imagery therefore depends on whether an attribute is visible and how well the place is already covered by existing data. Because machine-derived labels are often reused as references, these comparisons also bear on how urban datasets are documented and evaluated.

0.08

From Street View Imagery to Street Quality Indicators: Vision Language Inference for the Suburban 15-minute City

cs.CV cs.LG ·2026-08-20 ·Joan Perez, Giovanni Fusco
code/datahot direction similarity 0.65
Abstract · 16 pages, 4 figures

Streetscape quality has become a central concern in contemporary urban planning, particularly within the framework of the pedestrian-friendly 15-minute city, where walkability and public-space quality are increasingly recognized as key determinants of urban performance. However, assessing streetscape qualities across large suburban and peri-urban territories remains challenging due to the time and resource demands of conventional field surveys. This paper presents a planning-oriented assessment of streetscape qualities in the north-eastern periphery of Nice (France) using the latest release of SAGAI (Streetscape Analysis with Generative AI), an open-source workflow that leverages vision-language models (VLMs) for large-scale streetscape analysis from Google Street View imagery. The new release addresses limitations of the original framework through improved image acquisition, geographically consistent view generation, support for multiple VLM architectures, consensus-based inference, and an integrated analytical environment. The workflow is applied to several thousand street-level observations to evaluate qualities relevant to pedestrian-friendly urban environments: sidewalk presence, pedestrian entrance density, and vegetation. The resulting maps reveal that the desired streetscape qualities characterize only a fraction of today's suburban streetscapes, mainly in compact developments and traditional suburban faubourgs, while they are particularly lacking on residential hills. The analysis demonstrates the potential of contemporary VLMs to support urban diagnostics in extensive suburban territories where fieldwork would be prohibitively time-consuming. Beyond the case study, the paper illustrates how recent advances in vision-language models can contribute to evidence-based planning by enabling scalable, flexible, and interpretable assessments of urban public-space quality.

0.39

Cross-View Urban Sensing: Mapping Subjective Streetscape Perception via AlphaEarth Embeddings and Urban Context

cs.CV ·2026-08-17 ·Peilin Li, Pengfei Chen, Jingyu Wang, Zhifeng Yang, Tiansheng Chen +2 more
hot direction similarity 0.63
Abstract

Residents' perception of the urban streetscape is an important factor in public health, active mobility, and social wellbeing. Street view imagery (SVI) has emerged as a widely used data source for assessing these perceptual qualities, yet its uneven coverage and irregular updating limit large-scale measurement. Here, we present CVLNet, a Cross-View Learning Network that predicts street-level perception from AlphaEarth embeddings and multi-source urban contextual data without requiring SVI at inference. CVLNet applies per-task adaptive gating to jointly model five perceptual dimensions, using labels from the pretrained SVI-Percept model as ground truth. The proposed method is evaluated across four Southeast Asian cities: Singapore, Kuala Lumpur, Jakarta, and Manila. CVLNet achieves a median road-segment-level Adjusted $R^{2}$ of 0.76 and consistently outperforms the baseline models, with gains ranging from 5.9--11.3% across the five perceptual dimensions. Ablation experiments show that AlphaEarth features and urban contextual features contribute complementary information. We further produce citywide road-level streetscape perception maps for five subjective perceptual dimensions across all four cities, extending perception estimation from the 13--31% of the road network directly covered by available SVI to the complete road network of each city. Integrating these maps with WorldPop gridded population data, we quantify exposure inequality across population-density, demographic, and land-use groups using the Deficit Palma Ratio. These results demonstrate that remote sensing can serve as a scalable alternative to SVI for citywide streetscape perception mapping, enabling a more comprehensive assessment of urban environmental inequality.

0.39

Developing a Street View Imagery Processing Pipeline for Building-Level Vacant House Assessment

cs.CV cs.CY ·2026-11-09 ·Dongjoon Park, Sunjae Lee, Jung Woo Kim, Bumjoon Kang
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 51 pages, 9 figures, 3 tables, including appendices

Street view imagery (SVI) is widely used to audit urban environments remotely. Automated assessments usually assume that each image shows the target building clearly. In practice, an image may lack task-relevant evidence or show a neighboring house. If this goes unchecked, a model's score cannot show whether it judged the correct building. We present a reproducible SVI processing pipeline that makes image suitability and target identity explicit and checkable. We apply it to vacant house assessment in South Korea, using 10,311 images of 1,609 detached-house parcels. Task-suitability filtering adapts its criteria to image composition and administrative area. This keeps coverage even across areas. While keeping as many images as a single uniform filter, our filtering left 101 more parcels with a usable image. Target-house alignment identifies the parcel's house from camera metadata and parcel boundaries. It needs no building footprints or additional training. Alignment matched human labels for 85.6% of images, compared with 79.8% for the best simple rule. In vacancy classification, filtering and alignment raised AUROC from 0.684 to 0.719, but marking a different house in the same image still gave 0.709. Grad-CAM showed that the model often looked at areas outside the target house. Image suitability, target identification, and model evidence are therefore separate problems, and scores alone do not resolve them. Recording which images were used and which house was selected lets reviewers verify each assessment and can support human virtual audits.

0.26

A Decade of PhotoMappers: A Longitudinal Study of Crowdsourced Disaster Photos Geolocalization with Vision-Language Models and Geospatial Reasoning

cs.AI cs.CV ·2026-10-11 ·Hao Li, Wenping Yin, Fabian Deuser, Jia Jia, Ziqi Liu +3 more
positioncode/data similarity 0.60
Abstract

Crowdsourced disaster imagery provides timely, ground-level observations when conventional disaster mapping is delayed or incomplete, yet its geographic value depends on where observations are produced, how they are interpreted, and whether they can be reliably located as actionable Geospatial Intelligence (GEOINT). Using more than a decade of PhotoMappers, a crowdsourced disaster-mapping initiative, this study examines the changing geography of disaster information and asks how emerging GeoAI models compare with human geographic interpretation. We combine longitudinal spatial analysis with cross-view geolocalization using street view imagery (SVI) and remote sensing imagery (RSI), and evaluate vision-language models (VLMs) reasoning through 30 indicators spanning geographic cues and reasoning evidence. The results reveal a geographically and temporally uneven archive shaped by changing disaster types, Community Lifelines, and operational priorities. Integrating VGI, SVI, and RSI with Sinkhorn re-ranking achieves 40.90% R@1, 61.10% R@5, and 69.45% R@10, while yearly R@1 varies markedly from 25.00% to 65.07%. Geographic reasoning is similarly uneven: Qwen3.6-27B achieves an overall agreement of 67% compared with 51% for InternVL3-8B, with both models showing greater difficulty with localized and place-specific evidence than broad spatial configurations. We argue that the value of GeoAI lies less in replacing volunteered geographic interpretation than in complementing it, scaling candidate retrieval while retaining human judgment for ambiguous and consequential cases. This provides a pathway toward more human-centered and responsible GeoAI for disaster mapping. All data and code are openly available at https://github.com/bobleegogogo/PhotoMappers-VLM.

0.28

Spot-the-shift: Evaluating Grounded Image Difference Captioning of Long-term Changes

cs.CV ·2026-09-09 ·Benedetta Liberatori, Nermin Samet, Paolo Rota, Matthieu Cord, Elisa Ricci +2 more
benchmark similarity 0.59
Abstract · Preprint

Long-term change understanding from images of the same place revisited over time is a challenging task with applications in map maintenance and urban infrastructure monitoring. Prior work addresses it either through pixel-level prediction or difference captioning, neither of which is sufficient to reliably measure how well models detect and describe such changes. We introduce SPOT-THE-SHIFT, a human-verified benchmark for grounded image difference captioning of long-term changes in real-world driving scenes. Our benchmark provides natural language captions and spatial masks for structural changes across each image pair. We further propose an evaluation protocol that reliably assesses models' captioning ability, validated through human studies. Benchmarking state-of-the-art MLLMs, we find that models struggle with the fine-grained multi-image spatial capability required for this task. Finally, we develop a synthetic data generation pipeline that improves an off-the-shelf MLLM without sacrificing general capabilities.

0.09

MAPS: A Multimodal Agentic Framework for POI Data Production Based on Crowdsourced Street-view Imagery

cs.AI cs.DB ·2026-11-15 ·Sijie Ruan, Tingyu Xie, Mingfei Liu, Yicheng Tang, Haoyu Han +5 more
top venuehot direction similarity 0.56
Abstract · Accepted for presentation at the 33rd ACM SIGKDD Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining (KDD 2027), Cycle 1

Point-of-interest (POI) databases support location-based services, yet urban changes quickly make their records stale and manual maintenance is costly. Crowdsourced street-view images provide timely visual evidence, but converting them into database actions requires separating multiple POIs and irrelevant text in each image, then resolving incomplete observations against ambiguous records. We study Street-view Image-based POI Data Production and propose MAPS, the first framework to integrate structured POI extraction with database maintenance from such imagery. MAPS contains two cascaded modules. SPICE progressively adapts a lightweight vision-language model to reconstruct and filter text, group entries belonging to the same POI, and classify their semantics and completeness. RIMA retrieves candidate records, performs evidence-grounded POI matching and attribute-level reasoning, and selectively acquires complementary visual, geospatial, or external-source evidence when necessary. In human-reviewed full-task evaluation, MAPS outperforms the strongest baseline by 21.8\%. MAPS has also been deployed in Kuaishou's large-scale POI production pipeline, reducing average processing time by 76.9\% relative to manual annotation. These results demonstrate the effectiveness and practical value of MAPS for scalable POI maintenance.

0.39

From Pixels to Policy: A Multi-Agent System for Intervention and Geo-Spatial Decision Support

cs.CV ·2026-10-01 ·Hosam Elgendy, Utkarsh Mall
position similarity 0.56
Abstract

Urban environments are shaped by design choices with long-term implications for health, safety, and quality of life, yet evaluating proposed interventions remains costly, time-consuming, and often impractical. Existing geospatial vision methods largely focus on monitoring urban indicators from aerial and street-view imagery, rather than proposing interventions and estimating their effects on such indicators. Moving beyond recognition, we introduce the problem of discovering interventions that improve target indicators for a given aerial or street-view image. We argue that a black-box indicator model, combined with a generative editing model, can serve as an implicit digital twin for testing intervention hypotheses. We present VIDA-Geo , a multi-agent system that explores this intervention space by coordinating segmentation, diffusion-based inpainting, and indicator scoring models to produce interventions that are both perceptually realistic and aligned with real-world policies. We evaluate our system on 8 indicators across aerial and street-view imagery, measuring changes in factors such as perceived safety and greenery. Our approach outperforms existing baselines in many cases, achieving up to 2X higher perceptual quality and policy alignment scores. Finally, our model provides users with multiple candidate interventions, supporting an expert city-planner-in-the-loop workflow.

0.22