CS Paper Radar

What Limits Robustness in Deep Image Watermarking: An Analysis of Mechanisms and Their Scaling Across Capacities

Marta Bistroń, Zbigniew Piotrowski

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-09-01 10:46 UTC · v1

Abstract

Robustness remains the principal open problem in deep image watermarking, and what limits it becomes sharper as payload grows. This paper asks whether capacity is itself the limit or only makes other limits visible, and answers in two parts. The first organizes the distortions a watermark must survive and the strategies developed to resist them, ordering each by the axis that governs it: payload capacity for the distortions, differentiability for the strategies. The second identifies and measures three mechanisms that limit robustness in schemes mapping the payload onto a spatial block grid with extraction trained separately from a frozen embedder: desynchronization of the payload grid, the resistance of codec-induced distortion to training, and the narrowing of the usable embedding-strength window. Payloads from 64 to 16384 bits are measured, well beyond the range those strategies address. Training the extraction stage against a codec proves not merely ineffective but harmful, degrading the reading at the operating points used in training. The limits follow the class of distortion rather than capacity itself, and none is removed by further training on the extraction side, because all three arise before extraction. An evaluation protocol making claims of generalization verifiable is also contributed. The conclusions are properties of a class of designs rather than of one implementation.

Comment
Submitted to IEEE Access

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

COVER: Codec-Robust Video Watermarking with Generative Video Priors

cs.CV ·2026-09-17 ·Yuxin Cao, Hao Yang, Ziqi Ding, Jie Hao, Wei Song
similarity 0.70
Abstract · 10 pages, 5 figures

Video watermarking underpins copyright protection and provenance for generated media, yet almost every video is compressed by a codec before it is stored or shared. A codec discards precisely the perceptually redundant components that most watermarks rely on, so the payload is often lost even when the marked video looked flawless beforehand. Existing methods leave this path open, since they treat compression as one entry in a generic list of distortions, while a real codec is not differentiable and cannot enter gradient-based training. We present COVER, the first learned video watermark built around codec compression as its design target, which survives that compression by embedding the payload in the latent space of a frozen generative video autoencoder and recovering it by re-encoding the received video into that same latent space. To make codec robustness trainable, we build a differentiable codec surrogate bank that simulates the dominant degradation modes of practical compression, and we train the embedder and the latent decoder through three shared recovery paths under a fidelity objective that constrains the residual in the pixel and frequency domains. Across four codecs at 12 settings, COVER attains 93.72% average bit accuracy, ranks first on 11 of the 12, improves the strongest prior method by 2.68 points, and lifts the worst operating point from 68.90% to 73.72% while each marked video stays visually close to the source clip that produced it.

0.47

What Breaks Local Watermarks? A Robustness Benchmark for Local Invisible Image Watermarking

cs.CV cs.AIcs.CR ·2026-09-15 ·Kai Yao, Bence Szilágyi, Sebestyén Kamp, Máté Poór, Máté Szilveszter +2 more
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.70
Abstract · This work has been accepted for publication in the proceedings of the 19th ACM Workshop on Artificial Intelligence and Security (AISec 2026)…

Local image watermarking embeds an invisible signal into selected image regions rather than spreading it across the entire image, enabling payload recovery from specific objects or regions without perceptibly altering the image. Existing studies evaluate the robustness of payload recovery and localization under image transformations, but they often focus on their own proposed method, resulting in narrow evaluations with inconsistent choices of transformations, datasets, and metrics. These inconsistencies across studies limit direct comparisons across methods and muddle the overall picture of local watermark robustness. To address this gap, we present the first systematic robustness benchmark for local watermarks across 55 image transformations, including (i) signal distortions, (ii) changes in image coordinate alignment, (iii) indirect local edits, and (iv) direct watermark edits. The benchmark evaluates MaskWM, WAM, OmniGuard, TrustMark, and PixelSeal, all methods that either provide native localization or require minimal adaptation to support it. Our results show that all evaluated methods are vulnerable to some transformation, with MaskWM standing out as offering the strongest payload recovery and localization, although it has the lowest image quality in the clean setting. Synchronization further improves MaskWM's payload recovery under several geometric transformations, albeit at an additional cost to image quality. A key finding is that local watermark robustness depends strongly on the nature of the transformation: signal distortions are often tolerated by the strongest methods, while geometric misalignment and generative local edits, such as inpainting and outpainting, can completely impair payload recovery. We observe that payload recovery and localization are related but not interchangeable, and both strongly depend on the transformation's impact on the watermark region.

0.24

Optimizing and Securing the Modern Watermarking Channel for Images

cs.CR cs.CV ·2026-09-28 ·Enoal Gesny, Eva Giboulot
position similarity 0.70
Abstract

To comply with recent regulations requiring traceable generated content, modern watermarking has adopted multi-bit post-hoc watermarking schemes. These modern designs rest on an encoder-decoder pair implemented as deep neural networks. These models are usually treated as pure black-boxes trained end-to-end, with the noise of the watermarking channel modeled through a fixed set of geometric and valuemetric transforms applied to watermarked images. We argue that this purely empirical approach leads to unquestioned design flaws and a lack of theoretical performance guarantees. This work proposes a general theoretical model of modern post-hoc watermarking schemes grounded in a statistical analysis of the outputs of the encoder/decoder pair. We show that these deep neural networks implicitly define a watermarking channel modeled as parallel AWGN channels, with messages transmitted using BPSK modulation. This imposes a binary alphabet, greatly limiting the capacity of these watermarking systems. Another fatal flaw is their lack of a secret key, making them intrinsically insecure. We make this notion of watermarking security precise for post-hoc schemes by linking it to the possibility of estimating the secret key under a given statistical model of the decoder's output. By putting together the results from this theoretical analysis, we introduce SNW: a novel post-hoc watermarking system that significantly outperforms existing state-of-the-art baselines in terms of capacity while also providing strong security guarantees. Notably, it does not depend on a fixed codebook or binary alphabet, allowing it to reach a rate close to Shannon capacity through the use of capacity-achieving error-correcting codes.

0.18

Attack-Resilient Multi-Bit Image Watermarking Framework via Latent Coordinate Sign Clamping

cs.CR ·2026-10-29 ·Marjan Beheshti, Ronghua Xu
similarity 0.69
Abstract

Watermarking is essential for image copyright protection and attribution, yet existing methods suffer from fundamental trade-offs among post-hoc applicability to pre-existing images, multi-bit capacity, training-free deployment, and adversarial resilience. To address these limitations, we propose a training-free watermarking framework that exploits the overcompleteness of diffusion latent spaces to embed multi-bit payloads into arbitrary images while preserving high visual quality. Additionally, we develop a three-layer decoding pipeline that combines magnitude-weighted majority voting, BCH, and Chase decoding to maximize message-extraction accuracy in the presence of channel noise. To counter active adversaries, our framework integrates a steganalysis-resistant noise camouflage layer and a dual-layer forgery defense that combines perceptual hashing with a Reed-Solomon fuzzy commitment scheme over CLIP features. Empirical evaluations demonstrate that our method applies to both natural and AI-generated images with a scalable $32\text{--}128$-bit capacity. Furthermore, it effectively mitigates advanced removal vectors ($94.6\%$ decode rate against CtrlRegen+ regeneration attacks) and secures robust forgery detection ($98.8\%$ accuracy via joint CLIP and RS fuzzy commitment mechanism).

0.04

Made to Measure: Designing Image Watermarks to Specification

cs.CR ·2026-09-30 ·Mingzhe Li, Yuefeng Peng, Kejing Xia, Pranav Jeyakumar, Ruolan Leslie Famularo +1 more
code/data similarity 0.68
Abstract

Image watermarking supports provenance and attribution by embedding verifiable identity information into images. Practical deployments, however, must jointly satisfy requirements for attack resistance, false-positive rate (FPR), image quality, and latency. Existing watermarking methods are robust to different classes of transformations, so combining complementary methods can provide broader protection than any single watermark. Such composition is challenging, as additional fragments increase distortion and decoding cost and must share the same FPR budget. Therefore, we propose **TAILOR**, a request-conditioned watermark composition framework with three stages: (1) *offline characterization* measures fragment recovery, distortion, and runtime as response curves over embedding strength; (2) *joint configuration selection* encodes the request as an SMT model over these curves and solves for the lowest-distortion composition of fragments, strengths, order, and geometric recovery; and (3) *live calibration* validates the selected configuration on the user's images and refines predictions that fail to transfer. Experimental results across 7,321 distinct requests spanning five scenarios and 20 attack settings show that **TAILOR** achieves **96.21%** scenario-averaged request satisfaction with a mean PSNR of **41.02 dB**, outperforming existing methods in robustness while achieving consistently better image quality. Code is available at [https://github.com/aaFrostnova/Tailor](https://github.com/aaFrostnova/Tailor).

0.32

SAMP: Self-Adaptive Margin Prioritization For Robust Diffusion Watermarking

cs.CV cs.AIcs.MM ·2026-10-15 ·Yuhao Xue, Jiuan Zhou, Yu Cheng, Zhaoxia Yin
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Diffusion models have made high-fidelity visual generation widely accessible, while also lowering the barrier to producing convincing visual forgeries and complicating content provenance. Existing watermarking methods typically use a fixed embedding strength throughout denoising or treat all watermark dimensions equally. As a result, they may introduce unnecessary distortion when some watermark dimensions are already reliable, while failing to sufficiently reinforce those that are more vulnerable to subsequent perturbations. Therefore, robust watermarking requires adapting both the embedding strength during denoising and the optimization priority across watermark dimensions. To address this problem, we present SAMP, a self-adaptive framework consisting of global margin regulation and vulnerability-sensitive allocation. Global margin regulation adjusts the embedding strength according to the separation between the target codeword and competing codewords, together with the estimated effects of common attacks. Vulnerability-sensitive allocation identifies watermark dimensions that are more easily weakened by local perturbations and gives them higher optimization priority. Experimental results demonstrate that SAMP achieves an average information recovery accuracy of 0.993. Compared with state-of-the-art methods, SAMP improves PSNR by 16.8% and reduces LPIPS by 47.1%. These results validate the effectiveness of SAMP for reliable and high-quality diffusion watermarking.

0.05

WARP: A Unified Benchmark for Invisible Image Watermarking -- Robustness and Protection Against Attacks

cs.CV cs.AIcs.MM ·2026-09-30 ·Khaled Abud, Aleksey Yakushev, Aleksandr Akimenkov, Irina Serzhenko, Kirill Aistov +7 more
top venuebenchmarkcode/data similarity 0.67
Abstract · Accepted to ACM MM 2026 (Main Track)

Digital image watermarking is increasingly critical in media contexts, as emerging regulations and industry practices require marking AI-generated content and ensuring traceable sources to prevent manipulation or misuse. Recent advances in invisible watermarking methods highlight the need to update existing benchmarking practices to reflect current techniques and evaluation criteria. We address this by introducing WARP -- a unified framework and benchmark for evaluating the robustness of invisible watermarks. WARP incorporates 32 recent classical, deep, and generative watermarking methods, as well as 34 different erasing techniques, ranging from traditional distortions to more sophisticated adversarial, purification, and re-embedding attacks. It provides standardized, reproducible, and easily scalable protocols for evaluating perceptual quality, watermark readability, and attack resilience. Using WARP, we extensively evaluate current invisible watermarking techniques, collecting the largest robustness benchmark in the field. Results identify the most robust approaches under both distortion and adversarial conditions, and reveal consistent relationships between watermarking methods and the attack strategies most effective against them. Our experiments also highlight that some of the watermarking methods considered are highly vulnerable to reembedding, even if they are robust to standard distortions. The code is made available at https://github.com/ispras/wibe.

0.46

Beyond Distortion Robustness: Rethinking Severe Cropping as Erasure-Resilient Message Embedding

cs.CR ·2026-08-19 ·Bo Pang, Weibin Kong, Juntu Dong, Minghan Li, Zhongping Zhang
top venue similarity 0.67
Abstract · Accepted by ACMMM 2026

Robust message embedding in images is important for multimedia security applications such as copyright protection and content tracing. Existing methods are largely developed under a distortion robustness paradigm, where the embedded signal remains spatially present but is degraded by noise, blur, or compression. Severe cropping poses a fundamentally different challenge because it removes part of the carrier itself, causing partial payload disappearance rather than mere signal corruption. In this paper, we revisit robust message embedding from an erasure-resilience perspective and present CREST, a proof-of-concept framework for severe-cropping-robust embedding. CREST combines coding-theoretic redundancy with neural embedding and recovery by expanding a compact QR message into a redundant spatial payload via LT fountain coding and coupling it with cropping-aware embedding and fragment recovery. Experiments on COCO, DIV2K, and VOC2012 show that CREST improves recovery under severe cropping while maintaining competitive visual quality. Under mixed distortions with an area retention ratio of 0.7, CREST improves TRA from 18.52% to 68.45% and reduces EMR from 13.88% to 4.21% over the strongest baseline. On COCO2017, CREST still achieves 48.55--65.12% TRA when only 30--50% of the image area is retained, whereas all compared baselines fail to recover the message. These results suggest that severe cropping is better understood as an erasure problem rather than a conventional distortion problem, motivating the joint design of neural embedding and coding-based recovery.

0.33