CS Paper Radar

Faster Convergence of Multidimensional Approximate Agreement via Smallest Enclosing Balls

Darya Melnyk

cs.DC ·submitted 2026-09-01 16:22 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

This work considers the multidimensional approximate agreement problem. In this problem, $n$ parties in a distributed system, up to $t$ of which may be corrupted by a Byzantine adversary, need to output vectors that are close to each other and that lie inside the convex hull of all non-corrupted input vectors. We assume that nodes communicate in a fully-connected authenticated network and analyze synchronous and asynchronous communication models. The focus of this work is on the contraction factor of approximate agreement protocols. The first multidimensional approximate agreement protocols had a contraction rate of $1-1/n$(VG, PODC'13) and $\sqrt[d]{1/2}$(MH, STOC'13). While a rate below $1$ is sufficient for convergence, it is not sufficient for practical applications. To date, the best known convergence rate of approximate agreement algorithms is $\sqrt{7/8}\approx0.935$ (FN, DISC'18), which is achieved through the MidExtremes protocol. This stands in contrast to the lower bound on the convergence rate in the $1$-dimensional setting, which is $1/2$. In this work, we propose BallMidpoint - a novel approximate agreement protocol with a contraction rate of $1/\sqrt{2}\approx 0.707$ in the synchronous and the asynchronous communication models. This algorithm satisfies the optimal resilience under convex validity. The presented contraction rate is achieved by choosing the midpoint of the smallest enclosing ball of the so-called local safe areas, and it is tight for the presented algorithms. Similar to (FN, DISC'18), our algorithm is coordinate-free, and the point inside the safe area can be computed efficiently. This work presents the first multidimensional approximate agreement protocol where the convergence rate is closer to the best known lower bound rather than the upper bound of $1$.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

New Contraction Bounds for Multidimensional Asymptotic Consensus in Dynamic Networks

cs.DC ·2026-10-08 ·Zeremonienmeister Berber Aab, Darya Melnyk, Stefan Schmid
theory similarity 0.77
Abstract · 21 pages, 2 figures

This work studies the multidimensional asymptotic agreement problem in dynamic networks. We assume that nodes have $d$-dimensional inputs and need to converge arbitrarily close to each other's inputs while their vectors stay inside the convex hull of all inputs. We present a new upper bound of $\sqrt{2d/(3d+1)}$ on the contraction rate of asymptotic agreement in the non-split network model, where $d$ is the dimension of the input and $\sqrt{2d/(3d+1)}\rightarrow \sqrt{2/3}\approx 0.816$ for $d\rightarrow\infty$. To this end, we adapt the BallMidpoint algorithm (Melnyk, 2026) recently introduced for the all-to-all communication model. This algorithm lets the nodes choose the midpoint of the smallest enclosing ball of the received vectors. This bound is strictly worse than the $\sqrt{1/2}\approx 0.707$ contraction rate for fault-tolerant approximate agreement in all-to-all communication networks because the convex hulls of the nodes do not have a common intersection, and only intersect pairwise. Our bound improves over the previously best-known contraction rate of $\sqrt{7/8}\approx 0.935$ for dynamic networks via the MidExtremes algorithm (Függer and Nowak, 2018). We present the first multi-dimensional lower bound of $2/3$ for the contraction of coordinate-free memoryless anonymous deterministic algorithms in non-split networks, for $d\ge 8$. This result shows that the previously best-known lower bound of $1/2$ on the contraction rate for $n\ge 3$ and $d=1$ is not tight in higher dimensions. If $n$ is infinite, we extend this lower bound to $\sqrt{1/2\cdot d/(d+1)}$, which converges to $\sqrt{1/2}$ for $d\rightarrow \infty$. We further show that for a single round, the one-round contraction is at least $\sqrt{\frac{2d-2}{3d+7}}$, which converges to $\sqrt{2/3}$ for $d\rightarrow\infty$, showing that the BallMidpoint strategy is asymptotically optimal for one round.

0.17

Optimal Adaptive Multi-Valued Byzantine Agreement

cs.DC ·2026-08-18 ·Marc Dufay, Anton Paramonov, Roger Wattenhofer
similarity 0.68
Abstract

In Byzantine Agreement (BA), $n$ parties, out of which $t$ can be Byzantine, run a distributed protocol to agree on a common valid input. Traditionally, these protocols have a linear latency and quadratic message complexity, making them impractical at a large scale. In their recent work, Constantinescu, Dufay, Paramonov, and Wattenhofer consider the actual number of byzantine parties $f \leq t$ and work toward decoupling the dependency on $n$ and $t$ in the complexity. They obtain a BA protocol with $\tilde{\mathcal{O}}(n + t\cdot f)$ message complexity and $\tilde{\mathcal{O}}(f)$ round complexity. However, their results are strictly limited to agreement on a binary value. Using the framework given by their work along with novel techniques, we extend these results for BA on an $L$-bit value. With $κ$ being a security parameter, and with optimal resiliency ($t < n/2$ in the synchronous setting or $t < n/3$ otherwise), we obtain: - In synchrony, a deterministic protocol with $\mathcal{O}(n\cdot (L + f \cdot κ))$ bit complexity and $\mathcal{O}(f + \log n)$ round complexity. - In synchrony and partial synchrony, deterministic protocols with $\tilde{\mathcal{O}}(n \cdot κ+ t\cdot (L + f \cdot κ))$ bit complexity and $\mathcal{O}(f)$ round complexity. - In asynchrony, a protocol with $\tilde{\mathcal{O}}(n \cdot κ+ t\cdot(L + t \cdot κ))$ expected bit complexity and expected $\mathcal{O}(1)$ latency.

0.45

Fast Quantum Byzantine Agreement with Nearly Linear Quantum Communication

cs.DS ·2026-11-03 ·Jan Olkowski
theory similarity 0.66
Abstract

We consider synchronous binary Byzantine agreement among $n$ processes connected by authenticated point-to-point classical and quantum channels. The adversary is computationally unbounded, sees all classical information, adaptively corrupts up to $t\le(1/3-\varepsilon)n$ processes, and may suppress messages sent by a process in the round in which it is corrupted. We give a quantum algorithm that solves Byzantine agreement in this model with probability $1$. It uses $O(\log^4 n)$ rounds, $O(n\log^8 n)$ qubits, and $O(n^2\log^8 n)$ classical bits in expectation, with constants depending on $\varepsilon$. This reduces the quantum communication of the protocol of Ben-Or and Hassidim (STOC~2005), which achieves $O(1)$ expected rounds but whose Byzantine coin implementation requires $Ω(n^4\log n)$ qubits and classical bits. We also extend the quadratic message lower bound of Abraham et al.\ (PODC~2019) to quantum channels, obtaining an $Ω(t^2)$ lower bound on worst-case expected total communication. For $t=Θ(n)$, the communication and round complexity of our algorithm are therefore optimal up to polylogarithmic factors.

0.24

Optimal Subcubic Byzantine Agreement with Plain PKI

cs.DC ·2026-11-04 ·Marc Dufay, Roger Wattenhofer
theory similarity 0.64
Abstract

We consider Byzantine Agreement (BA), where $n$ parties run a distributed protocol to agree on a common value, despite $t$ parties being byzantine. In the synchronous setting, a choice must be made between the weaker unauthenticated setting, which only allows $t < n/3$ byzantine parties, and the stronger authenticated setting that allows up to $t < n/2$ byzantine parties. For this latter setting, BA can be solved with optimal resiliency and optimal bit complexity. However, so far, all optimal solutions rely on the use of threshold signatures. This shows a gap compared to regular signatures, where only protocols with cubic complexity are known for optimal resiliency $t < n/2$. We wonder whether this cubic complexity is required without the use of threshold signatures and show that this is not the case. More specifically, given $κ$ an upper bound on the size of a hash or signature, we describe a deterministic protocol solving BA with bit complexity $\mathcal{O}(κ^{(\sqrt{13} - 1)/2} n^{(\sqrt{13} + 1)/2}) \approx \mathcal{O}(κ^{1.303}n^{2.303})$ while having optimal resiliency $t<n/2$ and round complexity $\mathcal{O}(n)$.

0.20

Affine Combiners for Reed-Solomon Proximity Gaps

cs.IT cs.CCcs.CR ·2026-11-11 ·Alessandro Chiesa, Guy Weissenberg, Eylon Yogev, Kai Zhe Zheng
theory similarity 0.63
Abstract

Reed-Solomon proximity gaps establish soundness guarantees for protocols that test received words through random combinations. For length-$n$ codes over $\mathbb{F}_q$, classical scalar combiners achieve error $O(n/q)$ in the unique-decoding regime, with larger known bounds near the Johnson radius. We prove smaller error bounds using affine combiners, which combine two received words $f,g$ as $f(x)+(α+βx)g(x)$, where $α,β$ are independent uniform elements of $\mathbb{F}_q$. For output degree bound $d=ρn$, fixed $ρ\in(0,1)$ and $0<η<1-\sqrtρ$, and sufficiently large block length $n$, we prove mutual correlated agreement (MCA) with one coordinate of agreement loss at threshold $A=\lceil(\sqrtρ+η)n\rceil$, with error $O_{ρ,η}\left(\frac{1}{q}+\frac{n^2}{q^2}\right)$. The result holds over arbitrary evaluation domains in every finite field, including prime and binary extension fields. The agreement threshold can approach the Johnson threshold, beyond unique decoding. For $q\ge n^2$, our error is $O_{ρ,η}(1/q)$, an asymptotic factor-$n$ separation from scalar combiners: we prove that their worst-case MCA error is $Ω_{ρ,η}(n/q)$ at the same agreement threshold and with the same one-coordinate loss. We also prove that affine combiners incur worst-case error $Ω_{ρ,η}(n/q)$ when no agreement loss is allowed. Thus one coordinate of agreement loss is necessary for our guarantee; this relaxation of standard MCA reduces the guaranteed common agreement fraction by at most $1/n$. We also extend the result to $k$-variate Reed-Muller codes on subfield grids, obtaining MCA error $O_{ρ,η,k}(q^{-k})$ for fixed $ρ,η,k$, sufficiently large $n$, and $q\ge n^{k+1}$, with agreement loss $n^{1-1/k}$.

0.08

Fast Multidimensional Approximate Agreement with Optimal Resilience Using Ball Validity

cs.DC ·2026-09-07 ·Tijana Milentijević, Stefan Schmid
theory similarity 0.63
Abstract

Multidimensional approximate agreement requires $n$ processes with inputs in $\mathbb{R}^d$ to output vectors close to each other, despite up to $t$ Byzantine faults. Under convex validity, outputs must lie in the convex hull of the correct inputs, which leads to resilience thresholds that grow with the dimension. We instead study Minimum Enclosing Ball (MEB) validity and its multiplicative relaxation $c$-MEB validity. Our first contribution is Adaptive MEB Contraction, a coordinate-free algorithm that, in the synchronous model with $n>(d+1)t$ contracts the correct MEB radius by $1/\sqrt2$ per round for $α=1$ while satisfying $\sqrt2$-MEB validity. We also give an example showing that this bound is tight for our analysis. Our main technical contribution is a dimension-free inflation theorem: if every $β$ balls in a finite family of Euclidean balls have a common point, then inflating each radius by $\sqrt{β/(β-1)}$ guarantees a common intersection. Applying the theorem to the candidate balls defining the local MEB-safe areas results in a synchronous algorithm with optimal resilience $n>3t$, contraction factor $\sqrt3/2$ and $\sqrt6$-MEB validity. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first multidimensional approximate agreement algorithm with optimal resilience, constant $c$-MEB validity and coordinate-free contraction. We further extend the approach to the asynchronous setting. Without inflation we obtain resilience $n>(d+2)t$, contraction factor $\sqrt{2/3}$ and $\sqrt6$-MEB validity, whereas with inflation for $n>4t$ we get the contraction factor $\sqrt{15}/4$ and $2\sqrt{10}$-MEB validity. Finally, we compare our guarantees with existing algorithms, including Minimum-Diameter Averaging (MDA), for which we derive MEB-validity guarantees. Our algorithms achieve strictly better resilience while providing substantially stronger MEB-validity guarantees than MDA.

0.45

A Simple Phase-King Protocol with Predictions

cs.DC ·2026-11-08 ·Antonia Giannoulea, George Papadoulis, Nikos Leonardos, Aris Pagourtzis
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Inspired by recent work (Ben-David, Dzulfikar, Ellen, and Gilbert, $\textit{Byzantine Agreement with Predictions}$, PODC 2025) we study synchronous binary Byzantine Agreement in the learning-augmented setting, where each process receives predictions about which processes are honest or Byzantine. We present a deterministic Phase King protocol for the anauthenticated setting, combining early stopping with a specifically designed prediction-aware king selection procedure. For at most $t<n/3$ Byzantine processes, the protocol handles arbitrarily many prediction errors, improving upon the $O(n^{3/2})$ bound of Ben-David et al., and terminates within $O(P)$ communication rounds, where $P=1+\min\{\mathbf{B}/n,f\}$, $\mathbf{B}$ is the total number of incorrect prediction bits held by honest processes, and $f$ is the actual number of Byzantine processes. Our protocol uses $O(n^2P)$ messages and $O(n^2P\log n)$ bits, avoiding the initial cubic bit cost of exchanging complete prediction vectors. In comparison to very recent independent work (Dufay, Dzulfikar, and Gilbert, $\textit{Predictions Can Only Help! Communication Efficient Byzantine Agreement with Predictions}$, DISC 2026), which achieves the same error tolerance and round complexity but better communication bounds, our construction provides a much simpler Phase King approach that completely avoids involved preprocessing constructions, rendering it more practical, especially for achieving agreement in time-evolving networks. We believe that the novel prediction-aware king selection technique of our scheme is of independent interest and can find further applications in learning-augmented distributed consensus.

0.29

Multivalued Consensus: General Adversaries Require More Communication

cs.DC cs.CRcs.IT ·2026-08-18 ·Mose Mizrahi, Roger Wattenhofer
theory similarity 0.59
Abstract · 33 pages, 1 figure, full version of a DISC 2026 paper

We study $n$-party fault-tolerant consensus against general (non-threshold) adversaries. We describe an infinite family $Z_\mathsf{proj}^{n,d}$ of $Q^d$-satisfying $n$-party adversary structures based on finite projective geometry which cause error-free $R$-round protocols for interactive consistency on $L$-bit inputs to require $Ω(Ln^{2+1/d})$ bits of expected communication. Likewise, $Z_\mathsf{proj}^{n,d}$ causes error-free byzantine agreement and broadcast to cost $Ω(Ln^{1+1/d})$ bits. In every case, the lower bound is $Ω(L_{\mathsf{out}} \cdot n^{1+1/d})$ bits, where $L_{\mathsf{out}}$ is the output length. The family $Z_\mathsf{proj}^{n,d}$ also causes reliable broadcast and byzantine agreement to cost $Ω(Ln^{1+1/d})$ bits of expected communication in asynchronous networks. Moreover, there exists a related family $Z_\mathsf{2\textsf-proj}^{n,d}$ of $Q^d$-satisfying adversary structures that make core set agreement cost $Ω(Ln^{2+1/d})$ bits. These asynchronous lower bounds hold against send-omission adversaries, even if the protocol uses cryptography. Their basis is that if a quorum of non-faulty parties agree on an output and terminate, then the messages they sent before terminating must suffice for the parties outside the quorum to also terminate with the same output. Surprisingly, if we do not require the parties to terminate (stop sending messages) after they output, then these bounds no longer hold. We show this by designing a non-terminating omission-tolerant reliable broadcast protocol that can for any parameter $δ> 1$ be tuned to cost $(1 + \frac{1}{δ- 1})Ln + O(δn^2\log(δn))$ bits, which is of independent interest. Lastly, we show how to get termination with $O(Ln^{1+1/d} + n^2\log n)$ bits (assuming the $Q^d$ condition), and thus prove our asynchronous lower bounds tight.

0.35