CS Paper Radar

No One Left Behind: Cross-Level Analysis for Sustainable Software Engineering

Masoum Salehi, Sandro Schulze, Jacob Krüger

cs.SE ·submitted 2026-09-03 13:50 UTC · v1
top venueposition

Abstract

Software engineers expect a software system to be efficient, maintainable, economically viable, and socially responsible throughout its lifecycle. Unfortunately, decisions made at the organizational, process, or product levels of software development - even when they improve one of these goals - often have unintended long-term consequences at other levels. In response, software-engineering research has explored different ways to achieve software sustainability, including energy efficiency, resource optimization, and code maintainability. However, existing research offers limited explanations for how sustainability problems emerge and reinforce one another across the socio-technical levels of software engineering. Moreover, we argue that sustainability challenges are not isolated but rather systemic: They stem from interactions among organizational priorities, development practices, and technical conditions. In this vision paper, we introduce the concept of sustainability antipatterns to capture conditions that systematically produce unsustainable outcomes. We demonstrate how this concept can help expose cross-level misalignments between socio-technical levels and sustainability dimensions that remain difficult to recognize through artifact-centric or dimension-specific analyses. To guide future research, we outline concrete directions for identifying, formalizing, detecting, and mitigating sustainability anti-patterns. We envision sustainability anti-patterns as a foundation for an integrated and actionable research agenda on sustainable software engineering.

Comment
Accepted for publication at the 2026 IEEE International Conference on Software Maintenance and Evolution (ICSME)

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Smells and Refactorings for Software Environmental Sustainability: A Systematic Literature Review

cs.SE ·2026-10-02 ·Ornela Danushi, Flavio Sampirisi, Jacopo Soldani, Stefano Forti, Antonio Brogi
survey similarity 0.69
Abstract

Context: The environmental impact of ICT is constantly growing. Enhancing its environmental sustainability requires dealing with energy-hungry software systems, by possibly reducing their footprint. Objective: To better frame the problem and its persistent nature, software can be viewed as carrying structural inefficiencies regardless of how advanced its functionality may be. Identifying these inefficiencies as "green smells" provides a basis for refactoring code to mitigate its ecological impact. We aim at identifying well-known green smells impacting environmental sustainable software and map them to corresponding refactoring aimed at reducing the impact therein. Method: In this article, we conduct a systematic literature review on the articles that discuss green smells and their possible refactorings. We analyse and classify 66 primary studies published up to March 2026. Results: We identify 20 smells impacting environmental sustainability of software. Each smell is associated with one or more refactoring techniques known to mitigate their negative effects on the environmental sustainability of software. Conclusions: The literature witnesses the interest in resolving the green smells affecting software systems. The catalogued green smells and the corresponding refactorings can provide pragmatic value for practitioners in their daily development workflows, while also offering researchers a starting point to establish new research directions in sustainable software engineering.

0.15

The Green Software Landscape: A Systematic Mapping Study on Evolution, Applications, Software Lifecycle, and Best Practices

cs.SE ·2026-08-26 ·Max Hort, Maria Kechagia, Federica Sarro
similarity 0.69
Abstract · 29 pages, 6 figures

Energy consumption and climate change have made sustainability critical in Software Engineering (SE), driving the emergence of Green SE. Over the past 15 years, numerous solutions for sustainable software systems have been published by the SE community, offering a rich resource for analyzing the field's evolution. To explore this, we conducted a systematic mapping study of Green SE research published between 2010 and 2024. We collected 390 publications, categorizing them by application domain (e.g., mobile, cloud, AI) and research type (e.g., optimisation study, benchmarking, literature review Additionally, we analyzed a representative subset of 79 papers to classify the key elements-such as hardware, measurement, stability, and replicability-considered during energy measurement experiments. Our findings indicate that SE conferences host the majority of energy-related literature. Notably, Green SE studies surged in popularity starting in 2023, largely driven by AI-related publications. Optimization and benchmarking emerged as the most prevalent research types. Ultimately, we aim to inform the SE community about current approaches to energy concerns, highlight critical experimental practices, and advocate for continued action toward more sustainable software engineering.

0.18

Perspectives on Sustainable Computational Science and Engineering

cs.CE physics.comp-ph ·2026-09-24 ·Julia Kowalski, Ann S. Almgren, Achim Basermann, Alan Correa, Immo Huismann +41 more
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Computational Science and Engineering (CSE) combines expertise at the intersection of engineering, applied mathematics, and computer science to form powerful methods for model-based design and model-based decision support across disciplines. Today, CSE methods and tools have an impact as an enabling technology in the development of increasingly sustainable products, processes, and operations. However, sustainability is rarely considered holistically in the context of CSE itself. This paper develops a perspective on sustainability in CSE by distinguishing CSE as an enabler of sustainability in application domains from sustainability within CSE itself, which rests on two complementary pillars: sustainable computing and sustainable software. We present illustrative examples for these pillars and derive recommendations and best practices for CSE stakeholders. Developing an understanding of how sustainability can create added value in CSE is an important future direction for the field. This calls for a concerted effort within the CSE community to define measurable outcomes and best practices that embed sustainability as a core design principle rather than an afterthought.

0.15

Beyond FAIR: A Fitness Function Framework for Sustainable Research Software

cs.SE cs.CR ·2026-10-07 ·Irdin Pekaric, Philipp Zech
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Research software sustainability is often assessed through the FAIR principles: findability, accessibility, interoperability and reusability. While important, FAIR does not cover all relevant sustainability concerns. Research software should also be environmentally responsible and secure over time. Excessive resource consumption increases environmental cost, while insecure software creates maintenance overhead, technical debt and barriers to reuse. To this end, in this paper, we extend a previously proposed fitness function framework for sustainable research software beyond FAIR. We introduce two additional sets of fitness functions: environmental functions targeting resource efficiency and execution footprint, and security functions targeting dependency health, vulnerability exposure and secure configuration. Together, these functions broaden continuous software assessment from FAIR compliance to a more complete view of sustainability. The resulting framework treats research software sustainability as a multidimensional property that includes FAIR, environmental responsibility and long-term security.

0.18

Developer Attitudes and Practices Towards Optimizing Software Energy Consumption

cs.SE ·2026-08-31 ·Max Weber, Alina Mailach, Florian Sattler, Sven Apel, Norbert Siegmund
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 36 pages, journal paper

Context: Software significantly influences the efficiency with which hardware resources are utilized, yet software energy consumption is seldom treated as a first-class concern in day-to-day development practice. Objective: This study investigates professional developers' attitudes, decision-making, and development practices related to software energy consumption, with particular emphasis on how energy considerations are recognized, assessed, and acted upon during software development. Method: To this end, we conduct an online survey with 134 software developers. Our study combines quantitative analyses with a qualitative open-card sorting of free-text responses to characterize perceptions, practices, and reasoning patterns around energy consumption. Findings: Energy consumption is explicitly considered in only a minority of projects. More commonly, developers influence energy use indirectly by optimizing proxy properties such as execution time and CPU utilization. Responses to scenario-based questions reveal systematic blind spots in this mental model, including cases in which performance improvements increase energy consumption or exhibit no correlation. We also identify organizational disincentives, limited tooling, and educational gaps as major barriers to adoption. Implications: (1) Institutionalize energy-aware approaches through visible flagship deployments that demonstrate value, (2) expand research and education on energy-performance trade-offs, and (3) develop practical, developer-oriented measurement and feedback tools that lower adoption barriers.

0.26

From Prompting to Engineering: A Research Agenda for Prompt Engineering in Software Engineering

cs.SE ·2026-09-02 ·Vincenzo De Martino, Giovanna Broccia, Fabiano Pecorelli, Jennifer Horkoff, Riccardo Coppola +4 more
top venue similarity 0.55
Abstract

Prompt engineering is increasingly used across Software Engineering (SE) activities, including requirements analysis, coding, testing, documentation, repository analysis, and planning. Yet prompts and related instruction artifacts are often created and evolved through task-specific and informal practices, with limited support for their systematic evaluation, management, traceability, and governance. To examine how SE can contribute to the maturation of these practices, we organized a structured community discussion at the First International Workshop on Empirical Prompt Engineering for Software Engineering (PROMPT-SE), co-located with EASE 2026. Participants discussed current prompting practices, challenges to their adoption and evaluation, and future directions for integrating prompt engineering into software development. We synthesized these discussions into five areas: prompt artifacts and standardization; evaluation and benchmarking; lifecycle integration; human-AI collaboration and skills; and governance, privacy, and technical debt. Based on these areas, we outline a research agenda to move prompt engineering from predominantly ad hoc interactions toward more systematic, maintainable, evaluable, traceable, and governable SE practices.

0.68

Systematic Detection of Energy Regressions in Software Version Histories

cs.SE ·2026-10-14 ·Jérôme Maquoi, François Bechet, Luís Cruz, Benoît Vanderose, Xavier Devroey
similarity 0.55
Abstract · 17 pages, 4 figures, submitted to Information and Software Technology journal

Context: Green software engineering is emerging as a crucial response to the rising energy impact of information technology, especially in continuous development. However, challenges remain in devising automated methods to efficiently identify energy regressions across commits. In particular, little effort has been put into automatically detecting regressions at the commit level by identifying statistically significant changes in energy consumption. Objectives: This paper presents EnergyTrackr, an approach for detecting energy regressions across multiple commits. Methods: We empirically evaluated EnergyTrackr on 1,932 commits from five Java projects, assessing its ability to identify significant energy changes. We also compared a straightforward linear algorithm that analyzes the entire commit history with a more efficient dichotomous search algorithm. Results: The evaluation demonstrates the effectiveness of EnergyTrackr in identifying significant energy changes across commits. Our findings highlight the efficiency of the dichotomous algorithm in uncovering overall software energy trends, achieving results comparable to the linear approach while reducing resource consumption and processing time. Conclusion: We expect EnergyTrackr to help developers accurately monitor energy regressions and improvements in their projects and optimize their source code to reduce software energy consumption.

0.19

From Smarter to Hungrier: the Role of Energy Efficiency in Software-defined Vehicles

cs.SE ·2026-09-18 ·Ella Peltonen
published similarity 0.55
Abstract · Accepted in the 9th Annual Conference on Technology Ethics (TETHICS 2026), Lahti, Finland, November 11-12, 2026

Automated features and advanced driving support systems have enabled a range of life-saving and comfort applications in modern personal vehicles. Development from mostly mechanical entities towards truly software-defined devices also means that added sensor complexity, processing power, and networking capabilities provide a platform for running even more complex algorithms and applications. As vehicles become smarter, they require even more energy to enable advanced machine learning- and artificial intelligence-based functionalities. This paper discusses the implications for sustainability and the threats to environmental ethics posed by the development of software-defined vehicles. We discuss the balance between introducing more resource-hungry software and hardware components and their effect on society and sustainability. We underscore the need for novel tools to measure, manage, and optimise energy consumption and other sustainability indicators, with design guidance and actionable recommendations.

0.28