CS Paper Radar

Practice Makes (Im)Perfect: A Look Back at Benchmarking Practices for Microarchitectural Side-Channel Attacks

Iliana Fayolle, Antoine Geimer, Daniel De Almeida Braga, Clémentine Maurice

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-09-03 14:12 UTC · v3
top venuesurvey

Abstract

Microarchitectural side-channel research has grown at an exceptional pace in recent years, increasing the need for rigorous and meaningful benchmarking. Early attack papers typically relied on indirect proxies, such as covert-channel bandwidth or key-recovery on naive AES and RSA implementations, setting de facto standards that many subsequent works continued to replicate, sometimes by directly comparing against raw numbers from prior work. While these practices offer convenient points of comparison, current benchmarks may not be the most relevant to assess specific properties of new primitives. Even more problematic, microarchitectural attacks are notoriously sensitive to experimental conditions: minimal changes in the target system can significantly alter outcomes and performance. As a result, inadequate evaluation practices undermine reproducibility and cast doubt on the relevance of comparisons, even in top-tier venues where such issues should be identified. This paper tackles the core problem of proper benchmarking for microarchitectural side-channel attacks and examines its broader impact on research quality in the field. We survey 83 attack papers published in top-ranked security and architecture conferences from 2014 to 2024. From this corpus, we identify and define 19 recurrent benchmarking flaws that affect evaluation completeness, relevance, soundness, and reproducibility. These flaws include unfair or absent comparisons, missing code or materials, and the failure to evaluate the key attack properties. On average, each paper exhibits 5.72 such flaws, highlighting how widespread the issue is, even in highly selective venues. Based on our findings, we identify and suggest key properties that are relevant to properly evaluate new attacks. We also highlight trends over time and different practices between security and architecture conferences.

DOI
10.1145/3830454.3846555

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

ANTMAN: An Efficient and Interpretable RTL-Level Run-Time Detection Framework for Stealthy Branch Predictor Attacks on BOOM

cs.CR ·2026-08-10 ·Muhammad Hassan, Sharjeel Imtiaz, Maria Mushtaq, Jaan Raik, Tara Ghasempouri
similarity 0.69
Abstract

Runtime detection of microarchitectural side channel attacks remains significantly underexplored in RISCV compared with x86 and ARM ISAs, posing a serious threat to critical applications. State-of-the-art branch predictor attacks bypass traditional data and instruction caches by directly exploiting the state of internal history tables, making them inherently stealthy. Recent research has explored offline detection of microarchitectural attacks on RISC-V; however, efficient runtime detection of microarchitectural attacks on RISC-V hardware remains significantly unaddressed. State-of-the-art hardware-based runtime detection solutions leverage hardware performance counters (HPCs) but suffer from a restricted set of counter registers and tradeoffs between detection accuracy, detection speed, and sampling granularity, making them impractical for stealthy attacks. Moreover, sampling HPCs after distinct intervals leaves intermediate relationships between different microarchitectural blocks unobserved. Additionally, proprietary x86 and ARM ISAs constrain researchers from modifying processor microarchitectural designs. To address these limitations, we propose the first secure-by-design, highly interpretable, non-intrusive, RTL-level runtime detection solution for stealthy branch predictor attacks on BOOM RISC-V, evaluated under both simplified Next-Line Predictor (NLP) and complex TAGE predictor configurations. The attack detection relies on association rules extracted offline and embedded in hardware as a non-intrusive rule monitor that enables runtime detection. The proposed approach achieves excellent detection speed, terminates execution before secret disclosure, and produces zero false positives while remaining flexible for detecting previously unseen variants within the same family of branch predictor attacks.

0.04

Foundations of Hardware-Software Leakage Contracts

cs.CR cs.AR ·2026-10-14 ·Jan Reineke
published similarity 0.63
Abstract · Author's manuscript. Final publication is available at Springer via https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-981-95-8617-2_4

Microarchitectural attacks such as Spectre and Meltdown undermine security by exploiting software-visible side effects of microarchitectural optimizations like caches and speculative execution. To use modern hardware securely, programmers must take into account the security implications of these optimizations. Yet instruction set architectures (ISAs)---the conventional abstraction layer between hardware and software---are ill-suited for secure programming: by design, they abstract from microarchitectural details and therefore fail to reflect their security consequences. A new security abstraction is emerging to fill this void: hardware-software leakage contracts. To support the principled development of secure software on modern hardware such contracts characterize side-channel leakage at the ISA level. Thereby they enable programmers and compilers to generate code that is provably resistant to side-channel attacks---without having to explicitly reason about the microarchitecture. On the other hand, they provide a specification for hardware designers to ensure that microarchitectures do not introduce unintended and undocumented side channels. This paper introduces the foundations of this emerging topic, discussing recent contributions and unresolved challenges along the way.

0.28

EVAX: Towards a Practical, Pro-active & Adaptive Architecture for High Performance & Security

cs.CR ·2026-11-08 ·Samira Mirbagher Ajorpaz, Daniel Moghimi, Jeffrey Neal Collins, Gilles Pokam, Nael Abu-Ghazaleh +1 more
top venuehighly cited similarity 0.63
Abstract · Author manuscript of 2022 55th IEEE/ACM International Symposium on Microarchitecture (MICRO), pp. 1218-1236 (2022). 19 pages

This paper provides an end-to-end solution to defend against known microarchitectural attacks such as speculative execution attacks, fault-injection attacks, covert and side channel attacks, and unknown or evasive versions of these attacks. Current defenses are attack specific and can have unacceptably high performance overhead. We propose an approach that reduces the overhead of state-of-art defenses by over 95%, by applying defenses only when attacks are detected. Many current proposed mitigations are not practical for deployment; for example, InvisiSpec has 27% overhead and Fencing has 74% overhead while protecting against only Spectre attacks. Other mitigations carry similar performance penalties. We reduce the overhead for InvisiSpec to 1.26% and for Fencing to 3.45% offering performance and security for not only spectre attacks but other known transient attacks as well, including the dangerous class of LVI and Rowhammer attacks, as well as covering a large set of future evasive and zero-day attacks. Critical to our approach is an accurate detector that is not fooled by evasive attacks and that can generalize to novel zero-day attacks. We use a novel Generative framework, Evasion Vaccination (EVAX) for training ML models and engineering new security-centric performance counters. EVAX significantly increases sensitivity to detect and classify attacks in time for mitigation to be deployed with low false positives (4 FPs in every 1M instructions in our experiments). Such performance enables efficient and timely mitigations, enabling the processor to automatically switch between performance and security as needed.

0.71

ProcReverser: Multi-Agent Black-Box Microarchitectural Reverse Engineering for Processor Vulnerability Analysis

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-11-16 ·Guanqi Lyu, Decheng Qiu, Guangyang Zhang, Fei Zhao, Zhaojun Lu +2 more
similarity 0.62
Abstract · Corrected an author affiliation

When processor implementation details are unavailable, black-box microarchitectural reverse engineering helps security researchers identify hardware conditions related to security vulnerabilities. However, this process requires substantial manual effort to design experiments, develop test programs, and analyze results for each processor. We present ProcReverser, a multi-agent system that automates this process. ProcReverser uses execution feedback to improve experimental plans and test programs and identifies microarchitectural properties from measurements. We develop a comprehensive suite of property identification tasks focused on hardware mechanisms relevant to Spectre-class attacks, covering speculative execution, branch prediction, memory dependence, and cache behavior. We evaluate ProcReverser on the XuanTie C910, the gem5 RISC-V O3 CPU model, and the SiFive P550. ProcReverser achieves Pass@1 and Pass@5 scores of 81.3% and 93.8%, respectively, on C910, and 83.0% and 100.0% on gem5 O3. On the SiFive P550, ProcReverser further characterizes microarchitectural properties covered by the proposed task suite. These findings highlight the potential of automated microarchitectural reverse engineering to support processor vulnerability analysis and defense evaluation.

0.36

SLAC: Access-Driven CPU-to-GPU Side-channel Attacks via System-Level Cache on Apple Silicon

cs.CR cs.AR ·2026-08-10 ·Tianhong Xu, Saion K. Roy, Ruyi Ding, Aidong Adam Ding, Yunsi Fei
top venue similarity 0.61
Abstract · Accepted to ACM CCS 2026. 15 pages

Modern heterogeneous System-on-Chip designs integrate CPU cores and a GPU that share a last-level cache (LLC) or system-level cache (SLC). This sharing exposes a new cross-domain attack surface, and existing attacks on integrated platforms either exploit coarse-grained cache-occupancy contention or require the adversary to co-reside on the GPU with the victim to obtain accurate timing measurements. In this work, we target Apple Silicon heterogeneous SoCs and discover that GPU memory accesses leave set-level footprints in the shared SLC, observable to an unprivileged CPU process. This keen observation enables the first fine-grained, access-driven, Prime+Probe-style CPU-to-GPU cache side-channel attacks against GPU workloads. We first reverse-engineer the Apple M1 SLC set-indexing functions and the interactions between local private caches and the SLC. Building on these findings, we construct the CPrime+CProbe SLC side-channel technique, which monitors GPU victim activity from the CPU at cache-set granularity. We then introduce an accelerated variant, GPrime+CProbe, in which an adversary leverages the GPU for faster SLC priming, yielding a 6.4x increase in the covert-channel throughput. Lastly, we demonstrate two end-to-end privacy attacks using the new side-channels: a graph-edge reconstruction attack on Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) that achieves 90% edge accuracy across five datasets, and an LLM privacy attack that recovers input keywords with up to 94.8% accuracy and model responses with up to 88.9% accuracy across TinyLlama and GPT-2 Medium models. Our results reveal a new class of microarchitectural vulnerabilities in Apple Silicon and call for secure system cache designs for heterogeneous SoCs.

0.37

Exploiting Per-Core Leakage: Electromagnetic Side-Channel Monitoring of Multicore Architectures

cs.CR ·2026-08-28 ·Daehyeon Bae, Sujin Park, Insup Lee, YoungGiu Jung, Kyeongsik Lee +2 more
published similarity 0.61
Abstract · 7 pages, 9 figures. Accepted at the 63rd ACM/IEEE Design Automation Conference (DAC 2026)

Multicore processors are increasingly adopted in embedded systems to meet growing performance demands. However, physical side-channel analysis of multicore architectures remains underexplored, as obtaining usable leakage is inherently challenging. Consequently, side-channel security research on such systems has lagged far behind, leaving a critical security gap. To address this gap, we reveal the electromagnetic leakage mechanisms in multicore architectures and, for the first time, demonstrate per-core leakage exploitation, thereby enabling physical side-channel analysis for these systems. As a practical extension, we present a non-intrusive side-channel monitoring method that achieves per-core granularity. To validate its feasibility and practicality, we implement a prototype on a heterogeneous SoC platform with an RF front-end, and evaluate on a commercial off-the-shelf quad-core embedded system, the Raspberry Pi 4B with ARM Cortex-A72 cores.

0.37

Side-Channel Analysis of the RP2350 Challenge 2

cs.CR ·2026-11-19 ·Nikhil Tattikota, Vincent Immler
similarity 0.61
Abstract · 7 pages, 12 figures

Bug bounty programs and community challenges have become an established mechanism to incentivize collective action to improve security. In essence, these can be considered as crowd-sourcing mechanisms where participants carry the risk twice over: performing the work in addition to having it officially accepted, which at times can be tied to unacceptable terms. Consequently, independent assessments and publications that are free from third party obligations remain important to highlight deficiencies in implementations of public significance. We consider the RP2350 side-channel analysis challenge and its hardened Advanced Encryption Standard (AES) implementation to be of reasonable importance to justify such an approach, especially so since the presented challenge remained unsolved for more than a year. In our paper, we present our analysis, demonstrating comprehensive leakage detection, plaintext dependence, and key extraction from the challenge implementation. Our work presents concerning weaknesses in the implementation that contradict the challenge authors' claims. We hope by openly sharing this analysis to motivate further public scrutiny.

0.40

Exploiting Decompression Latency for Covert Channels in Inter-Line-Compressed LLCs

cs.AR ·2026-09-23 ·David K. Oh, Hiroshi Sasaki
top venue similarity 0.58
Abstract · 4 pages, 1 figure. Accepted for publication in IEEE Computer Architecture Letters

The recently proposed XOR cache is an inter-line-compressed last-level cache (LLC) that leverages the data-inclusion relationship between the private caches and the LLC, compressing two cache lines into one by XORing them. The architecture relies on the cache coherence protocol for data decompression. In this paper, we demonstrate that this mechanism - specifically the latency asymmetry between a cache hit on an uncompressed vs. compressed line - introduces microarchitectural vulnerabilities. Based on this observation, we propose a covert channel attack targeting the XOR cache. A colluding sender controls the receiver's access latency by triggering decompression through targeted write requests to partner cache lines. By exploiting the data-dependent compression behavior of the XOR cache, the sender and receiver establish the channel using pre-agreed data values. The channel achieves higher bandwidth than the Prime+Probe baseline for two reasons: first, each bit is encoded in the compression state of an individual line rather than the occupancy of a cache set, so a single set carries multiple bits; second, each bit is resolved by manipulating coherence-protocol state rather than forcing shared-cache evictions, so it costs fewer LLC accesses and demand misses than Prime+Probe. Full-system simulations show a bandwidth of 2.9 Mbps at an observed 0.98% bit-error rate (BER) over 50,000 transmitted bits, 13.1 times the bandwidth of Prime+Probe under the same sub-1%-BER selection rule.

0.45