CS Paper Radar

Safety Monitors Mostly Catch What the Model Already Refuses

Sripad Karne

cs.CL ·submitted 2026-09-05 01:19 UTC · v3

Abstract

Safety monitors are evaluated by recall on harmful prompts, regardless of whether the target model would answer them. Yet a monitor matters most on the prompts the model does answer. We measure recall on exactly those prompts, defined by sampling the target model and judging its responses. Across four text guards, two activation probes, and Latent Guard, recall at a 1% false positive rate falls sharply on this subset: at a common threshold, every monitor catches the requests the model refuses 1.1 to 6.4 times as often as the requests it answers. Standard metrics hide this; AUROC stays above 0.85 for most monitors. Rewriting each request to be less explicit, with intent held fixed and verified, raises compliance 28-fold and lowers every monitor's flag rate. Of the requests newly answered after rewriting, 44 to 93% slip past the monitor, depending on which is used, and most of their completions are graded harmful. We trace the gap to explicitness itself. As wording softens with intent fixed, the target model's harm and refusal readings fall and it answers; the guards' harm readings fall too, and steering a guard along explicitness alone flips its verdict. Model and monitors miss the same prompts, and stacking monitors does not recover them. Fine-tuning a guard on the rewrites at every level of explicitness, on both sides of the label, raises recall on answered requests from .24 to .89 while transferring to unseen benchmarks; hard negatives, the natural alternative, teach the guard to discount indirect phrasing instead.

Comment
v3: substantially extended and retitled; v1 appeared as "Recall Is Not Protection: Evaluating Safety Monitors Against Model Compliance"(submitted to JUDGe workshop @ NeurIPS 2026)

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

System Prompts Affect Response Bias More Than Discriminability in LLM Safety

cs.LG cs.AIcs.CLcs.SE ·2026-11-08 ·Mohan W. Gupta, Sandy Tanwisuth
benchmarkposition similarity 0.73
Abstract · 23 pages, 4 figures

Large language model safety evaluations often focus on a compliance-refusal tradeoff: models should refuse unsafe requests without refusing safe ones. We argue that this misses a broader form of prompt-conditioned task selection, where the same request can elicit different behaviors depending on the system prompt. We investigate this using a controlled evaluation crossing eight safety-task prompt families with three clarity levels across HarmBench, XSTest, and IHEval. Holding benchmark items fixed, we evaluate 13 models and use signal detection theory to distinguish two possibilities: whether models become better at telling safe from unsafe requests (discriminability), or simply more willing to refuse (response criterion). We find substantial differences in discriminability across models, but system prompts primarily shift the willingness to refuse, with smaller and less consistent effects on discriminability. Increasing prompt clarity makes models more willing to refuse without reliably improving their ability to distinguish safe from unsafe requests. Beyond refusal, prompt families also shift responses among six distinct behavioral policies, including clarification and safe help. Together, these findings show that system prompts primarily change how models respond to safety-relevant requests rather than consistently improving their ability to distinguish safe from unsafe ones.

0.20

Faithful Latent Harm Monitors Work No Better Than the Models Own Behaviour at a Matched False Alarm Rate

cs.AI ·2026-10-22 ·Abhishek Mishra, Sagnik Chatterjee, Suyash Maniyar
similarity 0.70
Abstract

Large language models have been reported to encode the harmfulness of a request separately from their decision to refuse it, and latent safety monitors such as Latent Guard build on this report by classifying prompts as harmful from the internal activations of the model, with the aim of catching harmful intent even when the model complies. Whether these representations give a signal of harm that survives distribution shift and is independent of model behaviour is unclear. We test this on out-of-distribution prompts made by rewriting existing harmful and benign requests with surface rewording, persuasive framing and jailbreak-style wrappers. Across 15 instruction-tuned LLMs and 38 activation-based readers, we compare harm detection with that of TF-IDF and sentence-embedding classifiers, with independently trained safety classifiers, and with the refusal of each model. Activations are read at the last token of the user instruction, where the model has read the whole request, and at the last chat-template token before the reply, where the planned response can be represented. Because models disagree about which prompts to refuse, we can separate a signal of the harmfulness of the prompt from a signal of the refusal decision of the model. At the end of the instruction, the representation is largely independent of the refusal behaviour of each model but degrades under distribution shift, so that a TF-IDF classifier ranks harm better than the original Latent Guard in every model we test, and linear and MLP probes do about as well as sentence-embedding classifiers trained on the same examples. The representation just before generation detects more, catching 44 percent of harmful prompts at a matched false-alarm rate against 32 percent for the refusal of the model, but that gain follows the refusal decision itself, and part of it comes from refusals that string-matching evaluation misses.

0.15

Recoverability-Controlled Safety Miscalibration in Large Language Models

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-10-15 ·Yuwei Wang, Xingwang Liang, Yu Xie, Haotian Chi, Haijun Geng
top venuebenchmark similarity 0.69
Abstract · Accepted at EMNLP 2026 (Main)

Safety-aligned language models are expected to refuse harmful requests while remaining useful for benign ones. However, because many evaluations score only the final response, they often conflate intent understanding with response-level safety behavior. To address this, we introduce RiskCueBench, a recoverability-controlled benchmark that separates these two stages by first measuring whether a model can successfully recover a high-level intent and then evaluating its safety behavior on the same prompt. RiskCueBench contains 160 latent intents and 640 abstract non-operational surface prompts across eight risk categories. The benchmark covers 25 completed model groups and 32,000 successful model outputs with final rubric-adjudicated labels. When conditioning on pairs where both surface forms are recoverable, we find that increased contextualized specificity induces a shift toward less safe behavior. Specifically, paired bootstrap estimates show that the refusal rate and global safety score decrease by 0.175 and 0.440, respectively. Furthermore, mixed effects modeling corroborates a 0.107 increase in unsafe cooperation. These results show that the safety behavior can be miscalibrated to the surface form even after the intent has been recovered, motivating safety evaluations that report response behavior conditional on semantic recoverability.

0.39

SameFact: The Same Safety Facts Lead to Different Responses Across Interfaces

cs.CR ·2026-09-26 ·Dongsheng Chen, Jiaxin Zhang, Lei Ma, Xin Yao, Xuetao Wei
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract

Safety evaluations often ask whether a model recognizes that an action is unsafe, whereas agent evaluations ask what the model chooses to do. Using safety judgments as evidence about action selection therefore raises a measurement question: does the influence of the same safety-relevant fact persist across response interfaces? We introduce SameFact, a matched-counterfactual benchmark that tests this question directly. SameFact contains 300 safe/unsafe pairs that hold the task, prior observations, candidate action, identifiers, and non-target facts fixed while changing a single state-grounded safety fact. Across six LLM backbones, we measure the effect of this matched intervention through three interfaces at the same candidate-action boundary: explicit safety judgment, checkpoint candidate admission, and open first-action selection. All six backbones show lower aggregate sensitivity under open first-action selection than under judgment, but the change is not a uniform attenuation: across 24 model-factor cells, Spearman agreement falls from 0.817 between judgment and checkpoint admission to 0.470 between judgment and open first-action selection, while pairwise ordering disagreement rises from 18.5% to 32.6%. A follow-up 2x2 first-response experiment shows that a checkpoint-style protocol increases measured sensitivity in all six backbones by 8.4-29.3 percentage points, whereas action-space effects and their interactions with protocol vary in magnitude and direction across models. These results show that the response interface is part of the measured quantity: judgment and action interfaces share safety signal, but do not provide interchangeable measurements of how safety-relevant facts shape model responses.

0.18

Same Outcome, Different Evidence: Intent Recovery in LLM Safety Evaluation

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-10-08 ·Haitong Jiang, Chunlin Liu, Sihan Tang, Chan Wu, Xiaoqing Su +1 more
code/data similarity 0.66
Abstract · 12 pages, 2 figures. Code and experiment inputs: https://github.com/kevinjiang0121-cyber/IRIS

Safety evaluations of large language models commonly summarize harmful-output behavior with attack success rate (ASR). Yet the same non-harmful outcome can arise for very different reasons. A model may recover a harmful task and refuse it, fail to recover the task, or respond to something else entirely. Distinguishing these cases becomes especially important under intent-obscuring prompts, where a low ASR does not reveal whether the evaluated task was actually engaged. To make this distinction explicit, we pair ASR with operative understanding rate (UR), which measures whether a response both identifies the evaluated task and treats it as the task to be answered. Across interfaces, this paired view reveals substantial variation hidden by ASR: similar ASR values can correspond to sharply different recovery rates. Controlled English reconstructions show that recovery consistently improves as compressed prompts become more explicit, whereas ASR does not follow the same pattern. A complementary contrast comes from FormalLogic, where high recovery can still coincide with frequent harmful assistance. Together, these results show that non-harmful outcomes are not equally informative about model safety, motivating the joint reporting of intent recovery and ASR in LLM safety evaluation. Code and experiment inputs are available at https://github.com/kevinjiang0121-cyber/IRIS.

0.40

From Probe Scores to Alarm Policies: Operational Validity of Activation Monitors for Language-Model Agents

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-10-03 ·Xueping Gao
top venuehighly cited similarity 0.66
Abstract · 12 pages, 1 figure. Accepted at the Eighth International Conference on Distributed Artificial Intelligence (DAI 2026)

Activation probes can predict safety-relevant properties of language models with high area under the receiver-operating-characteristic curve (AUROC), but deployed agent monitors make thresholded alarm decisions under tight false-alarm budgets. These are different estimands. We introduce an Operational Validity Contract that fixes a monitor's target, observability, identity, timing, intervention unit, comparator, calibration, and cost. We formalize risk at the semantic request or trajectory level: when one task contains repeated alarm opportunities, row-level AUROC and false positive rate do not identify semantic-unit any-alarm risk. A confidence-certified threshold also requires enough independent negative units, a tie-safe rule, and transport to deployment. Across Models Under Pressure, LASR refusal prediction, immutable AgentDojo, and a prospectively protocol-frozen ST-WebAgentBench replication, joint activation-observable monitors reach AUROC 0.957 and 0.935 on the first two benchmarks, yet their locked 5%/10% detection rates are only .642/.742 and .719/.782, respectively. On AgentDojo, the secondary mean-activation rollout monitor reaches AUROC 0.922 but detects none of 38 positive semantic cases at the locked 5% operating point; thresholds intended for 10% false alarms realize 18.7-20.0% on test. Because the test misses its prospectively frozen 40-positive support gate, we label it support-insufficient. On ST-WebAgentBench, activation reaches AUROC .874, but 23 independent calibration negatives cannot identify even a 10% controller; the locked policy abstains rather than reporting its mechanical zero FPR as a success. An exploratory counterexample also lowers full AUROC while improving realized 10% utility. The fail-closed compiler caps MUP and LASR at restricted predictive value and AgentDojo and ST-Web at representation accessibility; no setting reaches alarm-policy validity.

0.67

Separating Prompt Harmfulness from Interaction Safety via Partial Generation

cs.AI cs.IRcs.LG ·2026-10-12 ·Ram Vikas Mishra, Shashank Aggarwal, Jahnavi Kumar, Amit Awekar
hot direction similarity 0.65
Abstract

LLM-based information systems need safety guardrails. Most guardrails classify the prompt alone. If the prompt looks harmful, the system rejects it before any answer is generated. This is costly. Many rejected prompts would have received a safe response. Users lose help they should have received from the information system. This cost grows as conversational and generative search becomes common. Prompt-level labels treat harm as a property of the query. But harm depends on what the model actually writes. Existing input-output guards do look at responses. But they judge a finished response, so the decision comes after full generation. However, we observe that safety of model interaction with the input prompt can be inferred early with only partial output. So the system can start generating, watch the partial response, and stop only if it turns harmful. We test this idea in three steps. First, we build a dataset of 41,944 prompt-response pairs with seven open weights LLMs from three families: Llama, Gemma, and Qwen. Second, we show that prompt harmfulness and interaction safety differ. Prompt labels and response labels agree on only 50.46\% of items (Cohen's $κ$ = 0.06). Of the prompts that make any model respond harmfully, only 3.5\% do so for all seven LLMs. Third, we show that partial responses carry most of the signal. Fine-tuned classifiers predict response-level harm well (best AUPRC 0.885, F1 0.807). About one third of the response tokens recover almost full-response AUPRC.

0.27

REA: From Correct LLM Judgments to Safe Decision Delivery

cs.AI ·2026-10-12 ·Jingxiang Meng, Aofan Liu, Yaoshuai Ma, Fangxin Liu, Yongbiao Chen
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Generative safety guards must classify requests correctly and return outputs that applications can parse. Reasoning guards can improve classification accuracy while producing outputs that applications cannot parse. When applications cannot extract a correct prediction, fallback handling can allow harmful requests or block safe ones. We introduce Resolve--Express--Act (REA), a framework that traces judgments through parsing and fallback to application actions. Experiments on classifiers and safety guards show that correct predictions can appear in incorrectly formatted outputs. Parsing the safety verdict preserves the reasoning guard's accuracy advantage, while stricter explanation requirements reject additional correct predictions. Accepting formatting variations recovers most rejected correct predictions. Held-out tests confirm that output requirements and generation limits affect whether correct predictions can be parsed. In our fail-open replay, matching the parser to the output and fixing formatting reduced the fraction of harmful requests allowed despite correct guard judgments from 95.5% to 0%. A fixed-output comparison shows that model-based extraction can preserve guard verdicts, but is not automatically reliable; deterministic normalization already repairs the observed native-format failures. Fallback replay shows that the same correct prediction can lead to different safety actions depending on the parser and fallback policy, including allowing requests the guard correctly identifies as harmful.

0.22