CS Paper Radar

Monadic Second-Order Logic in HOL: Deep and Shallow with Automated Faithfulness (Extended Preprint)

Christoph Benzmueller, Daniel Kirchner

cs.LO cs.AImath.LO ·submitted 2026-09-07 11:09 UTC · v3
publishedtheory

Abstract

In Isabelle/HOL, we apply the deep-and-shallow embedding methodology of our prior work to monadic second-order logic (MSO). Three embeddings are developed side by side: a deep embedding (an inductive datatype with an explicit satisfaction relation); a maximal-shallow embedding that translates the connectives and quantifiers directly into HOL, carrying the interpretation and both assignments explicitly; and a minimal-shallow embedding -- a locale that fixes those parameters, collapsing the formula type to bool. The enabling new ingredient is a two-sorted substitution apparatus -- capture-avoiding substitution, renaming, and a substitution lemma per namespace -- in which each binder is transparent for the other; faithfulness of all three embeddings is mechanised and largely automated. Our central contribution is a fully mechanised two-sorted downward Loewenheim-Skolem theorem: the minimal embedding recovers deep validity relative to the (countable) assignment ranges, and this range-relative reading is shown to coincide with the general (Henkin-style) reading of MSO, whereas the standard reading validates strictly more formulas, witnessed by comprehension. Both readings are nonetheless recovered from the minimal embedding, differing only in the admitted interpretations: all of them for the general reading, only the elementary substructures of the full model for the standard. We exercise the embeddings on classical MSO landmarks: the Boolean-closure and graph schemata hold under the full second-order domain yet fail in the minimal embedding, making the dichotomy concrete, while reachability and 2-colorability are refuted throughout.

Comment
38 pages. Extended version -- with the full two-sorted Loewenheim-Skolem proof (Appendix A) and the rendered Isabelle/HOL theory sources (Appendix B) -- of a contribution accepted to a Festschrift for David Basin (Springer LNCS); the proceedings version is 19 pages. The Isabelle/HOL formalisation is published in the Archive of Formal Proofs: https://isa-afp.org/entries/MSOinHOL.html

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

A Taxonomy of Predicate Transformer Monads for Specifying Monadic Programs

cs.PL ·2026-10-16 ·Abigail Pribisova, Yao Li, Cezar-Constantin Andrici, Catalin Hritcu, Kenji Maillard +1 more
similarity 0.66
Abstract · Submitted to ESOP'27, in v2 same PDF but fixed author order in metadata

Monads of weakest precondition predicate transformers are the foundation of several verification frameworks for monadic programs. For specifying monadic computations with nondeterminism and nontermination, in addition to weakest preconditions, we introduce the first strongest postcondition monads covering all combinations of angelic or demonic nondeterminism and partial or total interpretations of nontermination. For extending these base strongest postcondition monads with side effects such as mutable state, monad transformers do not yield the expected monads, so we instead generalize the base monads to arrows and use arrow transformers. We give a taxonomy of weakest precondition and strongest postcondition monads, for the base monads and for their versions with state, and show that the known relationships between under- and over-approximate triples based on predicate transformers already hold at the level of the predicate transformers themselves. We use the predicate transformer monads to define under- and over-approximate triples and, where possible, Dijkstra monads. Finally, we relate these two specification styles.

0.06

Tracking relevance syntactically: A nested approach to weak relevant logic

cs.LO ·2026-11-12 ·Fabio De Martin Polo, Han Gao
theory similarity 0.62
Abstract

The variable-sharing property (VSP) is regarded as a key feature of relevant logics, while the Craig interpolation property (CIP), formulated with respect to relevant implication, implies the VSP in constant-free propositional languages. However, to the best of our knowledge, no constant-free distributive relevant logic has previously been shown to enjoy the CIP. This absence of positive results has contributed to a widespread impression among relevant logicians that relevance and Craig interpolation are incompatible. In this work, we address this tension by proving that the negation-free fragment of base relevant logic B, denoted B+, enjoys both properties. Our proof is purely syntactic and is based on a novel nested sequent calculus featuring binary relevant blocks as primitive structural constructs. Unlike conventional nested sequent calculi, where unary nesting reflects the binary accessibility relation of Kripke semantics, our calculus employs a binary nesting operator that directly reflects the ternary relational structure of Routley-Meyer semantics for relevant logics. After establishing soundness and cut-free completeness of the calculus, we prove several meta-logical properties for the logic. Most notably, we provide the first syntactic proof of the VSP (along with a variety of its stronger variants) and the first proof of the CIP for B+, both derived directly from the cut-free system using a structural notion internalized within nested sequents.

0.26

Two-Variable Logic with Arbitrarily Many Successor Relations

cs.LO ·2026-10-07 ·Jakub Michaliszyn, Piotr Witkowski
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract

We study two-variable first-order logic with a finite, input-dependent number of distinguished successor relations and arbitrary additional unary and binary predicates. Each distinguished relation must be the exact immediate-successor relation of some linear order on the common domain; the orders themselves are not available in the language and may have arbitrary order types. We prove that satisfiability belongs to 2NEXPTIME, uniformly in the number of successors. The proof gives finite certificates for possibly infinite models. A closure operation separates local neighbourhood descriptions, called star types, into those of bounded multiplicity and those that can be realized infinitely often. The bounded part is represented explicitly. Outside it, integer height vectors allow overlapping successor requirements to be matched without creating cycles or unintended identifications. Ordering the resulting path components densely then recovers exact successor relations. Consistent assignments of the additional binary predicates handle witnesses involving the bounded part. The same certificates decide infinite satisfiability in 2NEXPTIME and give a doubly exponential threshold above which a finite model guarantees an infinite model. A doubly exponentially large finite core can be forced with only two successors and unary predicates. For finite models, we prove that satisfiability subject to a bound on the total number of reference adjacencies lost by the other orders is NEXPTIME-complete, even when the budget is encoded in binary and the number of successors is part of the input.

0.49

Internal Languages for Thin Epsilon-Hyperdoctrines: Soundness, Completeness, and Rocq Formalization

cs.LO math.LOmath.CT ·2026-10-10 ·Zoltán Gábor Molnár, Csaba Tóth
code/data similarity 0.60
Abstract · 41 pages, 1 figure. Rocq formalization: https://github.com/mozow01/HyperLogic

We present a typed proof-term calculus for intuitionistic intensional first-order logic with Hilbert's epsilon-operator and prove its soundness and completeness with respect to hyperdoctrinal models with thin bicartesian closed setoid categories (BiCCCs) as fibres and formula-indexed witness selections. The calculus provides an explicit internal language for these epsilon-hyperdoctrines: for each fixed typed signature, its syntactic term model is initial for syntax-indexed, interpretation-preserving model morphisms, with uniqueness up to setoid equality. The nested epsilon syntax is organized by a well-founded dependency relation on formula labels. Concrete countermodels exhibit failure of excluded middle and show that formula conversion need not identify the selected witnesses. We also compare the full calculus with its epsilon-free and epsilon-only fragments. The principal constructions and metatheorems are formalized in Rocq. With setoid BiCCCs, proof irrelevance is a choice of equality, not the erasure of proofs: the proofs and their categorical operations remain available as the basis for a future proof-relevant categorical semantics.

0.43

Whiel: A Neurosymbolic Platform for Certified Relational Program Verification

cs.DB cs.AIcs.LO ·2026-11-03 ·Jesse Comer, Fangzhu Shen, Shuo Zhang, Mayur Naik, Sudeepa Roy +1 more
benchmarktheory similarity 0.60
Abstract

We present the Whiel (a contraction of Whi(le-R)el) system for Lean-certified reasoning about imperative relational programs. The system can encode containment and equivalence problems for Datalog, its extensions with negation, and the core fragment of graph query languages. It can also represent optimized or incremental evaluation algorithms that are not expressible in the original query language, as well as first-order specifications of integrity constraints, schema mappings, and views arising in data integration, exchange, and sharing. Whiel's program states are database instances, and its imperative structure enables compositional Hoare-style reasoning with first-order relational specifications, using prophecy variables and leveled invariants to support inductive arguments. Whiel supports neurosymbolic discovery of loop invariants whose verification conditions can be checked using the Vampire first-order theorem prover. Counterexamples are fed back into the neurosymbolic pipeline, while proposed solutions are translated into Lean proof certificates. To validate the Whiel system, we evaluate its performance on a curated benchmark suite. In summary, we envision the Whiel system as a tool for tackling mathematically demanding, typically undecidable problems involving complex query and constraint languages, with a high degree of trust in its output.

0.24

Evidence-Carrying Transport Across Effects

cs.LO ·2026-11-13 ·Félix Castro, Liron Cohen, Ariel Grunfeld, Étienne Miquey
similarity 0.60
Abstract

A program logic proved sound against one effectful semantics need not remain sound when the effect is re-implemented, yet the semantic relationship between reasoning before and after a change of effect is usually left implicit and re-established by hand. This paper provides a uniform, proof-relevant account of it. Working in realizability, where a notion of computation determines a model whose entailments carry explicit program evidence, we introduce simulations between effectful realizability cores, generalizing Longley's applicative morphisms to computation over an arbitrary strong monad. A single simulation transports the source logic along a ladder: it induces a morphism of the associated evidenced frames and, functorially, of the induced triposes. These passages are $2$-fully-faithful, so the three levels agree and a change of effect carries the entire higher-order program logic together with the evidence witnessing each derivation. A computationally dense simulation moreover computes a modality on the source logic, a nucleus through which the transport factors and which marks exactly the reasoning stable under the change, read off from the translation rather than postulated. This recovers known examples such as the double-negation modality of classical realizability, and examples such as sheafification arise from a modal refinement of the construction. Overall, the framework makes a change of effect a first-class object, one that can be composed, factored through its modality, and shown in cases not to exist, opening a path to transporting verified reasoning across effects.

0.34

Comparing Call-by-Name and Call-by-Value Reduction and Reduction Strategies in Calculi for Classical Logic

cs.LO ·2026-08-12 ·Steffen van Bakel, David Davies
similarity 0.59
Abstract

We define call-by-name and call-by-value reduction and reduction strategies for the calculi slmu (symmetric lmu), lmmt, and Xs (X with implicit substitution). We establish a strong relation between these notions through defining a single interpretation from slmu to lmmt that respects normal reduction, as well as the call-by-name and call-by-value reduction in slmu within the their counterpart in lmmt; for the strategies, we will show similar, but weaker results. We also define a single mapping from lmmt to Xs, and show that this also respects all three notions. We then continue with studying the natural encoding of Xs into lmmt, and show that only full reduction is respected, but that reduction steps are needed to model substitution, so the CBN and CBV strategies cannot be respected. We conclude with studying the combination of our efforts and define an interpretation of slmu into Xs, and show that CBN and CBV reduction are respected. This result underlines that Xs and lmmt are similar, but different calculi, and that the nature of slmu makes that any encoding into either can never fully respect the strategies.

0.04

Two Variables and Two-Dimensional Structures

cs.LO ·2026-10-14 ·Bartosz Jan Bednarczyk, Daumantas Kojelis, Krzysztof Szymański
theory similarity 0.59
Abstract · 23 pages, 4 figures, 1 table. Under submission

We study the two-variable fragment FO^2 of first-order logic over two-dimensional structures. Formulae may employ two linear orders <=_1, <=_2, their successor relations S_1, S_2, and auxiliary predicates of any arity. Despite two decades of work, three cases of finite satisfiability in this setting were still open; we settle all three. First, finite satisfiability of FO^2 with one linear order and one successor relation, of the same or of a different order, is NExpTime-complete, even with arbitrary auxiliary predicates and constant symbols. This closes a gap left open by Manuel and Zeume (CSL 2013). As an application, a reduction based on swaps of adjacent elements shows that order-invariance and order-successor-invariance of FO^2 are coNExpTime-complete. This reproves the main result of Zeume and Harwath (LICS 2016) and settles their question on order-successor-invariance. Second, finite satisfiability of FO^2 with two linear orders is ExpSpace-hard, already without auxiliary non-unary predicates, matching the upper bound known since 2010. Our reduction combines Kieronski's encoding of alternating Turing machines with the classical fact that the pre-order and post-order traversals of a tree define its descendant relation. Third, with two linear orders and the successor of one of them, finite satisfiability is in ExpSpace even with arbitrary auxiliary predicates, improving the previous 2NExpTime bound and confirming a conjecture of Zeume and Harwath. Together with known results, our theorems show that in two dimensions, auxiliary (non-unary) predicates and constants come for free: with or without them, the complexities coincide. All our proofs are simple.

0.10