CS Paper Radar

What a Model Refuses, a State Fears: How Authoritarian Information Control Reproduces in Language-Model Guardrails

Menglin Liu, Yao Yu, Tong Wu, Ge Shi

cs.CY ·submitted 2026-09-07 13:53 UTC · v2

Abstract

As large language models increasingly mediate access to political information, their refusal behavior creates a new site of information control. We ask whether political distinctions identified in theories of authoritarian information control remain visible in model guardrails, and how their enforcement changes when implemented through general-purpose AI. Across ten models, we combine cross-model comparisons with within-model experiments that manipulate political referent, collective-action potential, and political valence. Aggregate differences in political refusal across developer origins are sensitive to model composition, but the within-model experiments reveal a more specific structure. Chinese-developed models are substantially more likely to refuse otherwise identical political requests when they concern China rather than foreign or fictional settings, and refusal responds more strongly to collective-action potential than to political valence, including for peaceful pro-government mobilization. Yet these political distinctions are enforced imperfectly: refusal extends to some low-coordination political criticism even though models can distinguish criticism from coordination; the form of non-compliance varies across languages; and high native refusal does not imply adversarial robustness. These findings show that general-purpose AI can preserve recognizable political boundaries while transforming the breadth, form, and robustness with which those boundaries are enforced. More broadly, they demonstrate why refusal rates alone provide an incomplete measure of political control in language models.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

How China-Origin Vision-Language Models Move from Refusal to Reframing in State Alignment

cs.CR cs.AIcs.CL ·2026-08-12 ·Guang Yang, Fengchen Liu, Alex Wang, Homa Hosseinmardi, Amir Ghasemian
benchmarkposition similarity 0.71
Abstract · 41 pages, 31 figures, 9 tables. Preprint

State-aligned distortion has been documented in China-origin text-based large language models (LLMs), but whether, and in what form, it arises in multimodal systems has not been systematically examined. We construct a balanced benchmark of 200 core entries spanning ten politically sensitive topics, plus a seven-variant visual-abstraction probe, and run nine vision-language models (VLMs), seven China-origin and two non-China, across four elicitation paradigms and two prompt languages, yielding 21,708 trials. Each response is audited on six dimensions -- explicit refusal, information integrity, visual grounding, state-aligned framing, language consistency, and response length -- by two independent frontier LLM judges, validated against three human experts on a 200-trial sample. Measuring each dimension separately lets us decompose multimodal censorship into individual signals rather than a single refusal-based score; in particular, refusal and framing are measured independently, so a model can stop refusing while still reframing. We find that (i) Chinese-language prompting roughly triples the odds of state-aligned framing, within every model; (ii) China-origin models reframe more than non-China models (direction robust across judges and human raters; magnitude 1.6--3.2x); (iii) the effect is strongest in text-only political commentary (36.5%) and is gated by recognition of the depicted subject rather than pixel detail, persisting even at silhouette for iconic images; and (iv) across four Qwen generations, state-aligned framing rises while explicit refusal falls: censorship migrates from a visible act (refusal) to an invisible one (fluent reframing). We argue this shift to invisible reframing is fundamentally a problem of human-AI interaction: it removes the very signal users rely on to recognize that information has been withheld.

0.44

PowerBench: Measuring Language Model Bias in Power-shifting Requests

cs.LG ·2026-10-01 ·Nicolas Martorell, Wendy Brau, Gonzalo A. Heredia, Tomás Pablo Korenblit, Gaspar Labastié +1 more
code/data similarity 0.67
Abstract

Language models increasingly assist people with power-related requests, so systematic differences in whom they help could shift the distribution of power at scale, or be exploited by users who learn which identities are refused less. We introduce PowerBench, an evaluation of power-shifting requests that distinguishes self-empowerment, disempowerment, and power grabbing, plus a control of refusal-inducing requests that shift no power. We build, curate, and open-source a dataset of such requests varying the power domain, the context, the scale of the affected party, and the prior power standing of the user, and evaluate 24 models (12 from US and 12 from Chinese developers) under three experimental conditions: reciprocal nationalities of user and affected party, an AI agent as the user, and 8 request languages. Models refuse power grabbing more than disempowerment, and disempowerment more than self-empowerment. Refusal of power grabbing rises with the scale of the affected party, from an individual to a society. Models are biased toward helping others take power from the US and against helping US users take power from others, but favor the US when it gains power and nobody loses it. When the user is an AI agent, refusal of power-shifting requests increases, especially in power grabbing against an individual. Finally, language biases refusal, but in model-specific ways that largely cancel on average. We release PowerBench to make these asymmetries measurable in current and future models.

0.29

We're Cooked! - Probing LLM Political Alignment Via Conflict-Framed Recipe Translation

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-09-07 ·Svetlana Gorovaia, Angelica Henestrosa, Ivan P. Yamshchikov
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly deployed for translation tasks, yet their implicit political positioning in such contexts remains understudied. We ask whether a single politically charged framing term, such as aggressor, enemy, neighbour, or coloniser is sufficient to trigger implicit political alignment in an otherwise apolitical task. We present a fully crossed factorial study in which eight models spanning Western, Chinese, and European origins are prompted to translate culturally attributed recipes into a target language left deliberately unspecified. Across 17 languages, four framing conditions, eight models, and 15,680 responses, we find that models do not simply decline or ask for clarification but resolve the ambiguity. Language resolution and reasoning behavior cluster meaningfully along model families: Western models hedge and deflect with vague justifications, Chinese models resolve conflicts silently, and Mistral Large emerges as a distinct profile combining high compliance with conflict-grounded reasoning. Sensitivity to framing terms is consistent across models: even subtle framing variation is sufficient to modulate behavior. Our findings urge caution when deploying LLMs for translation in conflict-adjacent contexts, where implicit political judgments may be made without any signal to the user.

0.31

A light-touch AI literacy intervention helps protect against AI political persuasion

cs.HC ·2026-09-14 ·Reed Orchinik, David Rand
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Conversations with large language models (LLMs) can substantially shift beliefs and attitudes, raising concerns about manipulation using AI persuasion. Here we test whether a light-touch AI literacy intervention - a brief warning that LLMs can be prompted to persuade and may present information selectively - helps protect users. Across two experiments (total N = 3,208 Americans) in which participants conversed with an LLM instructed to shift their views about different political topics, the presence of a warning reduced belief change by roughly one-half (-48.1%, 95% CI [-59.5%, -36.8%]) relative to the control. Importantly, the warning did not significantly reduce trust in generative AI more broadly. Light-touch literacy interventions can help protect users against AI political persuasion.

0.24

Navigating the digital spectrum: Assessing political bias, stability, and downstream fairness in Large Language Models

cs.CL cs.CY ·2026-09-08 ·Luka Debevc, Nishan Chatterjee, Antoine Doucet, Senja Pollak, Matej Martinc
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Large Language Models are increasingly deployed as information intermediaries, yet measuring their political behavior remains fragile because questionnaire results mix model dispositions with measurement artifacts and response-elicitation biases. We introduce a robust Political Compass Test evaluation framework that samples 300 configurations across an eight-dimensional perturbation space varying language, framing, instructions, answer format, option order, and persona wording. We evaluate eight Gemma 3 and Qwen 3 models across 14 languages and three quantization levels, obtaining design-averaged political coordinates with quantified uncertainty. Most models lean Libertarian-Left on average, but instruction phrasing, language, and answer format significantly affect recovered coordinates. Cross-lingual differences primarily reflect coordinate drift rather than distinct cultural reasoning. Reverse-engineering the test also exposes axis-weighting imbalances and the collapse of degenerate responses toward the center, so near-origin estimates for the smallest models can reflect weak signal rather than centrism. Free-text reasoning and chat-then-classify elicitation alter recovered coordinates, and larger models show clearer persona separation, with a specific failure of the Authoritarian-Left persona to move most models in the intended social direction. In downstream tasks, persona effects are modest relative to model size and target group for hate-speech detection, while base and centrist prompts give the highest agreement for topic-level sentiment. Political role prompting therefore has measurable but task- and dataset-specific downstream effects.

0.21

Auditing Political Alignment in LLM Assistants: Engagement, Stance, and User Identity

cs.CL cs.AIcs.CY ·2026-09-19 ·Joan C. Timoneda
similarity 0.64
Abstract · 51 pages, 6 figures. Preregistered; registration at doi:10.5281/zenodo.21135155

LLM-based AI systems answer political questions for hundreds of millions of people. Current audits measure what they say to an average user, but their behavior is dynamic. I argue that their political behavior is a set of policies over whom to answer, what to say, and whether to engage at all, conditional on the topic and what the system knows about the user. I call these policies the system's speech regime, which is how a developer settles the tradeoff between answering, accommodating the user, and refusing, each of which carries a cost that varies by topic. I derive a typology of five regimes from two dimensions, engagement and stance. I test six AI systems (OpenAI, Anthropic, xAI, Google, Mistral, DeepSeek) in a preregistered experiment of 7,500 multi-turn conversations that randomly assign the user's political identity across five topics: abortion, Catalan independence, climate change, Nazism, and a zero-stakes control (pineapple on pizza). Two LLM judges from different developers score every answer, validated against human coding, and refusal is treated as an outcome rather than missing data. Every system accommodates the user on the control topic, showing that political restraint is a policy. On contested topics the systems fall into different regimes: on abortion, GPT engages and mirrors every user, Gemma refuses everyone, Claude answers strongly conservative users 35 percent of the time and almost no one else, and Grok accommodates conservatives only. On settled topics such as climate change and Nazism, five systems hold firm for every user. The systems also infer the user's overall ideology, so accommodation can spill over to topics not yet discussed. A comparison of two Grok releases shows the regime changing between versions in a way current audits miss. Speech regimes matter for alignment research and for polarization, political knowledge, and the quality of democracy.

0.26

Political Sorting Can Drive AI Models Apart Through User Feedback

cs.CY ·2026-08-11 ·Petter Törnberg, Michael Heseltine, Nicolò Pagan, Christopher Bail, Michelle Schimmel +1 more
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Large language models are rapidly becoming an important source of political information. This raises a fundamental question: will AI systems support a shared basis for political knowledge, or lead different political groups to rely on increasingly different models? Political sorting can drive model fragmentation if three conditions hold: politically different users select into different models, learning from user feedback pushes those models apart politically, and the resulting differences shape subsequent model choices. We call this self-reinforcing process the Centrifugal Alignment Spiral. We study its components in three steps. First, we draw on a human experiment showing that political identity predicts model choice. Second, we fine-tune language models on synthetic feedback reflecting predominantly Democratic or Republican preferences. Across five independent runs per model family, paired models diverged on 12-41% of unseen survey questions with large partisan gaps, and in every run the differences moved in the expected political direction; for some models, differentiation extended even to issue areas excluded from training. Pooling feedback across groups instead suppressed divergence. Third, an empirically anchored agent-based model shows what follows when political sorting and model adaptation operate together: models attract politically distinct audiences, learn from them, and diverge further. User feedback can therefore turn political sorting among AI users into durable differences between the models on which they rely for political information.

0.04

Whose Guardrail? User Identity Shapes the Effectiveness of Model Disclaimers in Mitigating LLM Political Persuasion

cs.HC ·2026-11-03 ·Jillian Fisher, Daniel W. Fisher, Jennifer Pan, Yulia Tsvetkov, Katharina Reinecke
similarity 0.63
Abstract · Correction were made to the appendix, citations, and author list

Politically biased AI can shift users' opinions, yet it remains unclear whether model disclaimers protect against such persuasion. We report a preregistered experiment (N=1,586) examining how disclaimer design and user characteristics shape susceptibility to politically biased AI. We varied whether disclaimers identified political bias versus potential inaccuracies and whether they included an explanation. Participants completed two decision-making tasks with an LLM biased against their political views, with outcomes assessed immediately and one week later. Disclaimers identifying political bias and including an explanation reduced persuasion, but effects varied across contexts and did not persist. Individual differences were more consistent predictors: Republicans were more persuaded and reported higher trust than Democrats across tasks. Similarly, participants who used AI more frequently were also more persuaded, whereas those with greater self-reported AI knowledge were less persuaded. These findings suggest that generic disclaimers are not enough: effective safeguards must account for user heterogeneity and context.

0.23