CS Paper Radar

From Bracha to Coded MBRB: Benchmarking Byzantine Reliable Broadcast Implementations

Yenan Wang, Jesper Kullberg, Fabian Paglianno Persson, Elad Michael Schiller, Timothé Albouy

cs.DC ·submitted 2026-09-07 14:03 UTC · v1
publishedcode/data

Abstract

Byzantine Reliable Broadcast (BRB) and Message-Adversary-Tolerant Byzantine Reliable Broadcast (MBRB) are reliable-dissemination abstractions for fault-tolerant distributed systems. Yet their operational behavior is shaped not only by specifications and asymptotic communication bounds, but also by serialization, cryptography, buffering, orchestration, deployment environment, and fault-injection semantics. This paper implements and evaluates Bracha [Information and Computation, 1987], AFRT by Albouy et al. [TCS, 2023], and Coded MBRB by Albouy et al. [OPODIS, 2024]. We implement the algorithms in a shared Go codebase with common orchestration, instrumentation, parser-based specification checks, fault injection, and an open-source reproducibility artifact. The evaluation uses single-shot broadcasts in the Shadow network simulator, native profiling, a Google Cloud Platform deployment, and a distributed FABRIC testbed, covering controlled experiments up to 30 nodes, payloads up to 40 MB, 92,190 runs, and 2,361,600 parser-checked entries. The results show that Coded MBRB reduces transmitted data and improves latency in the evaluated cloud setting for larger payloads, but shifts cost to cryptographic and coding computation. Bracha and AFRT incur lower CPU costs at smaller payloads, but their full-payload dissemination increases processing, allocation, and network costs as payloads grow. Across the tested configurations, the parser found no duplicate deliveries, conflicting deliveries, or deliveries of values different from the sender's payload. The paper contributes implementation-level evidence and an extensible artifact for benchmarking BRB and MBRB as executable distributed-system components, exposing bottlenecks and operational trade-offs that are hidden by algorithmic descriptions alone.

Comment
to be published in SSS 2026

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Byzantine Causal Reliable Broadcast with Constant Metadata Overhead

cs.DC cs.DS ·2026-09-29 ·Purv Patel, Ajay D. Kshemkalyani
similarity 0.68
Abstract

Asynchronous Byzantine Reliable Broadcast (BRB) is a fundamental primitive that guarantees agreement and validity in distributed systems subject to Byzantine faults, but it lacks ordering guarantees. Causal message ordering is important for many applications such as blockchain and social networking. Existing solutions for Byzantine Causal Reliable Broadcast (BCRB) have several drawbacks. Such protocols typically append vector clocks or dependency barriers to application messages, resulting in a metadata overhead that scales linearly with $n$, the number of processes in the system. In this paper, we propose the first optimal message overhead BCRB algorithm that guarantees safety. We do this by re-engineering Bracha's BRB algorithm with relatively small but critical modifications, and prove that our algorithm solves BCRB with optimal message metadata. The algorithm achieves constant-size $\mathcal{O}(1)$ message metadata overhead and $\mathcal{O}(n^2)$ messages, resulting in $\mathcal{O}(n^2)$ communication word complexity. This is as against $\mathcal{O}(n^3)$ communication word complexity of existing protocols. The algorithm tolerates $f < n/3$ Byzantine processes, which is the well-known optimal resilience bound, and uses four phases.

0.34

Byzantine Causal Reliable Broadcast (BCRB) with Constant-Size Message Metadata

cs.DC cs.DS ·2026-09-21 ·Purv Patel, Ajay D. Kshemkalyani
theory similarity 0.66
Abstract

Asynchronous Byzantine Reliable Broadcast (BRB) is a fundamental primitive that guarantees agreement and validity in distributed systems subject to Byzantine faults, but it lacks ordering guarantees. In this paper, we address Byzantine Causal Reliable Broadcast (BCRB), which builds on BRB to enforce causal message ordering. We present a novel BCRB protocol that decouples causal ordering from the BRB layer, achieving constant-size $\mathcal{O}(1)$ message metadata overhead and $\mathcal{O}(n^2)$ communication word complexity as against $\mathcal{O}(n^3)$ communication word complexity of existing protocols; here $n$ is the number of processes. We present two variants of our protocol: a cryptographic version using a threshold encryption scheme and sequence gating, and its non-cryptographic version. In the cryptographic version, senders broadcast ciphertexts immediately, and decryption shares are piggybacked on out-of-band ACKs, preventing early decryption and front-running. In both versions, causal safety is achieved probabilistically. We evaluate the probability of causal safety violations using a random variable path analysis under independent exponential link delay distributions. We show that both variants satisfy liveness and the probability of weak safety violation is bounded by $\mathcal{O}(f^{-3}\cdot\ln^3 f)$, where $f$ is the upper bound on the number of Byzantine processes, and $f < n/3$ and $f=\mathcal{O}(n)$. Further, for the crypto version, we show that the probability of strong safety violation is bounded by $\mathcal{O}(f^{-1} \cdot \ln^2 f)$. We also show how to modify our two protocols to guarantee 100\% weak safety keeping $\mathcal{O}(1)$ message space overhead but with $\mathcal{O}(n^3)$ messages and $\mathcal{O}(n^3)$ communication word complexity.

0.29

Pangolin: Efficient DAG-based BFT State-Machine Replication with TEE-Accelerated Commitment

cs.DC ·2026-10-19 ·Paul Franke-Bergmann, Maya Kuhlmann, Alexander Heß, Marc Leinweber, Rüdiger Kapitza +3 more
similarity 0.61
Abstract · 28 pages

Currently many Byzantine fault-tolerant (BFT) protocols use directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) to let replicas propose blocks of requests in parallel for improved throughput. Yet, the existing DAG-based designs mainly consider the atomic-broadcast layer: They typically do not describe an efficient client interaction layer, their garbage collection is either unspecified or relies on trusted external storage, and the lowest-latency designs rely on timing assumptions that may be violated in geo-distributed deployments. In this paper, we propose the Pangolin protocol: It introduces a novel low-latency DAG-based atomic broadcast layer and completes it into an efficient state-machine replication (SMR) framework. To preserve system throughput, clients issue requests to a single replica and verify replies efficiently via compact execution proofs. Furthermore, Pangolin introduces a new garbage-collection scheme for DAGs which bounds memory usage even under full asynchrony. Pangolin leverages trusted execution environments to tolerate f Byzantine faults with only n >= 2f + 1 replicas and accelerates vertex commitments significantly: Broadcasting certified vertices requires only a single communication step, and commit rules are refined to commit both frequently and early without revealing the coin-elected anchor. This way, Pangolin overtakes the fastest partially synchronous DAG protocols while being live under asynchrony: In our evaluation, Pangolin achieves an average 1.27x (up to 1.52x) latency speedup over Mysticeti.

0.23

Byzantine-Tolerant Causal Unicast with Constant Message Space Overhead

cs.DC cs.DS ·2026-10-05 ·Purv Patel, Ajay D. Kshemkalyani
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Causal message ordering provides essential semantics for distributed applications, yet ensuring it within an asynchronous system subject to Byzantine failures presents fundamental theoretical and practical challenges. Prior research establishes that algorithms cannot guarantee both strong safety and liveness without using cryptography under these conditions. Existing Byzantine-tolerant solutions make synchrony assumptions or suffer from $O(n)$ message space overheads and $O(n^2)$ message complexity, where $n$ is the number of processes in the system, or use cryptography, but may not guarantee strong safety. In this paper, we present a novel Byzantine-tolerant causal ordering algorithm that achieves an optimal $O(1)$ application message space overhead for point-to-point messages. Our approach uses a Sender Permission to Send (SPS) invariant and an \textit{Isolated-Buffer Optimistic Model} for the memory management architecture. To circumvent Byzantine state-pinning and head-of-line blocking attacks, instead of unified causal buffers, we use isolated, per-peer queues equipped with event-driven \textit{Cascading Space Evictions}. We formally prove that our algorithm guarantees system-wide liveness and satisfies a weakened causal safety abstraction called \textit{Congestion-Relaxed Causal Delivery}. Under this model, weak causal safety is strictly preserved for all honest-to-honest communications unless extreme network latency or Byzantine withholding attacks exceed quantifiable local buffer capacities, forcing optimistic queue evictions. This formal guarantee successfully balances causal ordering with high throughput, constant message space overhead, low computational overhead, and strictly bounded local space.

0.03

Sintr: Safe Interactive Transactions in the Presence of Byzantine Clients

cs.DC ·2026-08-27 ·Austin T. Li, Daniel H. Lee, Lorenzo Alvisi, Natacha Crooks, Florian Suri-Payer
top venueposition similarity 0.59
Abstract

Byzantine fault-tolerant (BFT) systems are, in principle, an appealing foundation for transactional applications involving mutually distrustful participants. Yet their adoption has been hampered by two persistent stumbling blocks-performance and developer convenience-which are often in tension with one another. Recent systems show promising progress on both fronts by shifting to a client-centric architecture; clients execute transactions locally and concurrently, while the system resolves any data conflicts to maintain database serializability. We argue that, in its current form, this approach introduces a critical vulnerability: it leaves the integrity of the database exposed to Byzantine clients, which may issue malicious or incorrect transactions. We address this threat with Sintr, a framework that prevents Byzantine clients from compromising database integrity by executing rogue transactions. Sintr combines redundant execution to validate transaction outcomes with a flexible, heterogeneous policy framework for expressing an application's data-integrity requirements. We apply Sintr to harden several existing BFT database systems and find that it imposes only modest overheads-3%-16% in throughput and 3%-21% in latency.

0.30

Robust, Lightweight Locally Differentially Private Histogram Estimation and the Role of Dropout Attacks

cs.CR ·2026-11-18 ·Haochen Sun, Jacob Imola, Xi He
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Local differential privacy (LDP) is vulnerable to output manipulation by malicious clients. Zero-knowledge proofs can enforce correct report computation, but clients may still selectively drop out after inspecting their outputs. Prior work combines zero-knowledge proofs with homomorphic encryption to hide reports from clients and prevent selective dropout, but incurs substantial computational cost. We instead develop a three-message lightweight verification framework for robust histogram estimation that uses proofs of plaintext evaluation to restrict output manipulation to selective dropout. Across the evaluated settings for PI-RAPPOR and Hadamard Response, mean per-client online latency remains below 500 milliseconds. We further establish tight error bounds showing that, for RAPPOR, PI-RAPPOR, and Hadamard Response, restricting malicious clients to selective dropout reduces attack-dependent error by a factor proportional to the square root of the domain size compared with output manipulation. Additionally, when client protocols cannot be modified, we propose server-side consistency checks for RAPPOR and Hadamard Response. These checks improve robustness without client-side cryptography and can be applied post-hoc to collected reports, offering an alternative under different deployment constraints. Experiments demonstrate that both verification and consistency checks substantially reduce attack error for certain mechanisms, with consistency checks yielding errors intermediate between those obtained with verification and those under unrestricted output manipulation.

0.37

Asynchronous Verifiable and Complete Secret Sharing: From Design Patterns to System-Level Trade-offs

cs.CR ·2026-10-27 ·Joachim Bruneau-Queyreix, Martin Zivojinovic, Leo Mendiboure, Tom Claudel, Laurent Réveillère
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Modern secret sharing protocols promise robust secret sharing in fully asynchronous Byzantine systems, but their practical costs remain difficult to compare across papers, assumptions, and workloads. The difficulty is not merely experimental: protocols with similar asymptotic guarantees often place very different work on the critical path through their choices of dissemination, verification, batching, and recovery. This paper turns that fragmented research landscape into a corpus-backed designspace analysis and systems evaluation of asynchronous verifiable and complete secret sharing. We derive a design sieve, select seven representative protocols, and implement them in a common Rust framework. In our experiments on the Grid'5000 platform, we evaluate honest-dealer and faulty-dealer stress executions using latency, throughput, message count, bandwidth, and aggregate CPU-time. The results show that message complexity alone poorly predicts latency, that optimistic paths can be dominated by recovery cost, and that batching or packing helps only when verification stays off the critical path. These findings turn protocol-by-protocol comparisons into design-to-cost guidance for choosing, implementing, and extending asynchronous verifiable and complete sharing protocols.

0.28

A Resilient Runtime-Verification Fabric for Security Monitoring of Critical Edge-IoT Infrastructure

cs.CR cs.DC ·2026-10-05 ·Nikolaos Kekatos, Marinelio Chintri, Panagiotis Katsaros, Alexios Lekidis, Tom Nianios +3 more
publishedhighly cited similarity 0.58
Abstract · 21 pages, 2 figures. Accepted at the 21st International Conference on Critical Information Infrastructures Security (CRITIS 2026)

Protecting critical infrastructure increasingly depends on continuously verifying large IoT fleets against formal security specifications at runtime. Yet the runtime-verification (RV) pipelines proposed for this task are typically single-host prototypes whose monitors read a shared log file, with no resilience to the failures such deployments incur: a crash or overload silently drops events, clock skew corrupts the ordering metric monitors require, a time-triggered "node has gone silent" property cannot fire when the network itself falls silent, and one slow consumer stalls the pipeline. Each failure is silent: the monitor keeps emitting verdicts over a corrupted view. We present RV-Fabric, a resilient delivery layer that carries the hierarchy over two brokers (MQTT for device ingest, a durable stream broker for backend delivery) and re-establishes five continuity guarantees: durable delivery under crashes, a trusted event order, progress under total silence, consumer isolation and flow control under bounded overload, each an invariant conditioned on broker durability. Above the transport, RV-Fabric makes evidence completeness part of runtime-verification semantics: every verdict carries a status (sound, degraded, incomplete or unavailable) derived from delivery gaps, retention pressure and liveness, so an incomplete stream cannot yield an unqualified all-clear. Under controlled fault injection on a containerised testbed, measured against a fault-free oracle using the real MonPoly engine, the shared-log baseline misses six of seven injected incidents, reporting each as an unqualified all-clear, whereas RV-Fabric preserves all seven; removing a delivery mechanism reintroduces silent loss, removing isolation costs only timeliness. Two published critical-infrastructure datasets, water-SCADA and IoT/IIoT, replay end-to-end.

0.59