CS Paper Radar

SQLMorph: Query Mutation and Fine-Grained Metrics for Text-to-SQL Evaluation

Mohammadhossein Malekpour, Mohamed Riahi, Maxime Lamothe, Amine Mhedhbi

cs.DB cs.AI ·submitted 2026-09-08 16:08 UTC · v1
top venue

Abstract

Text-to-SQL systems translate natural language queries into executable SQL, democratizing access to structured data. Despite recent advances driven by large language models (LLMs), evaluation remains a major bottleneck: public benchmarks fail to capture the complexity of enterprise schema, while building private evaluation sets is costly and nondeterministic, making evaluation results difficult to reproduce. To address this issue, we present SQLMorph, a framework for Text-to-SQL evaluation via query mutation. SQLMorph introduces two techniques to automatically generate and expand evaluation sets: Join Query Expansion (JQE), which systematically increases structural complexity through valid join additions, and Textual Query Augmentation (TQA), which generates controlled natural language perturbations to assess robustness to linguistic variation. JQE and TQA create targeted choke points to challenge specific system components. When applied to state-of-the-art systems, JQE increases query coverage and reveals accuracy degradation as the number of joins grows. Meanwhile, TQA shows that linguistic brittleness induced by heavy abbreviation can reduce accuracy by up to 17%. Beyond evaluation sets, SQLMorph introduces a family of execution-level metrics that address the limitations of current binary measures, such as Execution Accuracy. We define Execution Precision (EXP) and Execution Recall (EXR) to quantify the fraction of correct and recovered results, respectively, and combine them via F1 for unified scoring. Our experiments show that these relaxed metrics enable fine-grained analysis of over- and under-prediction, revealing differences across systems that binary metrics obscure. Together, SQLMorph's query mutation and fine-grained metrics support debugging and better align Text-to-SQL evaluation practices with real-world deployments.

Journal ref
2026 IEEE 42nd International Conference on Data Engineering (ICDE), pp. 2628-2640
DOI
10.1109/ICDE65706.2026.00196

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

FALCON: A Model and Dataset Agnostic Framework for Synthetic Data Generation for NL2SQL Pairs

cs.CL cs.DBcs.LG ·2026-10-02 ·Darian Lee, Shannon Rumsey, Jack St. Clair, Xinyi Tang, Aditya Bansal +1 more
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.75
Abstract · Accepted to AKBC Workshop, EMNLP

Relational databases are among the most widely deployed forms of structured knowledge, and natural language access to them requires grounding language onto schema entities and relations while handling the ambiguity inherent in how people phrase requests. Existing synthetic NL-to-SQL data generation methods largely ignore this ambiguity and produce oversimplified queries that fail to prepare models for the complexity of real-world structured knowledge access. We present FALCON, a framework that generates realistic, ambiguity-aware NL-to-SQL data matching the complexity of challenging real-world benchmarks, at low cost using compact open models. Our approach combines reserved-word SQL seeding and persona-based prompting to generate structurally complex queries, while alignment-based filtering preserves difficulty by distinguishing genuinely incorrect examples from complex but valid queries. Human evaluation confirms consistent high quality across model sizes, and our generated data exceeds existing benchmarks in both SQL complexity and natural language richness. Difficulty-stratified analysis shows models trained on FALCON data increasingly outperform baseline-trained models as query complexity increases, validating our pipeline's success in generating challenging training data. When combined with a small proportion of existing benchmark data, mixed training recovers performance on simpler queries while preserving these advantages on complex ones. The model- and database-agnostic design enables organizations to generate high-complexity NL-to-SQL training data locally without external APIs.

0.20

Closing the Cross-Dialect Gap: Query Plans as a Portable Interface in Text-to-SQL

cs.CL ·2026-09-27 ·Corentin Royer, Robin Oester, Yotam Perlitz, Yannick Metz, Andrea Giovannini +1 more
top venueposition similarity 0.74
Abstract · Accepted at Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: EMNLP 2026

Text-to-SQL systems are typically trained and evaluated on a single dialect (SQLite), yet production deployments span PostgreSQL, MySQL, ClickHouse, and beyond. We show that this single-dialect assumption leads to a substantial drop in cross-dialect accuracy for every model we tested. The drop persists across scale, architecture, and even purpose-built text-to-SQL systems. We argue that the fix is to change the generation target: instead of asking an LLM to emit dialect-specific SQL, we have it emit a dialect-agnostic relational algebra query plan, which a deterministic compiler then renders into SQL for any supported backend. Across thirteen models from 3B to frontier scale, this restores cross-dialect portability nearly uniformly, at a small cost in peak accuracy on the model's home dialect for capable prompted models and none once fine-tuned on plans; under matched fine-tuning, plan supervision yields a stronger model than SQL supervision. We also introduce MetricName, a question-aware result-set comparator needed to evaluate fairly across dialects, where existing metrics confound semantic errors with benign cross-dialect variation. More broadly, the result is a reminder that a generation target chosen for execution is not necessarily the one that maximizes generation quality.

0.47

FlinkEval: A Synthetic Corpus for Evaluating Natural Language Interfaces to Streaming SQL

cs.DB ·2026-11-12 ·Alfio Massimiliano Gliozzo, Nandana Mihindukulasooriya, Gaetano Rossiello, Erick Lee, Lisa Amini
benchmark similarity 0.74
Abstract · 17 pages

Existing natural-language-to-SQL benchmarks primarily evaluate queries over bounded relational data, leaving streaming semantics underexplored. We introduce FlinkEval, an execution-grounded synthetic benchmark comprising 3,903 question--SQL pairs across 45 industry domains and 45 semantic labels. We create diverse schemas and domain-plausible, temporally consistent data through iterative generation and validation. SQL patterns collected from the human-written NL2SQL pairs and vendor documentation drive quota-balanced generation, and execution with a repair loop on Confluent Cloud Apache Flink produces reference queries covering windowing, temporal joins, pattern matching, nested types, and data manipulation. The corpus includes paired schema-explicit and business-language requests, with annotations for analysis by query pattern, complexity, and execution mode. A seven-level Question Specification Ladder examines semantics-preserving reformulation and underspecified requests augmented with oracle-derived clues. Baseline evaluations combine execution outcomes with adjudicated LLM judgments, revealing challenges in pattern composition and request specification.

0.10

BIRD-History: A Benchmark for History-Driven Text-to-SQL with Fine-Grained Knowledge Annotations

cs.AI cs.CL ·2026-08-29 ·Yunfan Zhou, Qiming Shi, Yizhou Yang, Di Weng, Yingcai Wu
top venuebenchmarkcode/data similarity 0.72
Abstract · Accepted at Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: EMNLP, 2026

While recent Large Language Model (LLM)-based text-to-SQL systems achieve impressive performance on standard benchmarks, they struggle when user queries implicitly rely on domain-specific knowledge, such as business logic, data conventions, and analytical practices, that is neither captured by the schema nor explicitly stated in the natural language question. Historical SQL query logs offer a valuable source of such knowledge, yet existing benchmarks do not adequately support evaluation of history-driven approaches. To address this gap, we introduce BIRD-History, a benchmark consisting of 1,393 tasks across 11 databases, designed to evaluate text-to-SQL systems' ability to ground underspecified natural language questions using historical SQL scripts. Each task is annotated with ground-truth labels specifying which historical queries contain relevant knowledge and which SQL clauses encode it, enabling systematic evaluation of both retrieval effectiveness and knowledge utilization. Alongside the benchmark, we propose a plug-in retriever that extracts five types of external knowledge from historical SQL scripts, then retrieves and reranks relevant fragments for query generation. The retriever integrates seamlessly into existing few-shot text-to-SQL pipelines without requiring prompt modifications. Experiments demonstrate consistent improvements across four text-to-SQL systems, highlighting the value of leveraging historical query logs for handling underspecified queries. Dataset and code are open-sourced on https://github.com/zjuidg/BIRD-History.

0.44

The Stochastic Shift: A New Evaluation Paradigm for Text-to-SQL with AI Operators

cs.DB cs.AI ·2026-09-17 ·Tarfah Alrashed, Fatma Ozcan, Per Jacobsson, Tal Neiman, Xianshun Chen
similarity 0.72
Abstract

SQL has been augmented with AI operators, enabling modern data analytics platforms to derive insights from both structured and unstructured data. We observe that while current Text-to-SQL systems can successfully generate these AI-augmented queries, reliably evaluating their correctness remains a critical open challenge. Current metrics, which rely on exact query results and deterministic execution, systematically fail against the flexible, non-deterministic outputs of AI operators. In this paper, we formalize these unique evaluation failure modes and introduce a Multilayered Evaluation Framework that decouples deterministic database logic from flexible AI semantics. We test our approach across both industry (BigQuery) and academic (ThalamusDB) systems. We demonstrate that traditional Execution Accuracy severely penalizes valid queries, achieving as low as a 25% detection rate for correct translations. Furthermore, even a state-of-the-art LLM-based autorater falsely rejects 32% of accurate queries due to the complexity of judging both relational and AI components simultaneously. By validating the standard relational logic and the AI operations separately, our framework achieves state-of-the-art overall accuracy across both platforms (up to 97.2%), proposing a reliable standard for benchmarking AI-powered SQL generators.

0.27

Reliable Text-to-SQL in Resource-Constrained Settings with Small LLMs via Iterative Retry Workflows

cs.AI ·2026-10-12 ·Bilel Abderrahmane Benziane, Xavier Schepler
publishedbenchmarkcode/data similarity 0.72
Abstract

Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently improved Text-to-SQL generation, but their computational cost can hinder deployment in resource-constrained settings. This paper evaluates the Text-to-SQL capabilities of small and medium open-source LLMs (1B-8B parameters) under a controlled inference budget, focusing on how model specialization and prompt formulation affect performance. Using the Spider benchmark, we compare multiple prompt representations and assess the accuracy of generated queries. Our results show that SQL-specialized models are consistently more reliable than general-purpose and chat-oriented models at small scales, and that performance can vary substantially depending on the prompt used. To reduce this variability without resorting to larger models, we introduce three lightweight inference workflows that automatically retry with alternative prompts and/or models when failures occur, including an optional syntax-correction step. These workflows significantly improve end-to-end success rates, with a trade-off in additional inference calls. These results demonstrate a practical path to stronger Text-to-SQL performance with small LLMs, by trading modest additional inference cost for higher reliability.

0.34

NL2SQL with Iterative Self-Refinement

cs.DB cs.AI ·2026-10-16 ·Anjali Vemula, Akshat Dasula
similarity 0.71
Abstract

Bridging the gap between human intent and machine logic remains a critical challenge in data access for non-technical users, yet Large Language Models (LLMs) remain unreliable: they hallucinate schema elements, generate syntactically invalid queries, or fail to capture user intent. These limitations are especially critical in domains such as insurance, where KPIs, regulatory constraints, and legacy relational systems demand high precision. We introduce a multi-agent, persona-driven NL2SQL framework that combines (1) domain relevance detection, (2) schema-grounded knowledge construction, (3) KPI-aware SQL synthesis, (4) syntax-level self-repair using sqlite execution feedback, and (5) semantic consistency checking via SQL-to-NL reverse engineering. Our system significantly reduces query hallucination and improves semantic fidelity compared to direct LLM prompting. Evaluated on 60 queries (50 from a HuggingFace text-to-SQL dataset and 10 custom domain queries), the system achieves 90% correctness using Mistral across seven coordinated LLM calls showing that this approach can substantially increase the reliability of NL2SQL pipelines in high-stakes environments.

0.19

DexterSQL: Deep Schema Exploration and Rule-based Correction for Text-to-SQL Generation

cs.DB cs.AIcs.CLcs.IR ·2026-08-12 ·Anik Pramanik, Murat Kantarcioglu, Vincent Oria, Shantanu Sharma
code/data similarity 0.71
Abstract · This version of the paper improved the SQL generation algorithm, increasing the system's overall accuracy. For details, please see the paper

Prompting-based (i.e., non-fine-tuning) Text-to-SQL methods, where underlying large language model parameters are not changed for the task, face three problems: (i) relying on coarse-grained schema information that may not reveal the fine-grained relationships needed to distinguish ambiguous columns, (ii) failing to capture recurring SQL-generation failures, and (iii) suffering from omission or hallucination of components in complex questions. This paper develops DexterSQL, a prompting/non-fine-tuning-based Text-to-SQL system that improves SQL generation with three novel components: (i) deep schema explorator that identifies ambiguous columns, analyzes their individual and joint data distributions to uncover their relationships and the distinct role of each, (ii) database-agnostic rule creator that mines mismatches between generated and gold SQL only on the training database and converts them into database-agnostic corrective rules that capture recurring LLM failure patterns; and (iii) multi-path SQL generation that introduces a dependency-tree-based intermediate representation that uses the question's sentence structure to guide its decomposition into an SQL skeleton for final SQL generation. DexterSQL achieves a higher accuracy compared to the state-of-the-art using both open-source/weight and closed-source/weight models. Particularly, DexterSQL shows a high improvement of at least 5.5% using an open-weight model (GPT-OSS-120B) on BIRDDev, with total accuracy 70.4%. DexterSQL also shows better improvement of at least 1.4% using closed-weight models, with total accuracy 72.1% and 72.9% on BIRD-Dev with GPT-4o and GPT-5.2.

0.20