CS Paper Radar

Democracy Needs Reach: Political Equality, Online Speech, and Algorithmic Recommendation

Etienne Brown

cs.CY cs.SI ·submitted 2026-09-08 21:31 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

Within democracies, the capacity to influence political outcomes through speech depends not only on the right to express oneself, but also on the opportunity to reach relevant audiences. In this paper, I argue that the unequal distribution of algorithmic reach on social media platforms undermines equality of opportunity for political influence (EOPI), which is a central democratic ideal. Drawing on Niko Kolodny's work, I contend that current recommendation algorithms create and perpetuate informal inequalities by concentrating attention among a small minority of already-amplified speakers while systematically marginalizing others. To address this problem, I propose recommendation floors as a mechanism for equalizing political speech. To help users achieve meaningful participation, each verified account would receive guaranteed minimum recommendation for up to a limited number of political posts per week. Although this measure represents one component of the structural reforms needed to move the digital public sphere closer to democratic ideals, it offers a feasible pathway to reducing informal inequalities in political influence online.

Comment
Published in Ethical Theory and Moral Practice
DOI
10.1007/s10677-026-10535-1

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Improving social media for democratic discourse

cs.CY cs.HC ·2026-10-07 ·Fan Cheng, Amirhossein Farzmahdi, Pinyuan Feng, Kedar Garzón Gupta, Trenton Jerde +6 more
similarity 0.69
Abstract · 55 pages. White paper presenting a modular set of mechanisms for designing social media to support democratic discourse

Social media have expanded opportunities for communication and political participation, but today's dominant platforms are optimized primarily for engagement and advertising revenue, contributing to concerns about polarization, misinformation, social isolation, and loss of civility. We explore how social media might instead be deliberately designed to support democratic discourse, collective deliberation, and collective intelligence. Drawing on literature across computer science, psychology, political science, and related fields, we present a modular collection of mechanisms that could be implemented individually or in combination. These include user-controlled and open recommender systems, tools for exposure to diverse perspectives, new forms of cognitive and epistemic feedback, collaborative and AI-assisted fact-checking, privacy and visibility controls, mechanisms for improving civility and evidentiary integrity, and reputation systems that reward high-quality participation. The proposals are intended both as a practical menu of design possibilities and as a starting point for broader interdisciplinary discussion about digital public spaces designed around democratic values rather than engagement alone.

0.11

From institutional journalism to political extremes: Structural asymmetries in YouTube's news recommender during the 2022 French presidential campaign

cs.SI ·2026-11-13 ·Julien Figeac, Erwan Le Merrer, Marie Neihouser, Gilles Tr{é}dan
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Debate has intensified over how algorithmic recommendations shape news visibility, particularly regarding structural and ideological bias. This study examines YouTube's News Recommender System (NRS) in the French ``News'' section, using a large-scale audit based on automated browsing agents operating under cold-start conditions, without prior viewing history, to isolate the algorithm's structural baseline independently of user preferences. Our results reveal that YouTube's NRS operates within a structurally asymmetric visibility regime: even in the absence of prior user behaviour, recommendation outputs disproportionately privilege platform-native creators and politically engaged content over established journalism. Television channels retain some relative advantage, but institutional news outlets, particularly press and radio, are systematically marginalised across recommendation sequences. Among political content, figures affiliated with far-left and far-right movements occupy a disproportionately visible position in recommendation outputs. Rather than correcting this asymmetry, continuity effects reproduce and stabilise it across recommendation sequences. These results show that visibility in YouTube's News section cannot be reduced to accumulated user preferences alone, but is also shaped by a structural bias embedded in the platform's recommendation system, which plays an important role in sustaining the prominence of political actors affiliated with the far left and far right.

0.22

Algorithmic Fairness for Influence Maximization: A Survey of Models, Metrics, and Optimization Techniques

cs.SI ·2026-10-14 ·Shashank Sheshar Singh, Sunil Kumar Meena, Kuldeep Singh, krati Saxena
survey similarity 0.60
Abstract

Influence maximization (IM) has become a basis of modeling information spread across social networks, with applications in viral marketing, public health, and political campaigns. However, classical IM algorithms often prioritize the spread of overall influence and ignore its fairness, resulting in disadvantages for marginalized or underrepresented communities. This survey provides a detailed look at fairness-aware influence maximization, focusing on important challenges, models, and methods designed to ensure fair influence maximization. We categorize existing methods into five groups based on their fairness objectives, including parity, diversity, and utility, and discuss how they handle biased network structure, protected attributes, and seeding constraints. We also examine how fairness-aware influence maximization methods perform on real-world data to highlight the importance of combining fairness with classical influence maximization methods. By bridging the gap between influence spread and social equity, this survey lays the foundation for designing fair algorithms that ensure fair representation in large-scale diffusion processes. The survey concludes by outlining emerging trends, open challenges, and prospective future directions in the domain, highlighting the need for expertise spanning multiple disciplines.

0.07

Fair Feed Ranking for Participatory Budgeting

cs.CY cs.IR ·2026-09-24 ·Carina I. Hausladen
publishedpositioncode/data similarity 0.59
Abstract · 8 pages, 2 figures, 2 tables. Published at GoodIT '26, the International Conference on Information Technology for Social Good, Pisa, Italy, …

In large-scale participatory budgeting, citizens cannot inspect the full proposal pool, so the order in which proposals are shown becomes a form of agenda-setting power. We argue that fair exposure should therefore be treated as a democratic-design goal. We study Consul Democracy, a widely deployed open-source digital-democracy platform, and show that its proposal feeds are typically ordered by popularity, recency, or comment activity. Building on this diagnosis, we propose FairFeed, a feed-ranking design for PB that uses transparently declared preferences, boosts under-exposed proposals, and admits a rate-limited reject channel for crowd-sourced vetting. We evaluate the design in a simulation anchored in Munich's 2025 PB process and compare it with random, newest, and most-commented feeds. In this simulation, FairFeed broadens proposal discovery, distributes visibility more evenly across the eligible pool, increases cross-cutting support, and improves resistance to manipulation relative to comment-based ranking. We conclude by outlining the human-subjects evaluation needed to test whether onboarding can recover voter preferences accurately enough for deployment in practice.

0.49

Free Speech and Artificial Intelligence

cs.CY cs.AI ·2026-08-29 ·Etienne Brown
similarity 0.58
Abstract · Preprint. Forthcoming in Mark Satta, Étienne Brown, and JP Messina (eds.), Philosophy and Free Speech: An Introduction. London: Routledge, 2…

Philosophers and legal scholars are engaged in debates about the implications of artificial intelligence for freedom of expression. This paper analyzes the free speech issues raised by two distinct AI technologies: social media recommendation algorithms and conversational AI (i.e., chatbots powered by large language models). The first part shows that, through their recommendation algorithms, social media platforms control the dynamics of speech visibility in the digital public sphere, making algorithmic recommendation relevant to the philosophy of free speech. The second part turns to conversational AI. It discusses both the reasons for granting or withholding speech rights to artificial agents and users' right to receive information, which may render specific forms of chatbot regulation illegitimate. Throughout, the chapter also considers whether social media platforms or AI developers hold corporate speech rights. Its general aim is to raise rather than settle questions that arise from the rapid development of AI technologies.

0.12

Large Language Models and Augmented Democracy

cs.CY cs.CLcs.CR ·2026-10-03 ·Jairo Gudiño-Rosero
similarity 0.58
Abstract · PhD thesis, Center for Collective Learning (Toulouse School of Economics), 2026. 149 pages, 28 figures

Artificial intelligence enables computational agents to represent political preferences and take part in collective decision-making. In this thesis, I investigate the opportunities and challenges of digital twins (DTs) based on Large Language Models (LLMs) as intermediaries in augmented democracy, focusing on individual preference representation, collective representation of political organizations, and the vulnerability of those representations to attackers. First, using data from an online experiment in Brazil, I examine whether personalized DTs can predict citizens' preferences for unseen policy proposals. Second, I extend the DT framework from individuals to political organizations. Using Swiss parliamentary data, I build topic-specific knowledge graphs from lawmakers' legislative records and connect them to LLM-based lawmaker agents, which are organized into party-level DTs representing collective positions. Agentic deliberation among these agents tests whether aggregated party representations capture a broader range of intra-party perspectives than official party communications. Finally, I study the vulnerability and robustness of LLM-mediated deliberation against prompt-injection attacks that amplify viewpoints, suppress opinions, or redirect consensus. Using data from a 2023 deliberative experiment in the United Kingdom, I analyze how attack effectiveness varies with the distribution of opinions and rhetorical strategies, and evaluate a pipeline combining injection detection, structured opinion representations, and reinforcement learning to improve resistance. These findings characterize the opportunities and challenges of LLM-based digital twins in augmented democracy, stressing accurate preference representation, faithful aggregation, and robustness to strategic interaction.

0.14

Digital Persuasion: Understanding the Impact of Online Influencers on Public Opinion

cs.SI cs.LG ·2026-09-13 ·Omran Berjawi, Rida Khatoun, Giuseppe Fenza
published similarity 0.58
Abstract

The studying of opinion dynamics and its propagation within social networks is crucial for addressing a wide range of challenges, including political polarization, public health, and marketing strategies. In this work, we study the problem of opinion dynamics by proposing a framework based on Friedkin-Johnsen (FJ) to identifies influential users and study their impact on dynamics opinions of community. The FJ model assume each individual have two opinions: initial and expressed. Through a series of initial opinion manipulation experiments, the proposed framework assesses the impact of influential versus random users on the overall community opinion. The proposed framework is validated using a tweet dataset representing the U.S. presidential election. The results shows that influencers with highest influencing score, significantly shift the overall community opinion. Moreover, the results shows that the impact of influencers not limited to direct neighbors , but beyond it, to their neighbors of neighbors . This study demonstrates how digital influencers on social media can shape public opinion regarding a subject or cause.

0.60

Hidden Distances: How Likert-Scale Spacing Shapes Algorithmic Voting Advice

cs.CY cs.IRphysics.soc-ph ·2026-11-09 ·Thomas Broholt Knudsen, Christian Høst-Madsen, Vedran Sekara, Jonas L. Juul
similarity 0.57
Abstract · 18 pages, 6 figures

Voting Advice Applications (VAAs) are algorithmic recommenders that match voters with political candidates on policy preferences. They are widely adopted across many multi-party democracies; in Denmark, 62\% of eligible voters used a VAA ahead of the 2022 general election, and 45\% of VAA users reported following its advice. VAAs typically ask voters and candidates to respond to policy statements on a Likert scale, from ``strongly disagree'' to ``strongly agree'', and recommend candidates whose responses are closest to the voter's. Computing these distances requires assigning numbers to response options, a design choice without an empirical basis, since it is unknown how people perceive the distances between options. Here we show that this seemingly technical choice substantially changes whom voters are matched with. We parameterize the distance between ``(dis)agree'' and ``strongly (dis)agree'' relative to the distance between ``neutral'' and ``(dis)agree'' as $α$, and quantify how it changes recommendations for a popular Danish VAA. We find that moving from equidistant options to doubling this distance can change $37.7\%$ of top candidate matches and $21.9\%$ of top party matches, although no answers change. Low $α$-values favor candidates with strong positions, with some parties receiving up to $ 19.6\%$ more recommendations, while high $α$-values favor moderates. Similarly, female candidates receive fewer recommendations at low $α$ and more at high $α$-values. Our findings demonstrate that undisclosed quantification choices in algorithmic recommenders can carry considerable electoral consequences, and they call for transparency and sensitivity analysis in VAA design. As Likert-based matching also underpins dating platforms and roommate allocation systems, these implications extend well beyond elections.

0.39