CS Paper Radar

Population Ecology of Tunes

John M. McBride, Armand. M. Leroi

cs.SD q-bio.PEphysics.soc-ph ·submitted 2026-09-08 22:31 UTC · v1
unusual

Abstract

How cultural repertoires maintain diversity under selection is a fundamental question in cultural evolution. We address this using thirteen years of weekly popularity data for approximately 20,000 Irish traditional tunes, fitting ecological birth-process models under neutral, frequency-dependent, and per-tune selection hypotheses. We find strong evidence that tunes differ in intrinsic fitness - some are systematically more likely to be learned than others. We find that 29% of the variance in fitness can be explained by a mixture of social and melodic features. Some tunes appear to be carried along via linkage due to the tradition of playing tunes in sets, analogous to selective sweeps in genetics. By measuring changes in fitness over time and comparing this with recordings we precisely identify the mechanism by which a long-dormant tune can become fit through a popular recording. Despite the directional selection, repertoire diversity increases, driven by the continual arrival of new compositions. These results demonstrate that selection and diversity can coexist in a cultural ecosystem, and establish Irish traditional music as a quantitatively tractable system for studying the evolution of cultural variants and understanding what makes a tune stand out.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

How Close to the Theme? Similarity-Label Conditioning for Game Music Generation

cs.SD cs.LGeess.AS ·2026-10-31 ·Shangxuan Luo, Zixun Guo, Jinjie Shi, Joshua Reiss
code/data similarity 0.56
Abstract · 39 pages, 6 figures, 10 tables, including supplementary material. Submitted to Computer Music Journal. Code: https://github.com/ShxLuo-Saxon…

Composers develop music from an original idea, controlling how similar each new section is to it, from near repetition to new material. Game music needs this often, as its material repeats over long play. Music models, however, rarely learn to control similarity from real pieces. We further train a pretrained MIDI model on section pairs from Super Mario pieces. A label states each pair's similarity, and a context vector summarises the given section, or context. For 157 test contexts, the model generates six outputs per label. Twelve measures score the outputs; one main measure each covers melody, pitch content, rhythm and note length. On average, outputs requested as similar are more similar to their context than those requested as dissimilar, and not to other pieces. All twelve measures favour them; each main measure stays significant after correction for multiple tests. On melody, the gap comes mainly from more frequent restatement of the context's melody. Against an otherwise identical model without a label, only the request for high similarity makes outputs more similar. In a listening test, ratings followed melodic overlap with the context most closely of all measures.

0.43

Music of the Deep: An acoustic blueprint of sperm whale codas

cs.SD ·2026-10-25 ·Mudit Sinha, Sanika Chavan
similarity 0.55
Abstract · 10 pages, 3 figures, 4 tables

Sperm-whale codas are usually described by the number and timing of their clicks. Earlier acoustic studies showed that individual clicks and longer coda sequences contain additional organization. We ask how that organization compares with music, whose smaller sounds also form larger units and ordered sequences. We compare codas with performed violin music, drum grooves, and sung melodies. Their sequences resemble music in some measures of predictability, yet codas show a different relationship between the smaller sounds within a unit and the order of units across a sequence. This combination was not observed in the musical references tested. Coda timing also varies coherently and carries information about individual callers. The recordings show another striking property: broad, reproducible variation along acoustic dimensions associated with human ratings of emotion, with a range comparable to human audio in most eligible tests. These findings motivate an acoustic blueprint that describes natural codas beyond their click timing. Its importance is apparent in synthetic audio: WhAM produces recognizable coda-like recordings, yet the tested clips remain distinguishable from natural codas in five of six acoustic comparisons after strict matching. The blueprint provides a fuller way to study natural codas and to evaluate how faithfully synthetic recordings represent them.

0.23

Vocal Music under Phoneme-Conditional Analysis

cs.SD cs.CLeess.AS ·2026-08-31 ·Hayoon Kim, Kyogu Lee
published similarity 0.53
Abstract · Accepted to the 27th International Society for Music Information Retrieval Conference (ISMIR 2026)

The vocal music of each language carries a distinctive sonic identity, even without instrumental accompaniment. We ask whether these differences are measurable and traceable to specific phonemes. To tackle this question, we introduce phoneme-conditional analysis, which isolates the acoustic effect of typologically distinctive phonemes by comparing marker syllables against matched non-marker controls within the same song, holding singer, melody, and genre constant. Across nine typologically diverse languages and thousands of songs, we measure effects along five acoustic dimensions. Song-level profiles built from these effects identify the language of an unaccompanied vocal at 85.5% balanced accuracy in a nine-way classification with folds grouped by artist; whether the separability arises by accumulation of the phoneme-local effects themselves is left open. Our findings suggest that phonological structure leaves systematic and measurable traces in how each language is sung.

0.41

Follow or Surpass? Collaboration, Sound, and the Recognition of Influence in Lineages of Jazz Trumpet Players

cs.SI stat.AP ·2026-11-03 ·Onur Tuncay Bal, Samuel Coavoux, Nathalia A. Loureiro, Balazs Vedres, Mark Wittek
similarity 0.53
Abstract

Cultural fields cohere not only horizontally, through collaboration, but also vertically, through lineages of artistic influence. Considerable attention has been devoted to collaboration networks in various fields of creative production; however, we know less about the structure of artistic influence that is nevertheless key to individual artistic development and the evolution of genres. We examine the structure of such an influence network in a genealogy of 52 prominent jazz trumpet players, combining musicians' discographies, demographic characteristics, geographical locations, and audio analysis of more than 16,000 recordings with exponential random graph models. Direct collaboration, overlap in collaborators, and sonic context similarity, that is, the similarity of the recordings on which players appear, are each associated with an ascribed influence tie, net of the others. Not surprisingly, ascribed ties connect musicians whose recordings share a similar sonic context, but musicians also tend to collaborate with their influences and share collaborators with them. However, players whose recordings share a sonic context and who move in the same circle of collaborators can be thought of as peers or rivals, rather than as influences of each other, because lineage implies a succession predicated on difference as much as on continuity. Taken together, our findings suggest that a field's account of its own evolution is neither a record of who played together nor a map of shared sonic contexts, but a selective ordering that requires both. While our data do not permit a causal account, our aim is to provide a rich and varied methodological strategy and descriptive as well as inferential tools to understand the yet understudied vertical integration of cultural fields through influence ties.

0.24

Measuring Cross-Cultural Style Diffusion Through Era Classification: US and Korean Popular Music

cs.SD ·2026-08-11 ·Dasol Lee, Minhee Lee, Seonguk Ju, Daewoong Kim, Harin Lee +1 more
published similarity 0.53
Abstract · 8 pages, 6 figures, 4 tables. Accepted at ISMIR 2026

Popular music circulates globally while being locally reinterpreted, yet this process of cross-cultural style diffusion has rarely been quantified. We propose an era-classification framework for measuring temporal alignment between chart cultures. CNN classifiers trained from scratch on Billboard Hot 100 audio are applied to Korean Melon chart songs. Korean chart songs from the 1960s through the 1980s are consistently inferred as belonging to earlier Billboard eras, by a median of about four to five years, while the same models remain unbiased on held-out Billboard audio. The offset then halves at the 1990s, to roughly two to three years, and holds there through the 2000s. Reverse inference shows a complementary narrowing, and the pattern holds across architectures and seeds. We interpret these results as reflecting how globally circulating pop styles were locally adopted and progressively synchronized. The framework can be applied to other pairs of chart cultures beyond the US-Korea case examined here.

0.25

Project Qualia: Recovering Experiential Music Structure from Session Co-occurrence Data

cs.SD cs.IRcs.LG ·2026-09-09 ·Nizam Mohammed, Abu B. S. Rahman, Dimuthu D. K. Arachchige
similarity 0.52
Abstract · 10 pages, 3 figures, 4 tables

This report presents results from Project Qualia, an ongoing effort to determine whether experiential similarity between songs, a structure not captured by genre or metadata taxonomies, can be recovered from real listening behavior. We constructed a large-scale dataset of listening sessions, comprising 1.29 billion scrobbles collected from 9,396 users via the Last.fm API and reduced through a preprocessing pipeline to 531.6 million training scrobbles across 28.6 million sessions. On this corpus, we trained a skip-gram Word2Vec model (Song2Vec), treating each session as a sentence and each track as a token. As anticipated, the resulting embedding space was dominated by artist identity, a consequence of single-artist runs within sessions. To test for a subtler, artist-independent signal, we developed an artist-residual procedure: subtracting each artist's centroid from its tracks' embeddings and evaluating whether the remainder retained structure. Mean cross-artist cosine similarity fell from 0.2487 in raw embedding space to 0.0005 in residual space, yet 4,577 cross-artist track pairs retained cosine similarity $\ge 0.70$ in residual space, forming coherent genre- and era-based clusters, including trip-hop, 1990s grunge, 2020 mainstream pop, and cross-composer classical piano pairs at cosine similarity up to 0.95. These results confirm that the training data contains experiential structure independent of artist identity, establishing an empirical basis for an architecture designed to learn this experiential layer directly.

0.25

On the Human and Computer Alignment of Attribute-Based Music Matches

cs.SD cs.AI ·2026-09-01 ·Roser Batlle-Roca, Woosung Choi, Joan Serrà, Fabio Morreale, Wei-Hsiang Liao +3 more
similarity 0.51
Abstract

Recent advances in generative AI are raising ethical concerns regarding the originality of generated content and the potential replication of training data, with further implications for transparency, attribution, and intellectual property. In music, several computational approaches have been proposed to identify potential replication, using audio-based similarity metrics. Yet, their alignment with human judgments across distinct musical attributes remains underexplored. To address this gap, we conduct a perceptual experiment on music matches, defined as strongly similar musical excerpts. We focus on five musical attributes: melody, harmony, rhythm, voice, and timbre. We design a triplet-based forced-choice task comprising 300 cases, including plagiarism examples, cover songs, and AI-generated music. From this experiment, we introduce the MATCHA (Musical Attribute-based Triplet Comparison with Human Annotations) dataset: a collection of 1105 perceptual assessments of attribute-based music matches from 83 expert participants. Our findings reveal measurable agreement among participants in identifying matches across attributes. We further observe partial alignment between human judgments and computational similarity measures. Overall, this work underscores the importance of domain-specific and perceptually grounded evaluation frameworks for generative AI in creative practice.

0.19

Composer2Vec: A Continuous Embedding Space of Composer Style Learned from Symbolic Melody Generation

cs.SD ·2026-09-17 ·Sakutaro Nishio, Osamu Ichikawa
similarity 0.51
Abstract

We analyze the composer embeddings learned by a composer-conditioned Transformer as a continuous latent space of compositional style, rather than merely as an internal representation for generation. A model that recursively predicts melody continuations was trained on melodic sequences extracted from MIDI data, conditioned on composer identity (124 composers). Principal component analysis of the learned composer embedding matrix (124x128) shows that the first principal component correlates strongly with composer birth year (r = -0.884, p < 0.001, n = 123), a stronger correlation than we obtain by applying the same PC1-birth-year analysis to existing general-purpose audio-text embeddings (CLAP, MuQ-MuLan) trained on unrelated audio-text corpora, not on symbolic melody generation. A shuffle test (2,000 permutations) confirms that the Silhouette score for stylistic-period labels is statistically significant (0.0110, p < 0.001). We further show that vector arithmetic in the embedding space captures meaningful stylistic relationships between composers. These results suggest that composer embeddings, learned without supervision beyond composer identity, form an interpretable latent space that captures musical-historical structure.

0.31