CS Paper Radar

On the Tightness of Standard Relaxations for Mixed-Integer Bilevel Linear Programs

Sergey S. Ketkov, Oleg A. Prokopyev

cs.CC math.OC ·submitted 2026-09-09 14:28 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

Exact algorithms for solving mixed-integer bilevel linear programs (MIBLPs) typically rely on sequences of lower and upper bounds that converge to the optimal value. These procedures are commonly initialized using the single-level relaxation (SLR), obtained by omitting the follower's optimality condition and solving the resulting single-level optimization problem. In this paper, we investigate whether, for broad classes of MIBLPs, the resulting standard bounds admit uniform improvements that can be computed within the same computational complexity regime. For pure continuous bilevel linear programs, we show that, unless $P = NP$, neither the SLR-based lower bound nor its associated upper bound can be uniformly improved in polynomial time, even for the class of min-max problems. We then extend this analysis to the class of pure integer min-max bilevel linear programs under the assumption that the polynomial hierarchy does not collapse. First, we show that the continuous relaxation of the SLR admits no uniform polynomial-time computable improvement. We then prove that neither the SLR itself nor its associated upper bound admits a uniform improvement by a polynomial-time algorithm with access to a mixed-integer linear programming (MILP) oracle. Importantly, this rules out uniform improvements by iterative MILP-based approaches, including cutting-plane-based and decomposition algorithms. Overall, our results demonstrate that the SLR-based bounds are, in a complexity-theoretic sense, unimprovable systematically within their natural computational regimes.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

On the Complexity of Linear Programs with Parametric Constraint Matrices

cs.CC math.OC ·2026-10-14 ·Laurie Boveroux, Margarida Carvalho, Andrea Lodi, Quentin Louveaux
benchmark similarity 0.70
Abstract

While sensitivity analysis for linear programs with parametric right- hand side vectors is well established, cases involving parametric constraint matrices remain less explored. To address this gap, we investigate linear programs where the constraint matrix depends linearly on a scalar parameter. Our goal is to compute the minimum and maximum optimal values of these parametric linear programs within a fixed parameter range. This corresponds to solving two bilevel programs. We show that both decision versions of these optimization problems are NP-complete by proving both NP-hardness and membership in NP. We additionally identify three sufficient conditions on the parametric matrix under which the bilevel programs are no longer NP-hard. We introduce a reformulation for both problems, together with a Farkas-based certificate for the lower-level feasibility condition, and compare the execution time for solving them on standard benchmark instances. The experiments highlight a practical dichotomy. Although both bilevel optimizations are NP-hard, computing the parameter value corresponding to the minimum of the linear program is fast, whereas computing the value corresponding to the maximum is not. We relate this asymmetry to the parametric equality constraints, whose free dual variables leave the relaxation of the maximum reformulation unbounded.

0.38

Linear Objective Problems: A Complexity Framework for Bilevel Optimization

cs.CC cs.DMmath.COmath.OC ·2026-11-08 ·Christoph Grüne, James B. Orlin, Lasse Wulf
theory similarity 0.67
Abstract

Many bilevel and robust optimization problems are complete for the second level of the polynomial hierarchy, but such results are usually proven one problem at a time with problem-specific reductions. A recurring obstacle is that the lower level must select an optimal solution rather than merely a feasible one, whereas standard reductions preserve only whether a solution exists, not which solutions are optimal. We introduce linear objective problems (LOP), a framework for optimization problems whose solutions are explicit subsets of a ground set and whose objective is linear in these elements. We define tight solution-embedding reductions, which map the optimal solutions of one problem element by element onto the optimal solutions of another, without having to recognize optimal solutions, which is coNP-hard in general. This gives a notion of LOP-completeness, with Satisfiability as the canonical complete problem, even with unit weights. We show that many classical problems are LOP-complete, including Vertex Cover, Dominating Set, TSP, Knapsack, and Steiner Tree, and we introduce a duality that transfers LOP-completeness between minimization and maximization problems. As our main application, we prove a meta-theorem for min-max regret optimization under interval uncertainty: for every LOP-complete problem, the min-max regret version is $Σ_2^p$-complete. Instead of a separate proof for each nominal problem, it suffices to show that the nominal problem is LOP-complete. This recovers known results for the interval min-max regret versions of Knapsack and Maximum Benefit Set Cover and yields completeness for over 50 further problems.

0.24

Solving Classes of Linear Programs with Strongly Polynomial Straight Line Complexity in Strongly Polynomial Time

cs.DS math.OC ·2026-10-19 ·Daniel Dadush, Zhuan Khye Koh, Bento Natura, Neil Olver, László A. Végh
published similarity 0.65
Abstract · This paper is based on the STOC 2024 proceedings paper "A strongly polynomial algorithm for linear programs with at most two nonzero entries…

Recently, Allamigeon, Dadush, Loho, Natura, and Végh (ADLNV, SICOMP 2025) introduced an interior point method for linear programs whose number of iterations is bounded by the so-called straight line complexity (SLC) of the instance. This yields a strongly polynomial bound on the number of iterations of the corresponding interior point algorithm for broad classes of linear programs. In particular, in the companion paper we give a strongly polynomial straight line complexity bound for two-variable-per-inequality linear programs. However, in order to obtain a strongly polynomial algorithm for these classes, one also needs to address two important technical issues: initialization and bit-complexity bounds. Standard IPM initialization techniques either require numerical estimates that cannot be obtained in the strongly polynomial model, or involve modifying the instance in ways that do not preserve the geometry of the original LP, potentially affecting the SLC. In this work, we present an initialization framework for interior point methods for linear programming, along with a rounding procedure that ensures the continued feasibility of the IPM. We develop a multistage scheme in which each stage can be initialized in strongly polynomial time given the output of the previous stage. Additionally, we address the challenge of controlling the bit complexity of each iterate throughout the algorithm. To this end, we show that it is possible to represent iterates as low-complexity convex combinations of vertices and extreme rays. Our combinatorial rounding step is independent of the algorithm in ADLNV 2025, and can be applied more broadly in the context of path-following methods.

0.30

Extending Tardos's Theorem to Separable Convex Quadratic Programming

cs.DS ·2026-10-05 ·Bin Cui, Hanqing Li, Xupeng Miao
theory similarity 0.65
Abstract · 13 pages, no figures. Substantially revised with a simplified algorithm and proofs. Title and author list updated

For an integer equality matrix $A\in\mathbb{Z}^{r\times m}$ of binary encoding length $\langle A\rangle$, Tardos's theorem solves linear programs using $\operatorname{poly}(r,m,\langle A\rangle)$ rational arithmetic operations and comparisons, independently of the right-hand side and objective coefficients. We extend this guarantee to continuous separable convex quadratic programming over $Ax=b$, $x\ge0$: the operation count is independent of the right-hand side, linear costs, and all nonnegative quadratic weights. The algorithm returns an exact optimal primal-dual pair or a certificate of infeasibility or unboundedness. All intermediate rational numbers have encoding lengths polynomial in the total input length. As an application, we obtain a strongly polynomial algorithm for continuous multicommodity flow with shared capacities and quadratic costs of aggregate arc flow, independently of demands, capacities, and cost coefficients. Objective compression and continuous-integer proximity yield a local solver returning a point close to an optimum. We relax nonnegativity on coordinates with zero optimal dual slack, minimize the largest remaining coordinate, and optimize over the relaxed coordinates. A descent LP over the recession cone provides a complementary bound. Circuit decomposition combines these bounds into a scale ensuring that each local call reveals a new coordinate. At most $m$ calls, followed by two LPs, recover an exact optimum and its dual certificate.

0.20

Approximating the Chvátal--Gomory Closure of Capacity-Bounded Min-Closed Systems

cs.DS ·2026-09-28 ·Stefano Huber, Monaldo Mastrolilli
publishedtheory similarity 0.64
Abstract · 19 pages, a short version of this paper appears in the proceedings of ISAAC 2026

Optimizing over the {0, 1/2} rank-1 Chvàtal-Gomory (CG) closure of a binary integer linear program is NP-hard. While polynomial-time approximation schemes (PTAS) are established for monotone packing and covering formulations, extending these guarantees to mixed-sign variants remains an open challenge. In this paper, we study the approximability of the CG closure for k-slack bounded (capacity-bounded) min-closed systems, a generalized packing formulation with mixed-sign constraints that extends weighted Boolean Horn logic. In these systems, a constant upper bound $k \ge 1$ bounds the ratio between the negative penalty coefficient $q$ and the right-hand side capacity $b$ of every constraint, enforcing $q \le k \cdot b$. We prove that a constant-degree sum-of-squares relaxation yields a PTAS for maximizing linear objectives over the first CG closure generated by multipliers in $\{0\}\cup[\tfrac1f,1]$, for any constant integer $f \ge 2$. This closure is contained in the {0, 1/2} rank-1 CG closure.Optimizing over the {0, 1/2} rank-1 CG closure of a binary integer linear program is NP-hard. While PTASes are established for monotone packing and covering formulations, extending these guarantees to mixed-sign variants remains an open challenge. In this paper, we study the approximability of the CG closure for \emph{$k$-slack bounded (capacity-bounded) min-closed systems}, a generalized packing formulation with mixed-sign constraints that extends weighted Boolean Horn logic. In these systems, a constant upper bound $k \ge 1$ bounds the ratio between the negative penalty coefficient $q$ and the right-hand side capacity $b$ of every constraint, enforcing $q \le k \cdot b$. We prove that a constant-degree sum-of-squares relaxation yields a PTAS for maximizing linear objectives over the first CG closure generated by multipliers in $\{0\}\cup[\tfrac1f,1]$, for any constant integer $f \ge 2$.

0.61

Hardness of integer linear feasibility with cyclic support

cs.DM math.OC ·2026-11-05 ·Marco Di Summa
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract

We prove that integer linear feasibility is strongly $NP$-complete even when the constraint matrix has exactly two nonzero entries in every row and column, with its support forming a single cycle. This holds already for monotone systems (one positive and one negative coefficient in each inequality) with nonzero coefficients of absolute value $2$ or $3$ and right-hand sides in $\{-1,0,1,2\}$. No variable bounds are supplied separately from the system. For systems in which each inequality involves at most two variables, this strengthens known hardness results by restricting all numerical data to fixed finite sets. For systems in which each variable occurs in at most two inequalities, this establishes, to the best of our knowledge, the first $NP$-hardness result for feasibility. We also give negative answers, unless $P=NP$, to questions on polynomial-time solvability of integer programs with bounded coefficients and bounded totally $Δ$-modular treewidth, and on fixed-parameter tractability of integer bound propagation with respect to coefficient and right-hand-side magnitudes.

0.24

On solving integer bilevel optimization problems with a non-convex quadratic follower objective function using disjunctive cuts

cs.DM math.OC ·2026-10-01 ·Kübra Tanınmış, Elisabeth Gaar, Jon Lee, Ivana Ljubić, Markus Sinnl
similarity 0.60
Abstract

In this work, we study bilevel optimization problems where all variables are integer, all constraints and the leader objective function are linear, and the follower objective function is non-convex quadratic. Relying on bilevel-free sets derived from improving directions, we develop a disjunctive cut approach to exclude bilevel-infeasible solutions within a branch-and-cut algorithm. We show that our disjunctive cuts can be obtained by solving a cut generating linear program. Furthermore, we discuss conditions that allow the number of disjuncts in the cut generating linear program to be reduced, and we propose several strategies to identify improving directions and generate disjunctive cuts efficiently. We evaluate various aspects of the proposed branch-and-cut algorithm on both convex instances from the literature that fit our setting and new non-convex instances and compare the performance of our best approach with existing state-of-the-art approaches, which we significantly outperform.

0.21

Two-Stage Mixed-Integer Quadratic Programming in Polynomial Time

cs.CC math.OCcs.DS ·2026-11-10 ·Alberto Del Pia
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Lenstra showed that mixed-integer linear programming can be solved in polynomial time when the number of integer variables is fixed and the number of continuous variables is arbitrary. Mixed-integer quadratic programming (MIQP) can be solved in polynomial time when the total number of variables is fixed. However, since MIQP is NP-hard already without integer variables, the analog of Lenstra's result fails unless P = NP. Hence, polynomial-time algorithms for MIQP with an arbitrary number of continuous variables must exploit additional structure. We study MIQPs with two-stage structure, which underlies Benders decomposition and two-stage stochastic programming. A few linking variables, including all integer variables, are coupled with many blocks of continuous variables that interact only through them, both in the constraints and in the objective. We give a polynomial-time algorithm for MIQP with an arbitrary quadratic objective when the number of linking variables and the block size are fixed, while the number of blocks, and hence the number of variables, is arbitrary. The case with no blocks is MIQP in fixed dimension. None of our assumptions can be dropped. Unless P = NP, the number of linking variables and the block size must both be fixed, the blocks cannot interact or contain integer variables, and large blocks cannot be allowed even if their objective is linear. Unless FPT = W[1], the exponent of the running time must depend on both the number of linking variables and the block size.

0.34