CS Paper Radar

Debate-to-Skill: Capability-Bound Process Supervision for Industrial Query-to-Agent Annotation

Shiyu Zhang, Leisheng Cheng, Huifu Li

cs.AI ·submitted 2026-09-10 07:24 UTC · v1
top venuebenchmark

Abstract

Industrial query-to-agent matching fails when topical relevance is mistaken for executable capability, especially on long-tail and boundary-sensitive requests. We formulate annotation as \emph{capability-bound process supervision} and instantiate it with Debate-to-Skill, which uses reusable decision principles, structured deliberation, verifier-based verdict extraction, and disagreement-driven refinement. On an industrial Query2Agent benchmark, we compare Debate-to-Skill with direct-label supervision, reasoning-SFT, and structural ablations. The results test whether gains come from supervising the capability-critical decision process itself, especially on grey-zone cases where semantic relatedness and executable capability diverge.

Comment
Accepted at EMNLP 2026

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

PrimeSeeker: Capability-Oriented Supervision for Deep Search Agents

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-09-20 ·Linzhi Peng, Hanting Chen, Heng Chang, Ke Cheng, Bowen Du +1 more
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Large language model search agents are often trained with synthetic questions whose difficulty is increased through larger evidence graphs, additional hops, and longer trajectories. These global properties, however, are only indirect proxies for the local retrieval capabilities required during search. To address this mismatch, we introduce latent anchor reasoning, which consists of resolving an unnamed retrieval anchor from descriptive specifications and transferring the recovered anchor into a subsequent information demand. This primitive retrieval unit decomposes deep search into chains of coupled operations and organizes question construction around anchor resolution and relation transfer, without prescribing a canonical search path. Based on this formulation, we propose PrimeSeeker, a capability-oriented framework that constructs web-grounded anchor structures and jointly derives a question and a reference evidence skeleton. The skeleton preserves supporting evidence from construction and guides expert generation through extractive highlights of current tool observations. These highlights are removed before supervised fine-tuning, while the skeleton is subsequently reused to audit reference-step coverage for reinforcement-learning rewards. We construct 9,221 expert trajectories, training a 30B search agent. Across five deep-search benchmarks, PrimeSeeker achieves strong performance, while reference-step optimization further improves the supervised policy. The resulting trajectories exhibit low retrieval redundancy, and fixed-budget evaluation shows strong solution coverage with substantially fewer tool calls than long-horizon systems.

0.14

SKALOS: Learning to Distinguish Similar Skills with Capability Graphs

cs.AI ·2026-10-26 ·Wenhan Xiao, Ziwei Zhang, Xingcheng Fu, Chuanyue Yu, Haonan Yuan +3 more
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 12 pages, 7 figures, 19 tables

Skills provide LLM agents with reusable procedural knowledge, making appropriate skill selection essential for reliable agent behavior. As skill libraries expand, distinguishing semantically similar candidates becomes increasingly difficult. Existing methods encode or rewrite skill descriptions for relevance-based ranking, yet heterogeneous descriptions can obscure capability differences. To address this challenge, we propose SKALOS, a graph-native reranker that compares skills via explicit capability evidence. Its multi-hierarchy graph aligns equivalent expressions across skills while preserving skill-specific capability evidence. Since individually relevant capability elements may not jointly support a query, semiring-based capability witness learning scores each branch by its weakest evidence, checks joint support for the extracted requirements within one implementation, and selects the strongest alternative. To reduce the influence of extraction errors, we develop ranking-feedback graph calibration that adjusts unreliable evidence for candidate comparison. Experiments on SkillRet show that SKALOS improves NDCG@10 by 2.68 percentage points over a matched text-only reranker. Witness-guided skill selection also increases ALFWorld task success rate from 22% to 29%.

0.27

Extracting Knowledge from Tools in LLM Agents

cs.CR ·2026-08-31 ·Chuanchao Zang, Jianing Wang, Wenyu Chen, Xiangtao Meng, Li Wang +4 more
similarity 0.62
Abstract

LLM agents commonly use knowledge-based tools and access their underlying files, databases, and search indexes through tool invocation. This integration improves agents' ability to provide domain-specific services but also introduces the risk of tool-mediated knowledge extraction: source content exposed to an agent for legitimate responses may be progressively recovered from its outputs, enabling reconstruction of the knowledge source behind a target tool. This paper systematically investigates this risk and identifies two challenges introduced by tool invocation: tool-selection uncertainty, where an agent may invoke a competing tool instead of the target tool, and tool-argument compression, where fine-grained query information may be lost when the agent generates tool arguments. To tackle these challenges, we propose ToolSiphon, a query-only extraction attack that introduces two complementary signals: a target-discriminative signal, implemented through Tool Contrastive Analysis, to steer queries toward the target tool; and a response-grounded factual signal, implemented through Evidence Chained Feedback, to mitigate argument compression and progressively expand extraction coverage. Across three types of knowledge-based tools and six domain-specific datasets, ToolSiphon recovers 74.3% of source records on average when coarse-grained information about non-target tools is available, with 83.2% textual recovery and 90.2% semantic similarity. Even without such information, it recovers 66.3% of source records. ToolSiphon also remains effective against representative defenses and on three real-world agent platforms.

0.23

Skill2Query: Exploiting Skill Structure to Generate Pseudo-Queries for Agent Skill Retrieval

cs.CL cs.IR ·2026-08-17 ·Lihui Ding, Zihan Guo, Bingwei Lu, Chenyu Zhou, Yuanjian Zhou +3 more
code/datahighly cited similarity 0.62
Abstract

Pseudo-query generation can alleviate the supervision bottleneck for agent skill retrieval, but existing document-level approaches typically leave the rich internal relations among capabilities, parameters, and usage examples implicit. As a result, generated queries may be topically relevant to a skill while lacking capability grounding and parameter consistency, raising the question of whether explicitly exploiting a skill document's internal structure can produce more effective retrieval signals. We therefore propose Skill2Query, a framework that first parses a skill document into a Skill Knowledge Graph and then generates pseudo-queries through a three-stage process including style mimicking, query template generation, and parameter filling. The generated queries can be used for offline index augmentation, online query expansion, and retriever training. Four benchmarks (TheoremQA, LogicBench, ToolQA, and CHAMP) are used to evaluate Skill2Query with large-scale skill candidate pools across multiple downstream applications, including skill retrieval, retriever training, and end-to-end agent execution. Using nearly 30K skills across diverse domains, we generate 700K category-diverse pseudo-queries. Skill2Query consistently improves sparse, dense, and skill-routing retrieval, with an average Recall@1 gain of 6.70 percentage points across retrieval settings. Skill2Query-generated training data also achieves the best Recall@1 and nDCG@1 among the evaluated generation baselines. Further evaluations with multiple LLM backends demonstrate that improved skill retrieval translates into higher agent task success rates. Code and resources are available at https://github.com/MatZaharia/Skill2Query.

0.52

SkillQR: Agentic Skill Discovery for Reason-Intensive Query Rewriting

cs.IR ·2026-10-24 ·Kenan Jiang, Meixiu Long, Zihao Zhang, Ran Xu, Eugene Agichtein +1 more
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Dense retrievers provide grounded evidence that mitigates hallucinations in outputs from Large Language Models (LLMs). Real-world queries are often verbose, ambiguously framed, or require multi-step reasoning, introducing irrelevant details that weaken semantic matching for dense retrievers. Query rewriting is a widely adopted pre-retrieval technique that leverages LLMs to reformulate queries and bridge the semantic gap between such queries and the retrieval target. Existing rewriting approaches either rely on expensive proprietary models, substantial training data, or iterative retrieval and rewriting, while largely applying a uniform rewriting strategy regardless of the retrieval corpus. We observe that effective query rewriting instructions are not universal: the optimal strategy depends on the retrieval target, rather than the model alone. We introduce SkillQR, a query rewriting framework that automatically discovers reasoning strategy sets from the retrieval target and dynamically routes a query to the appropriate rewriting strategy at inference time. Without relying on training data, SkillQR achieves competitive performance compared to fine-tuned rewriting models on the BRIGHT and R2MED benchmarks, while also providing lower inference latency than iterative rewriting approaches.

0.13

IndustrialKnowEval: A Benchmark for Evaluating Multi-Level Industrial Knowledge in LLMs

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-11-16 ·Haiteng Wang, Haoze Li, Jingwei Guo, Jingbo Zhou, Si Liu +1 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.61
Abstract · 26 pages (13 pages of main text and 13 pages of appendix), 11 figures

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly explored for industrial tasks, yet few benchmarks evaluate their mastery of industrial knowledge across different types of cognitive demand. We introduce IndustrialKnowEval (IndKnow), a benchmark for industrial knowledge and engineering question answering. It contains 43,282 samples covering 21 task types across seven industrial sectors, including aerospace, electric power, and metallurgy, organized into four levels of cognitive demand: memory, comprehension, reasoning, and engineering application. Enterprise-based domain specialists and experienced researchers participate in all stages of dataset construction and quality control. We conduct a series of experiments on 18 representative LLMs, with domain experts deeply involved in the evaluation. Building upon IndKnow, we propose the Industrial Cognitive Capability Gap (ICCG) metric to characterize the performance differential between foundational industrial knowledge and higher-order reasoning and application, and we analyze it alongside absolute performance to provide a more complete view of model capabilities. We anticipate that IndustrialKnowEval will support the benchmarking of LLMs in industrial scenarios and promote the development of robust industrial intelligence. Code is available at: https://github.com/J4cksonLee/IndKnow

0.52

SkillRefine: Cross-Source Skill Induction and Execution Validation for LLM Agents in Refinery Planning Software

cs.CE ·2026-09-25 ·Dongxiao Liu, Boren Zhu, Yuwen Ding, Linghui Li, Lei Li +1 more
benchmark similarity 0.61
Abstract · 8 pages, 4 figures, 2 tables

Operating industrial planning software such as AspenTech PIMS (Process Industry Modeling System) requires an LLM agent to combine structural knowledge, procedural knowledge from expert records, and constraints revealed only during execution. These evidence sources are heterogeneous and individually incomplete: documentation describes tables and interfaces but omits task-level coordination, expert CASE records expose multi-table modification patterns without explicit schema grounding, and execution feedback reveals latent constraints only when a plan is executed. We present \textsc{SkillRefine}, a framework that exploits the Documentation--Practice Gap between documented structure and expert practice to extract candidate coordination patterns, ground them against table definitions and COM specifications, and compile them into progressively disclosed skill packages with provenance. The library is then refined through label-free compliance screening, oracle-based match decomposition over table, row, column, and value dimensions, and signal-conditioned trajectory attribution for localized repair. We evaluate \textsc{SkillRefine} on PIMS-Bench, a benchmark built from two AspenTech PIMS demonstration models, using disjoint construction and held-out test tasks. On the held-out test set, \textsc{SkillRefine} achieves absolute component match F1 gains of 14\%--30\% across four LLM backbones, with the largest gains on complex multi-table coordination tasks.

0.48

From Relevance to Validity: Zero-Shot Tool Selection via Functional and Contextual Validation

cs.AI ·2026-10-14 ·Xiaoxuan Dong, Jin Zhang, Zichen Yuan, Yue Zhou, Zihao Rao +9 more
hot direction similarity 0.60
Abstract

Large language model (LLM) agents increasingly face tasks from unseen domains and execution contexts, making zero-shot tool selection essential for identifying tools that can satisfy task requirements. Existing dominant methods mainly rely on relevance ranking, but semantic matching alone cannot ensure that a tool is functionally compatible or remains applicable in a new context. We preliminarily identify a \emph{transfer-validity gap}, where semantically relevant tools may still fail to satisfy functional or contextual requirements after transfer. To address this gap, we propose \methodname{}, a progressive validation framework that complements semantic relevance with endpoint-grounded functional compatibility and task-conditioned contextual evidence. Across cross-domain and cross-dataset transfer, \methodname{} consistently improves capability ranking, with larger gains under functional or contextual ambiguity. Ablation results further confirm the complementary contributions of functional and contextual validation.

0.31