CS Paper Radar

Existence of the Core in Approval-Based Committee Elections

Patrick Becker, Matthias Greger, Dominik Peters

cs.GT ·submitted 2026-09-10 17:57 UTC · v2
theoryhighly cited

Abstract

We resolve the central open question in the theory of approval-based committee elections: we prove that the core is always non-empty. This means that there always exists a committee for which no coalition of voters can deviate to an alternative committee of proportional size that every member strictly prefers. This property was introduced by Aziz et al. (2017) to capture proportional representation and coalitional stability, but no known algorithm achieved it except up to a constant approximation factor or in special cases. Our approach begins by strengthening the core to core+, which requires the committee to be robust even to fractional deviations. Using LP duality, this property can equivalently be defined in terms of a payment-based certificate under which no losing candidate gathers too much support. We then define a voting rule that chooses a committee admitting a certificate that maximizes a novel harmonic entropy objective function, which rewards balanced payment distributions. We show that the payment system associated with an optimal committee certifies that the committee satisfies core+, establishing existence. The same is true for local optima, which allows us to design a polynomial-time algorithm computing a core+ committee.

Comment
43 pages, with a completely rewritten exposition of the argument

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Nash Core in Multiwinner Election

cs.GT ·2026-08-31 ·Ashish Goel, Zhihao Jiang, Chenghan Zhou
theory similarity 0.78
Abstract

In the approval-based committee selection problem, a committee is said to be in the core if no subset of voters has an incentive to deviate by selecting a \emph{blocking} committee of proportional size, such that every voter in the deviating group strictly prefers the blocking committee. We consider the setting where candidates can be selected fractionally. Under a mild regularity assumption, we show that there always exists a weighting of candidates such that the fractional committee maximizing the candidate-weighted Nash Social Welfare is in the core. We refer to such a solution as being in the \emph{Nash core}. Additionally, we show that a Nash core solution admits a payment assignment between voters and candidates, where each voter pays a candidate they approve in proportion to the weight. For the discrete setting, where each candidate is either included or excluded from the committee, we prove that every approval-based committee election with at most eight equally weighted voters has a core committee by rounding the fractional Nash core solution. Although the non-emptiness of the core in this setting remains an open question and checking core membership is coNP-hard, we extend the notion of the Nash core to the discrete case, yielding a formulation that is efficiently verifiable and offers a promising path toward establishing core existence in discrete settings. Finally, we test our approach on real voting data using a payment-guided heuristic. We empirically show that the Nash core solution can be efficiently computed through an iterative algorithm in both the fractional and discrete settings.

0.37

Best-of-Both Worlds Proportionality in Structured Committee Elections

cs.GT ·2026-10-20 ·Dimitris Avramidis, Mark de Berg, Ulrike Schmidt-Kraepelin
similarity 0.76
Abstract

We study randomized committee elections with additive preferences, where we seek best-of-both-worlds proportionality. That is, we strive for strong guarantees for the selection probabilities ex ante and each realized committee ex post. We focus on structured preferences and introduce antichain single-peakedness, a restricted domain generalizing single-peaked additive preferences as well as several well-studied approval domains. Our approach first computes a fractional committee and then decomposes it through a rounding rule called systematic rounding. Among profile-oblivious rounding rules, we characterize systematic rounding as the unique rule satisfying natural quota guarantees, and thereby the only promising rule for our two-step approach. We show that ex-ante core stability is incompatible with ex-post justified representation $JR$, even under single-peaked preferences. However, applying systematic rounding to certain fractional allocations that form so-called Lindahl equilibria yields ex-ante core stability and ex-post core stability up to one. Alternatively, we retain exact ex-post proportionality and approximate the ex-ante core using two parameters: $α$ raises the utility gain required for a deviation, while $β$ reduces the coalition's proportional share. We establish the tight threshold $αβ$=2. Below it, ex-post JR is incompatible even under single-peaked preferences; at and above it, adapting a fractional rule called BestRepresentative [Pierczyński and Skowron, 2022] and applying systematic rounding to its output yields ex-ante $α, β$-fractional core stability and ex-post PJR under antichain single-peaked preferences.

0.07

Finding Representative and Approximately Efficient Committees

cs.GT ·2026-09-07 ·Dominik Peters, Rohit Vaish, Jatin Yadav
similarity 0.74
Abstract

In approval-based committee voting, proportional approval voting (PAV) is a well-studied rule that combines proportional representation with Pareto efficiency. However, computing a PAV committee is NP-hard, raising a natural question: Can the proportionality and efficiency properties of PAV be achieved via computationally efficient procedures? We make two contributions toward answering this question. First, building on the known proportionality guarantees of the local-search-based variant of PAV (or local PAV), we systematically study its efficiency properties. We show that local PAV committees are weakly Pareto optimal, meaning that no other committee is strictly preferred by every voter. We also identify limitations: Local PAV guarantees only a $2$-approximation to fractional Pareto optimality ($2$-fPO) and a $2/3$-approximation to the optimal PAV score, and both bounds are tight. In contrast, global PAV is Pareto optimal and satisfies the stronger $α^\star$-fPO guarantee, where $α^\star \approx 1.346$ is the unique solution of $\int_0^{α^\star} \frac{1-e^{-y}}{y} \, dy = 1$, and this approximation is tight. Second, we design a polynomial-time algorithm that combines the best of these guarantees. The committee returned by our algorithm satisfies EJR$+$ (a proportionality guarantee), $α^\star$-fPO, and weak Pareto optimality. It also achieves a $0.79$-approximation to the optimal PAV score, matching the best possible polynomial-time approximation assuming $P \neq NP$. Our algorithm works by pipage rounding a concave relaxation of the PAV objective and using that committee to initialize local PAV, thereby combining global approximation guarantees with local search stability.

0.41

Sequential Phragmén Guarantees 2-Approximate Core Stability

cs.GT ·2026-09-11 ·Jianan Lin, Chenhao Wang
similarity 0.70
Abstract

We study approximately stable committee selection under approval preferences, following Cheng et al.~[EC~2019] and Jiang, Munagala, and Wang~[STOC~2020]. In an approval-based committee election, $n$ voters each approve a subset of the candidates, and a committee of size $k$ is selected. A size-$k$ committee is $λ$-stable if, for every nonempty subset $T$ of candidates, the number of voters who strictly prefer $T$ is less than $λ$ times the proportional share $\frac{n|T|}{k}$. We consider sequential Phragmén, a classical polynomial-time voting rule, and prove that it always returns a $2$-stable committee. This implies that the $2$-core is always nonempty and improves upon the $3.651$-stability guarantee of Gao, Sun, and Vondrák~[EC~2026]. The guarantee also extends to weighted voters and is tight even for unweighted elections: for every $1\leλ<2$, sequential Phragmén can return a committee that is not $λ$-stable. Compared with the exact-core algorithm developed in concurrent work by Becker, Greger, and Peters~[arXiv~2026], sequential Phragmén is simpler to implement, and our proof of its $2$-stability is elementary.

0.39

Exact Sizewise Least Cores for Candidate-Disjoint Approval Chains

cs.GT ·2026-09-03 ·Jiarui Fang
code/data similarity 0.70
Abstract · 14 pages, code and other materials are available at: https://github.com/Baymax-ray/sizewise-least-core

For approval-based committee elections, the sizewise least-core value $Γ(P)$ minimizes the maximum excess support of a deviation over size-$k$ committees. Deviations are nonempty and contain at most $k$ candidates, with support measured relative to their Hare quota. A negative value certifies core nonemptiness, while $-Γ(P)$ is the largest worst-case quota shortfall secured by any committee. We quantify this margin on candidate-disjoint approval chains, a domain whose qualitative core nonemptiness is already known. We first factor each committee's deviation score over disjoint components. For chains, a closed local table yields the exact value and an attaining committee in polynomial time for rational weights. For nonnegative normalized real weights, let $q_{\mathrm{act}}\ge1$ count the connected components of the positive-support incidence graph. Then \[ Γ(P)\le-\frac{1}{k\min\{q_{\mathrm{act}},k+1\}}. \] Explicit extremal profiles show that this dependence on the active-component count is sharp. The margin is $1$-Lipschitz in total variation on the full ballot space. Each negative margin therefore certifies a neighborhood with nonempty core, even when perturbations leave the chain domain.

0.41

Veto Proportionality in Multiwinner Voting with Ranked Preferences

cs.GT ·2026-11-14 ·Haris Aziz, Yuhang Guo, Patrick Lederer
similarity 0.69
Abstract · Abstract shortened due to arXiv length restrictions

Proportional representation in committee voting with ranked preferences requires voter groups to influence the selected committee in proportion to their size. Existing axioms, such as proportionality for solid coalitions (PSC), demand that like-minded groups of voters are entitled to elect a fair number of candidates to the committee. However, in applications where voters are collectively affected by the entire committee, it may be equally important that no group is confronted with a disproportionate number of candidates that it regards as undesirable. Motivated by this, we initiate the study of veto proportionality in committee elections with ranked preferences. Our central notion, the proportional multiwinner veto core (PMVC), generalizes Moulin's proportional singlewinner veto core to multiwinner elections by allowing groups of voters to partially veto sets of candidates. We analyze how the PMVC relates to existing fairness notions and design rules that are guaranteed to select committees from the PMVC. Specifically, we first introduce a duality framework that connects inclusion- and exclusion-based fairness notions and show, e.g., that the dual axiom of the PMVC strengthens PSC. We further show that STV satisfies the dual axiom of the PMVC, which also implies the existence of committees in the PMVC. Subject to a strengthening of committee monotonicity, we characterize the rules that always return committees in the PMVC as sequential adaptations of singlewinner voting rules that always select from the proportional singlewinner veto core. By our duality framework, this also gives rise to a new class of rules that satisfy PSC. We further prove that the dual axiom of the PMVC and RankPJR+ are jointly satisfiable, thereby pushing the frontier of fairness guarantees that can always be attained. Finally, we show that deciding whether a given committee belongs to the PMVC is coNP-complete.

0.09

The Deterministic Hare Core Is Nonempty for Nine-Seat Approval Elections

cs.GT math.CO ·2026-09-03 ·Jiarui Fang
theorycode/data similarity 0.69
Abstract · 12 pages. Verification code and reproducibility materials: https://github.com/Baymax-ray/approval-core-nine-seats

Core stability gives approval-based committee elections a strong form of coalitional proportionality, but deterministic existence is not known for an arbitrary number of seats. We prove that every finite election with nine seats has a deterministic Hare-quota core committee. Starting from an eight-seat committee that is both a global Proportional Approval Voting (PAV) maximizer and core stable, we suppose that all one-candidate extensions are blocked and extract an inclusion-minimal closed response system. Singleton responses are eliminated by exact equality rigidity. For the remaining responses, rational Farkas certificates bound every nonpositive PAV add-marginal drift below by $-n/189$ and force every successor drift above $n/126$. The uniform response chain is irreducible, so stationarity makes these bounds incompatible. The computer-assisted component comprises an exact pointwise check over 7,356 voter types, 36 one-blocker cells, and a symmetry-complete family of 19 two-blocker motifs. Exact certificate archives and standard-library verifiers support these checks. The theorem settles the nine-seat case but does not decide deterministic core existence for arbitrary committee size.

0.46

Proportional Representation for Almost-Solid Coalitions and the Proportional Veto Core for Rankings

cs.GT ·2026-11-19 ·Evi Micha, Fatih Erdem Kizilkaya
similarity 0.69
Abstract

A proportional ranking should give groups of voters representation commensurate with their size at every prefix. Proportionality for solid coalitions (PSC) provides this guarantee to groups whose members rank the same set of candidates above all others. How much representation should a group receive when a few outside candidates disrupt that agreement? We extend the proportional veto core to rankings through candidatewise and setwise guarantees. We show that setwise veto protection is equivalent to robust Rank-PSC under reversal of both the voters' preferences and the collective ranking. Robust Rank-PSC extends representation guarantees to almost-solid coalitions at every prefix. Each distinct outside candidate that disrupts a coalition's agreement reduces its guaranteed representation by at most one, and this bound is tight. Using reverse-sequential variants of Ordered Phragmén and STV, we construct rankings satisfying robust Rank-PSC$+$ in polynomial time. This stronger axiom preserves the guarantee after deleting any suffix of the collective ranking and restricting voters' preferences to the remaining candidates. Verifying robust Rank-PSC is coNP-complete, whereas verifying robust Rank-PSC$+$ takes polynomial time. We also introduce Rank-Aligned PJR$+$, which requires the first $r$ candidates of the collective ranking to satisfy PJR$+$ when each voter approves their top $r$ candidates. We give a polynomial-time algorithm that meets this requirement simultaneously for every $r$. For fixed-size committees, the Expanding Approvals Rule guarantees Rank-PJR$+$ but can violate robust PSC regardless of how ties are broken or payments are assigned. We give a modification that satisfies both guarantees for any prescribed committee size.

0.14