CS Paper Radar

Investigating Developer-Reported Software Security Testing Challenges

Md Erfan, Ahmed Ryan, Md Rayhanur Rahman

cs.SE cs.CR ·submitted 2026-09-10 04:41 UTC · v1

Abstract

Software security testing (SST) is essential for identifying vulnerabilities and improving software security, but developers often face practical challenges when selecting tools, configuring test environments, interpreting scanner outputs, testing authentication workflows, and acting on reported vulnerabilities. This study empirically characterizes developer-reported SST challenges in Stack Overflow (SO) discussions and examines their prevalence, difficulty, temporal evolution, co-occurrence, and taxonomy stability. We analyze 17,743 SO questions collected using SST-related keywords. Through manual labeling, we identify 582 SST-related questions and construct a taxonomy of 8 categories and 31 subcategories. We then analyze these challenges using prevalence, difficulty, correlation, temporal trend, co-occurrence, and held-out stability analyses. The results show that developers frequently discuss security finding interpretation and reliability, security testing guidance and tool selection, authentication and authorization testing, and security tool integration and automation. Validation-related challenges often require more technical context and longer resolution time. Security finding interpretation and remediation-related actionability show increasing trends over time. Co-occurrence analysis shows that false positives frequently appear with explainability, while integration challenges often appear with tool suggestions and documentation/resources. Overall, developer-reported SST challenges extend beyond vulnerability detection and include workflow, configuration, interpretation, and remediation concerns. These findings can help researchers, practitioners, educators, and tool providers improve SST usability, documentation, result interpretation, and remediation support.

Comment
34 pages

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Automating Static Code Analysis Through CI/CD Pipeline Integration

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-09-01 ·Zachary Wadhams, Ann Marie Reinhold, Clemente Izurieta
top venuehighly cited similarity 0.73
Abstract · 7 pages, 3 figures, published in 2024 IEEE International Conference on Software Analysis, Evolution and Reengineering - Companion (SANER-C),…

In the contemporary landscape of software devel-opment, securing sensitive data is paramount to safeguarding organizational reputation, preventing financial losses, and pro-tecting individuals from identity theft. This paper addresses the pervasive challenge of identifying and rectifying security vulnerabilities early in the development process, emphasizing the role of Static Application Security Testing (SAST) tools. While SAST tools play a crucial role in detecting vulnerabilities, widespread adoption has been hindered by usability issues, including high false positive rates and a lack of native pipeline support. This paper proposes a novel, generalized, and automated process for aggregating SAST tool outputs and integrating them into developers' familiar issue-tracking software. The process streamlines the identification and communication of security vulnerabilities during the development lifecycle, facilitating more efficient remediation efforts. We demonstrate the successful implementation of the proposed process with the SonarQube SAST tool in a GitLab-based development environment. Developers were positive about the structured implementation, real-time feedback, and proactive vulnerability management. However, despite some challenges such as a potential learning curve and tradeoffs between secure coding and workflow disruption, the overall positive impact on security awareness and responsiveness suggests that the proposed process holds promise in enhancing the security posture of software development practices

0.74

Barriers to Using Static Application Security Testing (SAST) Tools: A Literature Review

cs.SE cs.CR ·2026-09-01 ·Zachary Wadhams, Clemente Izurieta, Ann Marie Reinhold
top venuesurveypositionhighly cited similarity 0.71
Abstract · 6 pages, 4 figures, published at 2024 39th IEEE/ACM International Conference on Automated Software Engineering Workshops (ASEW)

Developers face a challenging problem with no clear solution. Modern software breaches can wreak havoc on businesses and individuals alike. With code vulnerabilities being a leading cause, securing applications must be a priority for developers. Static Application Security Testing (SAST) has the potential to harden applications by assisting in the identification and resolution of security vulnerabilities. Despite this, many development teams have not adopted SAST tools into their environment. In this paper, we survey the recent literature to uncover why some developers are apprehensive towards SAST and identify what specific problems they encounter when using it. We found a variety of usability problems developers face when using SAST. Some are inherent of the tool and ultimately require some level of developer investment while others are tool shortcomings that SAST tool creators must address. Ultimately, we argue that in order to drive widespread adoption and consistent SAST usage, developers will need to embrace that some investment is required. Simultaneously, developers will be more likely to integrate SAST tools into their workflows if the creators of SAST tools simplify many aspects related to tool usage. Surmounting the primary obstacles preventing the adoption of SAST requires full consideration of both the technical and human factors.

0.65

Large Language Models at the Intersection of Software Engineering and Software Security:An Evidence-Centered Structured Survey and Research Agenda

cs.AI cs.SE ·2026-08-21 ·Wei Lin, Tao Zhou, Zhaofei Xie, Changgui Hong
benchmark similarity 0.69
Abstract

Large Language Models (LLMs) are moving from code completion toward repository-scale agents that retrieve context, edit files, execute tools, and participate in security-sensitive workflows. The evidence for these systems, however, remains divided between software engineering evaluations centered on functional task completion and software security evaluations centered on vulnerability detection, secure generation, or exploit-oriented validation. This evidence-centered structured survey synthesizes representative work available through May 31, 2026 across software engineering tasks, software security tasks, adaptation mechanisms, artifact granularity, and evaluation design. In addition to a task taxonomy, we introduce an assurance framework that separates functional correctness, security, operational reliability, evidence provenance, and agent authority. The review shows that execution feedback and repository access can substantially improve engineering task completion, but do not by themselves establish security; conversely, static-analysis labels or vulnerability-classification scores rarely establish deployable correctness. We identify recurring validity threats--weak test oracles, duplicated and temporally leaked data, changing agent harnesses, proxy-only security checks, and under-reported budgets and human intervention--and derive a minimum reporting protocol for cross-study comparison. The resulting research agenda prioritizes jointly secure-and-functional benchmarks, repository-scale threat models, calibrated human oversight, longitudinal maintainability evidence, and reproducible agent evaluation. The central conclusion is that model capability should be judged as an assurance case supported by task-appropriate evidence, rather than by a single benchmark score.

0.14

Characterizing GitHub Security Actions Alerts For Web Application Tutorials

cs.SE ·2026-11-18 ·Bhagya Chembakottu, Martin P. Robillard
similarity 0.68
Abstract

The high frequency of cybersecurity incidents involving web applications highlights the importance of secure software development practices. Static Application Security Testing (SAST) tools help identify potential vulnerabilities in source code without executing the code. Integrating SAST tools into GitHub Security Actions enables security alerts to be reported during development. However, the characteristics of these alerts can make them difficult for developers with limited security expertise to understand, prioritize, and address. Many tutorials for learning web application development also involve source code with security implications. We investigated the properties of SAST alerts relevant to this learning context. We analyzed 6,609 alerts from four default GitHub Security Actions configurations across 60 Django and Spring tutorial repositories. We evaluated the alerts along four dimensions: alert volume, alert relevance, conceptual breadth, and remediation usability. Of the 6,609 alerts, 3,750 (56.7\%) targeted tutorial-related files, while 2,859 (43.3\%) targeted other repository files. The configurations triggered between 34 and 646 distinct rules, and the five most frequently triggered rules accounted for 25.2\%--68.2\% of alerts, depending on the configuration. Across configurations, 0.4\%--32.1\% of alert messages named concrete framework or code constructs, and 0\%--8.1\% met our operational criteria for remediation specificity. Overall, default GitHub Security Actions report a diverse set of security alerts, but these alerts do not consistently focus on tutorial code or provide concrete guidance for addressing the reported issues.

0.28

How Effectively Do Security Skills Guide Coding Agents in Vulnerability Detection in Linux Kernel?

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-10-19 ·Haoran Xue, Nikta Akbarpour, Gias Uddin, Song Wang
benchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract

Large language model (LLM) coding agents, such as Claude Code, are increasingly used for security auditing, with task-specific skills providing reusable vulnerability-analysis procedures. However, their effectiveness in detecting real vulnerabilities and the reasons for their failures remain unclear. We conduct the first large-scale empirical study of 37 security skills using Claude Code with four underlying LLMs on 100 real Linux kernel vulnerabilities across ten classes, totaling 14800 runs. We evaluate vulnerability detection at the function, statement, and vulnerability-class levels. Results show that 24.4 percent of runs locate the correct function, 18.3 percent identify both the function and responsible statement, and 15.7 percent correctly classify the vulnerability. Our failure analysis reveals limitations in evidence acquisition, state-relation reasoning, code interpretation, candidate verification, investigation coverage, and reporting. Based on these findings, we propose SKILL-SIF, a self-improving framework that iteratively evolves security skills by learning from missed vulnerabilities and failure patterns. We evolve five top-performing skills using the original benchmark and evaluate them on 100 previously unseen vulnerabilities. SKILL-SIF improves fully correct vulnerability detection by up to eight times (from 2 percent to 16 percent) on unseen vulnerabilities, while aggregate accuracy across four LLMs increases by 1.85 times (from 6.05 percent to 11.20 percent). These findings highlight the limitations of existing security skills and demonstrate the potential of failure-driven skill evolution to improve vulnerability detection in coding agents.

0.26

An Empirical Analysis of CodeQL False Positives and Query Refinements for Java Vulnerabilities

cs.SE cs.CRcs.PL ·2026-09-03 ·Amirali Sajadi, Saikat Dutta, Preetha Chatterjee
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Static application security testing (SAST) tools help developers find vulnerabilities before deployment, but false positives create substantial triage effort. We study whether CodeQL false positives in Java security analysis form recurring, explainable patterns that can be reduced by refining the analysis. We run CodeQL's Java security query suite on 167 CVE instances from 110 projects, focusing on the ten queries with the highest false positive rates. We manually review 500 sampled false positive paths and locations and construct a source-level taxonomy. The five categories are Missed Path Constraint or Sanitization (36.6%), Benign Execution Context (29.4%), Missing Trust Boundary Modeling (27.6%), Imprecise Concurrency Modeling (5%), and Imprecise Sink Modeling (1.4%). Guided by these findings, we implement CodeQL refinements that detect and filter recurring false positive patterns at the query level. The refinements remove 81.8% of reviewed false positives. Across the full selected-query dataset, they remove 15.8% of reported paths and locations while retaining 7 of 8 true positives. This shows that many false positives can be reduced in the analysis, although fixed refinements often depend on project-specific context. To address this generalization gap, we evaluate whether agentic coding tools can adapt refinement patterns to new projects. Given our patterns as templates, the two tools succeed on 56% and 62% of tasks, with query compile-pass rates above 90%. Without this guidance, both succeed on only 28%, while compile rates fall to 30-36%. These results support a refinement-oriented SAST workflow in which recurring false positives are modeled in CodeQL queries and automatically adapted to different project contexts, reducing repeated triage.

0.49

Evaluating the NIST Bugs Framework Against CWE as a Successor for Automated Vulnerability Classification

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-09-14 ·Md Nazmul Hoque, Shaswata Mitra, Subash Neupane, Sudip Mittal, Shahram Rahimi
code/data similarity 0.66
Abstract · 48 pages, 21 figures, 11 tables, code link: github.com/shaswata09/cve2bf

Vulnerability classification based on root cause weaknesses is essential for numerous cybersecurity activities, where the Common Weakness Enumeration (CWE) serves as a public repository of such flaws. However, its overlapping entries create a non-orthogonal structure. The result is the same vulnerability being mapped to multiple weaknesses, complicating Root Cause Analysis (RCA) and triage. To address this, NIST Special Publication 800-231 introduces the Bugs Framework (BF), which organizes vulnerabilities into <cause, operation, consequence> triples and links such triples into a causal chain, so that a vulnerability carries its root cause and its sink together instead of a single terminal label. To date, however, BF has been specified but not evaluated regarding its performance against the challenges to automated classification. The evidence required for adoption has not been investigated empirically. We evaluate BF as a classification target and a complement to CWE using a systematically screened corpus of automated Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures (CVEs) linked to CWE research. We assess the reproducibility of CVE-to-BF classification through two evaluations. The first is qualitative: an anonymized inter-rater study in which 2 subject-matter experts (SMEs) independently mapped 13 CVEs onto the four BF axes. Annotators showed strong agreement on the cause and operation axes, while the attribute axis indicated fair agreement. We also tested our automated framework across two large language model (LLM) deployments under different budgets for reproducibility analysis. Despite limitations, such as evidence availability and the absence of retrievable fix commits for closed-source software, our findings support the claim that BF is a more structured and automation-friendly framework than CWE. Our exploration reveals specific gaps in BF, including under-specified guidance on attributes.

0.23

Learning from Failures: A Failure-Driven Prompt Refinement for LLM-Based Vulnerability Analysis

cs.SE cs.AIcs.CR ·2026-10-06 ·Mandana Ghadamian, David Mohaisen
published similarity 0.64
Abstract · Accepted at CSoNet 2026. 15 pages, 6 figures/tables combined

Large Language Models have emerged as promising tools for software vulnerability analysis, but their effectiveness depends heavily on prompt design. Existing research primarily compares prompting strategies using aggregate performance metrics, providing limited insight into why models fail or how prompts can be improved systematically. We propose Failure-Driven Prompt Refinement (FDPR), a methodology that analyzes recurring model failures to guide evidence-based prompt refinement. Using the Damn Vulnerable Java Application (DVJA), we identify recurring failure modes, including false positives, false negatives, unsupported reasoning, and CWE misclassification, and translate them into targeted prompt refinements. We then evaluate the resulting prompt on the Juliet Test Suite and perform cross-model validation to assess generalizability. The results show that failure-driven refinement improves the reliability of LLM-based vulnerability analysis while yielding reusable prompt design principles. More broadly, this work demonstrates that recurring model failures provide a principled foundation for prompt engineering, enabling the systematic development of more reliable LLM-based vulnerability analysis systems.

0.29