CS Paper Radar

An Evidence-First Multi-LLM Framework for Auditable Critical-Infrastructure Dependency Modeling

Nurjahan, Mst Eshita Khatun, Lamine Noureddine, Aisha Ali-Gombe

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-09-11 02:33 UTC · v1

Abstract

Critical-infrastructure knowledge is distributed across heterogeneous, incomplete, and weakly structured evidence, making dependency models difficult to construct automatically and difficult to trust. Large language models (LLMs) can extract structured knowledge from such evidence, but direct LLM-to-graph generation risks unsupported relationships, inconsistent terminology, incorrect entity identities, and erroneous dependency endpoints. We present an evidence-first multi-LLM framework for constructing Infrastructure Knowledge Bases (IKBs) and Infrastructure Dependency Graphs (IDGs) from heterogeneous infrastructure documentation. Multiple open-weight LLMs independently extract candidate entities and dependencies from normalized evidence, after which the framework separates evidence verification, ontology grounding, entity resolution, dependency alignment, validation, fusion, and human review. Evidence support, ontology reconciliation, endpoint resolution, model agreement, and human validation remain distinct states, while provenance and unresolved cases are preserved throughout. The validated IKB is then projected deterministically into the IDG without introducing new LLM-generated knowledge. Evaluation in nine infrastructure projects shows that entity recovery achieves substantially higher recall than complete directed dependency recovery and that canonical endpoint resolution is a major constraint in dependency construction. Cross-model overlap is also much lower for dependencies than for entities, indicating that the models often produce non-overlapping candidate assertions rather than a stable majority consensus. These findings support an auditable evidence-to-IKB-to-IDG process in which uncertainty is preserved and resolved progressively rather than collapsed into a single confidence or voting decision.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

GrOIL: Graph-Grounded Domain Ontology Induction with Constrained LLM Mediation

cs.IR ·2026-08-22 ·Maruf Ahmed Mridul, Abid Talukder, Oshani Seneviratne
top venue similarity 0.67
Abstract · 12 pages, 9 figures, 3 tables

Constructing formal ontologies from domain documents requires simultaneously enforcing corpus grounding, vocabulary consistency, axiom-level expressivity, and end-to-end provenance, a combination no existing automatic system delivers. We present a seven-stage graph-grounded pipeline that converts domain documents into a complete, auditable Web Ontology Language (OWL) Terminological Box (TBox) without any unconstrained generation step. Documents are first encoded as Unified Discourse-Hypergraphs (UDH) capturing entity participation and discourse dependencies; subsequent stages transform this graph evidence into a class hierarchy, typed object and datatype properties, and restriction axioms, with Large Language Model (LLM) usage restricted to narrow, graph-grounded mediation tasks. A paired Assertional Box (ABox) population procedure grounds named individuals in the induced TBox, enabling SPARQL-based functional evaluation. Every emitted term carries a full decision chain from raw source passages through each pipeline stage, making the TBox directly auditable and suitable for targeted human refinement. Evaluated on the life insurance domain using two established benchmarks and a new 100-contract corpus spanning ten product types, our pipeline achieves strong results across all evaluation dimensions, outperforming direct and multi-agent LLM baselines on competency-question (CQ) coverage (0.85 vs. 0.63 and 0.62 on one term-life contract; 0.77 vs. 0.40 and 0.44 on another contract), while also attaining high keyphrase coverage comparable to a manually-constructed reference ontology and strong performance on structured gap-and-overlap reasoning, all without any manual TBox engineering. Ontology growth analysis provides evidence consistent with vocabulary saturation at scale, demonstrating that the pipeline produces stable, reusable domain representations from large document corpora.

0.36

LLM-Guided Ontology-Driven Knowledge Graph Construction from Unstructured Text

cs.CL ·2026-09-15 ·Abdelhadi Belfadel
publishedcode/data similarity 0.64
Abstract · arXiv admin comment: This version has been removed by arXiv administrators as the submitter did not have the rights to agree to the license …

Ontology-driven knowledge graph construction from industrial text remains challenging due to the domain specificity of documents, the scarcity of annotated resources, and the complexity of ontology engineering workflows. This paper presents and investigates the applicability of an ontology learning pipeline that combines compact open-source Large Language Models (LLMs), reusable prompting strategies, and open knowledge bases to support the extraction, structuring, enrichment, and evaluation of knowledge from textual corpora. The approach is tested and evaluated on a private French corpus of power-grid incident reports, using locally deployable open-source LLMs ranging from 7B to 32B parameters. Starting from unstructured reports, the approach extracts entities and relations, generates RDF triples, constructs related OWL ontology, enriches it using external knowledge sources, assesses the quality of the ontology, and subsequently constructs a populated knowledge graph grounded in the resulting ontology schema. Experiments on 80 manually annotated private reports show that schema-guided prompting significantly improves extraction quality, while quantized models provide an effective trade-off between performance and computational cost. These results demonstrate the feasibility of transforming domain-specific industrial text into ontology-based knowledge graphs using locally deployed open-source LLMs, while supporting the generalization of the extraction process through reusable prompting strategies.

0.43

Verifiable Disaster Storylines and Causal Knowledge Graphs: A Citation-Grounded Pipeline from Heterogeneous Humanitarian Sources

cs.AI cs.CL ·2026-09-01 ·Ivan Decostanzi, Michele Ronco, Sergio Consoli, Christina Corbane, Lorenzo Bertolini +6 more
publishedhot direction similarity 0.64
Abstract

Effective humanitarian response depends on the rapid synthesis of heterogeneous, high-volume information sources - a task that routinely exceeds human analytical capacity in the critical early hours of a crisis. We present a pipeline that combines structured disaster records from EM-DAT with unstructured documents from ReliefWeb and the European Media Monitor (EMM) to produce source-grounded disaster storylines and causal knowledge graphs supporting situational awareness for responders and analysts. Using Retrieval-Augmented Generation, the pipeline extracts structured storylines - tabular event profiles covering 17 fields, from severity and key drivers to child-sensitive impact indicators - and constructs causal knowledge graphs where each node and edge is enriched with citation-grounded explanatory narratives, enabling full traceability back to primary sources. We evaluate the system on three diverse crisis use cases through a human evaluation involving 9 domain expert and 9 non-expert evaluators. Results confirm high retrieval precision, strong faithfulness of extracted causal relations, and a clear expert preference for citation-grounded components over ungrounded alternatives. The pipeline is designed to scale to the full EM-DAT catalogue, with the goal of publicly releasing a new collection of disaster stories complementing the EM-DAT database.

0.49

Walking on the DARKSIDE

cs.AI cs.LO ·2026-08-24 ·Aldo Gangemi, Emanuele Bottazzi
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 23 pages, 4 figures, 5 tables

Large Language Models (LLMs) do not natively track the path of exclusions that a coherent discourse demands. When an input rests on a fabricated authority, a misapplied mechanism, or a surreptitious analogy, an unsteered LLM tends to engage with it as if it were well-posed, and this affects its generation. POLANYI++, an LLM-steering method that uses heuristics, ontologies and problem-solving methods for tacit-knowledge extraction, produces an Extended Knowledge Graph (XKG) in OWL2, but when a sophisticated nonsensical input is reified into the graph alongside the legitimate triples, it gets hardly detectable by automated reasoners, since the XKG is generated jointly with the wrong assumptions. We introduce DARKSIDE, a coherence-auditing method on top of POLANYI++. DARKSIDE formalises an explicit data structure of accumulated exclusions over discourse time, complemented by a warrant axis that classifies each named referent as Warranted, Unattested, Misattributed or Fabricated. The method is anchored in nine theoretical fragments unified under a shared deep frame of path integrity. The resulting DARKPOLANYI is evaluated as a steering layer over Gemini 3 on BSBench, a 100-item adversarial corpus of sophisticated-sounding nonsense across multiple domains, with Claude Sonnet 4.6 as an independent judge. DARKPOLANYI scores 1.89/2 mean versus 0.95/2 for the unsteered Gemini 3 Pro baseline; on the 97 cases with valid judgments in both arms, paired McNemar gives a paired bootstrap mean-diff = +0.92 (95% CI [+0.75, +1.08], p = 0.0001). The evidence supports an architectural claim: when an LLM forward pass is wrapped in an ontology-mediated auditing, structurally inevitable hallucination can be partially recovered. The XKG functions as the missing memory that LLMs lack, and the warrant axis as an epistemic firewall.

0.49

Valhalla: A Layered Knowledge-State and Service-Governance Framework for Long-Term Scientific Knowledge Work

cs.AI q-bio.NC ·2026-08-15 ·Yuyang Zheng, Nan Li, Wenxia Deng, Lige Yan, Xiang Li +1 more
similarity 0.62
Abstract

As large language model (LLM) agents are increasingly adopted in scientific research, external knowledge bases, knowledge graphs, and long-term memory have improved information retrieval and task continuity. However, most structured knowledge systems remain node-centric, representing files, concepts, results, and judgments as nodes and relations in a graph. While suitable for personal knowledge management, such structures often depend on individual organizational practices, limiting knowledge sharing, integration, and reorganization across users. This paper presents Valhalla, a layered knowledge-state and service-governance framework for long-term scientific knowledge work. Valhalla replaces flat graphs with layered encapsulation and stable semantic boundaries through a five-layer File-Resource-Entity-Relationship-Graph (FREG) model. File and Resource preserve source identity and provenance, Entity represents knowledge objects, Relationship captures semantic judgments, and Graph provides task-oriented knowledge views, enabling knowledge states from different researchers to be exchanged and reorganized under a unified structure. We further introduce a Router-Contract-Workflow service-governance architecture, inspired by the microkernel paradigm, to constrain how language models access, modify, and extend knowledge states while maintaining structural consistency and auditable operational boundaries. We implement a Valhalla prototype and validate knowledge ingestion, cross-member integration, and scientific writing support through an antibody-design review task comprising 26 paper resources, 80 knowledge entities, and 92 semantic relations. Rather than proposing a new knowledge-extraction algorithm, Valhalla offers a paradigm for organizing collaborative scientific knowledge, transforming individualized knowledge structures into transferable and reorganizable shared knowledge states.

0.04

5W1H+Which: Context-Valid Semantic Indexing with Progressive Ontology Binding

cs.AI cs.CLcs.IR ·2026-09-28 ·Yaxiao Liu, Pengbo Liu, Yiwen Liu, Yihua Guan, Jiaxing Song
similarity 0.61
Abstract · 30 pages, 6 figures, 7 tables. Expanded related work and temporal policy examples; added an indexed-corpus application for training and eval…

Semantic indexing must preserve reusable source information without committing too early to one business schema, while providing checkable premises for reasoning. We propose 5W1H+Which, a design that separates source-grounded content extraction from progressive ontology binding. The 5W1H questions organize independently addressable content units; Which records links to versioned ontology elements, mapping relations, applicability scopes, and validation states. Time, location, system environment, and participant roles constrain when facts, bindings, and rules may be used. Unbound content remains searchable, whereas formal reasoning requires explicit premise checks. The design distinguishes business valid time, system knowledge time, and operational traces, and tracks dependencies for revalidation and incremental maintenance. Worked examples illustrate cloud migration and temporal policy validity. The resulting linked corpus can support downstream training and evaluation organized around benchmarks, positive and negative examples, trajectories, and costs. Trajectories preserve steps, evidence-backed checkpoints, recovery, and local-to-global failure impact; reusable skills remain downstream abstractions requiring cross-episode validation. We specify falsifiable hypotheses and capability-matched baselines to test cross-task evidence coverage, contextual misuse, and update cost under equal information and budgets. The contribution is a proposed indexing and maintenance contract, not a new universal ontology or post-training algorithm. No experiments have yet been conducted, and no performance improvement is claimed.

0.19

Reimagining Enterprise RAG for Multi-Agent Systems: A Knowledge Layer That Organizes Before It Retrieves

cs.AI ·2026-10-23 ·Garima Agrawal, Prasun Das, Akshay Sarvade, Priyanka L, Minisha N +7 more
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Enterprises are deploying agentic AI across the software development lifecycle, and they need the behavioral logic of the systems they act on, not stakeholder documentation. A seven-agent reverse-engineering pipeline recovered this logic, processing 241 repositories across 18 services into thousands of artifacts describing scope, journeys, rules and acceptance criteria. Recovery does not confer usability. Entities like offer, eligibility, and activation recur across services under a shared vocabulary, related in name but operationally distinct, so one end-to-end journey implicates over a thousand near-identical rules that must not be conflated. Flat vector retrieval fails, returning an identical rule from the wrong service at high similarity with no signal of error. Content-level ontology, the traditional remedy, did not exist, and relating every occurrence of recurring entities would have cost more than the engagement and not survived a release cycle. We place the ontology at the artifact level. In this machine-generated corpus, each artifact retains its producer, component, service, domain and type, provenance that disambiguates before content is read. We present a knowledge layer that organizes before retrieving: a self-describing catalog, a sparse metadata registry, and a navigation hypergraph defined over artifacts rather than extracted entities. Queries resolve to artifact identifiers that constrain vector search, so the competing rule from another service is absent rather than outranked, making disambiguation structural, not statistical. Built in under a week and admitting new services by convention, the layer serves SDLC agents, developers, quality engineers and analysts. It supported root-cause analysis and resolution of 100+ production defects with developer verification and attributed 35 release regression failures to specific rules and services.

0.20

Specification-Driven Data Architecture Reconstruction: From Physical Code to Logical and Conceptual Specifications

cs.LO cs.DBcs.SE ·2026-09-12 ·Oleg Grynets, Olena Pochernina, Vasyl Lyashkevych
similarity 0.61
Abstract · 15 pages, 3 figures, 7 tables, 35 references

Legacy database migrations often begin with incomplete or outdated documentation, leaving physical data definition language (DDL) as the principal evidence of data architecture. However, DDL does not fully encode conceptual intent, and model-generated completions can be plausible without being correct. This study proposes and evaluates a provenance-aware, deterministic-first pipeline for reconstructing logical and conceptual data specifications from Oracle-oriented DDL while explicitly separating observed facts, deterministic derivations, and large language model (LLM) suggestions. The pipeline performs DDL investigation, parsing, consolidation, primary-key backfilling, type normalization, and declared relationship-graph construction before optional LLM-assisted enrichment. It preserves source provenance in the deterministic catalog and declared relationship graph, and records inferred primary-key and foreign-key candidates in a separate reviewable overlay. We evaluated the implementation on 249 artifactized schema samples comprising 1,225 SQL files. The pipeline completed 244 samples (97.99%); 52 completed samples contained no extractable DDL. Across completed samples, the deterministic path reconstructed 208 tables and recovered 278 declared foreign-key records; 168 of the reconstructed tables lacked an explicitly parsed primary key before backfilling. LLM enrichment generated 100 foreign-key candidates in 36 samples, but the parent-table admissibility rate was only 17.9% for logical-specification candidates and 17.5% for conceptual-specification candidates. These findings show that the proposed deterministic-first architecture can preserve an auditable structural baseline, quantify observed primary-key and relationship gaps, and prevent model-generated hypotheses from being silently promoted to source-grounded architectural facts.

0.30