CS Paper Radar

Reconceptualizing Age Assurance as a Sociotechnical Problem: Connecting Evidence, Evaluation, Claims, and Decisions

Renkai Ma, Prakriti Dumaru, Thomas Synaepa-Addison, Jess Kropczynski, Pamela J. Wisniewski

cs.HC cs.CY ·submitted 2026-09-11 23:08 UTC · v1
position

Abstract

Age verification is often treated as a technical problem: can a system determine a child's age accurately? We argue this framing is too narrow. Age assurance becomes consequential when evidence is evaluated, translated into age-related claims, and used to decide whether a person can access, purchase, or belong. We review 85 publications on children's age assurance published from 2020 through February 2026. We find that shared terms such as age verification describe different processes. Age is represented as threshold eligibility or inferred estimation, and the same eligibility claim can arise from different evidence and components. Rights, access, and privacy receive more attention than accuracy, error, and fairness; yet institutional actors are rarely connected to system failures or user remedies, an accountability gap. We introduce the Age-Assurance Process Framework, which treats age assurance as a sociotechnical process connecting evidence, evaluation, claims, and decisions rather than reducing it to a technical problem.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

From Digital Accountability to Accountable Digitality Through Needs-Aware Information Systems: The Case of Auditable Child-Welfare Judgments

cs.CY ·2026-09-10 ·Soheil Human
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Digital accountability research asks how digital systems can, among other aims, be made transparent, explainable, auditable, contestable, and supportive of ongoing learning and improvement. This paper reverses the question: how can digital transformation make established human institutions more accountable? It theorizes this reversal as accountable digitality and specifies needs-aware information systems as the mediating mechanism. The hard and paradigmatic case is child-welfare judgment, where best-interest procedures must protect children, preserve confidentiality, and respect judicial independence while enabling aggregate learning about needs, reasons, exceptions, and disparities. The case is used diagnostically and illustratively to derive and examine the design logic, not as empirical evidence or validation. Conceptual design-oriented analysis decomposes and recombines digital and legal accountability under child-rights constraints, deriving a canonical theory-to-design chain, contingent mechanisms, implications, and safeguards. It advances IS responsibility and ethics research by showing how privacy-preserving, co-created, needs-aware information systems can support institutional self-knowledge and auditable justice.

0.26

"We'll Fix It Later": Education, AI, and the Deferral of Privacy in EdTech

cs.CY cs.AI ·2026-09-23 ·Meghna Manoj Nair, Rachel Greenstadt
similarity 0.57
Abstract

Educational technology (EdTech) platforms collect highly sensitive student data, including behavioral logs, disability records, and academic histories. However, privacy considerations are often postponed rather than treated as a foundational design requirement. We present a mixed-methods study combining 12 semi-structured interviews with EdTech professionals and a privacy policy audit of 48 platforms coded across five dimensions, with strong inter-rater reliability (mean Cohen's Kappa = 0.781). Our interviews reveal a recurring organizational pattern in which privacy is recognized as important but deferred across the product lifecycle as organizations prioritize product functionality, growth, funding, and immediate educational outcomes. Responsibility is often delegated to cloud providers, policy documents, or downstream institutions, while limited privacy-related feedback gives organizations little pressure to change these practices. The policy analysis reflects these patterns: platforms describe what data they collect relatively well but provide substantially less information about how that data is subsequently governed. Thirty-three percent make no meaningful Artificial Intelligence (AI) disclosure despite visible AI features, and 73% provide only generic accountability and breach-response language. K-12 platforms perform better on children's consent where regulation creates explicit requirements, but this advantage does not extend to AI governance or accountability. These findings suggest that meaningful improvement requires enforceable institutional and regulatory mechanisms rather than voluntary privacy commitments alone.

0.07

Legally Mandated, but Still Inaccessible: Digital Tensions in Older Adults' Use of Norwegian Web Services

cs.HC ·2026-08-12 ·Yavuz Inal, Sujay Shalawadi, Eleftherios Papachristos
published similarity 0.56
Abstract · 7 pages

Norway is among the most digitalized countries in the world, where access to essential services increasingly depends on digital systems. Although universal design of ICT is legally required across public and private sectors, ensuring cognitive accessibility for older adults involves more than technical compliance. We analyzed responses from 294 participants aged 55 to 90 to examine the barriers they encounter when using digital services. Our findings identify four tensions, namely navigational, semantic, procedural, and temporal, which reveal how accessibility barriers emerge through misalignments between service design, system assumptions, and older adults' capabilities. Together, these tensions show that checklist-based compliance does not necessarily translate into lived accessibility when engaging with mandatory or near-mandatory digital services. We discuss the need to move beyond minimum compliance frameworks toward accessibility approaches that better support older adults' independent participation in digital society.

0.24

Multi-Jurisdictional Legal Identity Assurance for Capability Gating: A Design-Science Proposal for Tiered, Reusable Identity Assurance of Natural, Juridical, and Machine Entities

cs.AI q-fin.GNcs.CRcs.CY ·2026-09-25 ·Walter Kurz
published similarity 0.55
Abstract · 29 pages, 3 figures, 9 tables. Written to solve the AML/KYC problem in financial services: proportional customer due diligence, beneficial o…

Identity assurance is the cost a digital system pays for dishonesty and uncertainty: it exists to make acts attributable when not everyone can be trusted at their word. A common way to pay that cost is flat maximum verification, asking each participant to meet a single high level of identification at entry, before any capability is exercised. Paid on everyone, it over-collects, excludes participants who cannot meet a bar they never needed to clear, taxes every interaction with the cost of the rarest high-risk case, and binds the strength of identification to the activity it unlocks. Existing frameworks compound this by fixing a small number of per-credential levels inside a single legal space and binding each verification to the institution that performed it, leaving cross-border reuse and the tension between data erasure and evidentiary retention unaddressed. This paper develops, as a design-science proposal, a tiered and reusable model of identity assurance for natural, juridical, and machine entities across jurisdictions. Reading the problem through systems theory, where a system changes only when an entity acts, the model holds the assurance state apart from the capability gate that consumes it, so that identity demand follows the act and the weight of its consequences rather than mere presence: a participant may take part with minimal disclosure and supply more only as an act requires. It comprises a typed entity taxonomy, a two-axis coordinate of disclosed assertion scope and source of information, jurisdiction as a time-indexed attribute of the entity, and reliance recorded as bitemporal, liability-allocated, point-in-time snapshots. Requirements are derived from anti-money-laundering, electronic-identity, and data-protection law, and the proposal is evaluated against flat maximum verification, per-credential level-of-assurance designs, and institutional reusable-KYC reliance.

0.69

A-GE: Privacy-Preserving Age Assurance via Fine-Grained Motion

cs.CR ·2026-10-23 ·Mohammed Gharib, Giovanni Cascone, Martin Zizi
similarity 0.53
Abstract

Age assurance faces a fundamental privacy dilemma: meaningful assurance typically requires revealing identity or other sensitive information, whereas privacy-preserving alternatives often provide little assurance. Existing approaches either disclose sensitive information directly or shift the disclosure and trust requirement to an identity provider, while self-declared age provides little meaningful assurance. Thus, a fundamental gap remains between establishing an age property and revealing information beyond what is necessary to establish that property. We present \textit{A-GE} (Age-Grounded Evidence), a privacy-preserving age assurance system that derives age-related evidence from fine-grained motion captured by commodity inertial measurement units (IMUs). A-GE exploits subtle motion dynamics that we hypothesize reflect underlying neuromuscular and physiological processes during ordinary device interaction. It requires neither identity information nor government identification and operates across available sensor sampling rates, including the approximately 60~Hz limit of web-based sensing, with configurable minimum-age thresholds ranging from 14 to 21 years. We evaluate A-GE on more than 600 participants, with separate participant-disjoint cohorts for model development and final evaluation. At a 16-year minimum-age threshold, A-GE achieves up to 93.8\% accuracy with a comparable F1 score across the evaluated configurations. We further demonstrate client-side deployment on Android, iOS, and the web, and examine unintended attribute inference and residual privacy risks, characterizing both the privacy benefits and limitations of deriving age evidence from commodity motion.

0.25

The Watchtower Imperative: Lifespan-Calibrated Evaluation for Frontier AI

cs.CY cs.AIcs.HC ·2026-10-26 ·Casey M. Williams, Jennifer Victoria Scurrell
similarity 0.52
Abstract

The gap between AI capability deployment and safety assurance is structural and cannot be closed through internal evaluations alone. Analyzing documented harms (2017-2026) across the human lifespan reveals that disparate incidents --- from voice assistants endangering children to AI companions implicated in adolescent suicide and automated care denials for the elderly --- reflect a single failure: evaluating systems against an implicit adult user model. We introduce five developmental moderators structured into a Lifespan Vulnerability Matrix across six life stages. The matrix reveals a nonmonotonic risk distribution: vulnerability peaks at both ends of the lifespan, governance coverage is asymmetrical, and authority to convert model errors into real-world impact is scrutinized least. We then propose a set of lifespan design principles generalizing existing child-protective instruments, and an institution-agnostic, three-tier external evaluation framework --- comprising automated simulation, expert red teaming, and post-deployment monitoring --- indexed directly to matrix risk cells.

0.26

From Maturity Models to Ground Truth: Reconciling Cybersecurity Capacity Frameworks with Household-Level Governance Realities in the Global South

cs.HC ·2026-08-28 ·Wael Albayaydh, Ivan Flechais
similarity 0.51
Abstract · 3 tabvles

National cybersecurity and digital-governance capacity frameworks, most prominently the Cybersecurity Capacity Maturity Model for Nations (CMM), shape hundreds of millions of dollars in donor-funded governance investments across the Global South. Yet a persistent, under-theorised gap remains between state-level institutional maturity and the governance actually experienced by end-users. We term this the last-mile governance gap: the structural space between what a maturity assessment can see - laws, agencies, standards, awareness campaigns - and what a household living under that formal architecture can access, understand, or enforce. Drawing on a dual vantage point combining CMM assessment experience with peer-reviewed empirical fieldwork on smart-home privacy governance in Jordan, corroborated against studies from Kenya and China, we identify four mechanisms by which national capacity fails to reach the household: legibility, intra-household power distribution, accessibility of redress, and infrastructure-affordability constraints. We map these mechanisms explicitly onto the CMM's five dimensions, propose four concrete, low-cost last-mile indicators pilotable within existing CMM deployments, and outline a staged adoption roadmap with responses to anticipated objections. With AI-enabled devices entering homes across the Global South faster than institutional capacity can adapt, the stakes are rising: this dynamic risks converting a measurable maturity gap into an invisible one. We conclude with actionable implications for the GCSCC, the ITU, the World Bank, and other institutions relying on maturity scores to prioritize investment.

0.19

When AI "Works," When Does Help Begin?: Intergenerational Support Around Older Adults' LLM Usage

cs.HC ·2026-08-25 ·Hyehyun Chu, Yuri Lee, Yeon Su Park, Saelyne Yang, Juho Kim
published similarity 0.51
Abstract · 5 pages, 1 table, Accepted by CSCW 2026 workshop Growing Up (and Old) with AI: Co-Constructing the Future for Family-Centered AI

LLMs are becoming part of everyday life, including for older adults (OAs). OAs often learn digital technologies with younger family members, who have traditionally served as "warm experts" providing trusted and personalized operational help. LLMs expand this role: family supporters may also help OAs judge appropriate uses, consider what information to disclose, assess the credibility of outputs, and decide when AI-generated advice is safe to act on. We conducted a formative qualitative study with six OAs and seven younger adults (YAs), using semi-structured interviews and scenario-based think-aloud activities. OA participants described using LLMs to lighten their recurring reliance on family, while preserving family as a selectively invoked support channel. However, because LLMs rarely produced visible operational breakdowns, YAs had limited signals for when support was actually needed. Instead, YAs relied on OAs' partial disclosures and negotiated intervention through general warnings and self-imposed action boundaries. As a result, family support often solved an immediate problem without leaving reusable calibration knowledge for future use. Based on these findings, we propose design implications for intergenerational LLM support (e.g., consentful help requests, learning-oriented family support that preserves OA task ownership).

0.26