CS Paper Radar

CRITICS - Critical Science Without Borders: Language Models to Promote Critical Thinking in Science Education

Rodrigo Agerri, Itziar Aldabe, Elena Cabrio, Mark Cieliebak, Jan Deriu, Mariana Flores, Jurgita Kapociute-Dzikiene, Dovile Kuiziniene, Arantza Rico, Aritz Ruiz-Gonzalez, Aitor Soroa, Mantas Vaskevicius, Serena Villata

cs.CL cs.AI ·submitted 2026-09-12 13:37 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

The CRITICS project addresses science accessibility and literacy by converging advanced Machine Translation (MT) based on Large Language Models (LLMs) with educational technology. By leveraging MT systems specifically optimized for scientific content, educational institutions can provide accurate, culturally relevant translations of scientific materials in students' native languages, ensuring that complex scientific concepts are comprehensible while maintaining technical accuracy. Building on these translations, the project explores the design and evaluation of innovative science teaching-learning proposals grounded in curriculum-aligned teaching-learning. Thus, CRITICS will investigate key components of scientific argumentation and critical thinking practices together with textual feedback aligned with learning objectives and assessment criteria inspired by competence-based evaluation frameworks. CRITICS aims to break down language barriers to accessing cutting-edge research and educational materials currently available only in high-resourced languages, thereby facilitating the democratization of scientific knowledge and fostering critical thinking in science education.

Comment
9 pages
Journal ref
SEPLN 2026: 42nd International Conference of the Spanish Society for Natural Language Processing, León, Spain, 22-25 September 2026

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

A Benchmark for LLM's Understanding of Middle School and High School Science Topics

cs.AI cs.CYcs.HC ·2026-09-25 ·Noah L. Schroeder, Yessy Eka Ambarwati, Yuji Zhang, ChengXiang Zhai
benchmark similarity 0.59
Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly integrated into educational settings, yet educators lack robust, standards-aligned tools to evaluate their effectiveness in K-12 science contexts. Existing benchmarks predominantly assess general language or advanced scientific reasoning, leaving a critical gap in understanding LLMs' performance on content directly relevant to secondary science curricula. To address this gap, we developed a comprehensive NGSS-aligned benchmark for both middle and high school science using a rigorous synthetic data pipeline, multi-judge validation, and item-level psychometric analysis. Nine open-weight LLMs were systematically evaluated using this benchmark, indicating that several smaller, locally deployable models achieved high accuracy across diverse science domains and question types. Our findings indicate that model size did not consistently predict performance, emphasizing the importance of intentional model selection for educational deployment. We then incorporated a human reviewer into the loop, reviewing the items generated by the LLMs for alignment with NGSS standards. The human review indicated that synthetically generated items were not in perfect alignment with the NGSS standards, indicating the benefits of human-in-the-loop item development, the need to explore the intersection of content and pedagogical knowledge, and the need to extend benchmarks to evaluate LLMs' capacity for interactive, evidence-based feedback in educational scenarios.

0.17

Beyond Human-Likeness: Mapping the Scientific Critique Profiles of LLMs and Human Reviewers

cs.DL ·2026-09-01 ·Yunhan Yang, Mike Thelwall, Guoxiu He
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly discussed as tools for peer review, but their value is often assessed through human-likeness, perceived usefulness, or textual overlap with reviewer comments. This study shifts attention from whether LLMs resemble human reviewers to what functions of scientific critique they perform. Using ICLR 2025 peer-review data, we compare human reviews with LLM reviews generated under baseline and expert prompts. We operationalize scientific critique through two review acts, weakness critique and scientific questioning, and annotate point-level review text using five theory-guided frameworks: Anderson's knowledge types, Toulmin's argumentation model, Graesser's question depth, SOLO cognitive complexity, and Hattie's feedback functions. The results reveal a differentiated critique profile. Human reviews placed greater emphasis on scientific framing and revision guidance, more often identifying higher-order weaknesses and asking questions oriented toward improvement. LLM reviews showed higher rates of explanatory depth, integrative reasoning, and explicit argument structuring. Expert prompting did not make LLM critique uniformly more human-like; it partially narrowed some gaps but mainly amplified LLM-specific tendencies toward integration and formal argumentation. These findings show that LLM-assisted peer review changes the functional composition of review text, making it important to distinguish LLM-amplified critique from areas requiring human prioritization and accountable judgement.

0.26

From Sentiment Classification to Actionable and Responsible Feedback: A Scoping Review and Evidence Map of NLP in Student Evaluation of Teaching, 2015-2026

cs.CL cs.LG ·2026-08-23 ·Jeff Eicher, Rafael da Silva
similarity 0.54
Abstract · 63 pages, 18 figures, 8 tables

Natural language processing (NLP) applied to open-ended teaching-evaluation comments (Student Evaluation of Teaching, SET) has tracked the field's technical evolution--from lexicons and conventional classifiers to transformers and large language models (LLMs)--but it is not evident that this technical diversification has been accompanied by corresponding gains in educational value and robustness of the evidence. This scoping review (PRISMA-ScR) maps 421 studies (2015-2026, 2026 partial) along a technical axis (RQ1) and four value dimensions (RQ2-RQ5). Dual mutually blinded LLM screening with sampled human adjudication coded seven extraction domains, with targeted codebook-boundary review at synthesis. The joint map's sharpest quantified gap is the actionability discontinuity: demonstrated output or stronger (A2+: 258/421; 61.3%) versus intended-user evaluation or stronger (A3+: 49/421; 11.6%), a 49.7 percentage-point drop. Sentiment analysis remains the modal task (300/421); diagnostic and generative depth is a substantial minority (D4-D5: 28.2% of resolved cases); a formal fairness metric is rare (1.9%). The findings are descriptive and do not support causal claims of progress: technological coexistence and uneven reporting are part of the map, but the A2+ to A3+ cliff is the contribution, not a quality ladder.

0.24

From Tool Use to Technological Agency: LoopCAT as a Local-First, Open-Source Tool for Translation Technology Education

cs.CL ·2026-08-31 ·Gokhan Dogru, Adrià Martín Mor
unusual similarity 0.52
Abstract

Translation students need to learn both how to use translation technologies and how to judge the choices those technologies make available. This article presents LoopCAT, an Apache-2.0-licensed, local-first computer-assisted translation environment co-created with OpenAI Codex using GPT-5.5 and GPT-5.6, and proposes a framework connecting workflow competence, evaluative judgement, and technological agency. The account draws on repository history, implementation inspection, and the verification records of an identified development build. LoopCAT combines local project storage, translation memories, terminology, quality assurance, document exchange, and optional connections to local or hosted AI services. Its English, Catalan, and Turkish interface catalogs also make the application itself available as teaching material: students can translate English UI strings into another language, review the existing automatically generated target drafts, import their revisions, and test the interface. We organize these opportunities around four forms of participation: operating a workflow, evaluating outputs, inspecting and configuring mechanisms, and making or defending a bounded intervention. A six-session sequence, a UI-localization assignment, a placeholder example, and an assessment rubric specify how teachers could use the framework. The paper separates implemented capabilities from proposed educational benefits; it reports no new student-learning outcomes. It distinguishes the latest package checks from earlier regression evidence and sets out a protocol for classroom evaluation. LoopCAT provides an inspectable setting for teaching how translation decisions interact with data, interfaces, and software rules. Whether these activities improve judgement, transfer, or participation remains an empirical question.

0.27

VeriMath: Human-in-the-Loop Generation and Verification of Curriculum-Aligned Mathematics Assessment Items

cs.AI cs.CV ·2026-11-17 ·Quy P. Nguyen, Duong Q. Nguyen, Dinh P. T. Nguyen, Truong-Giang T. Le, Truong A. Bui +7 more
similarity 0.52
Abstract

Automatic generation of mathematics assessment items is a growing area in educational artificial intelligence, yet classroom deployment remains challenging. Generated questions must satisfy multiple constraints: mathematical correctness, curriculum alignment, appropriate cognitive difficulty, and educator reviewability. While prior work has advanced text generation, reliable assessment authoring requires granular control over localized examination formats and expert educational judgment. To address this challenge, we present VeriMath, a generalized, human-in-the-loop framework for generating rigorous, curriculum-constrained mathematics assessment drafts. Using annotated reference items, the framework anchors generation to the requested examination section and cognitive reasoning level, then applies sequential automated verification and guided repair before submitting drafts for expert review. We evaluate VeriMath through a national curriculum case study using 4,555 mathematics items from the Vietnamese Grade 12 curriculum and 50 distinct generation requirements covering multiple-choice, true/false, and short-answer formats. Across two model backbones, the framework produces verifier-accepted drafts for 94% (47/50) of requirements per run. Blind expert evaluations confirm high mathematical accuracy and curriculum alignment, with strict teacher-readiness assessments accepting up to 56.8% of generated items. Analysis of rejected drafts reveals persistent domain-agnostic challenges involving formatting, statement validity, and solution-step completeness. These findings demonstrate that VeriMath can bridge generative AI and dependable educational applications by producing highly reviewable assessment drafts within tightly constrained national curriculum frameworks.

0.12

Clause Encounters of the Third Kind: Can LLMs Replace Language Teachers?

cs.CL ·2026-08-17 ·Kristina Šekrst, Ana Kovačić
published similarity 0.51
Abstract

While various organizations now actively encourage LLM use in classrooms, we still lack rigorous, systematic evaluations of how well these models actually perform the fundamental tasks of language pedagogy. This paper examines whether state-of-the-art LLMs can deliver the kind of corrective feedback and methodological explanations that language learners need. The study tests multiple large language models on their ability to identify, correct, and explain common learner mistakes in English, by systematically varying model parameters to investigate how these technical adjustments affect output quality, pedagogical clarity, and consistency, along with using retrieval-augmented generation to query methodological data. The evaluation employs automated metrics (GLEU, BERTScore) but also human expert judgments to capture dimensions that purely computational measures miss: linguistic nuance, cultural sensitivity, and instructional appropriateness. While models demonstrate impressive surface-level correction abilities, their explanations often lack the terminological and domain knowledge that effective language teaching requires, suggesting that current enthusiasm for AI-assisted language learning may be outpacing our understanding of these systems' actual pedagogical competence.

0.35

Critical Thinking with Generative AI: A Constraint-First Design Pilot of a Thinking-Partner Intervention

cs.HC ·2026-09-29 ·Fatima Tuz Zahra, Jiangen He, David M. Bowers, Wei Wang
similarity 0.51
Abstract · 53 pages, 5 figures

Generative AI (GenAI) tools entered higher education classrooms faster than the field was able to study their effects on learning. One concern is that GenAI may displace the critical thinking and AI literacy that students will need after graduation. This paper reports a Design-Based Research pilot of a GenAI-assisted critical thinking framework, in which ChatGPT was used as a thinking partner in an undergraduate research methods and statistics course during Spring 2025 (N = 14). The mixed-methods design combined pre- and post-intervention measures of statistical learning (AASCDM), AI literacy (MAILS), and critical thinking (WGCTA) with instructor field notes, student artifacts, and student-AI interaction logs. Pre-post tests showed gains on every AASCDM dimension and on eight of nine MAILS dimensions, while WGCTA percentiles did not change. Qualitative analysis identified four themes: the ways students positioned the LLM (as answer generator, validator, or co-thinker); the depth of student engagement (procedural vs. conceptual); occasional humanizing of the tool; and the role of curriculum design in shaping each of the prior three. Read together, the findings indicate that one semester of GenAI-assisted instruction can move domain learning and self-reported AI literacy but does not move standardized critical thinking, and that the modal student-LLM relationship is one of validation instead of dialogue. We end with design principles for the next iteration of the framework and implications for research on adaptive and personalized learning.

0.20

Self-Explanation Tutor for Active Study of CS1 Worked Examples

cs.CY cs.AIcs.HC ·2026-08-25 ·Arun-Balajiee Lekshmi-Narayanan, Mohammad Hassany, Kamil Akhuseyinoglu, Rully Hendrawan, Peter Brusilovsky
similarity 0.51
Abstract

Worked examples are an important part of introductory programming, but reading their expert explanations is passive. Self explanation, students explaining the problem and its solution to themselves with subgoal level analysis, converts passive reading into an active study of worked example, yet it is hard to scale because assessing free-text explanations and returning timely feedback has had no easy automated solution. We investigate whether a large language model (LLM) can fill that gap. We build a self-explanation tutor for introductory programming, ESSE, in which students explain lines of worked examples and receive immediate LLM feedback on the correctness and completeness of each explanation, and we pursue two goals. First, we ask whether the LLM judges student explanations well enough to serve as the engine of the tutor; we assess its judgments against two independent human reference standards of different kinds, a single domain expert and a crowd of non-expert raters, each with its own strengths and weaknesses, characterizing both where the LLM is reliable and the systematic tendencies in how it diverges. Second, we ask whether the LLM-based tutoring benefits students; deploying it in an introductory Java course, we find that its feedback leads students to persist and revise rather than abandon a line, that their explanations grow more complete and conceptually richer across attempts, and that students show evidence of learning. These indicate that LLM-based assessment is good enough to power a self-explanation tutor, and that the tutor positively shapes how students study worked examples.

0.10