CS Paper Radar

Torsion detection in clique complexes is conditionally $QMA_1$-hard

Adam Wesołowski

cs.CC quant-ph ·submitted 2026-09-12 19:14 UTC · v2

Abstract

Quantum algorithms for topological data analysis compute Betti numbers, the ranks of the homology groups of a simplicial complex, which can be read off from the kernel of a combinatorial Laplacian. Deciding whether a Betti number of a clique complex is nonzero is $QMA_1$-hard, and remains so under a spectral gap promise on vertex-weighted graphs. Integral homology, however, contains information inaccessible to the Laplacian spectrum. A new part that appears in integral homology is \emph{torsion}: cycles that become boundaries only after being traversed several times, as in a projective plane or a Klein bottle. We provide a simple reduction that allows us to establish the first hardness results for the problem of detecting torsion. We attach to an arbitrary clique complex a fixed $31$-vertex triangulation of the projective plane. The $k$th mod-$2$ Betti number of the input then reappears as $2$-torsion two degrees up, while all rational homology disappears and every combinatorial Laplacian acquires a constant spectral gap. We conclude that detecting torsion in clique complexes of \emph{unweighted} graphs is $NP$-hard, even under a constant gap promise, and that it is $QMA_1$-hard if mod-$2$ clique homology is.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Average-case hardness of Betti number estimation

cs.CC quant-ph ·2026-09-11 ·Sergii Strelchuk, Sathyawageeswar Subramanian, Adam Wesołowski
similarity 0.74
Abstract

We establish the average-case hardness of Betti number estimation on random clique complexes via a reduction from the planted clique problem. We further show that our reduction implies a series of hardness results for many problems in both classical and quantum Topological Data Analysis (qTDA). Under the classical planted clique conjecture, no randomized polynomial-time Betti number estimator achieves additive error below $\tfrac12$ with constant advantage. Under a new quantum planted clique conjecture that we introduce, the same conclusion holds for quantum polynomial-time algorithms. We also obtain related conditional hardness results for homology vanishing, additive approximations with larger error tolerances, preparation of simplex and harmonic states, cycle recovery, and counting eigenvalues at low energy. Our reduction clarifies the structural requirements for quantum advantage in TDA and provides a new lens to investigate the classical and quantum complexity of related problems.

0.44

Exact Kernel Transfer to Clique Complexes and the Hardness of Normalized Persistence

cs.CC cs.CG ·2026-09-05 ·Cheng Xin
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract · 23 pages; computational certificate data and verification scripts included as ancillary files

For clique complexes $X_1\subseteq X_2$, normalized persistence in degree $d$ is $\operatorname{rank}[H_d(X_1)\to H_d(X_2)]/\dim H_d(X_1)$. Estimating it requires exact endpoint homology and the inclusion-induced map, even with inverse-polynomial endpoint Laplacian gaps. We prove that additive-error $1/24$ estimation is hard for $\mathsf{BQP}_{1}^{G_2}$, the perfect-completeness class over the exact gate set $G_2=\{X,\mathsf{CX},\mathsf{CCX},H\otimes H\}$, and hence for $\mathsf{BQP}_{1}$ over every finite gate set with entries in a cyclotomic field $\mathbb{Q}(ζ_{2^k})$, even for unweighted clique complexes. The main tool is a finite-certificate kernel-transfer theorem. For a fixed palette of weighted clique gadgets satisfying finitely many exactly checkable local conditions, every unit chain $x$ of the full geometric complex satisfies $\operatorname{dist}(x,K)^2\le C(tλ^2+\langle x,Δx\rangle/(gλ^{26}))$, where $K$ is the embedded kernel of the simulated projector Hamiltonian, $g$ its gap, $t$ the number of gadgets, and $λ$ the private vertex weight. Since $λ$ is chosen independently of $g$, the geometric Laplacian has exactly $\dim K$ zero modes and a gap linear in $g$ above them. Exact fillings identify the endpoint homology with a quotient $V/W_A$ of the register cycle space, and nested term sets induce the natural quotient epimorphisms, so the persistent rank equals the later kernel dimension without any choice of compatible harmonic representatives. A fixed eight-dimensional label register turns a $\mathsf{BQP}_{1}^{G_2}$ verifier into instances with $β_d(X_1)=8$ and normalized persistence $3/4$ or $1/8$, and an established common-copy blow-up transfers everything to unweighted graphs.

0.30

Spectral Methods for the Complexity of Planar Graph Homomorphisms

cs.CC ·2026-09-28 ·Ashwin Maran, Jin-Yi Cai, Zhuxiao Tang
theory similarity 0.59
Abstract · 35 pages, 2 figures

We explore the frontier beyond the recently discovered barrier represented by the \emph{quantum automorphism group} $qut(M)$ in the classification theory of planar graph homomorphisms $PlGH(M)$. We show that analyzing the spectral relations of $M$ can prove \#P-hardness when traditional vertex separation and domain-reduction methods with planar edge gadgets provably fail due to the $\qut(M)$ barrier. We prove two criteria of \#P-hardness for $PlGH(M)$: a spectral criterion and a determinant criterion. It is known that the core problem for the classification of $PlGH(M)$ for nonnegative matrices $M$ is for positive definite entry-wise positive matrices. We use the spectral criterion to show that $PlGH(M)$ is \#P-hard for all circulant matrices of prime order $q \ge 3$, while for $q=2$ it is precisely the matchgate case and is P-time computable by the FKT algorithm (for planar perfect matching). We also prove a complexity dichotomy for $\PlGH$ problems defined by tensor products of 2 by 2 matrices. This gives a complete complexity classification for this class of matrices, and the FKT algorithm together with a holographic transformation is \emph{universal}---every $PlGH(M)$ is either (1) P-time computable over all graphs, or (2) \#P-hard in general but P-time computable over planar graphs, or (3) \#P-hard over planar graphs; furthermore, $PlGH(M)$ in (2) consists of precisely those computable by FKT with a holographic transformation.

0.30

Updating a Discrete Morse Vector Field for a Lower Star Filtration Vineyard

cs.CG math.AT ·2026-09-25 ·Kevin Woytowich, Nkechi Nnadi, Elizabeth Munch
similarity 0.57
Abstract

In this paper, we provide a construction of an acyclic discrete vector field that is compatible with a total order associated with a lower star filtration on a simplicial complex, called the colex vector field. We show that the colex vector field induces a filtered acyclic vector field, whose resulting Morse complex computes the persistent homology of the lower star filtration on the underlying simplicial complex. We show that the colex vector field can be recomputed quickly when the vertex function that induces the lower star filtration is modified via order-adjacent vertex swaps. We provide a framework for storing and computing the number of paths between cells in the simplicial complex, as well as a method to update these values quickly when the colex vector field changes. Finally, we provide publicly available proof-of-concept code for the ideas shown. When applying it to the Persistent Homology Transform, we show that its runtime is comparable to a more standard matrix reduction approach.

0.27

On Angle-optimization and Simplification of Degree-1 Homology Representatives

cs.CG math.AT ·2026-08-25 ·Emerson G. Escolar, Yuta Shimada
similarity 0.56
Abstract · 26 pages

In topological data analysis, in particular persistent homology analysis, extracting "optimal" representatives for homology classes is crucial for identifying geometric regions of interest. In prior work, optimality is defined in terms of minimizing length or volume. In this work, we restrict our attention to a single homology class in degree $1$ and introduce the total absolute curvature of cycles as the cost function. We show that this cost function, based on angles between edges of cycles, penalizes departures from planarity, convexity, and simple-ness of the cycle representative. We formulate the "angle-optimal homologous cycle problem", recast it as a binary quadratic optimization problem, and show the results of experiments on artificial toy data.

0.29

New persistent chain spaces: identifying and computing the relevant persistent Laplacians of a filtration

cs.CG math.ATmath.COmath.SP ·2026-11-06 ·Joris Kirchner, Martina Vittorietti
similarity 0.55
Abstract · 34 pages, 12 figures

Persistent homology (PH) summarizes the topological features of data that persist across scales, but it is insensitive to many geometric properties. Persistent Laplacians (PLs) address this limitation: for a pair of simplicial complexes in a filtration, the kernel of the persistent Laplacian recovers the persistent Betti number, while its non-zero spectrum carries additional geometric information. However, PLs are defined for individual pairs of filtration values, so analysing a whole filtration requires evaluating many operators that largely contain the same information, and the result is hard to summarize and interpret. In this paper, we show that this redundancy has a precise structure. For each pair of filtration values, we decompose the space of chains underlying the persistent up-Laplacian into the contributions inherited from the neighboring pairs and a remaining part, which we call the new persistent chain space. We show that the new persistent chain spaces of all earlier pairs form a direct sum decomposition of this space, so that every persistent up-Laplacian in the filtration is determined by them. Moreover, the new persistent chain spaces are non-trivial only at pairs given by the persistence pairing in the same and in the next homological dimension, so that the persistence pairing determines exactly where the persistent up-Laplacian can change. Experiments on several types of point clouds show that evaluating persistent Laplacians only at these pairs reduces the computation time, both for our implementation and for existing software.

0.37

KnottedGraph: Scalable knotted-graph topology for scientific and mathematical discovery

cs.MS cs.CGcs.SCmath.GT+1 ·2026-09-25 ·Hakan Akgün, Xianquan Yan, Kehan Liu, Zhaoyun Chen, Ching Hua Lee
code/data similarity 0.55
Abstract · 40 pages, 15 figures, 4 tables; includes Supplementary Information. Source code, documentation, workflows and data are available at https://…

Scientific data span heterogeneous structures, including coordinates, networks, surfaces, volumes and fields, yet their topology can be quantified within a common framework through graph connectivity, cycle structure, genus and spatial embedding. Graph- and homology-based summaries do not determine spatial embedding, while standard knot and link polynomials require extensions to accommodate branching graphs. Here, we introduce KnottedGraph, a computational framework that converts such scientific representations to knotted graphs that retain graph connectivity and spatial embedding together. It constructs projected diagrams and PD codes, enabling various topological analyses, including Yamada-polynomial evaluation for topological classification. For scalable exact evaluation, it combines partial resolutions that leave the same unresolved connections and optimizes their processing order; the resulting algorithm is verified against published topological invariants of knotted graphs with up to 500 crossings. This scalability enables us to introduce an LLM-assisted mathematical-discovery methodology, in which computational topological data generated across knotted-graph families are used to identify candidate closed-form formulas. With this approach, we identify analytical Yamada-polynomials for generic graph motif families exhibiting Abelian and non-Abelian word sequences. Together, these scalable capabilities make knotted-graph topology computationally accessible across scientific domains, enabling large-scale classification and introducing a route from topological data to LLM-assisted AI4Math discovery.

0.38

Planted Cliques and Quantum Symmetry-Adapted Measurements

cs.CC quant-ph ·2026-09-30 ·Vojtech Havlicek, Jordan Docter, Subhash Khot
theory similarity 0.55
Abstract · 21 pages, no figures. Revised it to improve clarity and readability. VH takes responsibility for the previous submission prepared under a ti…

We study how quantum encodings and symmetry-adapted measurements preserve information for planted-clique detection from one classical graph. For $k=\lfloor n^{1/2-\varepsilon}\rfloor$, with fixed $0<\varepsilon<1/2$, detection is statistically possible but conjectured hard for polynomial-time classical algorithms. For a compact binary phase encoding, we prove that constant-advantage detection requires $Ω(n^{1+2\varepsilon}\ln^2 n)$ copies of the phase state of the same graph, even under arbitrary joint measurements. In the large-copy limit, the optimal decision rule thresholds the total number of $k$-cliques in the graph and its complement, but this characterization provides no efficient detector. We therefore explore measurements guided by the symmetries of the input distributions, starting with the efficient Schur transform on the full graph register. We show that weak Schur sampling, which measures only the representation label, depends only on edge count and has vanishing distinguishing power in this regime. When the label and multiplicity registers are discarded, the remaining quantum states are almost perfectly distinguishable. We show that the support of the planted state occupies only a vanishing fraction of the graph Hilbert space. Any subspace containing it still permits near-perfect detection if its relative dimension also vanishes. This gives us freedom to choose a subspace that is easier to measure. We propose exploring subgroup isotypic measurements to find such subspaces. Whether they can yield an efficient detector remains open. Finally, we show that a single supplied coherent quantum sample permits efficient detection, yielding a conditional computational separation from one classical sample under quantum planted-clique hardness.

0.32