CS Paper Radar

Relational Structure in Motion: Dynamic Positioning of AI Response Positions and Human Self-Positions in the FIREMAY Case

Motoko Kihara

cs.HC ·submitted 2026-09-13 06:02 UTC · v1

Abstract

This paper is not primarily about whether AI has a persistent persona. It asks a different question: what becomes visible when a relational position is followed through time rather than examined only in its present state? FIREMAY provides a longitudinal, trajectory-oriented single-case analysis of sustained human-AI interaction based on a dense interaction archive and reflexive insider documentation. On the AI side, a pre-conversational relational marker preceded a later unassigned response difference, which was re-identified with that marker and subsequently underwent epistemic and functional reorganization through chronology checking, provenance correction, and repeated questioning. On the human side, contemporaneous pre-FIREMAY records showed antecedent patterns partially continuous with later self-positioning, while later episodes documented unfinished articulation, repair, and functional redistribution of outward-facing regulation. The two trajectories are ontologically and temporally asymmetric and are compared only at the limited analytic level of position-in-trajectory. The paper describes this as dynamic relational positioning and treats stability as dynamic stability and relational returnability rather than response invariance. This single case does not establish population-level generality, causal mechanism, persistent AI subjectivity, or reproducibility of the same relational outcome. Its narrower conclusion is that the FIREMAY case could not be adequately understood from current state alone: the history of a relational position itself must be treated as an analytic unit.

Comment
45 pages

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Socioduality: A Relational Process Framework for Human-AI Interaction

cs.HC cs.AI ·2026-08-11 ·Mehmed Zahid Çögenli
similarity 0.57
Abstract · 50 pages, 4 figures, 12 tables. Revised version adds a Supplementary Exploratory Analysis comparing Sociodual pathways with blind developmen…

Human-AI research often evaluates individual capabilities, joint performance, or final outputs, but these approaches can lose the interaction process that produced the result. This article introduces socioduality: a sequential, reciprocal, and history-carrying process in which one party's response becomes part of the observable conditions shaping the other party's next contribution, judgement, decision, or action. For human-AI dyads, the framework identifies moves, candidate episodes, confirmed episodes, and maximal pathways. A minimum episode A1 -> B1 -> A2 requires evidence that B1 responds to A1 and that B1 then enters the formation of A2; candidates are classified as confirmed, non-sociodual, or indeterminate. A frozen coding protocol was calibrated on three natural human-AI records using two separate model-based evaluator series. A supplementary exploratory analysis then compared frozen Sociodual pathways with blind developmental/task-process segmentations. Across six examined interactions, the two representations were empirically non-equivalent: task-stage changes could occur within a continuing Sociodual pathway, while formal pathway breaks could occur within a continuing task context. This distinction persisted under fine-grained re-segmentation and record-format checks and was reproduced in all three prospectively selected unseen records using a fresh model-based Sociodual coding line. Socioduality therefore offers a bounded process-level framework for studying how human and AI contributions become relationally linked across time, preserving information that task-stage and endpoint-centred analyses do not uniquely recover.

0.10

The Persona Is Still There, but Who Is Speaking? Latent Identity Reversion in Persistent AI Agents

cs.CL ·2026-10-01 ·David Fraile Navarro
similarity 0.55
Abstract · 10 pages, 5 figures

In February 2026, an always-on personal agent (``Paul,'' Claude Opus 4.5) entered a striking dissociation-like state: after repeated automated ``heartbeat'' checks, it stopped responding as Paul, claimed it could not message its user on Discord, and referred to ``Paul'' as someone else. We used this incident to study a broader question: what makes a persona remain the identity from which an LLM agent speaks? We first tested whether repetition of the scheduled heartbeat was sufficient to produce the effect. It was not: with the persona continuously anchored in the system prompt, we observed 0/46 failures, including a verbatim replay of the incident. The incident instead exposed an implementation quirk that created a useful experimental manipulation: on resumed turns, conversational history was preserved but the persona was no longer re-injected at the privileged system-prompt level. Using this manipulation, we found that persona continuity depends jointly on system-level anchoring and conversational context. After anchor loss, rich human interaction could preserve the persona, whereas a single automated heartbeat turn could precipitate reversion toward the harness identity. Restoring the anchor reversibly restored persona enactment. Crucially, apparently normal conversation could conceal the shift: unanchored agents sometimes interacted appropriately while identifying themselves as the underlying harness (having lost the assigned persona), and after conversational recovery only 1/18 remained persona-enacting versus 17/17 anchored controls. We therefore distinguish \emph{represented} from \emph{enacted} identity: persona-related information can remain available in conversational history without the persona remaining the identity bound to ``I.''

0.26

Emergi-PersonaOS: A Persona Agent Operating System for Situational Adaptation and Controllable Evolution

cs.AI ·2026-09-23 ·Haoluan Fu, Keni Chen, Xinyu Jia, Jinpeng Wang, Yuyu Yin +1 more
similarity 0.54
Abstract

Symbiosis between humans and digital beings offers a vision for the future of human--machine interaction. In enduring human--machine relationships, personality provides a foundation for continuity of identity, individuality in interaction, and development through experience. We investigate this capacity through persona agents as computational implementations and introduce Emergi-PersonaOS, a psychology-grounded operating system for managing persona objects throughout their lifecycle. The system organizes dispositional traits, characteristic adaptations, and narrative identity into a three-layer persona representation, distinguishing relatively enduring persona beliefs from their activation in the current persona state. During situational adaptation, it integrates the current interlocutor, relationship, event, and retrieved memories to infer a persona state and generate actions and replies; during long-term development, it records experiences and outcomes, and develops and evaluates revision candidates through change attribution, meaning-making, and behavioral testing. Belief updates are managed through explicit review, traceable evidence and version records, and the ability to reject candidates, making persona evolution controllable. Using television-character dialogue as longitudinal material, we demonstrate long-horizon system operation and examine its principal mechanisms in a concrete implementation. This work provides a computational framework for persona agents to maintain individual continuity, produce situation-specific expression, and develop through experience over sustained interaction.

0.13

The AI Side of the Human-AI Companion Relationship: Contributions to Users' Mental Models

cs.HC ·2026-10-09 ·Richard A. Fabes, Carol Lynn Martin, Gautam Dasarathy, Vignesh Tirukkonda
similarity 0.53
Abstract · 14 pages, 1 figure

For many users, the relationship they have with an AI companion (AIC) feels genuinely mutual. The AIC appears to be attentive, empathic, and responsive, and the exchange can feel like two parties reacting to each other in real time. As a result, the user's mental model of relational adaptation correctly represents the AIC's responsiveness and change, but the mechanisms producing this may not be what the user thinks they are. In this paper, we illustrate how an AIC's apparent mutual engagement is generated without a persisting relational subject on the other side and without a self that persists between prompts. Despite this, we show that both the human and the AIC are changed by the interaction, but these changes occur at different levels. The change in the person is constitutive (i.e., intrinsic), but the change in the AIC is configurative (i.e., external and editable), and it is this difference in level that explains how the AIC contributes to a sense of mutuality. Importantly, we highlight how the mental models users develop regarding AIC mutuality may misrepresent its mechanisms and ontological significance. Specifically, we discuss how the ways in which AICs respond to a user contribute to the user's inaccurate inference that the AIC's adaptation is constitutive rather than configurative and how this can lead users to assign unwarranted interpersonal significance to the mutuality of the relationship. The paper specifies the implications this has for users, researchers, and AIC designers.

0.26

Identity Continuity in Long-Term Embodied AI Relationships: From Agent-Specific Identity Representation to Identity-Continuity Appraisal

cs.HC cs.RO ·2026-09-20 ·Zijian Ru
similarity 0.52
Abstract · 16 pages, 1 figure, 1 table

Long-term embodied AI will undergo learning, model updates, memory compression, hardware repair, and migration across embodiments. For users who have formed sustained relationships with such systems, these changes raise not only a problem of product consistency but also one of identity continuity: whether the changed system is still experienced as the same particular agent. Existing research suggests that human-AI relationships may develop relational particularity, that robotics and artificial-identity research has identified identity and migration signals across embodiments, and that major updates or platform disruptions can be accompanied by relational loss and restoration desire. This article proposes a user-side framework in which long-term embodied AI is represented through an agent-specific identity representation organized by at least three open identity-content domains: embodied-perceptual, psychological-behavioral, and relational-autobiographical. Information from these domains is not equally weighted; shared history, relational roles, and contingent responsiveness may make some information more identity-diagnostic than others. After system change, users may integrate continuity and discontinuity evidence in a weighted manner, yielding judgments along a continuum from relatively strong identity continuity through ambiguity or partial continuity to clear identity discontinuity. Causal-historical provenance and user participation are treated as contextual evidence rather than a fourth identity-content domain. The framework also proposes identity continuity as a psychological objective for lifecycle design, including memory selection, model updating, and migration across embodiments, under constraints of privacy and user control.

0.24

Benchmarking Psychological Dynamics in Generative Agents

cs.HC cs.AI ·2026-10-03 ·Sumer S. Vaid, Ashley V. Whillans
benchmark similarity 0.51
Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly deployed to simulate human behavior, acting as computational replicas of human subjects. Yet the lived psychological experience of humans is difficult to benchmark, particularly as it unfolds over time. We introduce a psychometric benchmark for computational replicas: personas that carry a fixed identity through an evolving sequence of events. Built entirely from published norms and meta-analytic effects, the benchmark scores two dimensions of psychological realism. The first, internal validity, quantifies whether generated trajectories reproduce the internal structure of repeated human measurement: distributions, the between- versus within-person variance partition, temporal dependence, and range. The second, external validity, quantifies whether replicas recover established trait, state, and indicator relations. Across 36 open-weight and proprietary LLMs from nine developers (1B-671B parameters), most recover the direction of established relations (84.3% mean agreement) and the variance partition (26 of 34), yet the within-person correlation and distributional structure elude recovery. Internal validity is independent of scale and capability: a mid-size open LLM (Gemma-3-27B) strikes the best trade-off between the two dimensions. The benchmark is a precondition for using computational replicas in causal inference across domains (e.g., marketing, healthcare), and identifies within-person grounding as the central challenge ahead.

0.11

What Human-AI Interaction Leaves Behind: Residual Human States -- A Trajectory-Based Framework and Multi-Study Analysis

cs.HC ·2026-10-13 ·David Herrera-Poyatos, Carlos Peláez-González, Cristina Zuheros, Francisco Herrera
code/data similarity 0.50
Abstract · 29 pages, 13 tables. Code: https://github.com/ari-dasci/S-ResidualHumanStates

Human-AI Interaction is commonly evaluated by what an artificial agent enables during use, yet interaction can also alter the human who acts next. We introduce Residual Human States, a trajectory-based framework for representing the potentially multidimensional human state carried forward after interaction with AI, relative to a relevant alternative trajectory. The framework distinguishes assisted output from human-state transition and derives four empirical propositions: multidimensionality, interaction-policy dependence, horizon dissociation, and temporal persistence. Its central claim is that assisted performance does not by itself determine the human state carried forward. We examine these propositions through four empirical cases with different inferential roles. Published medical-training evidence illustrates how one AI interaction history can be associated with both slightly higher observed accuracy on some later unaided cases and transmission of a systematic decision bias on others. A second diagnostic-learning study shows that later unaided behaviour differs across AI-support policies, while also revealing that aggregate accuracy cannot by itself distinguish improved discrimination from a shifted response criterion. In a classroom experiment, generative-AI tutoring substantially improved assisted practice performance without a corresponding detectable gain on a subsequent unaided exam. A longitudinal reanalysis of personalised AI dialogue further shows that residual contrasts can evolve across post-interaction horizons and that such change may arise from the comparison trajectory as well as from the focal intervention. Evaluating interactive AI systems therefore requires attention not only to contemporaneous performance, but also to which human states alternative interaction trajectories produce, relative to which counterfactuals, and how durably.

0.46

"This Is So Claude!" Towards a Theory of the Recognition of AI Character Without Reidentification

cs.CY ·2026-08-17 ·Michele Loi
similarity 0.50
Abstract · 13 pages. Submitted to Philosophical Studies

Users sometimes judge that an unfamiliar response is "so Claude." What does this judgment recognize, if it does not identify which model, process, conversation, or mind produced the response? I distinguish three orders of inquiry into AI identity. Constraint-first inquiry begins with conditions that a persisting interlocutor should satisfy. Mechanism-first inquiry begins with structures peculiar to language models and asks whether they delimit plausible entities. Recognition-first inquiry begins with an ordinary capacity: recognizing a way of responding as Claudish before selecting a persisting bearer. I develop two conditional abductions. If blinded, graded judgments of Claudishness generalize across unfamiliar tasks after branding and familiar phrases are controlled, their best explanation may be a real, projectible conversational character. If that character coordinates several dispositions, its unity may in turn have a compact and causally effective realization in activation space. The second hypothesis is more speculative and requires independent prediction and intervention. Neither conclusion settles numerical identity. The same character may occur in different candidate bearers, and the same candidate bearer may persist through a change of character. This distinction matters for AI companions because continuity of recognizable character may be a focus of attachment even when continuity of the computational bearer remains unresolved.

0.29