CS Paper Radar

Equality saturation theory exploration à la carte

Anjali Pal, Brett Saiki, Ryan Tjoa, Cynthia Richey, Amy Zhu, Oliver Flatt, Max Willsey, Zachary Tatlock, Chandrakana Nandi

cs.PL ·submitted 2026-09-13 14:06 UTC · v2
publishedhighly cited

Abstract

Rewrite rules are critical in equality saturation, an increasingly popular technique in optimizing compilers, synthesizers, and verifiers. Unfortunately, developing high-quality rulesets is difficult and error-prone. Recent work to automatically infer rewrite rules does not scale to large terms or grammars. Users struggle to guide inference and incrementally construct rulesets because existing rule inference tools are monolithic and opaque. As a result, most equality saturation users still manually develop and maintain rulesets. This paper proposes Enumo, a new domain-specific language for programmable theory exploration. Enumo provides a small set of core operators that enable users to strategically guide rule inference and incrementally build rulesets. Short Enumo programs easily replicate results from state-of-the-art tools like Ruler, but Enumo programs can also scale to infer deeper rules from larger grammars than prior approaches. Enumo's composable operators even facilitate developing new strategies for ruleset inference. We introduce a new fast-forwarding strategy which does not require evaluating terms in the target language, and thus supports domains that were out of scope for prior work. Enumo is also easy to extend: two new operators suffice to incorporate large language models into rule inference, where they complement guided search. We evaluate Enumo and fast-forwarding across a variety of domains. Compared to state-of-the-art techniques, Enumo can synthesize better rulesets over a diverse set of domains, in some cases matching the effects of manually developed rulesets in systems driven by equality saturation.

Comment
43 pages, 9 figures, Extended version of the OOPSLA 2023 paper, submitted to the Journal of Functional Programming. v2: corrected the accent in the title metadata; paper unchanged

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Augmenting Rewrite Rule Sets via Knuth-Bendix Completion

cs.PL ·2026-10-01 ·Michael Schifferer, Marcel Ullrich, Sebastian Hack
similarity 0.72
Abstract

Equality Saturation (EqSat) is a powerful technique for program optimization, systematically exploring the search space of candidate programs to overcome the phase ordering problem. However, the feasibility and performance of EqSat rely heavily on the specific rewrite rules used to derive equivalent programs. These rule sets are typically handcrafted, requiring extensive domain expertise and carrying the risk of missing valuable transformations. In this work, we evaluate Knuth-Bendix Completion (KBC) as a method for automatically generating and augmenting rewrite rules for EqSat. Our experiments show faster optimization as well as reaching better terms with previously missed optimizations.

0.21

LLVM Translation Validation Automated with Large Language Models and Lean

cs.PL ·2026-09-17 ·Chunhao Liao, Hongxu Xu, Xintong Zhou, Yizhou Zhang, Chengnian Sun
theory similarity 0.65
Abstract

LLVM is the cornerstone of modern compilers, but its subtle intermediate representation (IR) semantics make transformations error-prone and necessitate formal verification. Alive2, a state-of-the-art translation validator based on satisfiability modulo theories, has achieved substantial success in automating the validation of LLVM transformations. However, it still faces scalability limitations, does not support symbolic bitwidths, and offers only bounded guarantees for loops. In contrast, interactive theorem provers such as Lean can address these cases but require substantial proof engineering. In this paper, we present Trivet, a framework combining large language models (LLMs) and Lean for automated translation validation of LLVM transformations. Trivet generates structured proof scaffolds based on source and target functions, automatically discharges obligations amenable to deterministic reasoning, and delegates transformationspecific obligations to LLMs. It produces refinement proofs or counterexample-based refutations, with every successful verdict checked by the Lean kernel. On 148 LLVM transformations, Trivet verifies or refutes 147, leaving one invalid case unresolved. Successful cases include 60 loop-free transformations with symbolic bitwidths, 27 cases from a restricted class of loop-containing transformations, and 10 complex valid fixed-bitwidth cases on which Alive2 times out. Compared with an unscaffolded baseline, scaffolding enables 26 additional proofs. On cases solved by both configurations, it reduces mean proof time by 75.9% and mean monetary cost by 88%.

0.20

MetaphIR: Corpus-Scale Applicability Analysis for LLVM Peephole Optimizations

cs.PL cs.SE ·2026-11-17 ·Hongxu Xu, Xintong Zhou, Chunhao Liao, Chengnian Sun
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Peephole optimizations replace short source instruction sequences with more efficient equivalents, typically guarded by preconditions such as requiring a constant operand to be a power of two. Since every new rewrite adds maintenance burden and compile-time cost, compiler developers need to know how often real-world programs both match the source pattern and satisfy its preconditions before committing to an implementation. Existing workflows fall short: structural search over an intermediate representation (IR) corpus of 4.8 million functions ignores preconditions and therefore overcounts, whereas implementing the rewrite and recompiling the corpus yields exact counts only after paying the engineering cost, with each run of the corpus's on-demand recompilation pipeline taking a median of 47 minutes. This delay is especially limiting when generalizing a rewrite, as developers often iterate over multiple variants to trade off coverage against complexity. We introduce MetaphIR, a system pairing a domain-specific language for expressing LLVM peephole optimizations with an indexed search engine over large IR corpora. Using a syntax modeled on LLVM's C++ matchers, MetaphIR patterns augment LLVM IR with holes and Boolean preconditions over matched values. To answer queries at interactive speed, MetaphIR builds compact per-function summaries ahead of time and uses abstract interpretation over those summaries to soundly filter out functions that cannot satisfy a query's constraints. Across twenty recent peephole optimizations from LLVM's InstCombine pass, MetaphIR recovers the exact set of functions where each rewrite applies in isolation, achieving 100% precision and recall. Queries complete in a median of 1.27 seconds---a 22x speedup over a full corpus scan---enabling developers to quickly gauge an optimization's reach and generality prior to implementation.

0.12

crush: Extensible Proof Automation for Lean

cs.LO cs.PL ·2026-10-29 ·Mike He, Dexin Zhang, Aarti Gupta
similarity 0.64
Abstract · 35 pages including appendices, 13 figures

Lean's rich expressiveness supports higher-order functions, inductive datatypes, and user-defined abstractions, making it challenging to translate proof obligations into first-order Satisfiability Modulo Theory (SMT) queries and reconstruct kernel checked proofs. We present crush, an extensible SMT-backed proof automation framework for Lean. To bridge the gap between Lean's higher-order constructs and the solver's first-order logic, crush uses defunctionalization to encode function values and their applications. We formalize this translation for a supported higher-order fragment and prove its soundness. Moreover, crush provides metaprogramming interfaces for extending both Lean-to-SMT translation and the reconstruction of Lean proofs from solver certificates without modifying the translation pipeline. We implement crush as both a tactic and a backend for other third-party automation systems. We show that across four such use cases that target verification and general proof automation, crush discharges more obligations than the competing backends and reconstructs more kernel-checked proofs than the baselines.

0.26

Symbolic Synthesis with Token-Level LLM Guidance

cs.PL ·2026-11-08 ·Derek Egolf, Stavros Tripakis
similarity 0.63
Abstract

We propose a synergistic combination of classical program synthesis techniques and contemporary large language models (LLMs) to solve the problem of recursive program synthesis from first-order logic specifications. Our approach leverages the strengths of both paradigms: we use LLMs as a source of statistical bias to guide the search for a correct program. At the same time we use techniques from classical synthesis to short-circuit on semantically incorrect prefixes and to avoid sampling semantically equivalent responses. The statistical bias is derived from the next-token distribution of an LLM, which is highly context-dependent. We operate with the understanding that (1) there is some class of synthesis instances that can be discharged by small models and symbolic tools, and (2) every other instance can be decomposed into these instances. Therefore, our intention is to expand the reach of small, open-weight LLMs and symbolic synthesis techniques, not to compete with proprietary frontier models on every possible instance. These are different tools for different jobs. In our experimental evaluation, we find that our method solves more benchmarks than either small LLMs or classical synthesis techniques alone. Our method solves 30/32 benchmarks using only a Qwen2.5 model with 32 billion parameters. Qwen2.5 solves 0 benchmarks on its own, and only solves a few additional benchmarks when combined with traditional constrained decoding techniques.

0.25

More Powerful Constant Value Checking with SMT Solving

cs.PL ·2026-10-04 ·Jonas Mittnacht, Florian Lanzinger
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Pluggable type systems extend the basic type system of a programming language by introducing additional type hierarchies to specify more complex properties and dependencies between variables. We consider the Constant Value Checker, a pluggable type checker for Java implemented using the Checker Framework, which provides various pluggable type systems and corresponding checkers. The Constant Value Checker lets users specify restrictions on the values a primitive integer or boolean variable can hold using a set or range of constant values. However, the current implementation of the Value Checker makes use of a limited set of syntactic typing rules that, in practice, often fail to verify well-typedness of more complex code. In this paper, we introduce an extension to the Checker Framework using Satisfiability Modulo Theories (SMT) solvers to address these limitations by creating corresponding first-order logic formulas for expressions whose type checks fail with the current syntactic typing rules and determining their well-typedness based on the satisfiability of these formulas. Furthermore, we introduce new dependent types for specifying allowed values with expressions that can depend on other variables in the program.

0.22

Verified Learning for Compiler Optimization: An LLM-Guided Architecture with Formal Control

cs.SE ·2026-09-23 ·Dev Pratap Singh, Rong Feng, Suman Saha
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Compiler optimizations traditionally rely on handcrafted heuristics that often fail to generalize across programs and architectures. We investigate whether large language models can participate in compiler optimization through a verification-centered systems architecture that couples generative rewriting with formal equivalence checking. Using lazification in LLVM IR as a case study, we fine-tune a code-centric LLM on transformations produced by Wyvern and embed Alive2 into a feedback loop that enforces semantic preservation for every generated rewrite. Correctness is enforced externally as a runtime control layer rather than learned implicitly. During inference, candidate transformations are symbolically validated and regenerated when necessary, ensuring accepted rewrites satisfy formal constraints. On the LLVM test suite, the fine-tuned model reproduces core optimization behaviors while applying fewer transformations overall. Although Wyvern remains faster on most benchmarks, 9.8% achieve comparable or improved runtime under the learned system, with no semantic violations observed. Verification overhead remains bounded and convergence stable. These results demonstrate that generative AI components can be safely integrated into compiler pipelines through deterministic validation and structured feedback, offering a scalable architectural pattern for trustworthy AI-driven software infrastructure.

0.16

RuleWeaver: Benchmarking Rule-Centered Scenario Reasoning for Large Language Models

cs.CL ·2026-08-27 ·Bohan Yu, Shi-Yang Li, Pengfei Cao, Jun Zhao, Kang Liu
top venuebenchmarkcode/data similarity 0.62
Abstract · Accepted by EMNLP 2026 Findings

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly applied to specialized domains, where effective use of domain expertise often requires reasoning over complex rules in concrete scenarios. However, existing benchmarks only partially evaluate this capability, as they either focus on output-level instruction constraints or overlook the distinct roles that rules play in scenario reasoning. To address these gaps, this paper introduces RuleWeaver, a benchmark construction framework for evaluating rule-centered scenario reasoning. RuleWeaver starts from corpus-derived IF-THEN Meta Rules, progressively augments them into complex rules, and composes these rules into rule-centered scenario QA instances. Beyond final-answer correctness, RuleWeaver further supports process-level evaluation through rubric-based answer quality, rule recall, and rule precision. Experiments on 11 representative LLMs show that current models still struggle with complex rule-centered scenario reasoning, with even the best-performing model achieving only around 50% of the maximum rubric score. We make our code and dataset available here: https://github.com/SharkSpicy-NLP/RuleWeaver.

0.69