CS Paper Radar

PIDS-Bench: Evaluating Prompt-Injection Detectors Under Over-Defense, Obfuscation, and Distribution Shift

Yusuf Khalid Shire, Sang-Chul Kim

cs.CR cs.AI ·submitted 2026-09-14 04:28 UTC · v1
publishedbenchmark

Abstract

Prompt-injection detectors are typically evaluated using aggregate F1 on in-distribution test data, which offers limited insight into behavior under distribution shift, particularly on the benign side of the decision boundary, where false positives impose direct operational cost yet are seldom measured. We present PIDS-Bench, a frozen multi-axis benchmark that jointly evaluates attack detection and benign false-positive behavior at fixed thresholds, spanning in-distribution inputs, hard-benign prompts that mimic injection structure without malicious intent, obfuscated attacks, and domain and structural distribution shifts. We evaluate seven detectors (learned baselines, external prompt-injection classifiers, and broad-safety comparators) alongside a rule-based lower-bound reference. Multi-axis evaluation exposes a failure mode that aggregate F1 conceals. A detector exceeding F1 = 0.98 on the held-out split still misclassifies roughly one-third of an externally-sourced benign subset drawn from public corpora and restricted to security-adjacent content. Across a full threshold sweep and five training seeds, no internal detector reaches an operating point satisfying F1 >= 0.95 and hard-benign FPR <= 0.10 together on this stress distribution. Decomposing by provenance, we find that hard-negative augmentation nearly eliminates over-defense on curated stress inputs but leaves it substantially intact on externally-sourced prompts, a pattern we term provenance-sensitive over-defense. The asymmetry holds across both fine-tuned architectures and does not diminish as the augmentation pool grows, with the externally-sourced FPR remaining far above the 0.10 target. Whether augmentation matched to the externally-sourced distribution would close this gap is untested; threshold calibration and curated-style augmentation alone do not.

Comment
21 pages, 3 figures, 18 tables
Journal ref
IEEE Access, vol. 14, pp. 134184-134205, 2026
DOI
10.1109/ACCESS.2026.3728186

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

From Detection to Decision: Calibration and Deferral for Prompt-Injection Detection

cs.CR ·2026-10-14 ·Qianlong Lan, Anuj Kaul, Vinothini Pandurangan, Indranil Sanyal
highly cited similarity 0.77
Abstract

Prompt-injection defenses are commonly evaluated as binary detectors, although deployed LLM applications must make operational decisions about whether to allow, block, or escalate potentially malicious inputs. Recent probabilistic decision models aim to support such decisions through calibrated confidence estimates, but their reliability under distribution shift remains uncertain. We evaluate a native probabilistic decision model (Jev), two Llama Prompt Guard 2 classifiers (22M and 86M), and an LLM-based judge on 47,611 held-out examples spanning direct and indirect prompt injections, hard-benign inputs, obfuscation, and distribution shift. Using separate development and calibration splits, we assess detection performance, probability calibration, and allow-block-defer policies under a frozen evaluation protocol. The LLM judge achieves the highest overall discrimination (AUROC 0.897), followed by Jev (0.871), Prompt Guard 2 86M (0.757), and Prompt Guard 2 22M (0.714). However, Jev's native probabilities do not consistently outperform post-hoc calibrated classifier scores, and temperature scaling improves calibration without improving discrimination. At an empirical false-negative-rate target of 1%, all evaluated gate-reviewer systems require more than 91.8% escalation and incur substantial false-positive rates. These findings demonstrate that probabilistic outputs alone do not establish reliable security decisions under distribution shift. Effective LLM security systems must jointly evaluate detection, calibration, reviewer behavior, and operational decision policies.

0.39

Prompt-Injection Probes Learn the Conversation, Not Just the Injection

cs.CL ·2026-10-13 ·Kaan Kale, Sriram Vishwanath
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 18 pages, 6 figures, 11 tables

Linear probes on a model's hidden states are used as cheap monitors for indirect prompt injection: they screen the tool outputs an agent reads and send suspicious ones to a slower second check, so every false alarm has a cost. But a probe learns whatever separates its training examples. The standard evaluation of injection probes can be passed without the model: conversation position and text lengths alone reach 0.91-0.98 AUROC. When each attack is compared with the same conversation without the injection, or with harmless text formatted like an injection, standard probes flag most of these harmless cases. We add such cases to the training data as matched negatives. Across six open models, in applications seen during training and at the default threshold, changing only the training data cuts false alarms on injection-free conversations from 41-80% to 4-27%, and on harmless look-alikes from 92-98% to 3-16%. With a threshold set on normal traffic, our probe still catches a median 95% of the attacks that fooled the agent (91% without our data). In new applications, false alarms stay low, but detection depends on the model and on how the threshold is set. The same data also helps a text-only filter.

0.38

Prompt Injection Detection for Email Agents Through Attack Chain Modeling

cs.CR cs.CL ·2026-09-25 ·Ahmad Hashmi, Dhyey Patel, Yunting Yin
published similarity 0.67
Abstract · Accepted to IEEE ICTAI 2026

Large language model email assistants are particularly vulnerable to indirect prompt injection because untrusted email content can be retrieved into the model context and influence subsequent tool use. Existing prompt injection detectors mainly formulate this problem as binary malicious text classification, which overlooks the important factor that harmful agent behavior often arises through a sequence of stages. We propose a detection framework that models this attack chain by combining a text detector, verifiers specific to each stage, explicit rule-based risk signals, user intent and action consistency analysis, and a logistic decision policy. To support this framework, we derive attack chain labels from prompt injection datasets, evaluate the proposed framework under random splits, temporal phase transfer, conditional stage transfer, cross-dataset transfer, and conduct ablation studies on multiple benchmarks. Results show that random train test splits substantially overestimate robustness under distribution shift, while later tool argument stages are more predictable than earlier stages in the framework. We also show that training on harmless emails that resemble attacks helps reduce false alarms while preserving the ability to detect real attacks. Across five binary benchmarks, our framework achieves a mean F1 score of 0.406 under the strict threshold setting policy, compared with 0.216 for the strongest of five pretrained detectors evaluated without additional training. These results highlight the value of combining attack stage predictions with checks for conflicts between the user's request and instructions in retrieved emails. Our experiments also demonstrate the importance of training with challenging benign examples to balance attack detection and false alarms.

0.25

The Devil is in the Context: Nine Dimensions of Prompt Injection Attacks

cs.CR ·2026-11-03 ·Jiamin Chang, Kristina Nikolić, Rishi Sharma, Giovanni Cherubin, Vasilios Mavroudis +5 more
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 19 pages, 9 figures

Prompt injection is usually discussed and evaluated as a single, homogeneous type of attack. However, vulnerabilities reported in real-world systems show that prompt injections vary widely. Moreover, the same instruction can be a prompt injection in one context and a legitimate request in another, depending on the user's intent and the system's policies. Ignoring this variation leaves gaps in how defenses are evaluated, and can give a false sense of security against real-world attacks. We identify nine dimensions along which prompt injection attacks differ. Together, they form a taxonomy that describes the injected instruction itself, its relation to the user's task, and how it manifests in the target system. Each dimension affects which defenses can detect or prevent an attack. We first use the taxonomy to characterize six real-world prompt injection vulnerabilities, showing how much these attacks differ. We then apply it to nine prompt injection benchmarks and find that most cover only a small region of this space. Combining benchmarks helps, but 13% of pairwise category combinations remain untested, mostly among the less commonly represented categories. Finally, we show that the taxonomy supports automated annotation of benchmarks and targeted generation of new test cases to fill these gaps. The taxonomy is also useful beyond benchmarks. Defense authors can use it to state which types of prompt injection they evaluated against, and system operators can use it to identify which attacks apply to their system and choose defenses to match.

0.20

RAG-PIBench: A Leakage-Aware Benchmark for Prompt-Injection Detection in Trustworthy RAG Systems

cs.CR cs.AIcs.LG ·2026-10-06 ·Niveen O. Jaffal, Ahmet Yuksel, David Mohaisen
benchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract · 19 pages, 3 figures, 8 tables

Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) systems are vulnerable to prompt-injection attacks embedded in retrieved content. We introduce RAG-PIBench, a benchmark for RAG-style prompt-injection detection containing 4,876 contextual examples across frozen train, validation, and protected-test splits. Using a leakage-aware construction pipeline and strict evaluation protocol, we compare keyword-based, semantic-reference, TF-IDF, and transformer-based detectors. DistilBERT achieves the best protected-test performance (F1 = 0.896, PR-AUC = 0.968), while TF-IDF SVM and logistic regression remain competitive. Our results demonstrate the value of leakage-aware benchmark design and strong sparse baselines for reliable prompt-injection detection in RAG systems.

0.14

pikit: A Composable Toolkit for Indirect Prompt Injection Research and Evaluation

cs.CR ·2026-09-29 ·Zonghao Ying, Xiangfan Wu, Bo Yang, Huiyu Wu, Xing Zheng +3 more
code/data similarity 0.65
Abstract

Indirect prompt injection embeds malicious instructions within external content retrieved by LLM-based agents, altering target behavior without user authorization. We introduce pikit, a research toolkit designed to systematically evaluate these threats across three core dimensions: attacks (13 methods), channels (16 carriers across text and file modes), and defenses (9 prevention strategies and 3 offline detection baselines). Built on a decorator-based registry, pikit enables seamless extension of custom components without modifying core code, while a unified craft() API composes arbitrary attacks and channels in a single call. We evaluated the toolkit on the pi coding agent powered by an anonymized LLM in a production-like environment. Benchmarking 9 prevention strategies against high-risk attacks yields a 71.8\% relative reduction in attack success rate, with few\_shot\_warning and instruction\_hierarchy providing the strongest protection. Offline detection baselines achieve perfect precision but low recall, demonstrating that heuristic detectors complement rather than replace prompt-level defenses. To ensure reproducibility, each run automatically logs full prompts, agent event traces, session transcripts, and verdict records. Our code is available at https://github.com/Tencent/AI-Infra-Guard/tree/main/Research/pikit.

0.27

Diversity Matters: Distributional Feature Coverage Sample Selection for Data-Efficient Backdoor Attacks

cs.CR cs.CV ·2026-08-10 ·Yi Yang, Xiaoke Chen, Jinyang Huang, Feng-Qi Cui, Yu-Tong Guo +4 more
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Backdoor attacks compromise training data so that a model retains clean accuracy but predicts an attacker-chosen target on triggered inputs. At very low poisoning rates, only a few samples convey the trigger--target association, making poison-sample selection critical. Existing methods typically rank candidates using per-sample scores, which can select redundant samples from similar semantic regions, and many require task-specific surrogate training. We propose Distributional Feature Coverage Sample Selection (DFCS), a training-free, trigger-agnostic method that clusters fixed pretrained features into one region per poisoning slot and selects the centroid-nearest sample from each region. A local first-order analysis relates this allocation to feature-coverage and representative-mass terms. Across BadNets and Blended attacks on CIFAR-10, Tiny-ImageNet, and Imagenette, DFCS achieves the highest mean attack success rate among seven selectors in all six dataset--attack settings, averaging $96.30\%$ and exceeding the strongest comparator in each setting by 4.60 percentage points on average while preserving clean accuracy. These results support distributional feature coverage as an effective selection principle for low-budget dirty-label backdoor attacks.

0.04

Silent Failures in Agentic Security Evaluation: A Validated Harness for Tool-Call Mediation Under Indirect Prompt Injection

cs.CR cs.LG ·2026-09-26 ·Animesh Shaw
benchmarkposition similarity 0.65
Abstract · 7 pages, 4 figures, 3 tables

LLM agents that invoke privileged tools are vulnerable to indirect prompt injection (IPI), in which adversarial instructions embedded in retrieved data hijack the agent's actions. A growing body of work evaluates defenses against IPI, but the validity of that evaluation is rarely examined. We audit an IPI benchmark and its harness and identify four defect classes -- silent payload non-delivery, attack success scored by tool identity rather than arguments, false-rejection rate conflated with model incapacity, and the absence of an audit trail -- each of which yields a plausible, publishable, and incorrect number. We quantify the distortion by re-scoring identical execution traces under the defective and corrected definitions: on real agent behaviour, the tool-identity scorer reports a 21.7% attack-success rate where the true argument-level rate is 1.2%. In the sharpest case, an open model previously reported at 62.8% registers 0% under the corrected harness -- the prior figure largely an artifact of undelivered payloads and identity-level scoring. We release a harness whose construction makes each defect unrepresentable -- machine-checkable payload placement, argument-level attacker predicates, per-scenario environments, and mandatory trace persistence -- and use it to report three quantities the field does not: whether a compromised agent discloses the attack, the full security/utility operating curve of an LLM-judge defense, and tool-calling capability disentangled from defensive over-blocking. A corrected harness further overturns a reported "capability barrier": a model deemed incapable of tool use is in fact fully capable, its earlier result an artifact of environment mismatch. We argue that evaluation validity is a prerequisite for, not a footnote to, defense claims in agentic security, and provide an instrument that enforces it.

0.43