CS Paper Radar

Efficient Branch-and-Bound Testing and Verification of zkVMs

Hideaki Takahashi, Suman Jana, Junfeng Yang

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-09-14 04:35 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

Zero-knowledge virtual machines (zkVMs) enable verifiable execution of general-purpose programs by translating virtual machine semantics into algebraic constraints over execution traces. The correctness of these constraints is critical: a single incorrect constraint can admit forged proofs (under-constrained) or reject valid executions (over-constrained). Existing approaches do not provide meaningful guarantees at production scale: fuzzers and unit tests often miss bugs, SMT solvers struggle with the size and nonlinearity of constraints, and theorem provers require substantial manual effort. We present ZEBRA, a fully automated verification and bug-detection framework: for a given program and input, the constraint must admit exactly one valid execution trace - no more and no fewer. This reduces zkVM verification to a solution-set cardinality problem over a canonical trace space, where redundancies such as null-row padding and non-deterministic permutations are eliminated prior to counting. To compute cardinality tractably, ZEBRA lifts analysis from finite-field witnesses to an integer interval lattice, exploiting a structural sparsity property of zkVM constraints: across 5 real-world zkVMs, constraints utilize only 14.0% of their theoretical connectivity capacity on average. This sparsity enables tight interval propagation with limited approximation error. ZEBRA performs a parallel branch-and-bound search that either produces a concrete counter-example or certifies the absence of violations within a bounded region. We evaluate ZEBRA on five real-world zkVMs. ZEBRA discovers 11 zero-day bugs; 6 have already been independently confirmed and 3 have been fixed by developers. Compared to SMT-based verification, ZEBRA is 51.5x faster, verifies 16.5 percentage point more instances, and its range verification provides up to 63x efficiency gain over repeated single-input verification.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Lie to Me: Finding Bugs in ZK DSL Toolchains with Adversarial Witness Injection

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-08-31 ·Sebastian Watzinger, Christoph Hochrainer, Valentin Wüstholz, Maria Christakis
similarity 0.73
Abstract

Zero-knowledge domain-specific language (ZK DSL) toolchains compile programs into constraint systems and generate witnesses for cryptographic proofs. Bugs in these toolchains can leave the enforced constraints weaker than the source-program semantics, admitting proofs for invalid executions. Such soundness bugs may remain invisible to valid-execution testing because all valid executions still behave correctly. We present Liezz, a testing framework that generates ZK DSL programs and exposes these bugs through adversarial witness injection. For each generated deterministic program, Liezz executes two public input assignments with different outputs and splices their witnesses, combining the input of one execution with the output of the other. The resulting witness is invalid by construction. A correct toolchain must reject it; acceptance exposes a soundness bug. Controlled divergence and multiple witness-splicing strategies preserve enough consistency to expose missing constraints. Liezz also generates parameterized standard-library calls to reach complex functionality. Liezz supports Circom, Corset, Gnark, and Noir. It finds 13 bugs, including seven with soundness impact. Several are reachable only through generated standard-library calls. Under the same testing budget, a valid-execution baseline does not expose any of the soundness failures revealed by accepted injected witnesses, showing that adversarial witness injection reaches failures missed by valid-execution testing.

0.22

Soliduzz: Finding Miscompilations in Smart-Contract Compilers with Assertion-Driven Equivalence Oracles

cs.SE cs.PL ·2026-10-13 ·Alexander Stromberger, Christoph Hochrainer, Valentin Wüstholz, Maria Christakis
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Smart contracts compiled to the Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM) can manage high-value assets and are difficult to patch after deployment. Compiler miscompilations are therefore especially dangerous: compilation succeeds, but the generated bytecode does not preserve the semantics of the source program. Existing smart-contract compiler fuzzers either focus on robustness failures or rely on differential oracles that compare compiler configurations. We present Soliduzz, an approach for finding miscompilations in EVM smart-contract compilers using assertion-driven equivalence oracles. Soliduzz uses product programs to encode semantic equivalence as executable assertions. The key shift is to compile these self-checking programs and let off-the-shelf fuzzers and symbolic execution engines explore the resulting bytecode for assertion violations, without requiring compiler-specific support from the analyzer. Soliduzz instantiates this idea with two complementary families of metamorphic transformations. The first starts from equivalent expressions and lifts them into smart-contract code that deliberately exercises EVM-specific features such as storage, data locations, control flow, contract interactions, and inline assembly. The second generalizes Equivalence Modulo Inputs (EMI) from fixed concrete inputs to symbolic input spaces. Our symbolic EMI records coverage in the original computation and uses it to guard mutations in the transformed computation. Together, these transformations produce product programs that assert that paired computations yield the same outputs. We evaluate Soliduzz on three EVM smart-contract compilers (solc, solx, and vyper) using several analysis tools. Overall, Soliduzz exposes 29 bugs. Of these, 24 are compiler bugs: 6 miscompilations, 17 internal compiler errors, and 1 hang. The remaining 5 are bugs in the analysis tools.

0.17

LLM-Assisted Bi-Approximate CHC Solving

cs.LO cs.AI ·2026-10-16 ·Baiting Jiang
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 22 pages, 8 figures, 5 tables

Constrained Horn clause (CHC) solvers often struggle to discover deep counterexamples whose derivations may require extensive rule unfolding. Although large language models (LLMs) can propose long-range symbolic relations, prior work on formally checked LLM-assisted verification has mainly focused on generating inductive invariants and concrete traces. We exploit this broader capability through Derivation Power Under-approximations (DPUs). Each DPU is a solver-certified under-approximation of the relation induced by a multi-step CHC derivation. An LLM proposes each DPU with symbolic intermediate-state witnesses that enable SMT validation without introducing additional quantifiers. Validated DPUs can be composed and reused soundly. Building on this mechanism, our LLM-assisted framework HornCraft combines invariant generation for over-approximation with DPU generation for under-approximation in CHC solving. On 260 linear and nonlinear integer-arithmetic CHC-COMP benchmarks left unresolved by a 30-minute Spacer run, HornCraft returns certified verdicts for 228 instances. It certifies 42 instances as unsafe, compared with 22 when DPU construction and reuse are disabled.

0.23

Proving the Wrong Program: Miscompilations as a Threat to zkVM Guarantees

cs.PL cs.CR ·2026-11-03 ·Hui Xuan Tan, Stefanos Chaliasos, Alastair F. Donaldson
similarity 0.66
Abstract

A zero-knowledge virtual machine (zkVM) lets an untrusted prover convince a verifier that a program, typically Rust compiled to RISC-V, ran correctly. The proof covers the compiled binary, so a miscompilation can make a correct zkVM produce a valid proof of a computation that differs from the developer's source. We present the first empirical study of miscompilation as a threat to zkVM guarantees, on the production zkVMs SP1 and Jolt. We assemble 88 known rustc and LLVM miscompilations with Rust reproducers, using an LLM agent to recover Rust triggers for 60 of 124 LLVM bugs reported only as LLVM IR. Many of the bugs carry over to zkVMs: 48 of the 88 make a guest commit a wrong output on SP1 and 46 on Jolt, including the same 15 rustc bugs on both. Most bugs that do not reproduce never reach the faulty code on the zkVM's target, e.g. because they need an instruction-set extension. Existing guest programs are rarely affected by accident. Across 13 guests of 10 popular SP1 projects, the buggy and the fixed compiler produce byte-identical binaries in 447 of the 552 guest-bug pairs that build, and the other 105 have the same code or agree on every input we ran. An attacker who contributes code to a guest, however, can trigger these bugs on purpose. For about $40 per project, an LLM agent found patches that look like ordinary optimisations, preserve the behaviour of the guest's source, and expose a known bug in 12 of 366 project-bug pairs, across 11 of 20 projects. In four cases the guest commits a wrong output, including an Ethereum client that rejects a valid block, and in the other eight it fails on a valid input. Reviewing or formally verifying the zkVM or the guest's source cannot catch such a patch, because both are correct. zkVM projects should treat their compiler as part of their trusted base and track the known bugs of their toolchain.

0.24

Performance Bottlenecks in Computing ZK Proofs on a GPU

cs.CR ·2026-11-06 ·Victor Carolino, Caleb Geren, Michael Kaufman, Maximilian Nussbaum, William Scott +1 more
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 8 pages

Zero-knowledge proofs allow one party to prove the correctness of a statement or execution of a computation while revealing no more than the statement of correctness itself. Recent use cases, such as AI datasets, suggest the need for faster proof generation over increasingly large constraint sets. This paper explores efforts in optimizing zero-knowledge proof generation, specifically PlonK, using GPUs, for applications that are not amenable to solution via incrementally verifiable computing (IVC). Our intention with this work is to improve ZK performance by introducing fundamental changes in the low-level architectural structure of proof generation. These changes affect performance curves for most current proof generation algorithms. In particular, this paper explores the trade-offs between increased parallelization on GPUs and the resultant memory management problems that occur due to this parallelization. We implement a parallelized PlonK in order to analyze these trade-offs and make arguments concerning the nature of data flows within the proving protocol. Our results lead us to consider multi-GPU environments to maximize performance for large circuit sizes. Such environments introduce issues of communication, efficient hardware management, data partition, and data transfers. This paper further discusses the use cases that motivate multi-GPU implementations, their cost models, and the use of remote direct memory access (RDMA) for data transfer among GPUs.

0.29

DSpec2Test: Specification-Driven Test Generation in Dafny

cs.SE ·2026-08-31 ·Sofia Vieira Pinto, Álvaro F. Silva, João Pascoal Faria, Alexandra Mendes
top venue similarity 0.65
Abstract

Verification-aware languages, such as Dafny, integrate logical constructs into code and enable automatic verification of program correctness. However, tests remain helpful in scenarios that verification alone does not address (e.g., to support test-driven development). Existing Dafny test generation tools are implementation-based, limiting their applicability in this context. We present DSpec2Test, a specification-driven test generation tool for Dafny that automatically derives tests from formal specifications, without considering implementation details. Our tool extends Dafny's generate-tests command with a new blackbox mode based on Disjunctive Normal Form (DNF) equivalence class partitioning and optional Boundary Value Analysis (BVA). DSpec2Test relies on the Z3 SMT solver to synthesize inputs and expected outputs that meet the specification-derived constraints. We evaluate DSpec2Test on programs from DafnyBench mutated using MutDafny and compare it against Dafny's existing implementation-driven Block mode. DSpec2Test achieves a 93.9% mutation kill rate on a dataset of 131 mutants, outperforming Block's 82.4%, and uniquely killing 17 mutants. These results suggest that specification-driven testing is an effective and complementary approach for testing Dafny programs.

0.32

SymFC: Configurable Semantics for All Paths Symbolic Execution in Haskell via Embeddings

cs.PL ·2026-11-05 ·Robin Webbers, Wind Wong, Klaus v. Gleissenthall
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Lightweight methods like QuickCheck have proven to be successful in functional languages and beyond, as they let users specify properties as Boolean functions directly in code. We can replicate some of their benefits for (bounded) proofs via symbolic execution. If we can execute arbitrary functions symbolically, we can specify properties just as easily. Unfortunately, existing symbolic execution tools for Haskell are restricted to a subset of the language that excludes many real-world applications like IO; they also have a hard time scaling to larger programs, making them a poor fit for general purpose lightweight verification. One reason behind these limitations is that existing techniques only offer fixed symbolic semantics for SMT base types. This makes it hard to cover more programming constructs and libraries; it also makes it difficult to fine-tune symbolic representations for better performance. We present SymFC, a new symbolic execution method for Haskell that offers configurable semantics via embeddings. An embedding of a function in SymFC is just another Haskell function that can use arbitrary code, as well as SMT primitives. Embeddings make it easy to support new programming constructs and fine-tune symbolic representations for speed. To integrate embeddings into Haskell's type system, we make use of Haskell's coercions, which let us transparently convert between a Haskell type and the type of its embedding. We realize embeddings in SymFC, an all-paths symbolic execution engine for Haskell, which lets us symbolically represent arbitrary types and values in GHC core. We implement SymFC as a GHC plugin, and evaluate it by checking properties of Haskell's container library, and the iproute library. We build embeddings for IORef, Haskell's Ptr/ForeignPtr interface, and the hardware library Clash, and our evaluation reports a 6.25x speedup on G2's own benchmarks.

0.26

Bits Under ZK-LLM: Evaluating Zero-Knowledge-Friendly Quantization for Verifiable Private LLM Inference

cs.AI ·2026-09-29 ·Taeung Yoon, Yupeng Zhang, Xiaojing Liao
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 22 pages, 5 figures

Zero-knowledge proofs are emerging as a promising approach for enabling private, verifiable LLM governance and auditing, where regulators, users, and auditors need to verify claims about training-data usage or LLM inference-time behavior, while model providers must protect proprietary model parameters. However, despite the growing interest in ZK-LLMs, the understanding of ZK-friendly quantization remains limited. This gap matters because in the ZK setting, quantization directly shapes the arithmetic structure, constraint complexity, and proving cost of ZK inference. ZK protocols operate over finite fields and incur costs that depend heavily on the number and type of arithmetic operations, nonlinearities, and lookup constraints. Understanding ZK-friendly quantization is therefore essential for making ZK-LLMs practical. In this work, we present the first systematic study of ZK-friendly quantization for LLMs. We first formalize the definition of ZK-friendly quantization, capturing the properties required for ZK proof generation. We then evaluate nine language models, including Qwen2.5-14B and the mixture-of-experts model Qwen3-30B-A3B, across a broad design space of weight, activation, and nonlinear lookup table precision. Our results show that activation precision is substantially more sensitive than weight precision, while nonlinear lookup approximations can become the dominant source of utility degradation. Also, we identify RMSNorm inverse-square-root lookups as a recurring bottleneck in several large models and recover near-baseline utility by selectively increasing precision only at the bottleneck. Finally, we show that reducing bit-width or lookup-table size does not necessarily yield proportional end-to-end proving savings, showing that conventional low-bit quantization heuristics do not directly translate to ZK proving efficiency and motivating operator-aware precision selection.

0.21