CS Paper Radar

Evaluating Losslessness in Speculative Decoding Under Finite-Precision Inference

Ilya Koziev, Leonid Sinev, Ivan Oseledets

cs.CL cs.AI ·submitted 2026-09-14 12:55 UTC · v2

Abstract

Lossless speculative decoding is typically defined at the algorithmic level: a speculative procedure proposes multiple tokens and a verification procedure is designed to preserve the output trajectory of an autoregressive reference model exactly. In practical neural inference, however, this guarantee is implemented using finite-precision floating-point computations, and discrete token selection can amplify small numerical differences into divergent generation trajectories. We investigate this distinction using Orthrus, a hybrid autoregressive-diffusion architecture that performs self-drafting and self-verification within a frozen autoregressive backbone, as a representative case study. Across 1,190 prompts from 12 domains, exact trajectory matching under BF16 occurs for only 45\% of the authors' checkpoint generations and 43% of those from our independently trained model. The probability of matching is strongly associated with the response-conditional perplexity of the autoregressive reference, indicating that trajectory divergence is not uniform across inputs. Despite these divergences, Orthrus does not exhibit systematic degradation on the evaluated downstream tasks. In contrast, FP32 inference yields exact trajectory matching on all evaluated prompts. These results demonstrate a gap between algorithmic losslessness and its implementation under finite-precision arithmetic, and motivate evaluating lossless speculative decoding at the level of exact generation trajectories as well as downstream task performance.

Comment
under review

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

ReTrace: Rejected-Trajectory Conditioning for Speculative Decoding

cs.CL ·2026-08-30 ·Luxi Lin, Zhanpeng Zeng, Shuang Peng, Songwei Liu, Rongrong Ji
similarity 0.72
Abstract

Speculative decoding accelerates autoregressive language model inference by having a lightweight draft model propose multiple candidate tokens, which are then verified in parallel by a larger target model. However, after the first rejection, standard prefix-based verification discards the remaining draft suffix, so the computation spent generating and verifying those positions does not contribute to decoding progress. Focusing on DFlash, we show that rejected positions in a rejected suffix may still align with the target continuation, indicating that the draft model can retain useful semantic and structural information despite local token-level errors. Motivated by this observation and inspired by conditional diffusion, we introduce ReTrace, a rejected-trajectory conditioning method that conditions each draft block on the rejected suffix from the previous round rather than generating it from fresh mask placeholders alone. ReTrace retains the hidden representations of the rejected suffixes, aligns them with the next draft block, refines them using target-aware correction signals from the same verification pass, and admits them into the drafter's input embeddings through gated residual fusion. Because rejected tokens are never committed and target-side verification remains unchanged, ReTrace preserves the lossless property of speculative decoding without requiring an additional model forward pass. Experiments with Qwen3 models across mathematical reasoning, code generation, and open-ended dialogue demonstrate that ReTrace consistently improves average acceptance length and end-to-end decoding speed over its DFlash backbone. By introducing cross-round conditioning without modifying within-round proposal generation, ReTrace is largely orthogonal to existing drafting improvements and might be combined with them for further gains.

0.41

One Call Ahead: Packed Self-Speculative Decoding with Diffusion Drafting

cs.LG ·2026-10-24 ·Yuxiao Chen, Changxiao Cai
similarity 0.69
Abstract

Autoregressive (AR) language models generate tokens sequentially, so generating long outputs is costly. Speculative decoding mitigates this by using a lightweight drafter to propose multiple tokens for the target AR model to verify in parallel, while a diffusion-based drafter can produce an entire draft block in one forward pass. In models with AR and diffusion modes, one network both drafts and verifies, but drafting still waits for verification, so the standard schedule needs two sequential model calls per iteration. Existing one-call schedules avoid the wait but incur input size quadratic in the speculative width. Motivated by this efficiency bottleneck, we introduce Packed-SS, a self-speculative decoding schedule that verifies and drafts in a single model call with input size linear in the speculative width, while preserving the target model's distribution. The key idea is to let the diffusion drafter run one call ahead: while verifying the current draft, the model simultaneously constructs the next draft from an older verified prefix and keeps its unresolved suffix for the next iteration. Under a mild monotonicity assumption on the drafter, we further show that Packed-SS requires no more model calls than the standard two-call decoding in the greedy setting. Experiments on Nemotron 3B/8B and SetDLM 1.7B show higher throughput and lower mean wall time than both baselines under greedy decoding.

0.18

ResiSpec: Enhancing Multi-Candidate Speculative Sampling via Residual Distribution Shaping

cs.AI ·2026-08-25 ·Zhi-Kai Chen, Jun-Jie Tao, Wei-Xiang Mao, De-Chuan Zhan, Han-Jia Ye
code/data similarity 0.69
Abstract

The efficiency of Large Language Model (LLM) serving is fundamentally limited by the sequential nature of autoregressive decoding. Speculative Decoding (SD) mitigates this by using a lightweight draft model to speculate future tokens, which are then validated by the LLM in a single parallel forward pass. To further boost efficiency, multi-candidate schemes propose diverse candidate sets to increase the likelihood of token acceptance. However, we show that these schemes are bottlenecked by Residual Drift: a phenomenon where the rejection of initial candidates causes the residual target distribution to diverge from the draft model's predictions. This shift renders subsequent candidates ineffective and forces the system into expensive resampling. To resolve this, we propose ResiSpec, a framework that strategically reforms the proposal distribution during verification to anchor the residual target mass within the draft model's high-confidence regions. By mathematically re-aligning the verification process without compromising output exactness, ResiSpec prevents candidate obsolescence and achieves up to 1.92$\times$ speedup over state-of-the-art multi-candidate methods. Code is available at https://github.com/Czzzk/Resispec.

0.48

APEX: Speculate smarter, not deeper

cs.CL cs.LG ·2026-10-06 ·Manvi Jha, Zach Zhang, Zhichao Xu, Linbo Liu, Sai Muralidhar Jayanthi +1 more
similarity 0.68
Abstract

Speculative decoding reduces large language model inference latency by drafting multiple tokens before target-model verification, but its effectiveness depends on both the proposal mechanism and draft depth. Fixed configurations cannot respond to changes in predictability, repetition, and acceptance during generation, so deeper drafting can increase wasted computation without proportional speedup. We introduce APEX, a learned controller that balances decoding speed and draft-token waste through request-level expert selection and block-level depth adaptation. APEX-Router selects among EAGLE-3, n-gram, and draft-model speculation for each request, while APEX-Depth adjusts draft length at each verification block using causal decoding signals and recent verifier feedback. APEX models accepted draft length as censored survival feedback, learning position-wise rejection hazards, block execution costs, and an action utility that balances throughput, accepted progress, and wasted tokens. This allows the controller to adapt speculation while retaining the target model's verification procedure. We integrate APEX into vLLM and evaluate it with Qwen3-8B across six workloads, achieving up to 5.24X speedup over autoregressive decoding. Across the aggregate evaluation, APEX-S achieves 4.27X speedup, while APEX-B achieves 3.27X speedup with a 41.0% relative reduction in wasted-token percentage compared with fixed n-gram speculation at k=16, providing distinct operating points for balancing acceleration and draft-token utilization.

0.13

LongSpark: Efficient speculative decoding with a fixed-cost parallel drafter

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-09-29 ·Hao-Yuan He, Peng-Fei Liu, Chen Chen, Si Shen, Quan He +4 more
position similarity 0.68
Abstract · update authorships & comparsions

Speculative decoding accelerates autoregressive inference by verifying multiple draft tokens in a single target forward pass. However, as the context grows, existing state-of-the-art drafters become increasingly expensive, eroding the very efficiency advantage they are designed to provide. We argue that this scaling is unnecessary. A standalone language model must grow with its prefix because it is solely responsible for every token it produces. A drafter, by contrast, only proposes candidates; the target catches and corrects every error before any token is committed. The drafter's decoding cost can therefore be made entirely independent of the prefix length. We introduce LongSpark, a block-diffusion drafter that achieves this by extracting fixed-size, multiscale views from the target's verification pass, thereby eliminating the need for a growing persistent state. Extensive evaluations demonstrate that LongSpark achieves state-of-the-art end-to-end efficiency across multiple model scales and realistic serving conditions. Notably, it delivers the lowest time-per-output-token on long-context tasks while reducing the drafter's context state by several orders of magnitude.

0.37

On the SPOT: Enhancing Speculative Decoding for Diffusion Language Models via Commit-Order Prediction

cs.LG ·2026-10-15 ·Eliezer Shlomi, Eliron Rahimi, Avi Mendelson, Chaim Baskin
code/data similarity 0.68
Abstract · Preprint, 44 pages. Project page: https://eliezer318.github.io/SPOT-dLLM/. v2: adds SPOT-Sets for dynamic threshold decoding; experiments re…

Diffusion language models (DLMs) promise parallel text generation, but in practice face an unresolved speed-quality trade-off. Exact decoding fills in only one masked position per model pass, while faster multi-token decoding schemes are lossy. Speculative decoding is the standard lossless acceleration for autoregressive models. However, it does not transfer directly to DLMs, which must choose both what to generate and where. We show that this order is the missing piece: the model's own predictions from the previous pass already give the right token at over $90\%$ of positions, but not which position comes next. We introduce Speculating Positions Order Trajectory (SPOT), a 0.62M-parameter model that reads only the target's output distributions, predicts this order and proposes a tree of candidate continuations, which the target verifies in a single pass by state equality. Coupled-noise match, which shares Gumbel noise between drafter and target, keeps this verification exact at any temperature. This approach also inspired us to introduce SPOT-Sets for dynamic threshold decoding, where a pass commits several positions: SPOT-Sets drafts whole commit sets together with their tokens. Our comprehensive experiments show that SPOT cuts target passes by up to $6.8\times$ and reaches up to $3.4\times$ the throughput of standard decoding on SDAR-8B, matching or beating the calibrated and training-free drafting baselines in every task and budget at $T=0$ and $T=1$. In addition, we show that SPOT's learned drafter transfers across models, demonstrating successful transfer across six different DLMs; with a light calibration, the SPOT-Sets drafter transfers as well. On top of dynamic threshold decoding, SPOT-Sets improves the throughput of SDAR-8B by 59% on average over the threshold decoder alone. Project page: https://eliezer318.github.io/SPOT-dLLM/

0.62

WaveFront Decoding: Parallelized Self-Speculative Decoding for Looped Language Models

cs.LG ·2026-09-19 ·Hyeongju Ha, Jae-Joon Kim
code/datahighly cited similarity 0.68
Abstract · 18 pages, 7 figures, 8 tables

Looped language models repeatedly apply a weight-shared block to increase effective depth without increasing parameter count, but the resulting T sequential recurrent-block calls per generated token substantially increase decoding latency. To address the issue, we introduce Wavefront Decoding (WFD), a training-free self-speculative decoding framework designed for looped language models. WFD exploits two properties of these architectures: intermediate recurrence outputs provide effective draft predictions, and weight sharing allows token states at different positions and recurrence depths to be processed in one batched recurrent-block call. WFD organizes these mixed-depth states into a diagonal wavefront, continuously drafting new positions at shallow depth while advancing earlier positions toward full-depth verification. Unlike the phase-separated draft-then-verify schedule, WFD therefore concurrently batches drafting and verification within the same recurrent calls, while rejected drafts are corrected using full-depth predictions. Across six Spec-Bench task categories, WFD achieves 2.42x speedup on Ouro-2.6B and 3.54x on Huginn-3.5B over autoregressive decoding, consistently outperforming draft-then-verify. Cross-recurrence KV sharing further reduces wavefront KV traffic and increases WFD's speedup to 4.81x on Huginn-3.5B. The code is available at https://github.com/summerbro-hhj/wavefront-decoding.

0.61

Reciprocal Guidance: Orchestrating Draft and Verify Budgets for Advancing the Diffusion-AR Self-Speculation Frontier

cs.CL ·2026-09-28 ·Linye Wei, Shutian Zheng, Haoyu Zeng, Meng Li
similarity 0.68
Abstract

Diffusion drafting with autoregressive (AR) verification has emerged as a promising paradigm for efficient speculative decoding. Recent self-speculation models, represented by Nemotron-Labs-Diffusion, further simplify the speculative pipeline by unifying drafting and verification within a shared backbone, while enabling longer acceptance lengths. However, the Pareto frontier between aggregate and per-request throughput remains underexplored. At low concurrency, sequential draft-verify execution requires two model forward passes per round, limiting the effective tokens per forward (TPF). By contrast, at high concurrency, longer drafts incur increasingly expensive computation, forcing individual requests to operate under constrained speculation budgets and preventing full exploitation of the full-backbone drafter. Our key observation indicates that drafting and verification exhibit reciprocal predictability. Draft logits can anticipate likely verification mismatches, while recent verification outcomes predict future drafting utility and suitable block sizes. Building on this observation, we introduce Reciprocal Guidance (RecGuide), a runtime draft-verify orchestration framework that adapts speculative decoding to varying serving loads. RecGuide exploits spare compute capacity through verification-overlapped drafting at low concurrency, while dynamically allocating request-specific draft block sizes as the workload becomes increasingly compute-intensive. Experiments across a wide range of concurrency levels demonstrate consistent throughput improvements over vanilla self-speculation, achieving up to $1.8\times$ speedup.

0.37