CS Paper Radar

Scalability and Performance Evaluation of Federated Learning Frameworks: A Comparative Analysis

Bassel Soudan, Sohail Abbas, Ahmed Kubba, Manar Wasif Abu Talib, Qassim Nasir

cs.DC cs.AI ·submitted 2026-09-14 14:53 UTC · v1
top venuehighly cited

Abstract

This paper presents a systematic examination and experimental comparison of the prominent Federated Learning (FL) frameworks FedML, Flower, Substra, and OpenFL. The frameworks are evaluated experimentally by implementing Federated Learning over a varying number of clients, emphasizing a thorough analysis of scalability and key performance metrics. The study assesses the impact of increasing client counts on total training time, loss and accuracy values, and CPU and RAM usage. Results indicate distinct performance characteristics among the frameworks, with Flower displaying an unusually high loss, FedML achieving a notably low accuracy range of 66% to 79%, and Substra demonstrating good resource efficiency, albeit with an exponential growth in total training time. Notably, OpenFL emerges as the most scalable platform, demonstrating consistent accuracy, loss, and training time across different client counts. OpenFL's stable CPU and RAM underscore its reliability in real-world scenarios. This comprehensive analysis provides valuable insights into the relative performance of FL frameworks, offering good understanding of their capabilities and providing guidance for their effective deployment across diverse user bases.

Comment
20 pages, 10 figures, 3 tables, published in International Journal of Machine Learning and Cybernetics, this version is largely before peer review revisions
Journal ref
Soudan, B., Abbas, S., Kubba, A. et al. Scalability and performance evaluation of federated learning frameworks: a comparative analysis. Int. J. Mach. Learn. & Cyber. 16, 3329-3343 (2025)
DOI
10.1007/s13042-024-02453-4

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Efficiently Distributed Federated Learning

cs.PF cs.AIcs.DC ·2026-09-17 ·Gianluca Mittone, Robert Birke, Marco Aldinucci
publishedcode/data similarity 0.78
Abstract

Federated Learning (FL) is experiencing a substantial research interest, with many frameworks being developed to allow practitioners to build federations easily and quickly. Most of these efforts do not consider two main aspects that are key to Machine Learning (ML) software: customizability and performance. This research addresses these issues by implementing an open-source FL framework named FastFederatedLearning (FFL). FFL is implemented in C/C++, focusing on code performance, and allows the user to specify any communication graph between clients and servers involved in the federation, ensuring customizability. FFL is tested against Intel OpenFL, achieving consistent speedups over different computational platforms (x86-64, ARM-v8, RISC-V), ranging from 2.5x and 3.69x. We aim to wrap FFL with a Python interface to ease its use and implement a middleware for different communication backends to be used. We aim to build dynamic federations in which relations between clients and servers are not static, giving life to an environment where federations can be seen as long-time evolving structures and exploited as services.

0.52

FedPCD: Priority-Constrained Federated Aggregation

cs.LG ·2026-10-09 ·Yousef Irshaid, Dara Varam, Mohamed I. AlHajri
similarity 0.72
Abstract · 30 pages, 17 figures, 5 tables

Federated learning (FL) seeks to optimize a shared global model from decentralized client data. While effective for average performance, this process can produce unfair performance across clients, particularly under statistically heterogeneous data distributions. Existing fairness-aware and multi-objective FL methods address this through client re-weighting, gradient correction, or common-descent formulations, but often change the global optimization direction or treat client objectives symmetrically. We propose FedPCD, a priority-constrained federated optimization framework that separates the global optimization objective from client protection. FedPCD preserves the conventional federated aggregate as the primary objective, while allowing only the minimum correction necessary to meet client performance constraints. Across heterogeneous FL benchmarks, FedPCD consistently outperforms state-of-the-art baselines, achieving the highest global accuracy across all configurations and leading worst-10% client accuracy in nearly all. FedPCD further preserves competitive trade-offs between global accuracy and client performance variability. Beyond this trade-off, FedPCD demonstrates faster empirical convergence, reaching matching or superior performance in substantially fewer communication rounds.

0.10

Latent Information Sharing for Accelerating Federated Learning

cs.LG ·2026-10-01 ·Seungjun Lee, Ensieh Khazaei, Dimitrios Hatzinakos, Baturalp Buyukates, Sunwoo Lee
similarity 0.71
Abstract

Federated learning (FL) is a communication-efficient distributed learning paradigm. However, client drift remains one of the most critical challenges, hindering the efficient training of a global model. In this study, we propose a novel latent information sharing scheme that directly mitigates data heterogeneity across clients. Our theoretical and empirical results show that sharing a small amount of hidden-layer activations significantly improves training efficiency while preserving convergence guarantees and data privacy. Furthermore, we compare our method with existing FL approaches designed to address client drift, including FedProx, SCAFFOLD, FedPVR, FedProto, and SplitFed, and demonstrate superior model accuracy under a fixed round budget without incurring excessive communication overhead. Overall, this work presents a promising new knowledge aggregation scheme and provides a comprehensive analysis of the impact of activation sharing on federated optimization.

0.30

Flower Hub: A Reproducible Benchmarking Platform for Federated Learning in Simulation and Deployment

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-08-25 ·Yan Gao, Mohammad Naseri, Javier Fernandez-Marques, Dimitris Stripelis, Lorenzo Sani +17 more
benchmark similarity 0.70
Abstract

Federated learning (FL) has emerged as a key approach for training models across decentralized data, yet benchmarking in FL remains difficult to reproduce, compare, and extend. Existing evaluations are often tied to custom infrastructure, released as incomplete research code, and conducted primarily in simulation, which limits portability and practical relevance. We present Flower Hub, a platform for publishing, discovering, and executing decentralized and federated applications. We show how it enables reproducible benchmarking by packaging benchmarks as executable, versioned applications with standardized metadata, pinned dependencies, and explicit evaluation workflows. We instantiate this approach with a multi-domain benchmark suite spanning cross-silo and cross-device settings, and including tasks in medical imaging, financial tabular learning, legal instruction tuning, phishing URL detection, and audio tagging. We further demonstrate that the same benchmarking application can run across both simulation and deployment runtimes without changing the application code, enabling unified evaluation across varying learning environments. Beyond model quality, our benchmark design supports system-aware reporting, including runtime and communication metrics. This work advances benchmarking in FL settings from ad hoc code artifacts towards portable, executable, and reusable benchmark applications.

0.31

Performance Benchmarking of Federated Learning Frameworks for Medical Image Classification

cs.DC cs.PF ·2026-11-07 ·Vithor Pileco, Luan Mantegazine, Claudio Geyer
similarity 0.70
Abstract · 9 pages, 7 figures

Selecting a Federated Learning (FL) framework requires understanding the resource demands of its training and evaluation workflow. This work compares Flower, NVIDIA FLARE, and FedBioMed using two-dimensional MedNIST classification with ResNet-10 in a containerized, single-host environment. Following a dated review of repository activity and documented medical applications, we evaluated nine configurations per framework, with three random seeds, for a total of 81 executions. The configurations varied federation size, communication rounds, and batch size. We monitored execution time, CPU and RAM consumption, host-level GPU utilization, server network traffic rates, and model accuracy at the end of each execution. The implementations shared nominal learning settings while retaining differences in data splitting and federated evaluation. Configuration-blocked non-parametric analysis identified differences in execution time, client and server memory, GPU utilization, and network traffic rates. NVIDIA FLARE exhibited the lowest server-memory consumption and the highest host-level GPU utilization, Flower exhibited the highest average server network traffic rate, and FedBioMed required more client memory and longer execution time. No statistically significant difference in final accuracy was detected within the evaluated short training schedules; this does not establish convergence or equivalent predictive performance. The results characterize the configured workflows under shared hardware resources. They provide a concrete case study of system behavior, with conclusions bounded by workflow asymmetries, local networking, and the lightweight MedNIST workload.

0.26

Agentic Federated Learning: Rule-Based Client and Server Agents for Adaptive Training

cs.MA cs.LG ·2026-09-28 ·Deepthy K. Bhaskar, VP Binu, B Minimol
similarity 0.69
Abstract

Federated Learning (FL) enables collaborative model training across distributed clients without sharing raw data, making it suitable for privacy-sensitive applications such as healthcare, finance, and edge intelligence. However, conventional FL approaches rely on static client participation and fixed aggregation strategies, which limits their effectiveness under non-IID data distributions, heterogeneous client behavior, and noisy or unreliable updates. To overcome these issuess, this paper proposes an Agentic Federated Learning (AFL) framework that integrates lightweight rule-based autonomous agents at both client and server levels. The proposed framework introduces a Client-Side Agent (CSA) that dynamically adapts local training parameters, controls participa- tion, and evaluates update reliability, while a Server-Side Orchestrator Agent (SSOA) performs quality-aware client selection and adaptive aggregation. Unlike traditional FL methods, AFL enables context-aware decision-making during the training process, improving adaptability and robustness in dynamic distributed environments. Extensive experiments conducted on the CIFAR-10 dataset under IID, non-IID, and noisy-client settings demonstrate that AFL consistently outperforms standard base- lines including FedAvg and FedProx. Experimental results show improvements in classification accuracy, convergence speed, robustness against corrupted updates, and communication efficiency. Ablation studies further confirm the complementary contributions of CSA and SSOA, while statistical analysis validates the significance of the observed gains. The proposed AFL framework demonstrates that incorporating autonomous agentic reasoning into federated learning provides an effective and practical solution for intelligent, adaptive, and robust distributed learning systems.

0.13

Federated Prompt Learning: A Unified Framework, Empirical Analysis, and Future Directions

cs.LG cs.AIcs.DC ·2026-08-14 ·Qinglin Yang, Chen Qiu, Hongyuan Zhang, Pengdeng Li, Yuan Liu +1 more
survey similarity 0.67
Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) have become core components of cloud-based intelligent services in academia and industry, yet their training and deployment are hindered by high computational costs, data centralization, and privacy concerns. Federated learning (FL) offers a decentralized training paradigm that enables clients to collaboratively train a learning model without sharing raw data, making it a promising solution for privacy-preserving LLM training and reasoning. This paper presents a comprehensive survey of federated prompt learning (FPL) to review recent advances in integrating the federated learning paradigm and large language models, answering the following research questions: RQ1: The fundamental motivations, characteristics, and enabling technologies of FPL, and how it differs from conventional FL and full-model federated fine-tuning; RQ2: The trade-offs FPL approaches exhibit in performance, communication efficiency, computational overhead, scalability, personalization, and heterogeneity handling; RQ3: The remaining security, privacy, robustness, and system challenges, along with key future research directions. To this end, we systematically examine existing FPL methods across the full model lifecycle: pre-training, fine-tuning, and practical applications, while discussing security, privacy, and robustness issues and summarizing existing defense mechanisms. Finally, we highlight open challenges and future directions, aiming to help readers understand how the insights drive research in FPL.

0.04

Resilience Beyond Stationary Client Unavailability: Unlocking Efficient and Unbiased Federated Learning

cs.LG cs.DCmath.OC ·2026-09-04 ·Ming Xiang, Stratis Ioannidis, Edmund Yeh, Carlee Joe-Wong, Lili Su
similarity 0.67
Abstract · Journal of Machine Learning Research

Due to resource constraints or external and internal uncertainties, clients in real-world federated learning systems are often intermittently available edge devices. In highly dynamic environments, the parameter server lacks prior real-time knowledge of clients' availability, making it challenging to adapt traditional federated learning algorithms to be resilient to uncertainties in client availability. If not carefully addressed, complex client availability can introduce significant bias, potentially harming the performance of the trained model. Most prior work either fails to account for non-stationary client availability dynamics or demands significant memory and computational overhead. This paper aims to develop efficient federated learning algorithms that are provably resilient to heterogeneous and non-stationary stochastic client availability. We propose FedSWE, which admits novel algorithmic structures to (i) compensate for missed computations, (ii) stabilize and diffuse the global updates over rounds, and (iii) evenly mix the local updates through implicit gossiping, despite being agnostic to non-stationary dynamics. Compared with the standard FedAvg, FedSWE introduces light additional memory and computation overhead. We show that FedSWE converges to a stationary point of non-convex objectives while achieving the desired linear speedup property in certain special cases. We corroborate our analysis with numerical experiments over diversified client unavailability dynamics on real-world data sets.

0.19