CS Paper Radar

Silicon sampling answers with country-level assumptions, not individual attitudes: Cross-national evidence from the European Social Survey

Chuyao Wang

cs.CY ·submitted 2026-09-14 22:01 UTC · v1
code/data

Abstract

Silicon sampling uses large language models (LLMs) to simulate survey respondents. Whether it recovers cross-national variation, and why, remains unresolved. This study evaluates it against European Social Survey Round 11 (30 countries, 42 items) with two open-weight LLMs under first- and third-person prompts, plus backstory and response-format experiments. Aggregate recovery is moderate and uneven across items. Adding the country name to a three-variable demographic backstory raises the median per-item correlation between simulated and observed country means from -0.03 to 0.52, and the richer profiles tested add no consistent gain. The respondent's country label acts as a country-level assumption that respondent detail does not revise. Naming the response-scale endpoints in words stops the model from ranking countries backwards, so the answer format sets the direction of the ranking. Individual-level recovery remains negligible in every condition and does not track aggregate recovery across countries. An average of neighboring countries, using no LLM, recovers country levels more accurately than every model condition and ranks them about as well. Silicon sampling can thus support exploratory country-ranking comparison after item-level validation and with the response format reported. It does not support individual or distributional inference.

Comment
49 pages, 11 figures, 6 tables, including appendix. Replication materials: https://github.com/chuyao-wang/silicon-replication

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Measurement Validity in LLM Cultural Alignment

cs.AI physics.soc-ph ·2026-08-29 ·An Duy Nguyen, Muhammad Aurangzeb Ahmad
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Researchers increasingly treat LLM survey responses as a proxy for human cultural values. This includes projecting model outputs onto instruments like the Inglehart-Welzel Cultural Map and drawing conclusions about which cultures a model resembles. While a model's answer to a value-laden questions may be interpreted as a cultural signal, it also carries sampling noise and, can be quite sensitive to question framing. In this paper, we separate survey responses, sampling noise and question framing for multiple LLMs. We decompose response variance from these models into variation across random seeds, prompt rewordings. We employ noise-to-signal ratio (NSR) to test whether a model's apparent cultural position is distinguishable from noise. When applied across a dozen models from four geographic origins, calibrated against 88 Integrated Values Survey countries, the answer is often no. NSR exceeds 1.0 on 49 of 117 valid model-question pairs (42%), reaching 5.56 in the worst case. Two models even refuse to answer sufficient number of survey questions outright. Our results corroborate previous findings that LLMs cluster toward Western, English-speaking cultural positions. However, what does not hold up in this study is the precision with which anyone can currently interpret a specific model's coordinates: prompt tone alone can shift a model by 2.4 map units, comparable to the distance between actual countries in the Inglehart-Welzel Cultural Map. These findings suggest that cultural attribution from LLM survey responses requires establishing the reliability of the underlying measurements before interpreting model coordinates as evidence of cultural representation.

0.37

Total Simulated Survey Error: Designing and Diagnosing Survey Responses from Large Language Models

cs.CY ·2026-09-09 ·Indira Sen, Georg Ahnert, Leah von der Heyde, Jana Lasser, Bernd Weiß +1 more
similarity 0.67
Abstract · Preprint

Large Language models (LLMs), having been trained on vast amounts of human-generated data, may encode the attitudes and behaviors of these humans. As such, LLMs show promise in mimicking human-like patterns that facilitate their use in simulating people in a wide variety of contexts. One such context is using LLMs as 'silicon samples', i.e., proxies of people in answering survey questions to establish public opinion, design policies, or use as (social) scientific data. However, several critical questions of social biases, generalization, and technical limitations remain, further complicated by a vast design space open to simulation designers. Multiverse analyses might help us make sense of the impact of different design choices, however, we lack a systematic understanding of the design space of LLM-generated surveys as well as how these decisions interplay with inherent LLM limitations. Therefore, how do we systematically identify, trace, and document limitations in LLM-generated survey responses? Building on traditions in the quantitative social sciences, specifically survey methodology and measurement theory, we investigate threats to the validity of LLM-generated survey responses. To do so, we design a framework that enumerates conceptual errors and systematic biases that can occur at different stages of the survey simulation lifecycle. Our framework, called the Total Simulated Survey Error (TS2E) Framework, provides a unified and end-to-end perspective on LLM-generated survey data. The framework, illustrated through a theoretical and empirical case study, enables survey simulation designers to systematically identify and reflect on errors in LLM-generated surveys.

0.20

Investigating Multi-Cultural Value Selection Biases in LLMs

cs.CL ·2026-10-22 ·Siddhesh Pawar, Arnav Arora, Dustin Wright, Dirk Hovy, Isabelle Augenstein
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 27 pages, 13 figures, 18 tables

Large language models (LLMs) serve users whose cultural identities are multi-layered, yet cultural evaluations commonly reduce identity to one label. In this work, we study LLMs under simultaneous identity cues, with a country persona in the system prompt and a second identity signaled in the user turn, either by naming a country (explicit cue) or through the query language (implicit cue). We test World Values Survey (WVS) multiple-choice probing and open-ended sociopolitical generation. In multiple-choice probing, language cues shift answers about three times more than explicit cues but away from the associated country's distribution, and explicit cues do not consistently move answers toward the named country. Across 1.6 million open-ended responses, naming a country closes 30-44% of the gap to the model's own responses for that country, and explicit cues produce more differentiated value changes than language cues. Our results suggest that country and language cues should be evaluated as distinct signals rather than interchangeable proxies for culture.

0.22

Silicon Samples Match the Answers but Not the Respondents

cs.CL cs.CY ·2026-10-22 ·Yusuke Kumagae, Masahiro Kaneko
survey similarity 0.65
Abstract

Silicon sampling generates survey respondents by having a large language model (LLM) answer a survey as a person with given demographic attributes, and the resulting synthetic populations are increasingly used in place of human ones. Existing evaluations focus on individual-answer accuracy, per-question answer distributions, and correlations across questions. None of these compares the respondents themselves, so a generator whose respondents have combinations of answers found in no human respondent can still score well if it reproduces every answer distribution. We propose the respondent coverage gap (RCG), which represents each respondent as a point defined by their complete answer profile and measures how far each human respondent is from the nearest generated one, relative to the distance between human samples. On two US social surveys, all six LLMs we evaluate leave human respondents uncovered, and under our main settings, they fall behind a baseline that samples each answer independently from the human marginals. Across the prompting and inference settings we test, every LLM has a higher RCG than a Gaussian copula fitted to the human data.

0.27

Simulating Respondents, Not Single Questions: Coherent Survey Generation with Large Language Models

cs.AI ·2026-09-28 ·Ji Huang, Mengfei Li, Shuai Shao
similarity 0.64
Abstract · 20 pages, 6 figures

Large language models are increasingly used to simulate response distributions in social surveys. Prior work has achieved accurate population-level simulation for individual questions. Real questionnaires, however, ask each respondent a sequence of related questions. A simulated respondent should show coherent preferences across the whole questionnaire, not merely accurate distributions for isolated items. Existing single-item methods cannot accurately reproduce how the same person answers a complete survey. We propose FullRespondent-LLM (FR-LLM), which fine-tunes two specialized LLMs: a marginal model for each item's response distribution and a respondent-level autoregressive model for dependencies across answers. Marginal-Constrained Joint Projection (MCJP) then projects the autoregressive joint distribution onto the set satisfying the item-level marginals learned by the first model. This yields complete questionnaires with realistic cross-item relationships while retaining strong item-level accuracy. On two real-world social survey datasets, FR-LLM more accurately reproduces multi-question response patterns, maintains competitive single-item accuracy, and generalizes better to unseen populations and questions. In a small commercial-survey dataset, we use simulated responses to make pricing and stocking decisions; FR-LLM achieves the highest realized profit.

0.37

ChronoCulture: Evaluating Cultural Awareness Across Time in Large Language Models

cs.CL cs.CY ·2026-10-14 ·Rusali Saha, Nitya Khurana, Ruihong Huang, Kuan-Hao Huang
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.64
Abstract · 28 pages (8 pages main text). Code: https://github.com/lab-flair/ChronoCulture

Cultural attitudes and social norms evolve over time, yet most cultural benchmarks for large language models (LLMs) treat culture as a static attribute of a country or region. We introduce ChronoCulture, a benchmark of 10,360 temporal pairs built from longitudinal survey data across 72 countries. Each pair contains the same survey question asked in the same country in an older and a newer year, with full population response distributions as ground truth. Across six LLMs, we find that models can often predict a country's attitudes at one point in time but do not reliably capture how those attitudes change. Their predictions for different years tend to stay close together, failing to capture much of the observed change. Specifying the intended year in the prompt also offers little overall improvement in alignment with survey responses. These findings suggest that models often present a largely static picture of cultural attitudes, highlighting the need to evaluate cultural awareness across time.

0.25

Population Fidelity: Evaluating Population Representativeness in LLMs

cs.CL cs.AIcs.CY ·2026-09-28 ·Neemias B. da Silva, Martin Lukk, Ali Sutani, Abhishek Moturu, Harris Yang +3 more
positioncode/data similarity 0.63
Abstract · 37 pages, 16 figures, 14 tables. Code and data: https://github.com/CriticalMaking/LLM-population-fidelity

Large language models (LLMs) show considerable potential in simulating human attitudes and preferences. Prior work finds that LLM-generated responses can compress the range of attitudes found within populations and misrepresent particular subgroups in ways that vary across models and topics. We introduce Population Fidelity, an evaluation framework that distinguishes key conditions required for a set of LLM-generated responses to represent a population. It incorporates three dimensions: group-level accuracy, the amount of between-group variation, and the structure of that variation. We demonstrate the framework's utility in two ways. First, we reproduce a prior study of "machine bias" in LLM survey responses and apply the framework to its models and more recent ones, showing that poor representation reflects not only insufficient between-group variation but also variation assigned to the wrong groups. Second, we evaluate one proposed approach to improving models' population representativeness: cultural fine-tuning. We find that cultural fine-tuning can improve alignment with the survey center without improving the representation of within-population differences, a distinction that measures of aggregate agreement do not capture. We argue that representing a population requires models to reproduce several features of human attitudinal variation simultaneously. Our framework organizes these features and provides reusable code, data, and trained models for evaluating population fidelity across substantive domains and assessing proposed alignment methods.

0.31

Necessary for What? Auditing Demographic Disclosure to LLM Synthetic Respondents

cs.CY cs.CL ·2026-11-16 ·Aspen Wang, Yen Yu Shan, Lun-Wei Ku
surveycode/data similarity 0.63
Abstract · 29 pages, 10 figures, 11 tables; Code: https://github.com/aspenywang/necessary-for-what

Large language models (LLMs) increasingly answer surveys on behalf of real panelists, and each panelist's recorded demographic attributes (e.g., age, education, ethnicity) are often placed in the prompt on the premise that richer profiles make more faithful synthetic respondents. While data minimization limits personal data to what a purpose requires, a synthetic survey serves several purposes at once, from predicting individual answers to estimating how opinions are distributed and comparing groups. We ask which of these purposes require the respondent's record, and whether improved estimates support sound conclusions about groups. We vary whose profile a model receives, where it comes from, and how many fields it contains, in two U.S. surveys with eleven open-weight and three hosted models, and compare each model with a statistical model fit to the same information. We make four contributions. First, we show that the record adds little to individual predictions and that, for the open-weight models, most of its gain in population estimates remains when it is replaced by census data or a synthetic persona. Second, we find that group comparisons improve only with the respondent's own record, and that even then the models' group differences rest more on the demographic label in the prompt than on the individual respondent, which the usual check of reproducing known group differences does not reveal. Third, we find that the models make groups look more alike than they are, keeping differences in circumstances while flattening or reversing differences in attitudes, most sharply for religious affiliation and ethnic origin, both special categories of personal data. Fourth, we outline an audit that a survey organization can run on questions it has already fielded to decide which estimates may use the record.

0.32