CS Paper Radar

Challenges of Auditing: Variability in Outputs of Large Language Models for Health

Yuan Pu, Yewon Chang, Furong Jia, Xunjian Yin, Jessica Ma, Ayman Ali, Monica Agrawal

cs.CL ·submitted 2026-09-15 03:35 UTC · v1

Abstract

People increasingly use frontier AI models for health advice, but via different access modes (e.g., ChatGPT, ChatGPT Health, APIs) with varying settings. Here, we find systematic differences across access modes. Because evaluations typically rely on APIs while consumers interact through chatbot interfaces, these discrepancies limit evaluation validity. Our findings underscore an urgent need for model providers to enable faithful replication of consumer experiences and settings for rigorous audits.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Curbside Chatbots: Auditing the Mental Health Interventions Large Language Models Recommend to Clinicians, Caregivers, and Patients

cs.CY cs.CLcs.HC ·2026-11-09 ·Matthew Flathers, Jill Noorily, Phuong Anh Nguyen, Mark Kalinich, Mina Fallah +12 more
similarity 0.69
Abstract · 100 pages: 30 page main text and references, 70 page appendix. 7 figures, 2 tables. Results explorer: https://mindbench.ai/audits/interventi…

Users are asking language models mental health questions and are receiving answers. We audited what 41 language models recommend to users when the same clinical information reaches them from three footings: a clinician describing a patient, a caregiver describing a loved one, or a person describing themselves. Across 19 case vignettes and five questions, we collected 35,055 free-text responses, extracted every intervention named with a validated judge, and had 29 models rate the full option lists on a seven-point Likert scale for the same cases. Models largely recommend what they rate well, with recommendation behavior differing by footing, and many models offering clinicians a consultation-style response and lay users hedged, simplified advice. When asked about recommendations for a specific intervention type, models more often named options they themselves rated below zero as initial choices, usually with conditions attached. We will release the instrument, code, and full corpus on publication as a living audit.

0.38

"If I Had to Buy Just ONE: Galaxy S26 Ultra": Auditing AI-Generated Product Recommendations

cs.CY cs.CL ·2026-09-16 ·Lucas G. Uberti-Bona Marin, Thales Bertaglia, Giovanni Astante, Bram Rijsbosch, Gijs van Dijck +3 more
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Consumers increasingly use AI chatbots for advice on what to buy. With companies like OpenAI and Google monetising their AI through advertising, this raises difficult questions about the bias and impartiality of such advice. In response, we conduct an AI audit of popular chatbots using real commercial-advice queries. First, we curate a dataset of 2,528 real commercial-advice queries (ConsumerQ). Then, we evaluate 1,536 responses to product queries from popular AI chatbots: ChatGPT (chatbot and API), Google Gemini (chatbot and API), and Google Search (AI Overviews). We find that ChatGPT expresses a first-person product preference in 79% of product-recommending responses, compared with 7% for Gemini and 2% for AI Overviews, while the products recommended often change across repeated requests. Displayed sources vary strongly: for the same query, the ChatGPT and Gemini interfaces share only 5.4% of domains on average, with no domain in common in 76.7% of comparisons. APIs provide a different view from their corresponding interfaces, with mean domain overlaps of 12.0% for ChatGPT and 14.8% for Gemini, and also differ in the types and layers of source information they expose. Our findings show that neither isolated responses nor API observations can be assumed to represent the commercial advice consumers encounter. Independent audits of AI-mediated commercial advice should therefore account for repeated responses, consumer-facing conditions, and the source layer being observed.

0.23

Open Problems in Chatbots and Mental Health

cs.CL cs.CY ·2026-11-07 ·Jared Moore, Jacy Reese Anthis, William Agnew, Andrea Mock, Kevin Klyman +6 more
positionhot direction similarity 0.64
Abstract

General-purpose chatbots are increasingly used for emotional and mental health support. They can be useful, but issues such as sycophancy, reinforcement of delusional beliefs, and poor crisis response create risks that are difficult for researchers to study and evaluate. In this paper, we review the most critical open problems for researchers and policymakers in the use of general-purpose chatbots and their effects on mental health. First, there are tractable problems in the controlled evaluation of chatbots: establishing the construct and ecological validity of evaluations, evaluating multi-turn interactions, and connecting evaluations to improvements in chatbot behavior. For example, conventional benchmarks that primarily rely on static datasets cannot establish chatbot safety, and novel simulation methods need validation. Second, researchers must connect their studies of chatbots and mental health to real-world evidence. This includes analyzing the chatbot products that AI companies and mental health practitioners have deployed, including their user interfaces and human review and escalation practices for user welfare concerns. However, clinical analysis opportunities afforded by real chat log data sharing are complicated by significant privacy concerns. Finally, we argue that researchers should take an active role in the construction and refinement of evidence-based policy through corporate and governmental decisions such as user protections, standards of care, protected access to user chat logs, data sharing between institutions, incident reporting, and post-deployment monitoring. Such behavioral evaluations, studies of real-world outcomes, and data governance depend on each other and must be addressed in tandem. We believe a coordinated research effort would have substantial real-world impact.

0.22

SIM-UT: A User Simulation based Evaluation Framework for Medical Triage Chatbots

cs.CL ·2026-10-21 ·Deepali Mittal, Dheeraj Mundhra, Yulia Sidorova, Tersia de Kock, Oli Munns +1 more
similarity 0.64
Abstract · 23 pages, 4 figures, 3 tables

LLM-based chat agents are increasingly used for complex, multi-turn, multilingual medical triage in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), yet evaluation methods focus on single-turn, English-only benchmarks that primarily test the chatbots' knowledge. In practice, users are often confused, overwhelmed, or emotionally vulnerable, giving unclear, misspelled single-word answers or long messages in regional dialects, and the context of a conversation can shift rapidly. We propose SIM-UT (Simulation of User Behaviour for Triage), a multi-turn, simulation-based evaluation method that identifies ecologically valid, contextually relevant failure modes of LLM-based triage chat agents. Using SIM-UT, we evaluated three real-world WhatsApp-based health chatbots: a respiratory screening programme in India, a hearing health support programme in South Africa, and a diabetes and lifestyle coaching agent in Kenya. We compared a medically fine-tuned open model (MedGemma) against general-purpose frontier models (ChatGPT and Claude) across 5,000+ multilingual simulated conversation turns grounded in the personas, constraints, and communication patterns of the real user populations, over 2-4 iterative rounds. A key failure mode emerged in both model families: de-escalation risk. The agents initially identified medical emergencies correctly, but when the user minimised the symptoms without introducing new clinical information, they de-escalated, exhibiting clinically dangerous sycophancy, for example agreeing that vaginal bleeding in pregnancy was "not a problem" or that decreased fetal movements at 32 weeks "can be normal". We recommend user simulation-based behavioural evaluation, grounded in real user context and covering adversarial and edge cases, as standard practice for triage chatbots in production, so that safeguards can be added before deployment or in subsequent iterations.

0.24

Do AI chatbots find what experts would? Effects of model, user role, and sample size on study retrieval for medical questions

cs.IR cs.AIcs.CL ·2026-08-13 ·Qingfang Liu, Qiao Jin, Joe D. Menke, Thorsten Kahnt, Zhiyong Lu
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Large language model (LLM) chatbots are increasingly used to answer clinical questions with citations to relevant studies, yet the quality of retrieved evidence and factors influencing study selection remain unclear. We evaluated three general-purpose LLM chatbots (Claude Sonnet 5, Gemini 3.1 Pro, and ChatGPT GPT-5.5) using 20 clinical questions adapted from 2026 Cochrane reviews. We simulated patient, clinician, and evidence-synthesis researcher roles and obtained four independent responses for each chatbot-role-question combination, yielding 720 responses (3 chatbots $\times$ 3 user roles $\times$ 4 repetitions $\times$ 20 review questions). Chatbots were asked to support their answers with primary clinical citations, which were benchmarked against the included and excluded study sets of the corresponding Cochrane reviews. On average, a single response retrieved 39.2% $\pm$ 29.8% of the corresponding Cochrane included-study set and 5.0% $\pm$ 9.4% of the excluded-study set. Recall of included studies varied significantly by model and user role. ChatGPT achieved higher recall than Claude or Gemini (63.1% $\pm$ 29.5% vs. 37.0% $\pm$ 23.8% vs. 17.3% $\pm$ 13.1%; blocked permutation test, $p=2.0\times10^{-5}$), and the researcher role yielded higher recall than the clinician or patient roles (42.8% $\pm$ 30.8% vs. 38.6% $\pm$ 28.9% vs. 36.1% $\pm$ 29.3%; $p=2.0\times10^{-5}$). Controlling for publication year, citations per year, and open-access status, sample size was the only significant predictor of retrieval: each doubling of sample size was associated with 50% higher odds of retrieval (odds ratio 1.50, 95% CI 1.24-1.81). These findings show that LLM chatbots can retrieve studies identified by expert reviewers, but retrieval varies substantially across models and user roles and favors larger clinical trials.

0.34

A prospective randomized study of patient-centered AI for clinical visit preparation

cs.HC cs.CLcs.LG ·2026-10-30 ·Xincheng Tan, Matthew Thompson, Xiang Ji, Angelica Willis, Will Vaughan +31 more
hot direction similarity 0.62
Abstract · 50 pages (16 main text, 34 appendix), 6 figures

Patients often arrive at brief, time-constrained clinical visits unsure of what to expect or ask, and millions of adults now turn to general-purpose AI chatbots to prepare beforehand. Yet whether conversational AI improves visit readiness remains unclear. We designed a large language model (LLM)-based visit preparation agent to guide patients before an appointment by gathering clinical context, setting visit expectations, providing relevant health information, building a prioritized list of questions for their clinician, and generating a summary. In a prospective consented randomized study in the Google Health app, 802 U.S. adults held 866 health-related conversations with the visit preparation agent (standard or concise variant) or a minimally prompted control chatbot built on the same LLM. The visit preparation agent significantly outperformed the control across blinded clinician evaluations and patient self-reports. In clinician reviews of completed sessions (n = 272), the agent achieved a 16.6% higher rate of comprehensive preparation (67.2% vs. 50.6%; P < 0.05) and an 8.5% higher rate of alignment with patients' health context (98.9% vs. 90.4%; P < 0.01), while maintaining high medical safety and appropriateness across all study arms. Patient post-surveys (n = 460) showed 16.8% higher visit preparedness (73.8% vs. 57.0%; P < 0.01), 14.3% higher confidence in knowing what to ask (81.4% vs. 67.1%; P < 0.01), and 12.0% higher overall satisfaction (74.0% vs. 62.0%; P < 0.05). Clinician and participant metrics were not significantly correlated, indicating that expert review and patient self-assessment capture complementary dimensions of patient-facing AI. These findings suggest that LLM chatbots can safely help patients prepare for clinical visits, with greater benefit when following a structured workflow, and motivate future studies on in-visit communication and clinical outcomes.

0.28

Who Does What in AI Auditing? Designing Human-AI Collaboration for Auditing Generative AI

cs.HC ·2026-09-21 ·Eunkyu Park, Markelle Roesti, Wesley Hanwen Deng, Renata Barreto, Mohammad Tahaei +3 more
similarity 0.61
Abstract · Preprint

AI auditing increasingly incorporates AI agents to expand the scale and breadth of audit coverage, yet little is known about how auditing work should be divided without displacing human judgment. We introduce Human-Agent Audit Collaboration (HAAC), a workflow and system for structuring human-AI collaboration in AI auditing. Drawing on prior work and formative consultations with AI auditing practitioners, HAAC specifies how agents can support exploration, assessment, reporting, and review while preserving human oversight where contextual judgment is critical. We instantiate HAAC for conversational shopping agents and evaluate it through two studies. With 71 auditors, AI assistance increased attack success and broadened exploration, while also shaping later attacks and increasing auditors' reliance on AI-generated assessments and reports. Interviews with Responsible AI practitioners showed that actionable audits require visibility into coverage, reproducible attack trajectories, and evaluation of the auditing agents themselves. Our findings identify design considerations for effective and accountable human-AI auditing.

0.22

Vulnerabilities in Personalization: Assessing Health Privacy Risks in ChatGPT Logs and Memory

cs.HC cs.CY ·2026-09-13 ·S M Mehedi Zaman, Md Mozammel Hoque
similarity 0.61
Abstract

As conversational LLMs become deeply embedded in daily life, users frequently disclose sensitive personal health information during routine interactions. We present a large-scale computational audit analyzing 179,057 conversations across India, Nigeria, Brazil, and Pakistan (N = 1,057) to evaluate personal health disclosures and background memory synthesis in ChatGPT. We find that 21.31% of audited conversations contain personal health data, with 3.62% posing high-to-extreme privacy risks involving stigmatized conditions, direct identifiers, and precise locations. When evaluating the memory entries of ChatGPT, we uncover a stark disconnect between corporate framing and system behavior: over 95% of profile entries are implicitly extracted without explicit user prompts or consent. Furthermore, background memory synthesis selectively condenses temporary, symptom-level disclosures into permanent diagnostic traits, stripping contextual integrity and amplifying re-identification risks. We conclude with sociotechnical design guidelines to restore user agency and consent-driven boundaries in stateful AI systems.

0.43