CS Paper Radar

Beyond Benefit or Risk: Perceived Impact Profiles of Human-AI Affective Interaction and Their Associations with Psychological Functioning

Lu Chen, Fenghua Tang, Jiayu Zhao, Xuanying Li, Yanli Wang, Weijia Fang, Mengyu Miranda Gao, Zhuo Rachel Han

cs.HC ·submitted 2026-09-15 05:07 UTC · v1

Abstract

Relational AI increasingly serves as an emotional shelter for humans, and its impact is mixed. Prior research has focused on either positive or negative impacts, leaving unclear how they are configured within individuals and relate to psychological functioning. To address these gaps, this study used a sequential mixed-methods design. Study 1 interviewed 52 users with emotional ties to AI and identified four positive impact domains (emotional relief, loneliness alleviation, enhanced interpersonal functioning, and personal growth) and four negative impact domains (virtual-real boundary blur, social replacement, cognitive-emotional reinforcement, and excessive use). Study 2 followed 673 Chinese AI users for six months and identified four profiles of individuals differently impacted by relational AI use: minimal impact, benefit-driven impact, mixed impact, and risk-driven impact. Users in the mixed impact and risk-driven impact profiles were both high in human-AI affective bonding, but those showing risk-driven impact had greater vulnerability, indicated by higher interpersonal need frustration and emotion-regulation difficulties, more depressive and anxiety symptoms, and lower self-esteem and flourishing. Users in the benefit-driven and mixed impact profiles showed more favorable psychological functioning. After controlling for baseline functioning and relevant covariates, Wave 1 profiles did not predict five of the six Wave 2 indicators; only users in the mixed impact profile reported higher flourishing than those in the minimal impact profile. Overall, potential psychological harms associated with relational AI engagement appeared limited and selective. These findings portray relational AI as a heterogeneous socio-emotional context that may partly mirror users' states and traits, warranting individualized, adaptive safeguards.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Affective and Functional Needs in AI Use: User Patterns and Their Relation to Real-Life Support and Well-Being

cs.HC ·2026-10-26 ·Jessy Wang-Sun, Estelle Yiyuan Sun, Hualin Zhang, Zihan Xu
published similarity 0.70
Abstract · 8 pages, 2 figures, including supplementary material. Full paper accepted at the 14th International Conference on Affective Computing and In…

Conversational AI systems are increasingly used to fulfill both functional and affective needs, yet how users perceive the AI-adoption effects varies. Existing research tends to treat these two needs as binary categories and to classify users by a single dominant need. However, this approach fails to capture users who engage with AI for both affective and functional purposes simultaneously, leaving it unclear how these needs combine in real-world AI use. To capture the multifaceted nature of users' AI engagement, we developed the AI-Support measurement with 1,090 participants, grounded in social support theory, which evaluates four dimensions of perceived AI support: emotional/esteem, social companionship, informational, and instrumental support. This study provided (1) an AI-Support Scale developed to measure the perceived support types from human-AI interaction, (2) evidence that users might adopt AI with a high level of both functional and affective use, and (3) exploratory indicators of users' real-life social support and well-being, enabling descriptive results aligning with theoretical expectations. Overall, this study highlights the importance of understanding individual differences in AI affordance use, enabling AI systems to be designed in alignment with different user adoption profiles rather than assuming uniform benefits across all users.

0.33

"I Just Don't Want to Be a Burden": Investigating AI Chatbot Emotional Support Among People with Suicidal Ideation and Other Mental Health Concerns

cs.HC cs.CY ·2026-11-17 ·Vasudha Varadarajan, Nathan S. Fishbein, Andrew Aquilina, Jordan Taylor, Hong Shen +1 more
survey similarity 0.69
Abstract · 41 pages, 9 figures

People experiencing high-acuity mental health concerns are turning to AI chatbots for emotional support, but little is known about what drives this use, their experiences, and their preferences. In a sequential mixed-methods study, we inductively analyzed Reddit posts and used the findings to develop a survey. We surveyed 202 adults with recent mental health concerns who had used AI for emotional support. Most participants were already receiving clinical care and reported turning to AI, most commonly because they did not want to burden others, rather than being driven by barriers to care. Benefits were broadly shared, but participants reporting past-year suicidal ideation described more harm-facilitating AI behavior and reliance than those without. Overall, participants ranked honesty above warmth, and preference for crisis escalation declined as clinical acuity rose. These findings motivate AI support that addresses perceived costs of disclosure, evaluates benefits alongside harms, and widens feasible paths to human connection.

0.33

Self-Expansion Through AI: Latent Profile Analysis of AI Companionship and Wellbeing Outcomes

cs.HC ·2026-10-30 ·Ali Sahandi, Jaime Banks
similarity 0.67
Abstract

People increasingly form meaningful relationships with conversational AI. Current variable-centered literature offers a mixed picture of relational patterns and how they associate with wellbeing. Taking a person-centered approach, we applied latent profile analysis to secondary data from 467 active conversational AI users, evaluating five indicators of machine companionship: utilitarian motivation, eudaimonic exchange, connective coordination, mind perception, and inclusion of other in the self. Five profiles emerged, ordering parsimoniously from objectified-utilitarian to intimate-bonded. Conceptually divergent utilitarian motivation and companionate engagement co-occurred, rather than diverging. Furthermore, deep companionship was achieved without users attributing a mind to the AI. Profile membership was strongly associated with relatedness need satisfaction, tracking upward across the groups, but was only weakly associated with loneliness, indicating AI fulfills immediate relational needs but may not resolve systemic human disconnection. Ultimately, these findings characterize human-AI relationships as graded configurations spanning a superordinate continuum of self-expansion

0.16

Living with AI Companions: Sustained AI Companionship Predicts Lower Well-Being Through Lower Human Interaction

cs.HC ·2026-09-07 ·Yutong Zhang, Dora Zhao, Yixin Wang, Rebecca Anselmetti, Jeffrey T. Hancock +2 more
hot direction similarity 0.64
Abstract

AI chatbots are increasingly used for companionship, emotional support, and personal self-disclosure; however, how social engagement with these systems unfolds over time and shapes users' well-being remains unclear. To address this, we conducted a two-wave longitudinal study of CharacterAI users, surveying 1,182 participants at baseline and 439 after a mean follow-up of 12 months. We examined how social engagement with AI companions evolves and how these longitudinal engagement patterns may influence well-being through two hypothesized pathways: sustained social engagement over time and the displacement of human social interaction. We found that interaction intensity, companionship use, and self-disclosure all showed substantial continuity over time. Greater interaction intensity at baseline predicted greater subsequent interaction intensity, companionship use, and self-disclosure. Consistent with the longitudinal engagement pathway, sustained social engagement across these dimensions was consistently associated with lower well-being. Results further support the social displacement pathway, indicating that these links were mainly explained by lower in-person social interaction. These findings highlight the importance of designing AI companions that support human social relationships without displacing them.

0.44

AI emotional support is better only when chosen, but shifts preferences even when it is not

cs.AI cs.HC ·2026-08-24 ·Yaoxi Shi, Cathy Mengying Fang, Guy LabanPattie Maes, Amit Goldenberg
similarity 0.63
Abstract

People increasingly face a novel decision when seeking emotional support: human or AI. In existing studies, AI's empathic messages are rated as well as or better than humans'. But these studies either assigned the support source or honored people's choice. In real life, support is often incongruent with choice, as people want one source and receive the other. Across three experiments (N = 1,951), participants chose whether to share an emotional experience with a human or an AI, then were randomly assigned to a congruent or incongruent partner. AI support was rated as superior only among those who had chosen it. Yet regardless of congruence, interacting with AI increased willingness to choose it again. In a 28-day study with OpenAI (N = 981), daily conversations shifted preferences toward AI and away from humans, but only when conversations turned personal. Emotional support choices are thus path-dependent, progressively redirecting away from human connection.

0.20

Early Signals of Problematic AI Use: The Longitudinal Roles of Motivation and Emotional Engagement

cs.HC cs.AIcs.CY ·2026-11-07 ·Jina Suh, Constance Hadley, Koustuv Saha
survey similarity 0.63
Abstract

Longitudinal evidence about the psychological impact of conversational AI use remains scarce. We report a survey study of 114 adults who reported their level of problematic AI use one year after reporting their motivations (for escape, social, entertainment, and instrumental reasons) for engaging with AI. We found high levels of AI motivation of all types predicted later problematic AI use, especially when participants turned to AI for managing their feelings and overcoming difficulties. Our findings imply that AI motivation could be used as an early warning signal of potential problematic use, especially if individuals engage with AI for emotional purposes over time.

0.23

Rewriting the Self: User Perceptions of AI-Mediated Cognitive Reframing

cs.HC ·2026-10-26 ·Yuewen Yang, Olzhas Yessenbayev, Anna R. Van Meter, Tanzeem Choudhury, Daniel A. Adler
similarity 0.62
Abstract · Data collected in summer 2024

Individuals are increasingly using AI for psychological support. One specific paradigm, AI-mediated cognitive reframing (AIM-CR), uses AI to automatically reframe users' negative thoughts ("I failed...") into more adaptive perspectives ("I am learning..."). While prior work suggests that AIM-CR tools reduce users' negative emotions, the complexities of AI automatically modifying users' personal narratives remain underexplored. In this work, we investigated these complexities through a mixed-methods study in which 28 participants engaged with an AIM-CR tool that reframed narratives about their stressors. Our findings suggest that participants had mixed perceptions of AIM-CR: although reframing reduced negative emotions for most participants, participants felt less ownership of, and less authenticity in, the reframed narratives. Participants perceived AIM-CR as a validating "mirror," as "another self" that could motivate or alienate them, or as an external social actor. These perceptions shaped therapeutic dynamics. We conclude by discussing design implications for future AIM-CR tools to better preserve user agency in narrative co-construction and more effectively support mental health and well-being.

0.22

Disrupted Companionship: A Risk Assessment Framework and Cross-Platform Quantitative Analysis of Psychosocial Responses to AI Companion Disruptions

cs.HC cs.CLcs.CY ·2026-09-15 ·Chau Do, Yunhao Yuan, Koustuv Saha, Renwen Zhang, Talayeh Aledavood
similarity 0.61
Abstract

AI companions can provide meaningful relationships, yet these relationships remain vulnerable to platform-initiated changes. We study AI companion disruptions: platform changes that alter or terminate users' ongoing companionship with an AI. We compile 30 disruption events across major platforms, develop a taxonomy of six disruption types, identify three broad reasons for disruption, and propose a risk-assessment framework comprising four dimensions: relational discontinuity, population vulnerability, communication deficit, and transition-support deficit. Using longitudinal Reddit data, we estimate community-level psychosocial responses with a hierarchical Bayesian interrupted time-series model incorporating predictive controls. Across events, disruption onset was associated with immediate increases in anxiety, stress, suicidal expression, and grief activation, with relational discontinuity and transition-support deficit being associated with more adverse immediate responses across several outcomes. Our findings provide a cross-platform characterization of AI companion disruptions, quantitative evidence of their psychosocial impacts, and a prospective framework for assessing their potential risks before implementation.

0.45