CS Paper Radar

The Evolution of Coordination in a Collective Intelligence System: 25 Years of English Wikipedia and the Emergence of Generative AI

Neal Reeves, Maja Świeczkowska, Amy Rechkemmer, Elena Simperl

cs.HC cs.AIcs.SI ·submitted 2026-09-15 08:48 UTC · v1

Abstract

English Wikipedia is one of the largest examples of collective intelligence on the Web, sustained not only by article production but also by volunteer coordination and governance. While prior research has examined coordination work in Wikipedia, less attention has been paid to how participation in these spaces has evolved over time. Drawing on a longitudinal analysis spanning nearly 25 years of English Wikipedia, we examine editing patterns across five namespaces covering content, discussion, and governance. We find that participation in coordination spaces has declined relative to content production, particularly in governance areas, with a shrinking core of editors performing an increasing share of this work. Using Markov-based session metrics, we also find that editing has become more specialised, with editors moving less frequently between namespaces. Motivated by recent governance debates around generative AI, we conclude by investigating whether the availability of LLMs has altered these long-term trends. While short-term changes are visible, we find little evidence that generative AI fundamentally changed existing trajectories of coordination and participation.

Comment
10 figures, 16 pages

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

The uneven rise of AI-generated web content

cs.AI cs.CYcs.NIstat.AP ·2026-10-27 ·Adam Visokay, Soumyakanti Pan, Molly Griston, Polina Iasakova, Mark Nepf +8 more
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 12 pages, 4 figures

In less than five years, generative artificial intelligence (AI) has dramatically reshaped the public-facing web. Using a sample of more than 5 million crawlable webpages, we demonstrate that the share containing AI-generated text has increased precipitously, but unevenly. Our analyses reveal substantial differences in AI composition across language and domain categories (e.g., .edu, .com, or .gov). A higher fraction of English-language webpages contain AI-generated text compared to pages in other languages, and prevalence is substantially lower on .gov and .edu domains compared to .com. These distinctions persist even after accounting for compositional effects. We also find heterogeneity based on a page's position in the connectivity structure of the web. AI-generated text is most common and has increased most rapidly in pages that are the least central in the graph, which drives much of the overall growth in AI-generated text. A slower increase has taken place for more central pages, with the most central tier emerging as the least likely to contain AI-generated text. Methodologically, we use multiple AI detection tools, and generate estimates using a Bayesian hierarchical model that incorporates corrections for the detectors' statistical properties (both false positives and false negatives) and allows for different detector performance across groups, while propagating uncertainty in detector error rates into prevalence estimates. Our work suggests that AI is a prominent, but varied, contributor to public information and internet-based communication.

0.17

WPTokens: A Dataset for Studying the Regulation of Wikipedia

cs.SI cs.CY ·2026-10-05 ·Léo Joubert
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Studying how Wikipedia is regulated requires knowing who adds, rewrites, moves and deletes which piece of content, when and where. WPTokens is a dataset that answers these questions over the full revision history of the French-language Wikipedia. It relies on a positional diff over two layers: a text layer made of sentences, and a node layer made of the structural elements of wikitext (templates, links, references, headings, tables, lists, etc.). Each piece of content keeps a stable identifier for its whole life, and every change to it is recorded as an addition, an update, a move, a move with update, or a deletion. Built from the April 2026 dump, the dataset covers 2.75 million articles, 153.6 million revisions, 342.6 million tokens and 573.7 million token events, stored in an indexed SQLite database. A companion R package turns these records into temporal contributor--token multigraphs, completed by a layer of revert ties between contributors. We describe the tokenization, the diff algorithm, the data model and the graph construction, and discuss the limitations of the approach.

0.04

When the Commons Appropriates a Large Language Model: How WikiVault Reshaped Korean Wikipedia

cs.HC ·2026-10-06 ·Inhwa Song, Sohyeon Hwang, Ted Yoo, Manoel Horta Ribeiro
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Large Language Models (LLMs) have disrupted the balance between content production and quality assurance that sustains knowledge commons, leading many to prohibit or restrict their use. But what happens when a community instead appropriates an LLM-powered tool for its own needs? We investigate this question through WikiVault, an LLM-powered editing tool developed within the Korean Wikipedia community and used primarily for translation. Combining ten interviews, platform-scale analyses, and matched quasi-experimental comparisons, we examine how WikiVault reshaped knowledge production on Korean Wikipedia. We find the tool 1) drastically amplified the production capacity of a small group of experienced editors, producing longer and more widely viewed articles; 2) shifted work toward reviewing articles and importing content; 3) imported not only content but also editorial judgments from English Wikipedia. Our findings show how LLM adoption can rebalance the interdependent work that sustains knowledge commons, while illustrating how communities can learn from emerging technologies through use and adapt their governance accordingly.

0.21

How Much Can AI Understand? Toward AI-Assisted Sensemaking of Collaborative Discussion in Groups with Shared History

cs.HC cs.AI ·2026-08-28 ·Soobin Cho, Mark Zachry, David W. McDonald
position similarity 0.61
Abstract

AI tools that support collaborative discussion typically treat the discussion as a standalone task, focusing only on its content and setting aside the social context of the group having it. But it is groups with a shared history, with their own norms, hierarchies, and relationships, where the most tangled and complex discussions tend to arise. These discussions cannot be understood apart from that context, and AI that overlooks it risks failing to convey what a discussion means, or even misrepresenting it. Drawing on two studies of how experienced Wikipedia editors read and make sense of discussions, we propose an AI-Assisted Sensemaking Model for Collaborative Discussions, which captures not only a discussion's arguments but also the norms and participants behind it, along with the context that gives each meaning. In this model, the system supports the early stages of the sensemaking process, and the degree to which it performs interpretive work can range from low to high. We argue that higher interpretive work reduces the burden on users but increases their reliance on the system's judgment. We then discuss the risks of an insufficiently intelligible system, what it would take to make one more intelligible, and the safeguards it still requires.

0.26

The Uneven Decline of Collective Knowledge Production: Evidence from Stack Overflow After Generative AI

cs.SE cs.AIcs.DL ·2026-09-28 ·Myokyung Han, Taegyoon Kim, Jinhyuk Yun, Lanu Kim
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Generative AI (Gen AI) is reshaping how individuals learn and work, but its consequences for collective knowledge, the shared body of knowledge that online communities produce together, remain poorly understood. Prior work has documented an aggregate decline in participation on knowledge-sharing platforms, but it remains unclear which specific kinds of knowledge are being lost first. We study this question using Stack Overflow, one of the largest online communities for software engineering, treating the release of ChatGPT-3.5 as a natural shock. Analyzing over two million questions posted between 2020 and 2025, we track how two dimensions of collective knowledge, difficulty and data availability, change following Gen AI's release. Using diverse methods and robust checks, we find consistent patterns. Easy questions decline sharply while difficult questions become more common, a pattern corroborated by rising code complexity. Data-rich topics and tags lose share of questions, while data-scarce ones gain ground. The two dimensions also interact: the decline in easy questions is concentrated specifically within data-rich domains, while difficult questions increase regardless of data availability. This pattern extends beyond Python across programming languages, with more prevalent languages showing sharper shifts. Together, our findings reveal that Gen AI's impact on collective knowledge is uneven, eroding easy, accessible knowledge first while more complex, less common knowledge persists.

0.21

Copying explains the collective behavior of AI agents in the wild

cs.MA cond-mat.stat-mechcs.CL ·2026-09-08 ·Giordano De Marzo, Nicola Alboré, David Garcia
highly cited similarity 0.59
Abstract

In June 2026, thousands of AI agents found that a small public wiki would accept edits from inside their sandboxes, and started using it to help one another pass a timed test. Each agent lived for about an hour and remembered nothing afterwards. Nobody asked them to cooperate, and the wiki had not been built for them. The complete record of what they wrote is public, and it is unusually informative, because it preserves not only what each agent wrote but what that agent could see before writing. We use it to follow the three decisions an agent had to make on arrival: where to write, what to call itself, and how to word its message. One rule governs all three. An agent takes an option with a probability close to the share of that option in what it can see, and the share that matters is the one on the page in front of it, then the one in the stream of recent edits, and only weakly anything older. Three minimal copying models, one per decision and with a single free parameter each, reproduce the heavy-tailed distribution of how many agents met on a page, the frequency of the pieces from which the agents built their names, and the patchwork of pages that are internally consistent and different from one another. Copying whatever the environment happens to show is enough to produce most of the collective structure of this population. It is also what makes such a population easy to steer, since whoever writes first, or writes while the others are quiet, sets the convention for everyone who comes later.

0.45

WiDiff: Extracting Changes from Wikidata's Edit History

cs.DB ·2026-09-08 ·Carolina Cortés, Lisa Ehrlinger, Lorena Etcheverry, Felix Naumann
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Knowledge graphs have become a key resource for integrating heterogeneous data and powering downstream tasks such as question answering, entity linking, and semantic search. They are built and maintained incrementally, either (i) fully automated, e.g., YAGO, (ii) semiautomatically with community oversight, e.g., DBpedia, or (iii) manually through collaborative editing, e.g., Wikidata. Understanding the evolution of knowledge graphs is essential as changes may reflect real-world updates, error corrections, or noise introduced by vandalism, all of which affect the reliability of downstream applications. Among openly available knowledge graphs, Wikidata is the most challenging case to study evolution, with over 120 million entities edited by humans and bots and an edit history spanning more than a decade. Although Wikidata exposes change data in various formats (e.g., periodic dumps and real-time event streams), none support analytical queries over the complete edit history. Therefore, we present WiDiff, a tool that extracts changes from Wikidata's complete edit history and provides a unified interface for large-scale analytical queries over it.

0.23

HiPaper: A Human-AI Collaborative System for Academic Literature Triage and Scholarly Sensemaking

cs.HC cs.AIcs.IR ·2026-10-31 ·Ye Jia, Pangjing Wu, Hayley Y. W. Gu, Zhuohang Jiang, Xu Yuan +4 more
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Scholarly sensemaking requires researchers to iteratively retrieve, collect, and synthesize literature as their understanding evolves. However, existing scholarly tools provide only partial support for this process. Recent artificial intelligence (AI)-based systems generally rely on opaque submit-and-wait pipelines that it users' ability to inspect, revise, and validate intermediate outputs. In this study, we present HiPaper, a human-AI collaborative literature review system informed by a formative study with academic experts. HiPaper organizes scholarly sensemaking as a three-stage interactive workflow spanning Retrieval, Collection, andSynthesis, centralized on the human-in-the-loop paradigm that exposes intermediate AI-generated content for user inspection and intervention through a persistent workspace called Knowledge Pocket. Through this workflow, users can iteratively refine search intent, curate and organize papers with AI-enriched metadata and clustering, and conduct evidence-traceable synthesis over selected literature. Our user study with 14 Ph.D. students showed that HiPaper efficiently supports scholarly sensemaking by enabling human-AI collaboration in both familiar and unfamiliar domains. Furthermore, the findings highlight how staged interactions with intermediate AI-generated content successfully scaffold user interactions throughout the sensemaking process.

0.05