CS Paper Radar

Decodability is Not Causality: Dissociating Probe Readouts from Behavioral Drivers via SAE Decomposition

Devesh Tiwari, Camille Davis, Shivank Sinha, Talia Weaver, Aditya Shah, Maheep Chaudhary

cs.AI ·submitted 2026-09-16 03:35 UTC · v1
highly cited

Abstract

Linear probes can decode safety-relevant concepts such as truthfulness from language-model activations, but probe accuracy may show only decodability, not that the features the probe weights causally drive model behavior. We demonstrate that this gap cannot be closed from the geometry of probe weights alone: the features geometrically aligned with probe direction need not be the ones the model uses, so causal relevance requires intervention. We introduce a feature-level diagnostic that decomposes a deployed True/False probe into sparse-autoencoder (SAE) features, ranks those features by both probe alignment and by gradient sensitivity of the model's behavior, and ablates the resulting shared, probe-only, and random feature sets under a coherence gate. On the truth probe of Buerger et al. (2024) (TTPD), applied in the instructed truth/deception setting of Long et al. (2025) for Gemma2-9B-Instruct, the two rankings overlap only weakly (about 12%, Spearman rho = 0.10), and ablation dissociates them sharply: features the probe shares with the model flip the output far more (up to 27%) than equally sized probe-only (6%) or random (1%) features at full coherence, while probe-only features instead perturb the probe's own readout. The dissociation holds across five seeds and a held-out split, and an activation-aware selection of features flips behavior nearly three times as often as the probe's geometric top features (17.6% vs. 6.1%). In this setting, therefore, the geometric projection of a probe's weight vector alone does not identify the features the model causally uses; however, combining probe information with feature activation statistics recovers substantially more behaviorally causal features, and coherence-gated SAE intervention is needed to separate them from probe readouts.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Decodable but Not Actionable: Auditing the Representation-Behavior Gap in Frozen LLMs for Geometric Constraints

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-08-18 ·Man Liang, Xinzhao Cheng, Faizan Wajid
similarity 0.65
Abstract · Revised manuscript with expanded experiments, analyses, and discussion

Large language models (LLMs) perform well on structured reasoning tasks, but what they encode and whether encoded information guides their behavior remain unclear. We introduce a controlled auditing framework that uses parametric CAD to distinguish failures of encoding, expression, and activation-level control. Applied to eight pretrained models and matched randomly initialized controls, our framework reveals that pretraining contributes substantially more to linear decoding of local relations than to global constraint status, which is already highly decodable from random representations. Yet strong local decodability does not translate into the models' zero-shot predictions, which remain far below supervised probe performance. Restoring clean internal activations can repair probe predictions, whereas simple activation steering does not provide reliable targeted control. With only 400 labeled relation pairs, low-rank fine-tuning substantially improves generation on three representative models, showing that the representation--behavior gap can be reduced through adaptation. Together, these findings show why decodability alone is insufficient evidence that encoded information will be expressed or controllable in model behavior.

0.24

HalluTracer: Pre-Decoding Truthfulness Prediction via Depth-Averaged Probe-Logit

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-08-17 ·Zhihao Guo, Zonghan Wu, Huan Huo, DaYong Ye, Junwei Zhang +4 more
benchmark similarity 0.64
Abstract

Internal-state probes enable truthfulness prediction before a large language model generates an answer. When detectors change both the layers they read and the rules used to combine them, the source of improved prediction becomes difficult to identify. We separate these choices and find that retaining more layers improves prediction even under fixed equal weighting. An exact Fisher-ratio decomposition explains why the additional benefit of linear reweighting is limited on these probe scores: information inlayer-wise differences largely overlaps with that captured by the depth mean. Estimating additional weights can then offset this small benefit when the data used to fit them are limited. These findings motivate our proposed method HalluTracer, which averages layer-wise probe logits to predict truthfulness before decoding. Across six models and four benchmarks, including TruthfulQA, HalluTracer achieves the highest area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUROC) in 23 of 24 model--benchmark pairs among the compared methods. The results support using evidence from across the network without requiring a correspondingly more flexible aggregation rule, clarifying the distinct roles of layer selection and weighting in pre-decoding detection.

0.24

From Input to Output: A Flexible Agent for Dual-End Interpretation of Sparse Autoencoder Features

cs.CL ·2026-09-28 ·Dewen Liu, Zixuan Li, Jonathan Pan, Zhao Wu, Zijun Yao +2 more
code/data similarity 0.63
Abstract · 25 pages

Sparse autoencoders (SAEs) are an important tool for mechanistic interpretability, but interpreting their many features remains challenging. Existing methods characterize input-side activation patterns and output-side intervention effects, yet often leave their functional connection implicit, while input-side evidence collection typically relies on costly large-corpus scans. We introduce functional interpretation, which characterizes an SAE feature as a mapping from its activating input semantics to its output effects under intervention, and present Dual-End Agentic Feature Interpretation (DAFI), an agent that actively gathers evidence and refines input-side, output-side, and functional interpretations through component-specific feedback. Its short-context token probing enables on-demand activation evidence collection without a full corpus scan. On GemmaScope, DAFI improves Input score by 13.1 percentage points over SAGE and Output score by 38.9 points over Token Change, while being substantially more token-efficient than a general-purpose coding agent. Skills distilled from successful refinements raise the held-out joint pass rate from 58.0% to 92.0% and improve both interpretation quality and efficiency when transferred to a new model-SAE setting. Across features with reliable endpoint interpretations, 70.7% exhibit non-equivalent input and output semantics. On AxBench, DAFI also improves steering-feature selection over output-score filtering. Code is available at https://github.com/THUAIS-Lab/DAFI.

0.34

REINS: Refusal-Enhanced Inhibitory Steering with Sparse Autoencoder Features

cs.AI ·2026-08-28 ·Kai-Xuan Ding, Hao-Xiang Xu, Ji-Hua Peng, Zi-Qi Chen, Jiaqi Wang +1 more
top venue similarity 0.63
Abstract · Accepted at EMNLP 2026 Main Conference

Steering with Sparse Autoencoders (SAEs) offers a lightweight inference-time path for adapting the behavior of large language models without retraining. By exposing sparse and interpretable features, SAE steering provides a promising interface for safety control that guides harmful continuations toward refusal. However, we observe that complex wrappers can still undermine existing SAE steering methods on harmful prompts. To evaluate this failure mode systematically, we construct Generalized Undercover Instruction Safety Evaluation (GUISE), a dataset of harmful prompts with complex wrappers. Existing single direction SAE steering methods do not reliably produce refusals on harmful prompts, suggesting that refusal enhancement alone can be too weak when the harmful continuation path remains active. This motivates us to propose Refusal-Enhanced INhibitory Steering (REINS), which suppresses harmful continuation features and enhances safe refusal features in the same SAE feature space. Experiments on GUISE and other datasets show that prior methods either intervene too weakly or achieve only apparent safety through collapse, while REINS substantially reduces harmful responses, markedly improves safe refusals and largely preserves general capabilities.

0.63

LLM Forensics: Where Do Backdoors Hide? Localizing and Controlling Trigger Mechanisms with Sparse Autoencoders

cs.CL ·2026-09-07 ·Wissam Antoun, Francis Kulumba, Théo Lasnier, Benoît Sagot, Djamé Seddah
top venue similarity 0.63
Abstract · Accepted at Findings of EMNLP 2026

Even though backdoors in LLMs have been a growing concern, their inner workings are still under heavy scrutiny. Trigger-based backdoors are easy to define behaviorally, a rare input that makes the model switch to a chosen response pattern, but the mechanism between triggers and their responses is less clear. We study this mechanism in a controlled, harmless language-switching setting, where fixed trigger sequences make 1B and 8B language models continue English prompts in French or German. For this, we train sparse autoencoders (SAEs) across layers and transformer components, then compare triggered prompts with translation and pretraining controls to identify trigger-relevant feature directions. We show how SAE features separate triggered prompts from controls with near-perfect F1, but features that detect the trigger do not necessarily control the behavior. In intervention tests, attention and MLP features often fire reliably on triggered prompts, making them good detectors, but ablating them rarely suppresses the language switch and activating them rarely induces it. In contrast, residual-stream features can suppress triggered generation when ablated, and some selected features can induce target-language continuations without the trigger. In short, these token-trigger mechanisms decompose into distinct SAE feature directions, with separate features for trigger detection, residual-stream propagation, and later language tracking. This role-level decomposition is the part most likely to transfer to other trigger-based backdoors, even when the payload, layers, or circuit locations differ.

0.47

From Error Prediction to Causal Influence: Auditing SAE Features in Multiple-Choice QA

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-10-27 ·Aria Nourbakhsh, Adelaide Danilov, Oleksandr Marchenko Breneur, Salima Lamsiyah
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Sparse autoencoders (SAEs) can predict internal features associated with model errors, but association alone does not establish causal influence. We study this distinction in multiple-choice question answering, where answer preference can be measured by the logit margin between the correct answer and the competing choices. Across eight datasets, we analyze Gemma~3 1B and 4B with Gemma Scope SAEs. We propose a pipeline to filter out the features that have high correlation with format and content artifacts, such as prompt and answer permutation, and evaluate the remaining ones with causal feature interventions. Our results show that SAE activations contain predictive signals about wrongness and uncertainty across models and datasets. After filtering artifact-contaminated features, selected features for causal intervention at question and option spans produce larger absolute margin shifts and a higher wrong-to-correct rate than randomly selected features, indicating greater causal leverage. However, answer flips are rare, and we do not observe stable effect directions across meaning-preserving changes in prompt format and answer order. An adapted HalluSAE baseline produces larger final-token margin changes, but relies on substantially contaminated features and does not significantly improve correction rates. Therefore, the identified features reflect context-dependent answer competition rather than the mechanism of incorrect answer errors.

0.23

Decodable but Misrouted: Sparse Features Uncover a Readout Gap in Vision-Language Models for Harmful Meme Detection

cs.CV cs.AIcs.CLcs.LG ·2026-09-16 ·Girish A. Koushik, Diptesh Kanojia, Helen Treharne
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 42 pages, 9 figures

When large vision-language models misclassify harmful memes, the failure may reflect missing internal evidence or an inability to route represented evidence to their outputs. We distinguish these cases in Gemma-3 and Qwen3.5 using sparse autoencoders, role-conditioned probes, causal interventions, and recovery experiments across six harmful content benchmarks, with additional Spanish and Hindi-English code-mixed evaluations. Sparse readouts outperform native prediction on all six primary binary tasks: Qwen averages $0.740$ versus $0.432$ for native macro-F1, residual reconstruction reaches $0.486$, and Gemma improves from $0.532$ to $0.714$. These gains measure how accessible the label is to a supervised readout; they do not show that the model's native generation already applies such a decision rule. Under the evaluated scales, Qwen silent-feature ablation is $24-63$ times more probe-sensitive, whereas routed-feature patching on literal yes/no tasks is $16-140$ times more output-sensitive. Native-only threshold calibration explains much, but not all of the gap: on five tasks with matched probe scores, it recovers $69.8$\% of the raw native-to-probe difference, while direct routing adds $0.094$ mean macro-F1 beyond calibrated native scoring. Joint gold-label, probe-KL, and pairwise LoRA supervision improves dedicated FHM prediction, but a gold-only adapter performs better on the shared seven-task mean. A case study of Gemma-3-12B on the Facebook Hateful Memes dataset finds a distributed rank-32 image-prompt interaction, reaching $0.756$ versus $0.685$ native macro-F1. Robustness controls show that the signal is not explained solely by accompanying OCR and depends on paired visual evidence, and that it extends beyond English. In many of the errors we study, the evidence is represented but does not reach the answer; therefore, routing is a common bottleneck in harmful meme classification.

0.22

What Do Sparse Autoencoder Feature Discovery Scores Identify? From Activations to Interventions

cs.LG cs.CLstat.ML ·2026-10-11 ·Yifeng Guo, Yanran Li, Xiang Chen
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Sparse autoencoder (SAE) features are typically discovered from how their activations co-vary with behaviour, yet they are often used through interventions such as steering or ablation. We take intervention attribution, the first-order effect of a specified intervention on the model output, as our estimand. For a broad class of response functions, we show that observational feature-discovery evidence generally does not identify this attribution, and derive an exact gradient-based decomposition of the gap between linear-probe predictions and intervention attribution. Across four model-SAE pairs, median probe-to-attribution magnitude ratios range from tens to hundreds, while attributions closely track small-step steering. For single-latent ablations with nonzero effects, gradient predictions match the realized sign in 91-97% of cases, compared with 17-35% for probe-implied changes. Attribution-selected sets also produce larger absolute mean ablation effects on held-out prompts than sets selected by correlation, rank tests or probe coefficients. Together, these results establish intervention attribution as a principled, gradient-estimable target for selecting SAE features for intervention.

0.17