CS Paper Radar

A Probe Shift Is Not a Fairness Fix: The Limits of Representation Steering in Speech Models

Nicolas Bourrel, Abderrahmane Issam, Gerasimos Spanakis

cs.CL ·submitted 2026-09-16 12:01 UTC · v1

Abstract

Automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems exhibit unequal error rates across speaker groups, motivating interventions on their internal representations. We ask whether speaker-linked attributes that are linearly readable from pretrained ASR encoders yield useful directions for reducing group word-error-rate (WER) gaps. Across Whisper-medium, HuBERT-large, and Wav2Vec2-large on Common Voice and the Speech Accent Archive, we probe every encoder layer for metadata-derived sex/gender, age, and native/accent labels; construct centroid and probe-derived directions; inject them at selected layers; and compare downstream probe trajectories with matched WER changes. Sex labels are highly decodable (best macro-F1 0.924--0.941), native/accent labels are also above chance (0.544--0.696), and age is weaker (0.354--0.397). Of 22 post-selected reruns, nine have 95% paired-bootstrap intervals entirely below zero, yet every absolute source-group WER reduction is below 0.7 percentage points. Conversely, a local target-class probe rate can rise from 8.09% to 99.87% while WER worsens. Linear readability is therefore neither evidence of causal use nor a reliable mitigation method. Our results motivate evaluating speech-bias interventions jointly at representation, propagation, and task levels.

Comment
Accepted at IMPACT-SPEECH 2026

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

When Entanglement Lower-Bounds Disparity: Auditing and Repairing Demographic Fairness in Audio Understanding Models

cs.SD cs.CL ·2026-09-23 ·Kian Shamsaie, Iman Modarressi
published similarity 0.74
Abstract · Accepted by IEEE SLT 2026

Speech technology penalizes some voices: recognition errs nearly twice as often for Black speakers, and accuracy declines for second-language accents and older speakers. We introduce TRIAD, an audit grid crossing 120 texts, 24 rendered demographic voice profiles (gender, age band, accent), and ten expressive styles via controllable text-to-speech, isolating perceived demographic attributes from content and affect. For ten open-weights encoders we define axis-fidelity functionals, principal-angle leakage between axis subspaces, and group-conditional gaps; a proposition proves that average probe disparity grows with the same aggregate voice-semantic leakage $Λ$ we measure, and a corollary shows that peak leakage forces worst-case disparity inside an active region. The measured mean-square probe disparity tracks $Λ$ (Pearson r = 0.93), and a black-box protocol exposes the same signature in two closed-source models. ORCA, an adapter combining axis-specific contrastive heads, an orthogonality penalty, and group-balanced sampling, cuts leakage 72% and roughly halves the gaps.

0.33

InterCorrect: Intersection-Aware Correction of Demographic Model Merging for Fair ASR

cs.CL cs.SD ·2026-10-06 ·Ashley E. Bravo-Bravo, Yuchen Zhang, Haralambos Mouratidis, Ravi Shekhar, Monorama Swain
similarity 0.73
Abstract · Under Review

Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems often show uneven performance across demographic groups, and errors can be especially difficult to address for speakers belonging to multiple demographic groups. This work studies demographic-aware model merging for fair Speech-LLM-based ASR. Starting from a SLAM-ASR-based model, we fine-tune only the connector on demographic-specific subsets and merge the resulting subgroup-adapted connectors into a global model. We then identify critical cross-axis demographic pairs using subgroup WER and task-vector conflict, and apply intersection-specific correction vectors to the global merged model. Experiments on Fair-Speech show that global demographic merging improves overall WER over the base model, while intersection correction provides additional gains for several merging strategies. In particular, TIES with WER-based correction achieves the best overall WER, reducing it from 7.38\% to 5.13\%. Subgroup and disparity analyses further show that the proposed approach improves performance across demographic axes, while highlighting that lower average WER does not always imply reduced subgroup disparity.

0.41

AfriBED: a Speech Recognition Bias Evaluation Dataset for Low Resource African Languages

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-10-19 ·Claytone Sikasote, Hussein Suleman, Jan Buys
dataset similarity 0.71
Abstract · Accepted at IEEE SLT 2026 Workshop Demo Track

Despite advancements in automatic speech recognition systems (ASR), current systems exhibit speaker-attribute bias, i.e., their speech recognition performance is biased against certain speakers based on their demographic attributes such as gender, accents, and speaker type. However, accurately assessing speaker attribute bias in a given ASR system requires the availability of a bias evaluation dataset with comparable speech across subgroups of a speaker attribute. In this paper, we introduce African speech Bias Evaluation Dataset (AfriBED), a novel speech recognition bias evaluation dataset for two low resource African languages, Bemba and Nyanja, to detect and estimate gender and speaker-type bias for ASR systems. The dataset comprises 9 hours of speech with 3928 utterances recorded by 80 speakers for Bemba, while the Nyanja set includes 6260 utterances with approximately 18 hours of speech recorded by 127 speakers. The results of our baseline experiments demonstrate that the datasets are useful for examining gender and speaker-type attribute bias in the target languages.

0.15

Training-Free Instruction TTS Gender Bias Calibration Using Model-Adaptive Steering

eess.AS cs.SD ·2026-10-07 ·Kuan-Yu Chen, Yi-Cheng Lin, Jeng-Lin Li, Jian-Jiun Ding
benchmark similarity 0.71
Abstract · 5 pages, 1 figure, 3 tables, submitted to ICASSP 2027

Instruction text-to-speech (ITTS) systems systematically encode acoustic gender skews from descriptive style prompts, such as occupations or personas, even when demographic attributes are left unspecified. Calibrating the implicit gender distribution of the synthesized voices, across heterogeneous architectures and without model retraining or overriding explicit user prompts, is an open problem. In this work, we propose \textit{model-adaptive steering}, a training-free bias calibration method that steers post-encoder conditioning representations using a group deviation vector paired with a coarse-to-fine strength search on a development set. A deterministic lexical gate bypasses intervention whenever explicit gender keywords are detected, preserving intended prompt semantics. Evaluated on a 12,800-prompt held-out benchmark across four ITTS models (three architectures), the proposed method reduces aggregate calibration error from 11.5--28.1 to 0.8--5.9 percentage points (e.g., shifting Parler-TTS Mini from 78.1\% and PromptTTS++ from 27.3\% female to 50.8--52.4\%). Output rates stay within 0.9 pp across anchor set sizes at fixed operating points, while UTMOS decreases by at most 0.08 and WER degrades by at most 3.3 pp.

0.15

Pruning for Efficiency, Paying in Fairness: Demographic Disparities in Pruned Speech-LLMs

cs.SD cs.CL ·2026-09-29 ·Ganesh Pavan Kartikeya Bharadwaj Kolluri, Michael Kampouridis, Ravi Shekhar
similarity 0.70
Abstract · Accepted to IMPACT-SPEECH@EMNLP'26

Speech-LLMs are expensive to run, making compression important for real-world deployment. However, compressed models are usually selected using aggregate word error rate (WER), which can hide how pruning affects different demographic groups. In this work, we systematically study the effect of audio encoder pruning on SLAM-ASR for different demographic groups. Using the Fair-Speech and Common Voice datasets, we found that the pruning does not affect all demographic groups equally; the gap between best- and worst-performing groups increases in fold. These disparities appear across all three encoder scales, but only the largest model initially hides them behind aggregate WER. LoRA adaptation improves WER for every group, but benefits groups already performing well more strongly and widens for certain groups. On Common Voice English, Danish, and Dutch, accent gaps persist but do not clearly widen, showing that the fairness effects of pruning vary across datasets and must be measured directly. Our findings suggest that for pruned models, deployment decisions should include per-group WER, with the worst-performing group's error rate as an explicit criterion.

0.23

Understanding Personalization Gains in Whisper ASR

cs.AI cs.CLcs.LG ·2026-10-12 ·Sergei Katkov, Antonio Liotta
published similarity 0.70
Abstract · 14 pages. Presented at SPECOM 2026

Whisper-style ASR models provide strong zero-shot transcription, but their residual errors are not evenly distributed across datasets, recording conditions, and metadata-based groups. We study when lightweight low-rank adaptation (LoRA) improves Whisper and whether observed gains require group-specific adapters. Across Common Voice, LibriSpeech, and VoxPopuli, we compare zero-shot Whisper, pooled LoRA, and group-specific LoRA under matched within-group splits. We find that adaptation is not uniformly beneficial: gains are concentrated in difficult Common Voice groups, are consistent on VoxPopuli, and largely disappear on low-error LibriSpeech. Crucially, pooled LoRA often matches, and sometimes clearly outperforms, group-specific LoRA. Gains over zero-shot should therefore be tested against matched pooled adaptation before being interpreted as evidence of personalization.

0.23

Layer-wise Linear Probing of an Encoder-free Audio-capable Language Model

eess.AS ·2026-11-16 ·Laishram Rahul, Shruthi B. S., Parismita Gogoi, Sishir Kalita, Deepak KT +1 more
published similarity 0.70
Abstract · Accepted in The 29th International Conference of Oriental COCOSDA

Encoder-free audio-capable multimodal language models pro- vide a unique setting for studying how speech representations emerge inside a language-model decoder. In Gemma-4-12B, short waveform frames are projected directly into the shared embedding space, and all subsequent contextual processing is performed by the decoder layers. We use this architecture to examine where acoustic, phonetic, segmental, and paralinguis- tic information becomes linearly accessible across depth. Us- ing the TIMIT corpus, we extract all 49 representations from the frozen model, including the embedding output and the out- puts of its 48 decoder layers. We train linear probes for log- F0, log-energy, voicing, phone identity, word-onset structure, speaker identity, recorded speaker gender, and dialect-region labels. The results show a broad progression in linear acces- sibility. Acoustic properties are most strongly decodable in the early layers, paralinguistic attributes are most accessible in the early-to-middle layers, and phone identity and boundary- sensitive information reach their highest performance around layer 11. Several properties remain strongly decodable across broad near-peak regions rather than at a single uniquely optimal layer. In deeper layers, phone identity and closed-set speaker identity decline sharply, while voicing, log-F0, and gender re- main more accessible. These findings provide an initial map of how speech information develops when the decoder is the first contextual stage to process audio.

0.16

Towards Interpretable Framework for Neural Audio Codecs via Sparse Autoencoders: Exploration toward Age, Gender, and Accent Steering

cs.SD ·2026-09-28 ·Shih-Heng Wang, Tiantian Feng, Aditya Kommineni, Huang-Cheng Chou, Bowen Yi +2 more
similarity 0.70
Abstract

Neural audio codecs (NACs) are widely used in speech generation and audio-language modeling, yet how they encode speaker-trait information remains poorly understood. Prior work applied sparse autoencoders (SAEs) to investigate accent information in NACs through task-level analysis. Here, we extend this analysis to the waveform level and to age, gender, and accent, using SAE steering to probe trait-related information in sparse activations. We identify trait-associated dimensions, modify their activations, and evaluate the resulting reconstructed speech. Across five NACs, steering the selected dimensions induces target-directed shifts in speaker-trait predictions. A random-dimension baseline on Mimi produces smaller shifts, supporting the relevance of the selected dimensions. However, responses vary across codecs, traits, and steering directions, and increasing steering strength does not consistently amplify the intended shifts. Steering also generally increases word error rates and lowers predicted perceptual quality. These findings suggest that SAEs capture speaker-trait information in steerable activations, while the accompanying quality degradation highlights the need to better separate trait-related information from other information.

0.21