CS Paper Radar

Deterministic Streaming Lower Bounds for Approximate Maximum Clique and Maximum Independent Set

Adithya Diddapur

cs.DS ·submitted 2026-09-16 13:20 UTC · v2
theory

Abstract

We study the canonical \textsf{Maximum Clique} and \textsf{Maximum Independent Set} problems in the one-pass edge-arrival graph streaming setting. Here, the edges of some input graph $G = (V,E)$ are presented one at a time (possibly including deletions), before an algorithm needs to produce either a large clique or independent set at the end of the stream, with the focus being on space complexity. We are interested in finding $β$-approximate solutions, for any $β\geq 1$. Previous work gave an algorithm using $\tilde{O}\left(n^2/β^2\right)$ bits of space, together with a corresponding $\tildeΩ\left(n^2/β^2\right)$ two-party communication lower bound [Halldórsson et al., ICALP'12], seeming to resolve the problem. However, their algorithm crucially relies on randomness, and the best known deterministic algorithm remains a folklore derandomisation using $O\left(n^2/β\right)$ bits of space, leaving a (deterministic) gap of size $\tilde{O}(β)$. We make progress towards this gap with a strong lower bound for a restricted range of $β$: whenever $β\leq \sqrt{n}/36\log n$, any deterministic algorithm for either problem must use $Ω\left(\frac{n^2}{β\cdot\log n}\right)$ bits of space. Our proof is via a two-party one-way communication lower bound, and highlights the power of randomness when approaching either of these problems.

Comment
25 pages, 1 figure

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Deterministic Connectivity Sketches Under Edge Deletions

cs.DS ·2026-11-04 ·Sanjeev Khanna, Aaron Putterman, Madhu Sudan
theory similarity 0.73
Abstract

How much information about a graph is needed to determine its connectivity after arbitrary valid edge deletions? This question is at the heart of designing deterministic dynamic streaming algorithms for graph connectivity. Towards answering this question, we study the deterministic one-way communication problem in which Alice holds a graph $G_A = (V, E_A)$ on $n$ vertices, Bob holds a graph $G_B = (V, E_B)$ with $E_B \subseteq E_A$, and Alice sends a message $M \in \{0,1\}^m$ that allows Bob to decide whether $G_A - G_B$ is connected. Randomized sketches solve this problem using $\tilde O(n)$ bits, whereas deterministic recovery of even one surviving edge requires $Ω(n^2)$ bits. We prove an upper bound of $m = \widetilde{O}(n^{7/4})$ bits and a lower bound of $m = \widetildeΩ(n^{3/2})$ bits for deciding connectivity. Thus, connectivity admits a subquadratic deterministic representation despite the quadratic cost of edge recovery, but remains polynomially harder than its randomized counterpart. The upper bound immediately yields an $\widetilde{O}(n^{7/4})$-bit deterministic $n^2$-fault tolerant connectivity oracle, which reports the connected components of a graph $G$ after any valid set of edge deletions. We also obtain an $\tilde Ω(n f^{1/4})$-bit lower bound for deterministic $f$-fault tolerant connectivity oracles for every $f \in [1,n^2]$. Finally, we show that the separation between connectivity and edge recovery persists in deterministic single-pass dynamic streams with bounded update multiplicity. For every fixed $ε\in (0,1/3)$, our algorithm reports the connected components of the final simple graph using $\widetilde{O}(n^{15/8 + 3ε/8})$ bits (subquadratic space), provided each edge undergoes at most $n^ε$ insertion or deletion updates in total.

0.25

Running-Time Lower Bounds under FPT $\neq$ W[1]

cs.DS cs.CC ·2026-11-19 ·Hendrik Molter
similarity 0.69
Abstract

We revisit running-time lower bounds historically based on the Exponential Time Hypothesis. Our case study asks how much of their quantitative content can be recovered under the assumption FPT $\neq$ W[1]. The reductions encode the choice of a clique in few bits and control the target parameter in terms of that encoding. This makes a sufficiently fast algorithm for the target problem yield a fixed-parameter algorithm for deciding whether a graph has a clique of the requested size. We obtain twelve lower bounds for deterministic algorithms across graph, string, and integer feasibility problems, including bounds that hold under structural restrictions. In several cases the same function of the parameter appears in the exponent as in the historical bound, with the additional requirement that the cutoff for any prescribed saving in the exponent be computable.

0.14

Tight bounds and output sensitive algorithms for maximal clique enumeration in link streams

cs.DS ·2026-10-08 ·George Manoussakis
theory similarity 0.69
Abstract

A link stream is a set of interactions between pairs of vertices, each one lasting during some time interval, and a clique of a link stream is a set of vertices together with a time interval during which all of them interact. A clique is maximal if neither its vertex set nor its interval can be enlarged. All known algorithms listing the maximal cliques of a link stream may spend time exponential in the size of a clique for each clique they output. Here, we approach the question under the light of two parameters of the instantaneous graphs of the stream, their maximum degree $Δ$ and their degeneracy $k$. We prove that a link stream with $m$ links has $O(mΔ^2 3^{Δ/3})$ maximal cliques, and that a link stream with $n$ vertices and $|\mathcal{T}|$ distinct end times has $O(n|\mathcal{T}|k^2 3^{k/3})$ maximal cliques. Both bounds are tight up to a factor polynomial in $Δ$ and $k$ respectively, and the second one improves the factor $2^k$ of previous bounds to $3^{k/3}$. Then we present two algorithms. The first one has setup time $O(m\log m)$ and polynomial time delay $\mathrm{poly}(Δ)\log m$. The second one has setup time $O(m\log m+mk^2\log^3 n)$ and polynomial time delay $\mathrm{poly}(k)\log m$. To the best of our knowledge, these are the first algorithms with polynomial time delay for this problem. We also give an online version of the second algorithm, and we show that our results apply to the $Δ$-cliques and $(Δ,γ)$-cliques of temporal graphs.

0.42

Settling Nondeterministic Communication Complexity of Graph Connectivity

cs.CC ·2026-10-23 ·Zhijun Zhang
publishedtheory similarity 0.68
Abstract

Determining the communication complexity of graph connectivity has been one of the longest standing open problems in communication complexity since the seminal work of Babai, Frankl, and Simon [FOCS'86]. A simple protocol transmits a spanning forest using $O(N\log N)$ communication on $N$-vertex graphs. While this was shown optimal for deterministic protocols by Hajnal, Maass, and Turán [STOC'88], the optimal nondeterministic and randomized complexities have remained unresolved for decades. We settle the nondeterministic communication complexity of graph connectivity by proving an optimal $Ω(N\log N)$ lower bound. The best prior bound was $Ω(N\log\log N)$ due to Raz and Spieker [Combinatorica'95]. Our bound is shown by upper bounding the maximum size of $1$-monochromatic rectangles. Generalizing our techniques to weighted, almost $1$-monochromatic rectangles yields an $Ω(N \cdot \log(\min(1/\varepsilon,N)))$ lower bound for randomized protocols with error probability $\varepsilon$. In particular, this bound is optimal for any polynomially small $\varepsilon$. For constant error probability, we also prove that any $r$-round protocol requires $Ω(N/r \cdot \log N)$ communication, which is optimal for every constant $r$. Previously, optimal $Ω(N\log N)$ lower bounds for graph connectivity were known only for $1$-round [Sun, Woodruff; APPROX/RANDOM'15] and $2$-round protocols [Radhakrishnan, Reddy, Venkat; ITCS'26]. Our proof introduces a new communication problem which can be viewed as a composition of inner product and pointer chasing problems. Our lower bounds can be extended to other fundamental graph properties, and also imply optimality of known query and streaming algorithms for related problems.

0.31

Optimal Passes and Perfect Sampling for Similarity Graph Statistics

cs.DS ·2026-09-17 ·Qin Zhang
hot direction similarity 0.66
Abstract · 32 pages

We study statistical estimation on implicit weighted similarity graphs presented as node-arrival streams. Previous work~\cite{LZ26b} obtained constant-pass, sublinear-space algorithms for several basic statistics of such graphs, including the diversity index $\mathsf{DI}=\sum_i d_i^{-1}$ and the degree moments $M_p=\sum_i d_i^p$ for $p>0$, together with their associated sampling problems $L_{\mathsf{DI}}$ and $L_{M_p}$. We settle three questions left unresolved by the previous work. First, we show that any two-pass streaming algorithm that $1.1$-approximates $\mathsf{DI}$ requires $Ω(n)$ bits of space; combined with the three-pass $\tilde{O}(\sqrt n)$-space algorithm of~\cite{LZ26b}, this establishes a sharp transition between two and three passes for $\mathsf{DI}$. Second and third, for every fixed $c>0$ we give a three-pass $n^{-c}$-perfect $L_{\mathsf{DI}}$-sampler using $O_c(\sqrt n\log n)$ words and a two-pass $n^{-c}$-perfect $L_{M_p}$-sampler using $O_{p,c}(n^{1-1/(p+1)}\log n)$ words. Matching lower bounds up to polylogarithmic factors show that both the number of passes and the polynomial dependence on $n$ are optimal.

0.43

Local Search for Almost-Spanning Square Grids in Erdős--Rényi Random Graphs

cs.DM math.PRmath.CO ·2026-09-11 ·Dávid Ferenczi, Alexander Grigoriev
theory similarity 0.65
Abstract · 18 pages, 1 figure

Finding large lattice subgraphs in sparse Erdős--Rényi random graphs is a classical problem at the interface of random graph theory and algorithms. General bounded-degree embedding and universality theorems give powerful results for broad graph families, but when specialized to square grids they operate at densities substantially larger than the grid-emergence scale. In this paper we exploit the specific geometry of the square grid. We introduce the Quarantined Local Search, a three-phase local algorithm that separates the construction of an initial boundary from the later corner-closure process and controls adaptive negative exposure through bounded pair-test histories. We prove that, for every fixed $δ\in (0,1)$, there exists $C_δ>0$ such that the algorithm embeds a $k\times k$ square grid with $k^2\le (1-δ)n$ in $G(n,p)$ with high probability whenever $p\ge C_δ\sqrt{\ln k/n}$. Thus, for $k^2=Θ(n)$, a density of order $\sqrt{\log n/n}$ is sufficient, a factor of order $\sqrt{\log n}$ above the corresponding $n^{-1/2}$ emergence scale.

0.15

Approximating Independent Sets Using Additive Combinatorics

cs.DS cs.CCmath.CO ·2026-10-18 ·Shachar Lovett
published similarity 0.65
Abstract

We give a deterministic quasi-polynomial time algorithm for approximating the largest independent set in a graph. We show that if an $N$-vertex graph contains an independent set of size $2^{-t} N$, then we can find an independent set of size $2^t$ in quasi-polynomial time, for all $t$ up to a constant factor of $(\log N)^{1/3}$. This gives an approximation factor of $N / \exp((\log N)^{1/3})$, which has the same shape as known hardness results for quasi-polynomial time algorithms, up to a different exponent of the logarithm. The algorithm builds on a structural principle: a graph containing a large independent set must also contain a large sparse structured set, and such a set can be found efficiently. A greedy algorithm then extracts an independent set from it. Our proof draws on tools in additive combinatorics, in particular spreadness and sifting, to obtain the combinatorial structural results. We then convert these to efficient algorithms using pseudo-marginals obtained by semidefinite programming.

0.60

Smoothed Analysis for Distributed MIS

cs.DC ·2026-11-12 ·Dipan Dey, Fabien Dufoulon, William K. Moses, Gopal Pandurangan
theory similarity 0.65
Abstract

We study smoothed analysis of the distributed Maximal Independent Set (MIS) problem. Luby's algorithm computes an MIS in $O(\log n)$ rounds, while the recent $Ω(\log n/\log\log n)$ lower bound of Khoury and Schild (2026) shows that it is nearly optimal even in the LOCAL model. We ask whether small random perturbations can overcome this worst-case barrier. Given an arbitrary base graph $G$ on $n$ nodes, we consider the smoothed graph $\mathcal{G}_s=G\triangle G(n,p)$, where $G(n,p)$ is an independent random graph and $\triangle$ denotes symmetric difference. Thus, each possible edge is independently toggled with probability $p$. We establish nearly tight bounds on the smoothing needed for faster distributed MIS. For every base graph $G$, when $p=β\ln n/n$ for a sufficiently large constant $β$, a randomized LOCAL algorithm, given only $\mathcal{G}_s$, computes an MIS of $\mathcal{G}_s$ in $O(\sqrt{\log n})$ rounds with high probability. This is almost quadratically faster than the worst-case lower bound. Conversely, if $p\le(1/2-δ)\ln n/n$ for a fixed constant $δ>0$, there exists a base graph on which every randomized LOCAL MIS algorithm requires $Ω(\log n/\log\log n)$ rounds on the smoothed graph. Hence, the smoothing parameter required for this speedup is optimal up to a constant factor. These results show that smoothed analysis can overcome worst-case lower-bound barriers for distributed local graph problems.

0.10