CS Paper Radar

ReFigBench: Benchmarking Scientific Figure Reconstruction as Editable PowerPoint Artifacts

Liyang Fan, Chi Wei, Yitai Li, Xinping Bi, Guhong Chen, Chenghao Sun, Haoxiang Yang, Qingwen Li, Kai Yan, Hong Li, Bo Li

cs.CL cs.CV ·submitted 2026-09-16 15:51 UTC · v1
benchmark

Abstract

Multimodal coding agents are expected to turn visual inputs into usable artifacts, and they act through a harness, the layer of tools, context management, and execution environment around the model. Existing evaluations often isolate short tool calls, API traces, or screenshot resemblance, and a low score under these proxies cannot say whether the model saw poorly, planned poorly, or was failed by its harness. We study scientific overview figure reconstruction, an agent task in which a source image must become an editable PowerPoint slide that preserves text, topology, layout, and native document structure. We introduce ReFigBench, a benchmark and evaluation framework built on 1,000 real overview figures retrieved from arXiv papers with full provenance. Coding agents from four model families reconstruct every figure under two workflows, direct code generation and a specialized PPTX workflow, and the strongest model runs inside two commercial harnesses, yielding ten configurations. Evaluation combines deterministic artifact checks, repeated automated scoring by judges from two model families, and blinded human comparisons. Perception remains a bottleneck that iterative rendering only partly repays. Whether workflow effort converts into quality depends on the model together with its harness, since the same model gains from the specialized workflow inside one harness and loses inside the other, and the harness shifts scores even under an identical direct prompt. The specialized workflow erases native connectors in every configuration, human judges still prefer its renderings in most matchups, and even the strongest agent falls short of the rubric ceiling. These results expose the tension between fidelity and editability as the central challenge for practical multimodal document agents.

Comment
31 pages, 7 figures, including appendices

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

SciFigure2Code: An AI-Reconstructed Benchmark for Scientific Figure-to-Code

cs.CV ·2026-09-08 ·Wentao Li, Yibo Wu, Yizhe Chen, Ruixuan Chen, Jiangjie Qiu +3 more
benchmark similarity 0.81
Abstract · 20 pages

Scientific figures are the interface through which research claims are inspected and reused, but final published panels rarely expose the data or plotting code that produced them. Recovering this hidden provenance from pixels is therefore underdetermined. We introduce SciFigure2Code, an AI-reconstructed benchmark that evaluates presentation recovery: generating editable Python programs that preserve how a scientific panel is arranged and read. Role-specialized Codex agents generate, execute, visually refine, and audit silver-standard presentation programs that capture geometry, visual hierarchy, encodings, annotations, and typography. This reconstruction-and-audit protocol turns final published panels into auditable reference packages; the resulting resource contains 6,740 reviewed panels and SciFigureBench, a balanced 337-panel test set across 31 chart subtypes, five domains, and three complexity levels. Across 14 zero-shot models, execution and structural fidelity remain weak; a 328-panel full-figure study further exposes failures to locate and isolate requested panels. Claude Opus 4.7 leads image-only reconstruction, Claude Opus 4.6 leads caption-assisted reconstruction, and plan-then-code prompting improves all four tested models. SciFigure2Code provides an auditable testbed for constructing editable, visually faithful scientific figure presentations.

0.11

PPTBench: Can Coding Agents Reconstruct the Visual World through Structured, Editable Slides

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-08-31 ·Xiaoqiu Wang, Yizhe Chi, Wenyi Li, Deyao Hong, Zhihan Shan +5 more
benchmark similarity 0.77
Abstract

Coding agents are increasingly moving beyond text-based software tasks to reconstruct visual targets through code. This capability, visual coding, requires agents to translate their understanding of visual targets into executable code. Slides provide a natural testbed for this capability, combining rich visual structure with objects that can be programmatically created and edited. To measure this capability, we introduce PPTBench, a benchmark for reconstructing scientific flow diagrams as editable PowerPoint slides. PPTBench covers 500 scientific flow-diagram tasks across 10 presentation domains, drawn from real research papers, and is evaluated with a four-stage agentic judge covering artifact validity, process and connector fidelity, rendering quality, and visual fidelity. Evaluation of ten models across 36 model--harness--effort configurations shows a substantial gap in reliable visual coding: the best configuration achieves 77.34, while the median across configurations is 24.38. Fine-grained analysis shows that agents can generally produce valid slide files, but struggle to produce high-quality reconstructions that faithfully recover the semantics and visual structure of the target. Further analysis shows that increasing reasoning effort primarily improves hard-gate passage rather than mean detail quality on each configuration's passing tasks, while configurations with more inspection tend to achieve higher overall scores. PPTBench establishes a measurable testbed for studying visual coding and advancing agents toward more reliable visual creation.

0.41

EdiTikZ: Scientific Figure Editing from Revision Trajectories

cs.AI cs.CLcs.CV ·2026-09-01 ·Christian Greisinger, Zhixue Zhao, Steffen Eger
benchmarkdatasetcode/data similarity 0.76
Abstract · 35 pages, 21 figures, and 19 tables. Models and datasets: https://huggingface.co/collections/nllg/editikz . Code: https://github.com/NL2G/Ed…

Vision-language models (VLMs) have shown strong performance in generating scientific figures from text or images. However, publication-ready figures often require iterative refinement, making scientific figure editing an important yet largely unexplored step toward interactive figure creation. Existing approaches rely on costly proprietary agentic systems, focus primarily on evaluation, or construct training supervision from synthetically generated edits. Instead, we leverage naturally occurring scientific revision and development trajectories as a scalable source of supervision. To this end, we introduce DaEdiTikZ, the first large-scale dataset of revision-derived scientific figure edits, constructed by mining 391K plausible TikZ edit pairs from arXiv, GitHub, and TeX SE and inferring 781K directed edit instructions with a VLM conditioned on rendered figures and TikZ code. We further introduce DaEdiTikZ-Bench, a human-refined benchmark with 690 instances, and train two compact Qwen3.5-based EdiTikZ models (4B and 9B) by jointly learning image-to-TikZ reconstruction and instruction-conditioned editing, followed by reinforcement learning (RL) with complementary rewards for rendered fidelity and edit application. Automatic evaluation places our 9B model above all tested baselines, while human evaluation with 9 annotators and 4,320 ratings places it above GPT-5.6-Sol and on par with Gemini-3.1-Pro. Under severe out-of-distribution shifts, it remains competitive with GPT-5.6-Sol near its 2K training sequence-length regime.

0.51

Edit2TikZ: A Comprehensive and Challenging Benchmark for Scientific Figure Editing with TikZ

cs.CV ·2026-08-13 ·Zongyun Zhang, Jiacheng Ruan, Xian Gao, Ruizhu Zhou, Lingcheng Meng +3 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.76
Abstract · 9 pages, 6 figures, work in progress

Although multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have shown substantial potential in visual understanding and graphic code generation, editing scientific figures through code presents a greater challenge: a model must jointly recover visual structure, ground the requested change, generate compilable code, and preserve all unrelated content. While existing TikZ benchmarks mainly focus on figure reconstruction and generation, few systematically evaluate instruction-guided scientific figure editing with compilable code. We introduce Edit2TikZ, a comprehensive benchmark for scientific figure editing tasks, featuring 1,548 diverse and high-quality samples. Edit2TikZ combines real-world and controlled synthetic edit cases, supports both textual and visual localization request, and contains multi-step editing, each with step-level annotations. We further construct a human-aligned evaluation framework to measure whether a requested edit is completed while irrelevant content is preserved. Utilizing Edit2TikZ, we evaluate 14 mainstream MLLMs and find that current systems remain unreliable: on average, proprietary models achieve a compilation success rate of merely 75% and remain limited in both figure restoration and edit correctness, while compact models below 9B struggle further with instruction following and complete figure generation. Therefore, we build a mixed training set TikZEditMix and adopt reconstruction-then-editing curriculum learning for compact models. On Qwen3.5-4B, this training improves the compilation success rate from 45.35% to 83.40% and yields an average improvement of 18.7 points across our proposed evaluation metrics. The code and data will be released at https://github.com/Solunny/Edit2TikZ.

0.60

Slide2PPT: Native PowerPoint Reconstruction with Localization-Guided Refinement

cs.CV ·2026-11-19 ·Baoliang Chen, Xinlong Bu, Lingyu Zhu, Xiangjie Sui
similarity 0.72
Abstract

Image-to-slide reconstruction must recover both visual appearance and native object structure for subsequent editing. Yet visually faithful charts and tables may lack editable series and cells, and direct code generation couples content prediction to rendering implementation. We present Slide2PPT, a model-agnostic, training-free framework that equips both open- and closed-source vision-language models with native PowerPoint reconstruction capabilities. Through a unified typed interface, the model predicts object records while a fixed renderer materializes their native properties, enabling integration with different backbones without task-specific training or architectural changes. Localization-guided refinement then connects visual discrepancies to object records for correction. Regional updates preserve unselected records, while whole-slide updates address cross-region relationships. Record refinement and targeted object editing support structural and attribute-level changes, with rendered feedback governing iterative acceptance. To evaluate this framework across diverse reconstruction demands, we introduce Slide2PPT-Bench, covering controlled elements, real slides, and scientific figures. Evaluation separately measures file production, rendered agreement, and native-object availability. Experiments across open- and closed-source backbones demonstrate substantially more reliable PPTX generation than direct code generation, improved layout and text recovery on scientific figures, and native chart and table interfaces beyond geometric primitives.

0.23

Figures as Programs: Recursive Generation of Editable Scientific Figures

cs.AI cs.GR ·2026-09-01 ·Yepeng Liu, Dasen Dai, Chengzhi Liu, Yiren Song, Hai Ci +5 more
similarity 0.72
Abstract

Scientific methodology figures are essential for communicating complex methods clearly, yet creating them remains labor-intensive and typically requires multiple rounds of refinement. Recent image-generation models can synthesize visually appealing raster figures, but producing a human-satisfactory result in a single generation step remains difficult. Moreover, precise edits to raster figures are challenging for both humans and models. We formulate scientific figure generation as recursive SVG program construction and propose \textsc{FigTree}, a \textit{multi-agent} system that automatically transforms a scientific paper into a structured vector figure. \textsc{FigTree} grounds figure content in the source paper, decomposes a figure into a hierarchy of local regions, generates each region as a short SVG program, and assembles the resulting fragments. A render-critic refinement loop jointly inspects the rendered figure and its underlying program, enabling visual defects to be traced to specific statements and accurately repaired. We conduct extensive evaluations of \textsc{FigTree} on figure quality and editability, showing that \textsc{FigTree} produces high-quality figures, while also enabling more effective editing than existing raster-based methods.

0.39

VectorHarness: Recovering Editable, Relation-Preserving Structure from Scientific Graphics

cs.CV ·2026-09-09 ·Jiahao Tang, Yiren Song, Alex Jinpeng Wang
similarity 0.69
Abstract

Converting scientific graphics into editable representations remains a challenging problem for image-to-code generation because of their heterogeneous elements and complex layouts. Recent multi-agent reconstruction systems have advanced this line of work, but often follow a copy-paste paradigm: the reconstructed image closely resembles the original, while complex regions remain effectively uneditable. We instead formulate a different objective, raster-to-authoring reconstruction, which aims to recover an authoring representation that supports native, customized editing rather than mere visual replication. To this end, we present VectorHarness, a multi-agent framework for raster-to-authoring reconstruction that recovers heterogeneous components using type-appropriate native representations. Text, formulas, shapes, connectors, icons, charts, and tables are reconstructed as natively editable objects, while intrinsically image-based regions remain raster content. To systematically evaluate reconstruction quality, we introduce VectorHarness-Bench, which jointly assesses rendering fidelity, raster fallback coverage, executable object edits, and relation-preserving edits. Experiments show that VectorHarness improves executable edit success and relation preservation, reduces avoidable raster fallback, and maintains high visual fidelity across heterogeneous graphics.

0.07

MatToolBench: Benchmarking Multimodal Agents in Real-World Materials Science Workflows

cs.AI ·2026-09-29 ·Mei Wu, Rui Xie, Runyu Zhang, Yuqiang Li, Tianfan Fu +4 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.69
Abstract · 25 pages, 15 figures. Mei Wu and Rui Xie contributed equally. Bo Chen and Lu Chen are corresponding authors. Project page: https://mattoolbe…

Multimodal GUI agents have achieved impressive results on general software benchmarks, yet their ability to operate professional scientific software remains largely unexplored. In materials science, sparse domain-specific web data, specialized interfaces, and tacit workflow conventions create blind spots that general-purpose pretraining cannot readily bridge. We present MatToolBench, the first real-environment benchmark for evaluating multimodal GUI agents on professional materials science software, comprising 204 tasks across 10 tools in three modalities: GUI operation, OriginPro scripting, and code-based database queries, all executed inside a Windows 11 VM. Each task is decomposed into fine-grained sub-criteria by domain experts, enabling interpretable partial-credit scoring; the GUI component of our multi-level evaluation pipeline achieves an average F1 of 0.98. For OriginPro figure-generation tasks, we further conduct a human-LLM agreement study to validate the use of a multimodal judge for secondary aesthetic assessment. Our experiments show that strong performance on general benchmarks does not transfer to professional scientific workflows, and that this gap is not a visual-grounding problem alone: failures arise from domain-specific operational knowledge, sparse pretraining coverage of scientific software, weak cross-tool artifact handoff, and critical states exposed only visually. Even the best model reaches only 25% success rate on GUI tasks and 45% on code tasks. MatToolBench therefore serves as a challenging diagnostic benchmark and real-environment testbed for data-scarce, knowledge-intensive scientific workflows.

0.57