CS Paper Radar

A Walk From Free Probability to Matrix Discrepancy I: Matrix Spencer

Tarun Kathuria

cs.DS ·submitted 2026-09-16 16:55 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

The Matrix Spencer conjecture asks whether any $n$ real symmetric matrices A_1,...,A_n \in \mathbb{R}^{m \times m} of operator norm at most one admit a signing $x\in\{-1,1\}^n$ such that the operator norm of the signed sum is at most O(\sqrt{n \log(2m/n)}) We give a randomized algorithm establishing this bound with polynomial runtime in the real-arithmetic model. We first prove the $O(\sqrt n)$ bound for $m\le n$, resolving the square case, and then obtain the rectangular bound by changing the regularizer. As in earlier algorithmic discrepancy methods \cite{lovettmeka2012,bansalLaddhaVempala2022,pesentivladu2026}, we run a covariance-controlled random walk from the origin of the hypercube, rounding coordinates near its faces and keeping them fixed. Our potential measures a soft spectral edge of the evolving discrepancy matrix perturbed by an operator-valued free semicircular element. Inspired by the free interpolation approach of \cite{bbvh2023}, we combine Lehner's variational formula for the free edge \cite{lehner1999} with spectral Tsallis regularization \cite{allenZhuLiaoOrecchia2015,pesentivladu2026}. This puts the discrepancy and remaining covariance in a single smooth optimization problem. The potential has a finite-dimensional semidefinite formulation. Stability of its optimizer, governed by equations related to the matrix Dyson equation \cite{erdos2019}, lets us find a large subspace in which to move while controlling discrepancy. The square case uses the Tsallis--$1/2$ regularizer; the rectangular case uses a suitable generalized Tsallis power regularizer. Our companion paper \cite{kathuria2026ks} applies these ideas to give an algorithmic proof of Weaver's discrepancy theorem, whose existence proof by [MSS15] resolved the Kadison--Singer conjecture \cite{mss2015}.Lean formalizations of our main discrepancy theorems have been completed and will be released shortly.

Comment
The authors explicitly reserve all rights in this work. No permission is granted for the reproduction, storage, or use of this document for the purpose of training artificial intelligence systems or for text and data mining (TDM), including but not limited to the generation of embeddings, summaries, or synthetic derivatives

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Matrix Spencer: Eight Standard Deviations Suffice and an Almost-Linear Time Algorithm for Dense Input

cs.DS math.FAmath.OCmath.PR ·2026-09-14 ·Zhao Song, Lichen Zhang
theory similarity 0.77
Abstract

The Matrix Spencer conjecture asserts that for all symmetric matrices $A_1,\ldots,A_n\in\mathbb{R}^{n\times n}$ with $\|A_i\|\le1$ there are signs $\varepsilon_1,\ldots,\varepsilon_n\in\{-1,1\}$ with $\|\sum_{i=1}^n\varepsilon_iA_i\|=O(\sqrt n)$. We prove it: a signing of discrepancy below $8\sqrt n$ always exists. We also give a randomized algorithm that finds a signing of discrepancy below $12\sqrt n$ with failure probability at most $p$. The algorithm uses $n^{3+o(1)}\operatorname{polylog}(1/p)$ arithmetic operations in the real-arithmetic model. This matches the size $n^3$ of the dense input up to subpolynomial factors. In the other direction, we prove that for every $n$ there are collections of symmetric matrices such that every signing has discrepancy at least $(2-o(1))\sqrt{n}$. We present three different proofs of the matrix Spencer conjecture. The key to every proof is a hereditary small-ball estimate. This is a lower bound on the Gaussian measure of the spectral body $\{x\in \mathbb{R}^n:\|\sum_ix_iA_i\|\le R\}$ that holds for every subfamily of the matrices. The other ingredient turns that Gaussian measure into a partial signing. We give three approaches to obtain such a signing. The first one covers the cube by partially signed faces through Gaussian concentration with a constant $7\cdot10^9$. The second proof replaces the covering by a projection lemma with explicit parameters for a constant $156000$. The third proof turns Gaussian measure into signs by a lossless coding, with no union bound. It proves the estimate at the right radius with smooth spectral barriers and certified coefficients. It gives a constant below $7.88$. For algorithms, the main idea is to project Gaussian points onto a smoothed spectral body. The $n^{3+o(1)}$ time algorithm tracks the Gibbs matrix of that body across coordinate-descent steps with sketched increments and random refreshes.

0.47

A Walk From Free Probability to Matrix Discrepancy II: Weaver's Problem and the Kadison-Singer Conjecture

cs.DS math.FA ·2026-09-16 ·Tarun Kathuria
similarity 0.73
Abstract · The author explicitly reserve all rights in this work. No permission is granted for the reproduction, storage, or use of this document for t…

\cite{mss2015} proved Weaver's discrepancy result existentially, resolving the Kadison--Singer conjecture . Finding such signs efficiently for general inputs remained an open algorithmic question. In the real-arithmetic model, we give a deterministic algorithm running in polynomial time with discrepancy at most $35\sqrt\varepsilon$. The algorithm walks from the origin of the hypercube to a vertex, fixing coordinates as they hit a face. Its potential measures a soft spectral edge of the discrepancy matrix perturbed by an operator-valued free semicircular element. The perturbation's covariance vanishes as the coefficients reach their endpoints. Inspired by the free interpolation approach of Bandeira, Boedihardjo, and van Handel \cite{bbvh2023}, we combine Lehner's variational formula \cite{lehner1999} with spectral Tsallis--$1/2$ regularization used in \cite{allenZhuLiaoOrecchia2015} and \cite{pesentivladu2026}. The resulting potential has a finite-dimensional SDP formulation, allowing the discrepancy and remaining covariance to be analyzed together. We analyze the optimizer's stability through the linearized Karush--Kuhn--Tucker (KKT) system of a regularized min--max problem, whose stationarity equations are related to the matrix Dyson equation \cite{erdos2019}. This gives the movement rule: either a coordinate can move toward its nearer endpoint at small spectral cost, or a low-curvature direction orthogonal to the current coefficient vector allows further progress. Choosing the better sign of this direction controls discrepancy while increasing the squared distance from the origin. Upcoming work \cite{kathuria2026higherRank} will address higher-rank Kadison-Singer and spectrally thin trees. Lean formalizations of our main discrepancy theorems have been completed and will be released shortly.

0.56

Free-Probabilistic State Evolution and Random Matrix Discrepancy

cs.DS math.PR ·2026-09-10 ·August Y. Chen, Ahmed El Alaoui
similarity 0.71
Abstract · Revised version contains stronger results on random matrix discrepancy, further minor edits, and an updated bibliography

Let $A_1,\ldots,A_n$ be independent $d \times d$ real symmetric Gaussian random matrices, and consider the linear operator $A(x) = n^{-1/2}\sum_{i=1}^n x_iA_i$, $x\in \mathbb R^n$. We construct an iterative algorithm in the Approximate Message Passing family which iterates over $A$ and its adjoint $A^*$, and establish a state evolution result which characterizes its behavior in the limit $d\to \infty, 2n/d^2 \to α$ in terms of a correlated Gaussian-semicircular process in a free probability space, in the sense of strong convergence of operators. We then apply this iteration to the random matrix discrepancy problem which asks for a binary vector $x \in \{-1,+1\}^n$ such that $A(x)$ has a small operator norm. Our algorithm achieves an operator norm $2σ(α)$, for a standard deviation $σ(α)<1$ for all $α>0$, and $σ(α) = O(1/\sqrt{α\log α})$ for large $α$. This resolves the algorithmic question of Kunisky-Zhang (2023) and Maillard (2025).

0.48

A Walk From Free Probability to Matrix Discrepancy III: Higher Rank Kadison-Singer and Spectrally Thin Trees

cs.DS ·2026-09-18 ·Tarun Kathuria
theory similarity 0.70
Abstract · The author explicitly reserve all rights in this work. No permission is granted for the reproduction, storage, or use of this document for t…

Let $A_1,\ldots,A_N$ be positive semidefinite matrices of rank at most $r$, with $\sum_i A_i=I$ and $\norm{A_i}\le\varepsilon$. We prove that one sign can be assigned to each original matrix with discrepancy $O(\sqrt{\varepsilon\log(2r)})$, independently of their dimension and number, which is known to be optimal upto constants. We give a separate existence proof and a deterministic algorithm with polynomial work in a real-arithmetic model with semidefinite-value and exact spectral primitives. Separate Lean formalizations verify the existence proof and the algorithm in this arithmetic model. The proof extends the variational approach to discrepancy developed in the companion papers, motivated by operator-valued free interpolation, Lehner's formula, and spectral Tsallis regularization. A concave matrix power interpolates between a trace source and a sandwich source. Its concavity controls the response of the optimizing density. The walk maintains independent source reserves and a second matrix recording reserve expenditure. This matrix certifies contraction of the unfinished input mass between epochs; within an epoch, preparation and a negative-curvature step control the spectral potential while the coefficients advance toward signs. As applications, one spanning tree can be chosen simultaneously $O(\varepsilon\log(2s))$-spectrally thin for $s$ positive weightings of a common graph whose edge leverages are at most $\varepsilon$. The diagonal specialization gives discrepancy $O(\sqrt{L\log(2k)})$ for matrices with row sums at most $L$ and at most $k$ nonzero entries per column, through a walk of fractional colorings.

0.38

Stable and Online Algorithms for Random Matrix Discrepancy

cs.DS cs.CCcs.DMmath.CO+1 ·2026-10-01 ·Eren C. Kızıldağ, Shuangping Li
theoryhighly cited similarity 0.69
Abstract

We study the average-case matrix discrepancy problem: given independent normalized $d\times d$ Gaussian orthogonal ensemble matrices $A_1,\dots,A_N$ and a fixed margin $κ>0$, find signs $σ_1,\dots,σ_N\in\{-1,1\}$ such that the operator norm of $\sum_{i=1}^N σ_i A_i$ is at most $κ\sqrt{N}$. Focusing on the proportional regime $N/d^2\to τ\in(0,\infty)$ as $d\to\infty$ followed by the small-margin limit $κ\downarrow 0$, we characterize the density required by stable offline algorithms and by online algorithms. In the offline setting, we construct a polynomial-time \emph{recenter-and-round} algorithm that is noise-stable and succeeds whenever $τ=Ω(\frac{1}{κ^2\log(1/κ)})$, along with a matching lower bound for all stable algorithms. In the online setting where each sign must be chosen irrevocably upon observing the corresponding matrix, we determine the exact limiting performance of the \emph{Frobenius-greedy} algorithm, establishing that it succeeds when $τ>τ_{\rm FG}(κ)\sim \fracπ{4κ^2}$, as well as a matching lower bound for all online algorithms by conditioning on a revealed prefix. At the core of our algorithms lies rotational symmetry, which enables us to transfer Frobenius norm control into operator norm guarantees. Together, our results identify the algorithmic phase transition points for random matrix discrepancy: $Θ(\frac{1}{κ^2\log(1/κ)})$ for stable offline algorithms and $Θ(\frac{1}{κ^2})$ for online algorithms. Both thresholds lie far above the satisfiability scale $Θ(\log(1/κ))$, as shown by Maillard~\cite{maillard2025}.

0.30

Fast Spectral Signing for Vector Balancing

cs.DS ·2026-09-24 ·Xiaoyu Li
theory similarity 0.68
Abstract

The Komlós conjecture, now a theorem, asserts that whenever the columns of a matrix $A\in\mathbb{R}^{m\times n}$ have Euclidean norm at most one, some signs $\varepsilon\in\{-1,1\}^n$ make every coordinate of $A\varepsilon$ bounded by an absolute constant. Guo, Fang, and Lu gave the first polynomial-time algorithm for finding such signs, a deterministic spectral signing procedure with discrepancy $8272$ and running time $O((mn^9+n^{10})\log(m+n))$. We give a deterministic algorithm that finds signs with $\|A\varepsilon\|_\infty<99$ using $O(mn+n^{ω+2}\log^3 n)$ arithmetic operations, where $ω>2$ is any fixed attainable matrix-multiplication exponent; with the current bounds on $ω$ this is $\widetilde O(mn+n^{4.372})$. Our algorithm uses the same framework: it rounds a single fractional coloring and watches all rows through the top eigenvalue of a Gram matrix of energy-corrected barriers. Steps follow flat directions, rescaled so that no barrier near its threshold moves faster than a constant, and the regularizer grows as coordinates freeze; together these bound the number of updates by $O(n^2\log n)$. A weak quadratic charge on the tracked row sums leaves $O(n\log^2 n)$ rows to evaluate at any time, and a motion clock bounds when any other row could approach its barrier. Each update is a short sequence of matrix products. Its direction is read off by conditional expectations from a polynomial soft projector, its small constraint residual is repaired in affine row representations, and one identity accounts for every change of representation. For rational input the algorithm has polynomial bit complexity.

0.32

On Complexity of Gaussian Sampling

cs.CC stat.CO ·2026-10-14 ·Huanjian Zhou, Taiji Suzuki
theory similarity 0.66
Abstract · 36 pages

We study the number of exact matrix-vector queries needed to sample a centered $d$-dimensional Gaussian with condition number at most $κ$ to total variation error $\varepsilon$. The best known algorithm uses $O(\min\{d,\sqrtκ\log(\frac{d}{\varepsilon})\})$ queries, while the known lower bounds do not grow as $\varepsilon\to0$ and match this bound only for $κ\le d^{1/5-δ}$ at constant accuracy. We introduce a construction based on a hidden determinant sign and prove a lower bound of $Ω\!\left(\min\left\{d,\sqrtκ\log\left(1+\frac{d}{\sqrtκ\,\varepsilon}\right)\right\}\right)$ uniformly for all $d\ge1$, $κ\ge4$, and $0<\varepsilon\le\tfrac{1}{16}$. This bound matches the known upper bound up to constant factors whenever $κ\le d^{2-δ}$ for fixed $δ\in(0,2)$, or $\varepsilon\le d^{-c}$ for fixed $c>0$. We also extend a recent fixed-spectrum construction with a hidden eigenbasis from $κ=2$ to $2\leκ\le d^{1-δ}$, for any fixed $δ\in(0,1)$. This gives an $Ω_δ(\sqrtκ\log d)$ lower bound at constant accuracy that holds even when the spectrum of the precision matrix is known to the algorithm.

0.13

An Exposition of the $\widetilde{O}(\log^{1/4} n)$ Bound for the Komlós Problem

cs.DM math.COcs.DSmath.PR ·2026-08-28 ·Nikhil Bansal, Haotian Jiang
publishedtheory similarity 0.66
Abstract · An extended abstract of this work appeared in STOC 2026: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2508.03961. The present article treats only the Komlós proble…

A conjecture of Komlós states that the combinatorial discrepancy of any matrix $A\in\mathbb R^{m\times n}$ whose columns have Euclidean norm at most one is bounded by a universal constant. We prove that the combinatorial discrepancy of every such matrix is at most $O((\log n)^{1/4}(\log\log n)^{7/4})$. This is the first asymptotic improvement over the $O(\sqrt{\log n})$ bound established by Banaszczyk [Banaszczyk, Random Struct.\ Algorithms, 1998], and it refutes a conjecture of Hajela [Hajela, European J.\ Combin., 1988] that a lower bound of order $Ω(\sqrt{\log n})$ should hold.

0.38