CS Paper Radar

Characterizing Network Centralization and Observability in the Remote MCP Ecosystem

Muhammad Abdullah Sohail

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-09-16 17:31 UTC · v1

Abstract

The Model Context Protocol (MCP) has emerged as the dominant interface for connecting autonomous agents to external data sources and execution environments. The ecosystem's transition from local process execution to remote Streamable HTTP deployments introduces unmeasured architectural and security constraints at scale. This paper presents a three-tier observability framework comprising catalog metadata (O_0), passive compliance signals (O_1), and live vulnerability analysis (O_2), applied to empirically characterize the public MCP server ecosystem. Evaluation of a stratified sample of 179 remote endpoints across two primary public registries reveals significant infrastructural consolidation. The Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI) computed over the Autonomous System Number (ASN) distribution yields a value of 0.736, well above the 0.25 threshold for a highly concentrated market. Analysis further indicates that server authentication is strongly correlated with hosting platform choice rather than individual operator configuration, with 95\% of commercial PaaS-hosted servers enforcing gateway-level OAuth 2.1 with PKCE. The empirical results identify a Security-Observability Tradeoff observed in the current ecosystem: the platform-level authentication mechanisms that secure the majority of servers simultaneously limit automated vulnerability scanning capabilities, constraining the ability of AI gateway operators to assess tool-poisoning vectors without prior credential provisioning.

Comment
6 pages, 3 figures. Accepted at the 1st IEEE ICNP Workshop on Network Infrastructure and Protocols for AI Agents (NIPA 2026)

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Same Name, Different Server: A Security Census of Silent Drift in the Model Context Protocol Ecosystem

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-09-12 ·Obada Kraishan
hot direction similarity 0.60
Abstract · 14 pages, 7 figures, 6 tables

The Model Context Protocol (MCP) has become the common interface through which large language model applications reach external tools, and its public registry now distributes thousands of community-built servers with little of the vetting infrastructure that mature package ecosystems have accumulated. This paper reports a census of that ecosystem. We harvested the full public MCP registry (21,643 servers, 72,606 version records, August 2026 snapshot), fetched source code for 14,353 servers, and applied a pattern-based scanner covering an eight-class threat catalogue whose accuracy we measured against 414 hand-labeled findings. Observed prevalence is dominated by unauthenticated network exposure (9.57% of scanned servers); after correcting each class by its measured precision, 11.14% observed high-severity prevalence reduces to roughly 7.6%. The central finding concerns instability rather than any single weakness: 51.1% of multi-version servers changed what they advertise between versions, 40.6% did so silently, and 4.2% redirected their remote endpoint to a different host while keeping their registry identity, a change the protocol never surfaces to installed clients. Silent drift is associated with nearly threefold higher odds of a high-severity finding (OR = 2.96, 95% CI [2.56, 3.42]). Popularity offers only weak protection (OR = 0.78 per unit of log stars), so star counts are a poor proxy for safety. We derive concrete recommendations for registry design, client-side pinning, and scanner triage, and release an anonymized artifact.

0.58

A Gateway Architecture for Enterprise MCP Authentication: Unifying Heterogeneous Auth, Identity Delegation, and the User / Non-User Persona Problem

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-08-11 ·Suraj Kumar, Amy Wang, Srinivasan Manoharan
similarity 0.59
Abstract

The Model Context Protocol (MCP) has become the de-facto interface for connecting LLM agents to enterprise tools, and adoption has been explosive: within a year, large organizations went from zero to dozens of internally built MCP servers. That speed created a governance crisis. Each team implemented authentication independently -- some with no auth, some with API keys, some with full OAuth -- producing a fragmented landscape with no consistent way to authorize callers, track who did what, or offboard a departing employee across the fleet. This paper reports an industry deployment that resolves the crisis with a centralized MCP gateway: a single aggregation, governance, and authentication layer that fronts every downstream MCP server. We make four contributions grounded in production experience. First, a two-axis authentication model crossing persona (interactive user vs. automated non-user) with credential type (no-auth, static/dynamic API key, PKCE, client credentials, platform app-context). Second, a gateway authentication layer supporting three enterprise SSO grants and three token-provisioning models: Bring-Your-Own-Token, Generate-Your-Own-Token, and delegated OAuth via RFC 8693 token exchange. Third, three end-to-end identity flows -- User-to-OAuth2, Non-user-to-Service-Account, and User-to-Service-Account -- composing client, gateway, and server. Fourth, the deployment evolution from CDN/WAF/edge perimeter to private MCP tunnels and enterprise-wide connectors. The architecture is in production, fronting dozens of MCP servers across web, desktop, custom-SDK, and low-code clients.

0.37

No-Box Vulnerability Analysis: Description-only Detection of Indirect Prompt Injection Vulnerabilities in MCP Servers

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-09-09 ·Zehua Zhang, Jie Hu, Pratham Hegde, Aditya Maheshbhai Gabani, Souradip Nath +11 more
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Conventional vulnerability analysis relies on either system access or dynamic interaction, all of which may be unavailable to third-party analysts auditing closed-source, remotely hosted, critical in situ systems, or commercially gated software. Therefore, we propose a new paradigm of no-box vulnerability analysis in which neither access nor runtime interaction is available, and only functionality metadata is available. Such metadata defines the intended behavior of the system, including its inputs, outputs, and side effects, while constraining the space of implementations consistent with that behavior. We propose hypothesizing about vulnerabilities that exist across all possible implementations of a given system metadata, without observing or interacting with the target system. An analyst can later validate these hypotheses when additional access is available. We showcase the feasibility of no-box vulnerability analysis through implementing a prototype called MCPSEC, which audits Model Context Protocol (MCP) servers for indirect prompt injection vulnerabilities using only the tool metadata exposed at server registration time. We evaluate MCPSEC on 20 widely deployed MCP servers comprising 177 tools, among which human evaluators confirm 95 vulnerable tools. MCPSEC identified 143 tools as vulnerable, and for each vulnerable tool, it produced a hypothesized vulnerability along with exploitation technique. Using metadata alone, MCPSEC predicted 94 (98.9% recall) real verified vulnerabilities, compared against an LLM baseline with 80 (84.2% recall). Overall, our results introduce no-box vulnerability analysis as a new analysis paradigm and demonstrate its practical feasibility in realistic systems.

0.23

Where Does MCP Security End? A Three-Tier Mitigation Mapping Framework for the OWASP MCP Top 10

cs.CR ·2026-11-02 ·Christopher Krakauer, Andreas Schaad
similarity 0.58
Abstract

The Model Context Protocol (MCP) has become a leading standard for connecting Large Language Models (LLMs) to external tools, software, and data sources. MCP architecture favors ease of integration over security, blending the data and control planes into a single natural language channel. This introduces confused deputy and prompt injection vulnerabilities that cannot be completely mitigated in the software development lifecycle (SDLC) of an MCP server. Structured security guidance for server developers has been outpaced by this adoption trend, leaving them without a clear way to identify where vulnerabilities can be addressed at the server layer and where architectural constraints create hard limits. This paper presents a framework based on OWASP MCP Top 10 mapped to three architectural tiers, developed using Design Science Research (DSR). Vulnerabilities are classified as server-primary, gateway-primary, or protocol-primary applying a cascading decision tree following four questions, resulting in reproducible tier assignments and confidence levels independent of who applies it. The framework was validated against an enterprise-grade Managed File Transfer (MFT) MCP server built in Go. Validation results showed that high-confidence server-tier controls worked as predicted, and low-confidence protocol-tier controls failed for architectural reasons beyond server implementation. The architectural ceiling encountered during practical validation is the main contribution and shows how secure-by-design development can reduce the MCP attack surface but not completely mitigate it.

0.30

API Secrets Should Never Become Tokens in the LLM's Vocabulary: A Threat Analysis of API Credential Handling in LLM Agent Systems and an Empirical Evaluation of a Vault-Mediated Execution Boundary

cs.CR cs.AIcs.LG ·2026-09-27 ·Patrick Kenney, Hadi Ahmadi, Denis Lusson, Donald Nguyen, Gurbinder Gill
similarity 0.56
Abstract

Tool-using large language model (LLM) agents turn credential hygiene from a storage problem into an execution-security problem. A key pasted into a prompt, or embedded in a system prompt or tool configuration, crosses from an authentication boundary into a data pipeline, where it may persist in conversation history, logs, memory stores, generated code, and error payloads. Prompt injection and excessive agency then convert passive disclosure into unauthorized action. This paper formalizes the credential-exposure threat chain for agentic systems; synthesizes evidence from a platform secret-store incident, vendor-reported secret-sprawl measurement, and OWASP and NIST guidance; and describes a vault-mediated execution architecture in which the model selects a connector identifier while a trusted request boundary supplies authentication. We evaluate a production implementation, Corvic Security Vault, in two controlled black-box experiments. Across 16 probes spanning seven control domains, every probe met its expected outcome: an authenticated GitHub API request succeeded while the credential stayed absent from process environment values, caller-visible request headers, tested filesystem locations, three third-party echo services, and two unrelated API origins; both cloud instance-metadata endpoints were unreachable. We also report a negative result, a connector whose stored header mapping did not satisfy its provider's authentication contract, showing that centralized custody does not by itself guarantee correct configuration. Vault mediation removes several disclosure paths but is necessary rather than sufficient: least privilege, deterministic action authorization, human approval, telemetry redaction, and rotation remain independently required. The study is purposive and small, a functional security evaluation rather than a certification.

0.15

When Agents Look Like Beacons: NIDS Evasion by Model Context Protocol Traffic

cs.CR cs.NI ·2026-09-16 ·Muhammad Abdullah Sohail
similarity 0.55
Abstract · 6 pages, 2 figures. Accepted at the 1st IEEE ICNP Workshop on Network Infrastructure and Protocols for AI Agents (NIPA 2026)

The Model Context Protocol (MCP) standardizes communication between autonomous Artificial Intelligence (AI) agents and remote tools over Streamable HTTP. This shift introduces a class of machine-generated, authenticated, and high-frequency JSON-RPC traffic directly into enterprise networks. Enterprise network defenders have historically relied on machine-like cadence as an Indicator of Compromise (IoC). In this study, we show that without explicit network-layer indication, MCP traffic structurally and temporally resembles Command and Control (C2) beaconing behavior, specifically the polling architectures used by advanced persistent threats like Cobalt Strike. Counter to theoretical assumptions about machine-generated polling, our measurements reveal a visibility gap: standard enterprise Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS) and behavioral beacon-scoring frameworks do not classify MCP remote tool usage as anomalous within our testbed scope. Through a controlled Docker-based testbed simulating eleven mathematically defined traffic profiles across three TLS conditions (Opaque, TLS-Inspected, and Cleartext), we evaluate Suricata signature matching and RITA behavioral scoring against MCP JSON-RPC patterns. Our results show that MCP traffic, regardless of temporal smearing (jitter) or TLS inspection visibility, evades detection within this configuration, yielding a consistent 0.0 behavioral beacon score and near-zero IDS content alerts under the Emerging Threats (ET) Open ruleset. While opaque TLS obscures HTTP content, it exposes agent traffic to flow-level temporal analysis; however, NIDS heuristics tuned to identify traditional malware do not flag the lognormal inter-arrival distributions characteristic of generative AI reasoning loops. To address this gap, we propose an agent-native network indication standard including Agent-Native ALPN and standardized out-of-band headers.

0.40

What a Random Draw from the MCP Registry Contains, and What Tool-Use Benchmarks Contain Instead

cs.SE cs.AI ·2026-09-10 ·Haseeb Mohammed Afsar
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.55
Abstract · 10 pages, 3 figures. Seeded, re-runnable pipeline and per-server outcomes: https://github.com/itguruhaseeb/mcp-probe ; archived at doi:10.52…

Studies of the Model Context Protocol (MCP) server ecosystem draw their samples in ways that quietly select for servers that work: reference sets, popularity lists, hand-curated frames, or pipelines that repair a server until it starts. We report what an unrepaired probability sample actually contains. From a 24,135-server registry census we draw 400 npm/stdio servers with a published seed and probe each one over the wire. Only 48.8% complete an initialize handshake, against 66.7% for a hand-curated frame measured with the same instrument, and the dominant failure is not missing credentials (13.3%) but servers that never start at all (37.5%). Among the 195 that do run, hard conformance is total: zero fatal JSON Schema violations across 2,766 advertised tools. Optional safety annotations are the real variance, and the tool-level omission rate on a random draw is 58.8% against 41.5% on the curated frame, so curation flatters this figure too. We then compare the tool descriptions these servers advertise against two tool-use benchmark corpora using one method held constant. Real MCP tools show 2.8% near-duplication at cosine 0.70, and all of it lies within single servers: cross-author near-duplication is 0.0% at every threshold tested. BFCL v4 shows 16.7%, of which 16.4 points lie between independently presented tasks. UltraTool shows 0.3%, cleaner than real tools, so this is a property of BFCL and not of synthetic corpora as a class. Separately, 68.8% of raw BFCL rows and 85.6% of raw UltraTool rows are exact name-plus-description repeats, against 0.4% for real MCP, so any statistic computed over these releases without global deduplication measures repetition rather than tools. All figures regenerate from released scripts and a published seed.

0.75

AgOSS: A Dataset and Multi-Layer Characterization of Open-Source Agricultural Software

cs.SE ·2026-09-02 ·Vatsal Dudhaiya, Mikhail Golovenchits, Aryan Banerjee, James C. Davis
datasetcode/data similarity 0.54
Abstract

Much of agriculture depends on open-source software spanning farm management platforms, cloud services, edge gateways, embedded systems, and field-deployed sensors, forming a domain-specific software supply chain that has drawn little empirical security attention. It is unknown whether this ecosystem's supply chain security posture differs from that of comparable non-agricultural software, and if it does, whether the difference reflects the agricultural domain or the size and maturity of the projects within it. As a step towards securing agricultural open-source software, we present AgOSS, a dataset of 66 repositories across six architectural categories. We assess supply chain security within the dataset via OpenSSF Scorecard, governance metrics, SBOM-based dependency analysis, and KEV matching, and compare against matched non-agricultural controls. We report two findings. First, governance is largely independent of inherited dependency risk. Scorecard tracks community activity, but we detect no association with vulnerability count, density, or known-exploited count, and in regression the exposure signal loads on architectural category rather than domain. Second, agricultural projects score far lower on raw Scorecard, but size and maturity confound the gap: the residual loses significance under matching and regression. Securing this ecosystem means investing in contributor capacity and dependency hygiene, not agriculture-specific controls.

0.20