CS Paper Radar

Who Decides? Agency and Legitimacy in Digital Educational Systems

Eriam Schaffter, Ahmed Bounekkar

cs.CY ·submitted 2026-09-17 09:13 UTC · v1
publishedposition

Abstract

Digital Educational Systems (DES) enable millions of individuals to learn or to acquire new skills. Their promises vary from one platform to another: some grant genuine degrees, others pledge rapid progress, drawing for this purpose on a range of techniques, from the recommendation of learning resources through complex models to a plain course textbook uploaded onto a learning management system. In this article, we argue that categorizing DES along two dimensions allows to map differences in the way these DES structurally conceptualise the learning process. These underlying dimensions are at once dimensions of the student model and mechanisms built in the DES's designs; we identify them as agency and legitimacy. Indeed, DES are, on the one hand, anchored in an institutionalised regime that grants them legitimacy and, in turn, legitimises the learning undertaken on these platforms; on the other hand, they make design choices as to the share of decision left to the learner in the learning process. We map a curated sample of common DES onto a plane composed of these two dimensions translated into indicators. This allows us to highlight underpopulated regions of the plane and to envisage how a DES might regulate these two dimensions algorithmically, in the interest of learning.

Journal ref
CELDA 2026, IADIS, Oct 2026, Lisbonne, Portugal

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Who Is Doing the Thinking? Characterising Human Agency in First-Year Students' AI Interactions

cs.SE cs.HC ·2026-11-03 ·Ali Shakiba, Thomas Chaffey
similarity 0.60
Abstract · 11 pages, 2 figures, 3 tables

When students use generative AI to produce their work, the learning process becomes invisible. Established frameworks such as Bloom's taxonomy then classify the cognitive level of what the AI produced, not what the student contributed. We propose the Human Agency Depth Taxonomy (HADT), a preliminary six-tier taxonomy that classifies the engineering contribution a student makes in a prompt, independent of the AI's output. HADT combines three dimensions: contextual bandwidth, engineering abstraction and student agency. We applied HADT to 962 prompts from 105 students' structured AI Journals in an AI-permissive, first-year software engineering course of 145 students, and examined how agency changed over ten journalled weeks. Most prompts (84.2%) carried some student contribution beyond delegation. Agency tracked the development lifecycle. Architecture-discovery prompts dominated the requirements phase (48% of turns) and fell to 5-12% from week 9, while prompts analysing existing systems rose during build and verification (odds ratio 2.88, with turns clustered by student). Two-thirds of the variance in tier lay within students, so agency depended more on the phase of work than on the student. A turn-level rise in delegation in deadline weeks did not hold once turns were clustered by student. Explicitly specifying constraints on the AI's output was rare throughout, which we interpret as a knowledge bottleneck for novices rather than a gap in instruction. We discuss implications for course and assessment design, and for using HADT as a formative lens on how students engage with AI.

0.21

Reclaiming Epistemic Agency: A Critical Framework for Human-Generative AI Co-Agency in Education

cs.CY ·2026-08-27 ·Biranchi Poudyal
similarity 0.57
Abstract

Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) has been primarily framed as an impartial educational tool. However, this framing overlooks an even larger shift: the reassignment of epistemological authority from teachers to students to machines. This paper presents a conceptual evaluation of the extent to which GenAI redistributes students' and teachers' ability to act in classrooms to produce knowledge, validate each other's claims, and create evidence of student learning while collaborating with and competing against humans. This evaluation draws on various theoretical paradigms, including Distributed Agency, Self-Determination Theory, Society 5.0, and Technology Integration Paradigms, including TPACK and SAMR. While all of the theoretical paradigms evaluated are relevant to the role of agency within education mediated by AI, none of them address the ongoing disparity regarding equitable distribution of power, ownership of the data used to mediate interaction, and accountability in relation to human-mediated interactions. As such, this paper introduces the Ecological Co-Agency Framework, which defines agency in terms of relational, regulatory, and pedagogical processes, conditioned by a defined commitment to human accountability for epistemological claims.

0.17

The Challenge of Modeling the Complexity of Use for the Measurement of Digital Maturity in Education

cs.CY ·2026-11-06 ·Christine Michel, La{ë}titia Pierrot, Frederic Oru, Olivier Vigneau
published similarity 0.55
Abstract

Measurement of teachers' digital maturity can be useful in diagnosing technology adoption in education and in supporting teachers' professional development. However, there is a lack of easily usable tools in the existing literature. By investigating the most effective ways to measure teachers' digital maturity, our research aims to fill this gap. The focus of this article is on a data-driven approach to the assessment of digital maturity in education. Following a process similar to teaching analytics (data collection, data modeling, data understanding and visualization, and contextual understanding), we draw on diary data collected from 12949 French primary school teachers using a virtual learning environment (VLE) during the 2022--2023 school year. Specifically, the paper presents results related to modeling and visualizing data. To this end, we propose a critical analysis of two automatic classification techniques, one supervised rule-based and the other unsupervised (hierarchical clustering). In addition to providing different scales to measure, we have proposed a new approach to diagnose and visualize digital maturity. In this way, the method provides insight into the diversity and intensity of technology use, contributing to a better understanding of digital maturity and providing a practical tool for assessing day-to-day teaching practices.

0.40

An emancipatory vision for designing (generative) AI for learner flourishing

cs.CY cs.AI ·2026-09-07 ·Luis P. Prieto, Yannis Dimitriadis
similarity 0.54
Abstract · Paper presented at the International Workshop on Critical and More-than-human Perspectives on AI in Education (at EC-TEL 2026), September 15…

The hype around generative AI seems to promise unprecedented productivity (and learning) gains. However, these technologies' increasing agentic features seem to push learners towards individualism (or individual isolation), over-reliance, and dependence on them. Human-centered design approaches (e.g., value-sensitive design) assume that, by unearthing human needs, preferences, and values, technology researchers/designers may avoid such dangers, which are driven by wider systemic factors like economic incentives or inherent human limitations (e.g., our tendency to seek, in the moment, the easiest path of action). Yet, so far these efforts seem insufficient to guide our design of educational technology that avoids the aforementioned dependency and isolation dangers, while finding widespread adoption. This paper presents an alternative, more emancipatory vision for future educational AI technology, oriented towards learner flourishing while considering the wider complex systems they inhabit, including tentative design principles and an overall design methodology. Yet, many open questions remain before this vision can be realized.

0.33

From Digital Competence to Demonstrated Digital Capability: Positioning the International Digital Driving License Against DigComp and UNESCO Frameworks

cs.CY ·2026-09-16 ·Ahmad Ghandour
similarity 0.54
Abstract

Digital competence frameworks define the knowledge, skills, attitudes and values required for participation in digital society. The European Digital Competence Framework for Citizens (DigComp) and UNESCO digital literacy and artificial intelligence competency frameworks provide reference structures for policy, curriculum and competency development. The growth of generative and agentic AI raises a further question: does knowing what constitutes competent digital behaviour provide sufficient evidence that an individual can act competently in an authentic digital situation? This conceptual paper addresses that question through a comparative analysis of DigComp, UNESCO Digital Literacy Global Framework, UNESCO AI Competency Framework for Students, and the International Digital Driving License (IDDL). Rather than treating these frameworks as competing models, the paper distinguishes their functions. DigComp and UNESCO primarily define what individuals should know, understand, value and be able to do. IDDL addresses the subsequent evidentiary problem by assessing digital capability through behaviour observed during authentic digital tasks. Its Knowledge-Capability-Reflection model distinguishes knowing what should be done, demonstrating the required behaviour, and explaining the judgement behind it. IDDL integrates Digital Skills, Cybersecurity Awareness and AI Competency, and extends assessment to human agency under AI delegation. The paper distinguishes defined competence from demonstrated capability and positions IDDL as an interoperable behavioural assessment and certification layer that can operate downstream of international competency frameworks.

0.33

Govern the Model, Not Only the Data: Storage, Circulation, and Learning in Creative AI

cs.AI cs.HC ·2026-09-03 ·Phoenix Perry, George Simms, Elizabeth Wilson, Yasmine Boudiaf, Nick Bryan-Kinns +7 more
position similarity 0.54
Abstract · 9 pages, 1 figure

Federated learning is increasingly presented as a privacy-preserving advance: personal data remain on the device, and only model updates are shared. It borrows the vocabulary of the federated social web, yet inverts its logic, distributing computation while the resulting model stays with whoever convened the training. We argue that federation is not in itself a remedy for extractive AI, because outcomes depend on who governs the data and the model and who has agency over the practices that shape them. We describe three layers at which a creative community can hold its work: storage, circulation, and learning. Examining artist-governed trusts, cooperatives, and consent infrastructures, we show that creator governance is established at storage and circulation but stops at learning: contributors can consent to training, yet have little say over the resulting model or its federation. We map the research space this opens, pairing technical open problems with the human questions from which they unfold. We propose four design principles for a creative data commons that governs models and their federation, not only datasets: govern the model, not only the corpus; make the terms legible at the moment of contribution; design for refusal as a first-class state; and decide stewardship in the open and account for it.

0.25

Agentic University: Collaborative Agents for Personalized Learning

cs.AI cs.CL ·2026-10-29 ·Jingru Fan, Tianle Zhou, Yunjie Zhou, Zihao He, Yixuan Zhou +8 more
code/data similarity 0.54
Abstract

Large language models support personalized tutoring, content generation, and adaptive learning paths. However, capability development requires these resources and interactions to form a coherent learning process that evolves with the learner. A central challenge is to align goals, activities, and assessment while using learning evidence to decide what should follow. We introduce Human-Participatory Multi-Agent Organization and instantiate it in Agentic University (AU). In AU, learners participate as organization members and work with specialized agents to maintain a revisable Capability Program. The program connects personal goals, learning activities across modalities, and layered assessment, while learner feedback and performance guide subsequent support. Our evaluation shows advantages in program organization, assessment design, and revision quality. Users achieved larger mean assessment gains (12.19 versus 5.61 points on a 50-point scale) and reported stronger cognitive support. This work contributes an organizational approach to adaptive learning that makes learner participation a continuing basis for multi-agent coordination. The Agentic University project is available at \href{https://github.com/AgenticOrgLab/AgenticUniversity.git}.

0.36

Addressing Trust in AI Systems through Education: A Didactic Perspective

cs.CY cs.AI ·2026-09-02 ·Pierre Haritz, Hendrik Krone, Thomas Liebig
position similarity 0.52
Abstract

Machine learning (ML) education faces two persistent and connected obstacles: many educational tools present ML as an opaque black box, which leaves learners with a superficial understanding, and this same opacity prevents users from forming the calibrated trust that appropriate reliance on AI systems requires. We present ICE-T, a didactic framework that integrates three mutually reinforcing facets: intermodal transfer grounded in Bruner's enactive, iconic, and symbolic modes of representation, computational thinking operationalized through the Use-Modify-Create progression, and explanatory thinking supported by a process model. Connecting the framework to the empirical literature on algorithm aversion, AI literacy, and mental model formation, and to systematic reviews of the K-12 ML activity landscape, we argue that the three facets supply the cognitive mechanisms that the trust calibration literature identifies as drivers of appropriate reliance: representational richness, graduated process control, and the capacity to contextualize errors. On this basis, we propose that trust calibration be treated as an explicit educational objective, with ICE-T as a principled and scalable means of achieving it.

0.29