CS Paper Radar

String Diagrams for Process Mining

Antony R. Lee, Peter Tiňo, Iain B. Styles

cs.LO cs.DBmath.CT ·submitted 2026-09-17 14:33 UTC · v1

Abstract

Run two process-discovery algorithms on the same event log and they return two different pictures of the same process. Petri nets, causal nets, process trees and BPMN each rely on routing machinery of their own, and their only common ground is the traces they generate. A trace lists activities one after another, so it discards the concurrency the notations exist to express, and two models with identical trace languages can describe genuinely different processes. Whether two discovered models mean the same thing therefore has no notation-independent answer. We show that all four notations admit one canonical presentation, a signature recording a model's activities and the typed interfaces along which they compose, and nothing of the routing machinery. Four construction theorems establish this presentation notation by notation, so two models are compared in a form that each notation determines on its own. Signature equality implies trace equivalence and is strictly finer, separating genuine concurrency from interleaved choice, which a trace comparison cannot, and signature inclusion implies trace inclusion. In a recovery study on one object-centric log, the discovered causal net has exactly the ground-truth signature, while the discovered Petri net's signature strictly contains it and locates every behaviour the Petri net adds in its silent structure. The gain is largest for object-centric data, where a single log supports several notations at once. The four notations become one calculus, in which a translation between them is a claim that can be checked.

Comment
67 pages, 22 figures, 4 tables

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

A Practical Approach To Verifying Structural Invariants In Colored Petri Nets

cs.SC cs.FL ·2026-09-28 ·Lorenzo Capra
published similarity 0.66
Abstract · In Proceedings ICE 2026, arXiv:2609.30353

Structural analysis is a core method in Petri Net (PN) research, offering a perspective complementary to state-space techniques while avoiding many of their limitations. It is well studied for classical PNs but far less for High-Level Petri Nets (HLPN). Symmetric Nets (SN), a common HLPN formalism, use compact annotations to encode behavioral symmetries, enabling the construction of a symbolic reachability graph (and a lumped Markov chain in stochastic SN) and the execution of symbolic discrete-event simulations. During the past two decades, structural techniques tailored to SN have been developed, notably supported by the SNexpression tool. This tool implements a formal calculus designed for the computation of symbolic structural relations, including, but not limited to, conflict relations and causal dependencies. Here, we focus on using this calculus to verify semi-automatically symbolic structural invariants, a task currently feasible only for certain restricted SN subclasses. We focus specifically on (semi)flows and briefly discuss an approach through which a flow generative family can be generated, at least theoretically. We further briefly outline a framework for the formal verification of a broader class of invariant properties. An extended formulation of the SN formalism is employed, which demonstrably satisfies the closure property with respect to fundamental functional operators. The core concepts are elucidated by means of representative examples throughout the exposition.

0.32

Semi-automated Verification of Symbolic Invariants In Extended Symmetric Nets

cs.SC cs.SE ·2026-09-28 ·Lorenzo Capra
published similarity 0.64
Abstract · In Proceedings FROM 2026, arXiv:2609.30324

Structural analysis is central to Petri Net (PN) research, complementing state-space methods while avoiding their combinatorial issues. It is well studied for classical PNs but much less for High-Level Petri Nets (HLPN). Symmetric Nets (SN), a common HLPN formalism, use compact annotations to encode behavioral symmetries, allowing symbolic reachability graphs and associated lumped Markov chains for stochastic SN. In the past two decades, specific structural techniques for SN have emerged, notably the SNexpression tool, which implements a calculus for symbolic structural relations such as conflict and causality. We propose using this calculus to semi-automatically verify symbolic structural invariants, currently possible only for restricted SN subclasses, for an extended SN formalism (ESN) closed under key functional operators. We focus on flows and outline, at least in theory, how to construct a flow-generating family. We also sketch a framework for formally verifying a wider range of invariant properties. Representative examples illustrate the main concepts.

0.30

Monotonicity-Guided Bottom-Up Petri Net Discovery: The SPECpp Framework

cs.DB cs.AI ·2026-08-10 ·Leah Tacke genannt Unterberg, Lisa L. Mannel, Wil M. P. van der Aalst
similarity 0.64
Abstract · 59 pages, 15 figures

Process discovery is one of the central challenges in process mining. Petri nets are particularly attractive because simple local constructs can express complex behavior, including concurrency. While their global behavior may be difficult to analyze, individual places can be efficiently characterized using monotonic properties, enabling bottom-up discovery. Unlike top-down approaches such as the Inductive Miner, which rely on predefined constructs for sequences, choices, loops, and concurrency, our approach allows such structures to emerge organically and can exploit the full expressive power of Petri nets, including free-choice constructs and long-term dependencies. The main challenge is the exponential number of candidate places and their combinations. We present the SPECpp framework which implements strategies to obtain high-quality models under time and resource constraints. SPECpp supports rapid experimentation and is used to evaluate these strategies using both synthetic and real-life event data.

0.42

Universal Properties of Petri Net Unfoldings

cs.LO math.CT ·2026-09-15 ·Serge Lechenne, Hugo Paquet
published similarity 0.64
Abstract

It is an established idea in concurrency theory that every Petri net admits an unfolding semantics. This is a denotational object that represents its domain of possible executions. Unfoldings play an important role in practical analysis and verification. This paper is concerned with the following well-known problem: while the unfolding resembles a universal construction in the category of Petri nets, it generally fails to satisfy the expected universal property. This is because the unfolding construction overlooks the net's internal symmetries. There are two solutions: make these symmetries explicit to obtain a weak universal property (one that holds only ''up to symmetry''); or break the symmetries by assigning individual identities to components of the net. We review these two solutions and establish, in each case, a universal unfolding of Petri nets to event structures. This paper demonstrates a 2-categorical approach to Petri net unfoldings. We show that each unfolding semantics determines a 2-categorical relative adjunction involving Petri nets and event structures. Viewed in this way, the above two constructions can be related formally via an appropriate morphism of adjunctions. We exhibit a 2-density property of event structures which implies that unfolding functors are essentially unique.

0.40

Concurrency-Aware Process Model Forecasting with Causal Nets

cs.LG cs.DB ·2026-09-18 ·Yongbo Yu, Jari Peeperkorn, Johannes De Smedt, Jochen De Weerdt
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 13 pages, 2 figures

Process model forecasting (PMF) aims to predict the process model that will characterize a future period, thereby providing a process-level view of how behavior is expected to evolve. Existing PMF methods, however, forecast directly-follows graphs, which cannot explicitly represent concurrency. We extend PMF to causal nets by forecasting time series of relation and binding counts and using these forecasts to reconstruct future process models with AND/XOR semantics. To evaluate the resulting models, we introduce a protocol that accounts for partial traces and constructs the workflow nets required for conformance checking. Experiments on four event logs show that the forecasted models achieve conformance levels close to those of models re-mined from observations in the corresponding future windows. They also outperform static discovery baselines, which retain high precision on the structurally stable log but exhibit substantial precision losses on the other three logs. Filtering infrequent bindings improves most conformance metrics, although it also removes much of the concurrent behavior captured by the models.

0.29

A Node Embedding Framework for Model-Centric Conformance Checking in Process Mining

cs.AI ·2026-10-13 ·Mostafa Abbasi, Homayoun Najjaran
code/data similarity 0.62
Abstract · 34 pages, 13 figures, 8 tables. Code: https://github.com/mstabc/cc_node2vec

Evaluating the quality of process models discovered from event logs is a fundamental challenge in process mining. Traditional evaluation relies on conformance metrics such as fitness and precision, which are highly sensitive to noise and deviations in event logs and therefore often fail to give a consistent assessment of discovery algorithms. We introduce a model-centric evaluation framework that combines node embeddings with Procrustes alignment to enable cross-graph comparability, since embeddings derived from different graphs reside in distinct vector spaces. The proposed PetriNetGraph method transforms Petri net process models into graph representations compatible with embedding algorithms. Comparing the node embeddings of ground-truth and discovered models through a parameterized cosine distance yields a unified and bounded metric for evaluating process discovery across datasets and methods. We evaluate the framework under static and context-aware scenarios to examine how prior knowledge of activity existence influences the assessment of structural similarity. The framework also integrates a compliance checking mechanism that localizes deviations at the activity level and an entropy-regularized node distance aggregation function that quantifies global deviations across the model. Experiments on nine publicly available event logs show that the approach provides a reliable embedding-based conformance indicator that reflects the behavior of fitness and precision. Experiments on synthetic logs with controlled noise levels confirm that it is substantially more robust to log deviations than traditional conformance metrics, PetriNet2Vec, and its dynamic-window and Procrustes-aligned variants, while remaining sensitive to process model degradation. All implementation details and datasets are publicly available.

0.32

Inductive Process Discovery from Partially Ordered Event Data

cs.DB ·2026-08-20 ·Humam Kourani, Tom Breuer, Gyunam Park, Wil M. P. van der Aalst
similarity 0.62
Abstract

The Inductive Miner (IM) family is a prominent class of process discovery techniques, combining efficient recursive decomposition with soundness-by-construction guarantees. However, IM techniques usually assume traces to be totally ordered sequences of activity occurrences. This assumption is convenient, but can introduce systematic bias: activities may have durations, events may share coarse timestamps, or the data may constrain only some event pairs. Forcing such executions into arbitrary sequences hides inherent concurrency and may introduce sequential dependencies that were never observed as causal constraints. Partial orders provide a more faithful representation, but integrating them into IM discovery is challenging because standard abstractions are sequence-based; directly reusing them would require linearizing each partial order, which becomes prohibitively expensive under high concurrency. We introduce a lifting of IM discovery from total orders to partially ordered traces. Instead of redesigning the miner and its cut detection logic, we redefine the trace abstraction layer and the recursive projections to operate directly on partial orders. The approach is conservative over totally ordered traces, avoids linearization explosion, and preserves the recursive structure and guarantees that make IM attractive. Experimental results show that the proposed lifting avoids the combinatorial overhead of linearization, reduces sensitivity to arbitrary tie-breaking in timestamped event data, and allows process behavior to be learned from fewer observations by preserving concurrency at the trace level.

0.17

Structure-Aware Message Passing on Petri Nets through Directed Walks and Incidence Diffusion

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-10-21 ·Geri Skenderi
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract

A common application of the process mining discipline is to connect observed event data with Petri nets, which are bipartite, directed graphical process models with rich formal underpinnings. Recent work learns vector representations of Petri nets to retrieve process models and relate them to event logs, but leaves implicit two key aspects hidden within the net's structure: directed cycles (process loops) and invariants recorded by the net's incidence matrix. We expose both of these to message-passing graph neural networks, through a positional encoding built from return probabilities of directed place-transition walks (PNRWPE), and through same-type messages gated by diffusion kernels of the incidence matrix (DA-PNGNN). Our constructions raise macro balanced accuracy in predicting the generation factors of the 96 Process Discovery Contest 2023 models from 0.751 to 0.796 with PNRWPE, which nearly doubles accuracy on process loops, and to 0.830 with DA-PNGNN, which, without retuning, also improves net-to-tree retrieval top-1 accuracy on the self-supervised ProcRosetta benchmark by 4.1 to 5.9 points.

0.15