CS Paper Radar

Mutual Evaluation and Supervision without Peers

Zachary Robertson

cs.GT cs.IT ·submitted 2026-09-17 17:53 UTC · v1
code/data

Abstract

This article introduces mutual evaluation of a replicable task worker and a critic that incentivizes truthful reporting, both modeled as strategic agents. The critic chooses a finite-valued rule that induces an evaluation score on joint report laws. Their common payoff is analyzed through regret relative to the unrestricted critic envelope. The critic rule is distinct from the evaluation score. This class enables a peer-free information elicitation mechanism using conditionally independent replications of a worker on the same task. This replication-loop mechanism implements a type-agreement payoff using same-task replications and new-task samples. In contrast to the peer-prediction and scoring-rule literature, implementations are shown that produce unbiased Pearson and Shannon information scores without requiring peers, a ground-truth reference, or likelihood-ratio estimation. A valid binary critic also can be represented by shared finite type annotations of worker returns. One runtime restriction is that the number of required replicas is random and can depend on the critic rule. Other timing effects, such as commitment and reoptimization, yield distinct incentives, connecting the framework to variational peer prediction. This mechanism class illustrates why strategic considerations matter for both critic and worker agents.

Comment
13 pages. Lean 4 formalization: https://github.com/zrobertson466920/mutual-evaluation

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Information Elicitation by Ordinal Agreement

cs.GT ·2026-11-05 ·Yiling Chen, Shi Feng, Grant Schoenebeck, Fang-Yi Yu
publishedtheory similarity 0.73
Abstract · 33 pages, 3 figures. Accepted to the 22nd Conference on Web and Internet Economics (WINE 2026)

Ordinal information is central to tasks ranging from conference peer review to Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback for large language models. In many such settings, there is no objective ground truth against which reports can be directly verified, making incentive-compatible elicitation challenging. Peer-prediction mechanisms have been designed to achieve truthful elicitation despite the lack of ground-truth verification. However, existing peer-prediction methods do not provide incentives for agents to truthfully compress rich private information (e.g. reviews) into coarser ordinal reports (e.g. rankings) requested by the mechanisms. We propose a simple ordinal peer-prediction mechanism that rewards agents based on pairwise agreement, measured by Kendall tau. Under a broad class of Bayesian Stochastically Order Consistent models---which includes classical models such as Mallows and Thurstone---we prove that truthful reporting is stochastically dominant, and strongly truthful under index-equivariant strategies. This provides robust incentives even for agents with non-linear utility functions, such as risk aversion. Our mechanism further accommodates heterogeneous agents, top-K reports, and subset assignments, where each agent is scored against one randomly drawn peer. Experiments on synthetic Mallows and Thurstone data, together with a real-data stress test on the SUSHI preference dataset, show right-shifted truthful-payment distributions and the highest normalized sensitivity among tested baselines.

0.24

Memory Is Communication: The Frontier Between Remembering and Signaling

cs.AI cs.CLcs.ITcs.MA ·2026-08-17 ·Yashar Talebirad, Eden Redman, Ali Parsaee, Osmar R. Zaiane
similarity 0.60
Abstract

A bounded agent may obtain information for a decision from its own past, from peers, or from both sources. Retaining task-relevant history can reduce later communication, while a peer message can supply what memory lacks. Under limits on both resources, how should an agent allocate its information budget? Given a fixed task and decision rule, the memory and message rate pairs attaining a performance threshold form an achievable region under specified rules for using history and peer observations. We call its efficient boundary the remembering--signaling frontier. Across conditions where history permits the same maximum reduction in task loss, we hypothesize that a bounded agent will need less peer communication when it obtains a larger loss reduction from history. In preliminary referential games, target repetition coincided with shorter successful messages, while predictability from a hidden cyclic rule did not shorten them. Experiments varying memory and message rates can estimate the frontier and test this prediction across cooperative tasks.

0.10

Sample Complexity of Peer Prediction

cs.IT cs.GT ·2026-08-17 ·Abdellah Aznag, Robin Bowers, Rachel Cummings, Jason Hartline, Matthew vonAllmen +1 more
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Peer prediction seeks to incentivize agents to truthfully report an observed signal by rewarding joint sets of reports without observing a ground truth. Following the generalization of information-theoretic mutual information introduced in Kong and Schoenebeck (2019), we call a function of a joint distribution over signals a mutual information when it is non-negative and disincentivizes garbling reports for all information structures. An unbiased estimator for a mutual information takes some number of samples from the distribution and returns rewards for both agents, such that the expected reward is equal to the mutual information. We seek to characterize the set of mutual informations with unbiased estimators for a given number of samples. We show that for three or fewer sampled report pairs, the only mutual information with an unbiased estimator is trivially zero, and for four or five samples with a binary report space, the Determinant Mutual Information (DMI) of Kong (2024) is the unique mutual information (up to a scalar multiple). We further show that DMI ceases to be unique at six samples. We provide an improved estimator of DMI for any given number of samples and characterize its convergence rate. We also examine mutual information estimators that accept a randomized number of samples. First, we show that mutual information estimators on an ex-ante bounded number of samples (termed "stop-short estimators") can achieve a lower variance than an equivalent fixed-sample estimator (for DMI). Second, we introduce the class of scoring-rule-based mutual informations and identify in this family a mutual information that can be estimated with under three samples in expectation.

0.45

Strategic Calibration in LLM Multi-Agent Systems: Audited Pivot Scoring for Truthful Elicitation

cs.GT cs.AI ·2026-10-24 ·Jinhao Zhou, Zhaohan Zhang, Xijian Xu, Jun Wu
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 22 pages, 12 figures, including appendices

In large language model (LLM)-based multi-agent systems, reported confidence increasingly determines the allocation of scarce downstream attention, computation, and decision influence. This makes reporting strategic: an agent may overstate the relevance of its contribution even when its underlying belief is well calibrated. Existing calibration methods largely assume passive reporting and therefore do not address strategic incentives created when confidence determines downstream allocation. We formulate strategic calibration as a reporting-layer incentive problem and propose the Audited Pivot Scoring Mechanism (APSM). APSM offsets platform-controlled allocation benefits, uses inverse-propensity-weighted sparse audits, charges the Clarke pivot externality, and applies a strictly proper score. Under the stated model assumptions, truthful reporting is the unique expected-utility best response. We also characterize approximate execution and the audit-variance trade-off. Calculator-free experiments show that LLM agents inflate confidence under Top-$K$ incentives. With a shared agent-local utility interface, LLM agents reduce distortion under both Compensated Proper Scoring (CPS) and APSM. CPS achieves higher exact allocation match, whereas APSM yields lower Brier loss and numerically fewer cutoff crossings. Experiments further show that APSM enlarges the utility margin against allocation-changing deviations by $1.93\times$ and improves robustness under approximate execution. These results support incentive-aware elicitation as a distinct layer for reliable multi-agent coordination.

0.20

Centralized Critics for N-Agent Ad Hoc Teamwork

cs.AI cs.LG ·2026-10-26 ·Andrew McAlinden, Caroline Wang, Steven Shi, Arrasy Rahman, Elad Liebman +1 more
theory similarity 0.59
Abstract

Centralized training with decentralized execution (CTDE) has become the dominant paradigm in multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL), motivating extensive study of what privileged information should be made available to the critic during training. While prior work has examined the role of global state in fully cooperative settings, the design of centralized critics for N-agent ad hoc teamwork - in which dynamically varying set of learning agents must coordinate with an arbitrary set of uncontrolled teammates drawn from an unknown distribution - remains poorly understood. We study this question by comparing two natural classes of advantage estimators: controlled history estimators, which condition only on the observation and action histories of the learner's own agents, and joint history estimators, which additionally condition on the histories of the uncontrolled teammates. We prove that both estimators are unbiased and characterize the conditions under which the joint history estimate attains strictly lower variance than its controlled counterpart. Empirically, joint history critics match or outperform controlled history critics across a range of NAHT tasks, yielding improved sample efficiency and final returns. Together, these results provide both a theoretical justification and an empirical recommendation for incorporating uncontrolled agent histories into centralized critics for N-agent ad hoc teamwork.

0.15

Ask on Demand: Targeted Peer Communication for Parallel Agentic Systems

cs.AI ·2026-10-30 ·Haofu Yang, Hongyang Yin, Ran Bi, Faguo Wu, Peng Xue +2 more
similarity 0.58
Abstract · Equal contribution: Haofu Yang and Hongyang Yin. Corresponding authors: Ran Bi and Faguo Wu

Parallel LLM agents tackle complex tasks by exploring multiple trajectories, yet useful discoveries remain isolated in individual execution histories. Existing sharing methods often select or summarize information before other agents' needs become clear, potentially overlooking details that become important later. We propose Ask on Demand (AOD), a communication framework that enables agents to seek targeted peer assistance when specific information needs arise. Upon an approved request, AOD retrieves relevant evidence from peer execution histories, selects a suitable peer, and generates a response tailored to the request. To determine when such assistance is worthwhile, we train a lightweight gate using paired team continuations, with supervision derived from final team outcomes and inference cost. Experiments on AppWorld and WebShop demonstrate that AOD consistently improves task performance over independent parallel execution while achieving lower inference cost than existing information-sharing baselines. These findings highlight the benefits of aligning peer communication with agents' evolving information needs to achieve more effective and efficient collaboration.

0.24

What Makes a Social Agent's Interactions Effective? Learning from Verifiable Outcomes in Paired Worlds

cs.CL cs.AIcs.SI ·2026-10-14 ·Caixin Kang, Ke Wang, Yuchuan Wu, Xiaoqiang Wang, Ling Li +3 more
benchmark similarity 0.57
Abstract

Effective social interaction requires more than fluent responses: agents must reach plans that fit the participants' needs and circumstances. Existing evaluations of social agents mainly rely on LLM judges that rate the conversation, without checking the resulting plan. We introduce HICO-Bench, a benchmark of 180 everyday coordination scenarios, such as resource allocation, scheduling, and authorization, in which two agents with private information converse and then independently record the plan they agreed on. A program checks Feasibility (the two records match and satisfy both participants' private conditions), and an LLM judge checks Integrity (the conversation supports the recorded plan); passing both is a Verified Success. Each scenario has two versions that share the same public context but differ in one private condition, so the correct plan differs between them. Across thirteen LLMs, 36% of conversations rated highly for goal completion fail Verified Success. To learn from outcomes that arrive only at the end of a conversation, we propose Paired-Credit Policy Optimization (PaCPO). After each turn, PaCPO asks the agent for a tentative plan, checks it in both versions of the scenario, and rewards the turns after which the tentative plans fit their respective versions. PaCPO raises Qwen3-8B's Verified Success from 20.4% to 28.3%.

0.61

SAGE: Optimal-Stopping Peer Selection for Decentralised Federated Learning

cs.DC cs.LG ·2026-09-20 ·Ke Xiao, Qiyuan Wang, Christos Anagnostopoulos
similarity 0.57
Abstract · 12 pages, 3 figures, 3 tables

Decentralised federated learning replaces server aggregation with peer-to-peer model exchange, making collaborator selection a local decision under uncertainty. Fixed probe budgets waste effort on easy choices yet fall short when peers are hard to distinguish. We propose SAGE (Sequential Anchor-Gated Exchange), an optimal-stopping peer selector under a one-model-bearing-exchange budget. A receiver scores candidate neighbours on receiver-owned anchor evidence and selects once an advantage is certified. It continues probing only while further evidence repays its cost, and otherwise falls back to random gossip. We show that the stopping problem admits an optimal rule attained at a finite stage, and that the anchor schedule is order-optimal in the peer-risk gap and the confidence level. We further show that the selector never returns a peer worse than random gossip with high probability, and prove that no such guarantee holds for selectors that commit without a certificate. A separability threshold follows, below which no probing budget improves on gossip. Experiments span two image benchmarks, two graph families and three heterogeneity levels. Selectors that always act on their evidence lose to gossip in every configuration tested. SAGE-OS matches gossip on 75.5% less evidence than a fixed budget, at half the communication overhead of two published selectors. The operative decision is not which peer to rank first, but whether the evidence justifies ranking at all.

0.33