CS Paper Radar

The Right Tool for the Job: On the Selection of Mitigations for GenAI Privacy Threats

Jonah Bellemans, Qianying Liao, Laurens Sion, Lieven Desmet, Wouter Joosen

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-09-16 21:36 UTC · v1
publishedposition

Abstract

Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) has rapidly evolved from an experimental technology into a foundational component of modern software systems. However, as its adoption grows, protecting sensitive personal data becomes increasingly challenging. Specifically, GenAI systems not only amplify traditional privacy threats but also introduce new inference-based risks, such as constructing detailed user profiles from seemingly harmless inputs. In response, privacy threat modeling frameworks are beginning to capture GenAI-specific privacy threats with finer granularity. At the same time, a growing number of mitigation techniques have been proposed to address these threats. However, although knowledge of both threats and mitigations continues to mature, the problem- and solution-space have developed largely independently. This position paper argues that the primary challenge in GenAI privacy engineering is not the lack of knowledge about privacy threats or mitigation techniques, but the missing bridge between them. We decompose this gap into three sub-problems: (i) lack of fine-grained threat-to-mitigation mapping for GenAI systems, (ii) inapplicable solution-space assumptions in the GenAI context, and (iii) prioritization difficulty under GenAI constraints. We derive four recommendations for future mitigation-selection approaches, and outline a suggested approach that extends established threat-to-mitigation mapping methods to GenAI-specific threat characteristics. We propose a research agenda toward more systematic privacy mitigation selection for GenAI-based systems.

Comment
Presented at the 21st IFIP Summer School on Privacy and Identity Management 2026

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

PrivacyFlow: Privacy in AI Agents through Information Flow Analysis and Consequence-Aware Risk Management

cs.CR cs.AIcs.LG ·2026-10-29 ·Robin Staab, Tom Wollschläger, Vahab Mirrokni, Reza Shokri
benchmark similarity 0.70
Abstract

Autonomous LLM agents executing multi-step workflows over personal data often misalign with user privacy expectations and leak sensitive, out-of-context information. Although Contextual Integrity (CI) formalizes this problem, existing benchmarks and defenses rarely operationalize CI for realistic multi-step task sequences in evolving environments. In this work, we first introduce agentic PrivacyBench, a benchmark of 5873 tasks in 986 task sequences with dynamic environment updates and CI-grounded allow-sets for sensitive information. We also introduce PrivacyFlow, a defense that separates deliberative privacy planning (System 2) from task execution (System 1), treating each sharing decision as a structured risk-management problem. Before execution, PrivacyFlow traces the provenance and purpose of each planned data flow, models recipient background knowledge, and simulates what external actors could infer. This allows us to model the downstream consequences of disclosure, including inference attacks and context-dependent harms. It then weighs the remaining disclosure risk against task utility and executes a minimized plan, blocks it, or consults the user. Across six models, PrivacyFlow significantly reduces step-level privacy failures and raises the share of completed task sequences without a detected privacy violation by 22--55 percentage points. We further highlight a new privacy--utility--autonomy tradeoff: allowing PrivacyFlow to proactively prompt the user in case of uncertainty can increase authorized task completion at the cost of shifting decision effort back to the user. Our results suggest that proactive CI reasoning can substantially improve agentic privacy and motivate further study of this tradeoff.

0.06

SoK: From Generation to Consumption of Privacy Documents in Software Systems

cs.CR cs.CL ·2026-08-12 ·Shidong Pan, Clark LaChance, Zhen Tao, Sepideh Ghanavati
top venuesurvey similarity 0.67
Abstract · This SoK paper has been accepted by NDSS 2027

Privacy documents (e.g., privacy policies) are a central mechanism through which digital services disclose data practices and seek user consent. Over the past decades, research on privacy documents has expanded significantly, encompassing not only traditional privacy policies but also short notices (e.g., privacy labels) and interface-level transparency mechanisms. As this research area continues to grow, it has become increasingly difficult to obtain a coherent view of how privacy documents are created, analyzed, evaluated, and maintained across their lifecycle. This SoK provides a unified, lifecycle-oriented view of privacy documents from a software engineering perspective. We systematically review and analyze 290 papers published between 2010 and 2025, organizing them around five research questions that examine how privacy documents are (1) defined and scoped, (2) generated, (3) analyzed and extracted, (4) checked for inconsistencies and noncompliance, and (5) evaluated and improved for usability. Building on our findings, we identify 15 key research trends and 21 open opportunities. We further chart four broader research directions that highlight (i) emerging challenges in AI-centric platforms, (ii) the need for diverse and up-to-date data foundations, (iii) LLM-based unified policy-code analysis, and (iv) dual usability for end-users and developers. We hope this SoK provides a shared foundation for future research on privacy policies and privacy documents.

0.64

AgentPrivArena: Evaluating and Auditing Real-world AI Agent Privacy

cs.AI ·2026-10-05 ·Shouju Wang, Haopeng Zhang
similarity 0.67
Abstract

The rapid advancement of LLM agents has enabled systems to autonomously perform complex tasks through external tools, but their growing access to personal data introduces significant privacy risks. Existing benchmarks primarily evaluate LLM agent privacy through simulated trajectories and outcome-based metrics, limiting their ability to capture privacy risks arising during multi-step agent execution. In this work, we introduce AgentPrivArena, a framework for evaluating privacy risks in realistic LLM agent workflows. AgentPrivArena integrates authentic MCP tools and self-hosted services within a reproducible execution environment. We further propose trajectory-level privacy metrics that quantify unnecessary information access beyond final response leakage. Building on this framework, we introduce AgentPrivAudit, a runtime auditing approach for monitoring privacy violations during agent execution. Extensive experiments on state-of-the-art LLM agents reveal substantial privacy risks overlooked by existing evaluation paradigms, highlighting the importance of trajectory-level auditing for trustworthy agent deployment.

0.10

Mitigating Private Data Leakage in LLMs with Whiteout

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-10-01 ·Anna Yoo Jeong Ha, Ronik Bhaskar, Haitao Zheng, Ben Y. Zhao
similarity 0.66
Abstract · v2: minor typos and formatting corrections

Modern large language models (LLMs) are trained on massive, largely unfiltered datasets, including content scraped from nearly every accessible website and user inputs. As a result, LLMs often memorize and reproduce personally sensitive information (PSI) such as birth dates, phone numbers, and home addresses. This leads to significant privacy risks, particularly for high-profile individuals such as executives, politicians, and judges. Existing mitigations largely rely on machine unlearning. However, these methods often remove more information than needed, degrade model utility and safety, and are highly vulnerable to attacks. This paper presents Whiteout, a practical tool that, upon requests by individuals, prevents LLMs from regurgitating their genuine PSIs, by overwriting them using precise and carefully designed obfuscation samples. We evaluate Whiteout on modern LLMs of varying sizes and makers, including a widely-used OpenAI model. Results show that Whiteout effectively prevents disclosure of the targeted PSIs, has negligible impact on model utility and safety, and outperforms existing alternatives. We also test Whiteout against a wide range of countermeasures, from black-box attacks like jailbreaking to white-box adaptive attacks like relearning and quantization. Finally, we conclude with a discussion on the security and ethical implications of Whiteout.

0.09

Confuse the Model, Control the Flow: Understanding and Mitigating Privacy Leakage from LLM Agents with Information Flow Control

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-09-12 ·Minsun Shim, Ramisha Raida Karim, Ruthwik Jakkula, Kaiwen Zhou, Xin Liu +2 more
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Personal AI agents built on large language models (LLMs) are increasingly given access to a user's private data and communications in order to provide personalized assistance. This access creates a persistent privacy risk: the agent must decide whether a given sensitive information should be disclosed to a particular party. Existing defenses address this by making the agent's backend LLM more privacy-preserving through stronger system prompts, training, or explicit consent-checking procedures, but this approach has a structural challenge: whenever enforcement is a judgment the LLM makes over the same conversational context an adversary controls, the enforcement mechanism and the attack surface coincide. We demonstrate this against existing defenses with three new attacks that require only ordinary agent interaction and no prompt injection: Collaborative Workspace Lure reframes an extraction attempt as collaborative work; Semantic Obfuscation Attack induces disclosure through omission rather than through anything the agent writes; and Channel Decoupling Attack splits the extraction request and the disclosure across independent channels. All three achieve substantially higher leak rates than the attacks these defenses were originally designed to withstand. Guided by this observation, we present FLOWSEAL, a defense that enforces confidentiality through a tool-level interceptor outside the LLM's context, grounded in data provenance and an information-flow-control lattice with controlled declassification. Evaluated across three benchmarks, five prompt-based baselines, and eight attacks, including a real agent executing live tool calls through MCP, FLOWSEAL reduces leak rates to near zero (e.g., 52.2% to 0.5% against Collaborative Workspace Lure) while preserving task utility, regardless of the underlying LLM backend.

0.38

PIA-Bench: Towards Automated Privacy Impact Assessment with Large Language Models

cs.CR ·2026-09-11 ·Jiamin Zheng, Hao-Ping Lee, Luo Mai, Jingjie Li
benchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract

Privacy impact assessment (PIA) is a critical instrument for institutions to proactively identify privacy risks and develop mitigation strategies before system deployment. While mandated across regulatory and institutional contexts, executing PIA requires extensive privacy and technical expertise, posing a particular challenge for teams without access to such resources. Prior work shows the potential of leveraging large language models (LLMs) to assist practitioners' privacy decisions, but little is known about how accurately and reliably LLMs can automate PIA. To this end, we develop PIA-Bench, the first open benchmark for evaluating LLMs on real-world PIAs. We first audited 499 expert-authored PIAs published by US federal agencies and curated 73 structured PIAs, comprising a total of 451 privacy risk and 831 mitigation items, to evaluate LLMs' ability to assess privacy risks and propose mitigations of complex systems. Our results show that off-the-shelf LLMs produce meaningful assessments and identify avenues for future improvement. Finally, we call for improving domain-specific workflows for LLM agents, developing accountable LLM infrastructure, and designing new quality standards for PIAs.

0.22

From Alignment to Access Control: A Framework for GenAI Policy Enforcement

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-09-22 ·Nathalie Baracaldo
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Generative AI (GenAI) applications have flourished enabling users to chat with large language models, and to create agents to act on their behalf for a variety of tasks. The pace of development of capabilities in this field is incredibly fast with security and safety taking a back seat. Unfortunately, the slower pace at which security and safety mechanisms have evolved has led to real incidents. Policy enables the definition of desirable behavior of applications, and for that reason, it is a cornerstone of making systems secure and compliant. Policy however means different things to different practitioners creating confusion and siloed solutions that are not adequate for compliance. This paper takes a tour of the good, the bad and the ugly when it comes to policy enforcement in GenAI applications. We propose a methodology to systematically analyze and dissect existing approaches to define and enforce policy found in the wild. Based on this principled analysis, we provide recommendations and call for action for the community to address. This paper is a companion extension of USENIX Security 2026 Enigma talk titled "From Alignment to Access Control: A Unified View of GenAI Policy Enforcement" by the author Nathalie Baracaldo.

0.37

Privacy in Personalized AI Is a System Property, Not Just a Model Property

cs.CR cs.IRcs.LG ·2026-09-29 ·Guillaume Salha-Galvan, Jiaying Xu
publishedposition similarity 0.65
Abstract · NeurIPS 2026 Workshop on Privacy in the Era of Large Opaque Models

In personalized AI applications, such as conversational assistants and recommender systems, users interact not with models in isolation but with broader systems that access, infer, and reuse user information across components and over time. While such use of user information is integral to personalization, it also raises important privacy questions. In this paper, we argue that individual model- or component-level analyses may not capture all privacy risks arising in such systems, motivating a system-level perspective on privacy. We distinguish and analyze four interconnected privacy-risk channels in personalized AI, and subsequently propose four requirements for system-level privacy evaluation, covering interaction trajectories, internal information flows, indirect leakage, and the privacy-utility trade-off. We argue for their systematic incorporation into privacy audits of personalized AI.

0.19