CS Paper Radar

All I Hear is Noise: Investigating Clever Hans Effects in Clinical Speech Datasets

Melanie Jouaiti, Ning Ma

eess.AS ·submitted 2026-09-17 20:57 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

Recent work revealed a striking Clever Hans effect in the Pitt dataset, where Alzheimer's detection achieved nearly 100% accuracy using only silent audio segments. This raises serious concerns about hidden confounding factors in speech-based health datasets. We systematically investigate whether similar biases exist across five widely used clinical speech corpora: DAIC-WoZ (depression), TORGO (dysarthria), Neurovoz (PD), MDVR-KCL (PD), and UCLASS (stuttering). For each dataset, we compare classification using the first second of audio, silent segments, and full recordings, and evaluate both raw and denoised signals. Across all datasets, silence-only classification frequently matched or exceeded full-audio performance, suggesting that classification performance may be influenced by dataset-specific confounds in addition to disorder-related speech characteristics. These findings question the reliability and generalisability of speech-based biomarkers and call for stricter methodological reporting, preprocessing transparency, and bias mitigation.

Comment
Accepted by IEEE SLT 2026

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Acoustic Biomarkers for Alzheimer's Disease Detection from Spontaneous Speech

eess.AS cs.LGcs.SD ·2026-09-30 ·Anh L Tran, Arjee Javellana Restar, Bereket Kindo
similarity 0.70
Abstract

Alzheimer's disease (AD) remains a major public health challenge, and early identification is crucial for timely intervention and care planning. Recent work has shown that speech-based digital biomarkers can capture subtle changes in vocal production, prosody, and timing that often precede or accompany cognitive decline. In this study, we investigate whether acoustic features extracted from spontaneous speech can reliably distinguish individuals with AD from healthy controls. Using a structured speech dataset derived from the Cookie Theft picture-description task, we extract clinically informative low-level descriptors spanning prosodic, spectral, and temporal domains, and evaluate a range of machine learning classifiers. Our results indicate that acoustic biomarkers carry strong discriminative value, with the best-performing models achieving clinically meaningful separation between diagnostic groups. These findings support the use of non-invasive, low-cost audio-based screening tools and motivate further work on multimodal and longitudinal assessment frameworks for dementia risk detection.

0.29

Cleaner Speech, Weaker Generalization: Revisiting Pitt-Derived Benchmarks for Alzheimer's Disease Detection

cs.SD cs.AI ·2026-08-31 ·Luqi Sun, Shreeram Suresh Chandra, Lin Zhang, You-Jin Li, Brian MacWhinney +3 more
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Speech-based Alzheimer's disease (AD) detection increasingly relies on speech-enhanced and curated versions of the Pitt Corpus, where speech enhancement, sample selection, and demographic balancing are often treated as beneficial preprocessing steps. However, whether these transformations improve real-world AD detection or instead affect model generalization and prediction behavior remains unclear. In this work, we revisit the role of speech preprocessing and dataset curation across widely used benchmarks for speech-based AD detection. We evaluate the speech quality of different datasets, the cross-dataset generalization of multiple deep learning models under matched and mismatched enhancement settings, and the behavior of several recent large audio-language models (LALMs). Experimental results show that across multiple supervised speech models, speech-enhanced datasets often improve in-domain performance while reducing robustness in cross-domain evaluation. Matched enhancement between training and test data alleviates, but does not eliminate, this degradation. LALMs show a similar sensitivity: enhanced datasets induce stronger class imbalance and prediction shifts than unprocessed data. These results suggest that speech preprocessing and dataset curation can substantially influence downstream AD detection behavior, indicating that ``cleaner'' speech datasets are not necessarily more reliable for real-world AD detection.

0.22

Disentangling Depression from Cognitive Decline in Elderly Speech Using Concurrent Clinical Assessments

eess.AS cs.AIcs.CLcs.SD ·2026-10-15 ·Woori Jeon, Seunghee Ha, Sang-Kyu Lee, Ji Hye Yoon, Tae-Jin Yoon +3 more
top venue similarity 0.65
Abstract · 6 pages, 5 tables, accepted to Interspeech 2026

Detecting depression from speech in elderly patients with mild cognitive impairment (MCI) is complicated by overlapping acoustic effects of cognitive decline. Without disentangling these, classifiers risk learning cognitive rather than depression-specific patterns. We present a Korean elderly speech corpus of 89 MCI speakers collected over three years with concurrent depression (SGDS) and cognitive (MMSE) assessments. Both linear mixed-effects models and partial correlations identify the same pattern: of seven feature groups, only formant features are associated with depression after controlling for cognitive function, while widely used F0 features carry no signal. The F1+F2 subset achieves UAR 0.760 with just 12 features, outperforming both the full eGeMAPS baseline and self-supervised representations. These findings show that concurrent clinical assessments can identify interpretable, depression-specific acoustic markers in populations where cognitive and affective symptoms co-occur.

0.29

Beyond Decodability: Do Acoustic Factors Drive Predictions in Speech-Based Alzheimer's Assessment?

cs.SD cs.CLcs.LGeess.AS ·2026-10-01 ·Serli Kopar, Alkis Koudounas, Roshan P. Rane, Sam Gijsen, Paula A. Perez-Toro +1 more
position similarity 0.64
Abstract

Speech-based Alzheimer's disease (AD) assessments increasingly rely on pretrained self-supervised learning (SSL) models that learn acoustic representations directly from raw audio, exposing the model to recording factors. We ask whether such factors are merely encoded in SSL representations or can systematically alter predictions. Using ADReSSo and three large SSL backbones, we apply controlled noise and reverberation interventions to participant-speech-only, non-speech, and full-recording audio. We combine layer-wise linear decoding, input- and representation-space interventions, and geometric alignment analysis to distinguish acoustic decodability from influence on AD prediction. Our results show that controlled acoustic interventions alter AD predictions across all three SSL backbones. Noise, despite showing no significant diagnostic-group difference in the original data, produces the strongest intervention effects. Importantly, these effects are systematically structured relative to the classifier's decision direction, replicate on the held-out test set and reverse when the representation-space intervention direction is reversed. Together, these findings show that high predictive performance and the absence of a significant diagnostic-group difference in a measured acoustic factor are not sufficient for robustness. We argue that intervention-based robustness tests should become standard for trustworthy clinical speech models.

0.13

Why Alzheimer's Speech Screening Fails to Generalize: Bridging the Deployment Gap via Cross-Corpus Evidence Anchoring

eess.AS cs.CLcs.SD ·2026-09-25 ·Zijian Lu, Sizhe Liu, Yin Zhang, Jixuan Deng, Xinrong Lin +4 more
published similarity 0.62
Abstract · Accepted to NCMMSC 2026

Speech-based screening is a promising, non-invasive approach for detecting Alzheimer's disease and related cognitive risks. However, models trained on a single domain often generalize poorly to unseen languages, tasks, or recording protocols. This paper investigates this deployment gap using a leave-one-corpus-out evaluation across four distinct datasets. Among 70 interpretable speech and language features, 59 exhibit direction conflicts between healthy control and cognitive risk groups across corpora, with pause, silence, and speech rate showing high protocol sensitivity. Furthermore, while the XLM-R text baseline achieves strong average performance, its Area Under the ROC Curve (AUC) drops to 0.520 on the weakest held-out domain. A standard GroupDRO baseline reaches a 0.766 mean speaker AUC and a 0.504 worst-domain AUC under the same protocol. To address this, we propose a fusion method that integrates XLM-R text baseline scores with evidence anchors selected during training. Balanced fusion achieves a 0.785 mean speaker AUC, while anchor-heavy fusion raises the worst-case speaker AUC to 0.615. This work highlights the need to audit feature transferability and report worst-case domain robustness in cognitive speech screening.

0.28

Towards clinical adoption of voice and speech as measures of health: the need for harmonization

cs.ET cs.SD ·2026-09-24 ·Nicholas Cummins, Vikram Ramanarayanan, Daniel Low, Fabio Catania, Si-Ioi Ng +7 more
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Speech and voice are multidimensional signals that capture both communicative intent and underlying physiological processes, providing a unique, non-invasive window into health. Analyzing these signals has the potential to yield digital biomarkers that (i) provide scalable, objective measurement tools for research and clinical care and (ii) reflect the presence or progression of diverse conditions, including neurological, psychiatric, respiratory, and cardiovascular disorders. Realizing this promise, however, requires the field to overcome pervasive reproducibility and generalizability issues due to heterogeneous data collection, processing, and analysis practices. A major source of this heterogeneity is how underlying acoustic measures themselves are defined and computed. In this paper, we outline key considerations across the speech biomarker discovery lifecycle, from data collection through machine learning modeling to clinical interpretation, needed to achieve reliable, reproducible, and clinically translatable results. Chief among these is the need for harmonization efforts to start from common, precisely specified measure definitions. As a first step, we therefore provide definitions, physiological correlates, and computational implementations for a minimal, clinically interpretable set of core speech measures spanning respiration, phonation, articulation, and fluency. We close by discussing ongoing standardization efforts and the open challenges that remain in advancing the adoption of speech- and voice-based digital biomarkers.

0.08

Audio Preprocessing Effects on Stuttering Detection: A Class-Specific Analysis

eess.AS cs.SD ·2026-09-26 ·Anisha Pattanayak, Hanie Kang, Huang-Cheng Chou, Sudarsana Reddy Kadiri
hot direction similarity 0.61
Abstract

Audio preprocessing can affect how well a system detects stuttering. We study a simulated chain of denoising,loudness normalisation, Opus coding, and voice activity detection on SEP-28k. We use frozen WavLM Base+ features and report pointwise confidence intervals from episode-level bootstrap resampling. At a fixed threshold of 0.5, the chain reduces block F1 from 0.638 to 0.465, with smaller decreases for the other four classes. ROC-AUC decreases for all five classes. Blocks show the largest F1 and ROC-AUC losses, while sound repetitions show the largest average precision loss. Tuning the threshold on processed validation audio raises block F1 to 0.630. Retraining on processed audio with threshold tuning gives 0.628. Threshold adjustment therefore accounts for most of the observed block F1 recovery. It does not change ROC-AUC, which retraining raises only from 0.620 to 0.633, compared with 0.724 on clean audio.

0.35

Improved automatic speech-based cognitive assessment using neuropsychologically calibrated diagnostic labels

cs.SD ·2026-10-20 ·Madhurananda Pahar, Caitlin Illingworth, Adam Hampshire, Peter J Hellyer, Agata J Hampshire +3 more
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Although automatic detection of cognitive impairment from conversational speech is a promising way, it becomes less accurate, as large real-world datasets often contain unreliable diagnostic labels due to self-referral and limited clinical verification, and here we investigated whether neuropsychologically calibrated diagnostic relabeling improves it. We analysed 138 hours of conversational speech from 720 participants, recalibrating unreliable diagnostic labels using attention, executive function, and memory performance via external clinical thresholds, Gaussian, and normative z-score calibration. Transformer-based classifiers were trained using both original and recalibrated labels and evaluated internally on 150 clinically verified participants and externally on Pitt, ADReSS and PROCESS-2 datasets. Memory- and MoCA-based z-score calibration produced the greatest improvements. Using our internal dataset, $F_1$ increased from $0.70$ to $0.83$ ($+13\%$) and from $0.54$ to $0.66$ ($+12\%$) for binary and multiclass classification, respectively. For external validation, the increases are $+4\%$, $+5\%$ and $+9\%$ on Pitt, ADReSS and PROCESS-2 corpus. Neuropsychologically calibrated relabeling substantially improves speech-based cognitive assessment, highlighting label quality, rather than model architecture, as a critical bottleneck in clinical AI for dementia screening.

0.25