CS Paper Radar

When Should Robots Intervene? Balancing Engagement and Intrusiveness in Human-Robot Interaction

Lavinia Hriscu, Valerio Bo, Alberto Sanfeliu, Anaís Garrell

cs.RO ·submitted 2026-09-18 13:14 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

Designing effective Human-Robot Interaction in task-oriented settings requires carefully balancing user engagement with socially acceptable levels of robot intrusiveness. In this paper, we examine how different robot intervention strategies shape user experience, interaction dynamics, perceived intrusiveness, and sense of support. We compare two approaches: a continuous engagement-seeking robot strategy, and a context-aware strategy that selectively intervenes based on the user's state and task context. Both approaches rely on multimodal behavioral cues, including body orientation and attentional signals, to guide robot actions. We evaluate these strategies in a user study with 32 participants performing a task in a simulated hospital environment. Our findings show that higher interaction frequency does not necessarily lead to better engagement. Instead, we observe a systematic trade-off between perceived support and intrusiveness, influenced by factors such as physical proximity and user effort. These results provide empirical evidence that effective engagement in HRI depends on adaptive, context-sensitive intervention policies.

Comment
Accepted for publication at the 35th IEEE International Conference on Robot and Human Interactive Communication (RO-MAN 2026)

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Understanding Engagement and Intrusiveness in Assistive Human-Robot Interaction Using Individual Traits

cs.RO ·2026-09-18 ·Valerio Bo, Lavinia Hriscu, Alberto Sanfeliu, Anaís Garrell
publishedposition similarity 0.84
Abstract · Accepted for publication at the 35th IEEE International Conference on Robot and Human Interactive Communication (RO-MAN 2026)

Robot assistance is particularly crucial in unfamiliar tasks, where users must understand task requirements while coordinating with the robot. Previous research offers mixed evidence on the role of robot proxemics in user engagement: some studies suggest closer proximity enhances interaction, while others report it can feel intrusive. In this work, we argue that perceptions of intrusiveness depend not only on proxemics but also on the frequency of robot interventions, and are strongly influenced by individual traits such as personality and demographics. We conducted an experiment with 32 participants who interacted with two assistive robots that provided similar task support but differed in their intervention strategies. Results indicate that overall engagement remains stable across conditions, yet affective responses and perceived intrusiveness vary significantly with personality traits. Moreover, personality shapes interaction dynamics differently depending on the robot's behavior. These findings emphasize that effective human-robot interaction should account for individual differences, tailoring robot behavior to maintain engagement while respecting each user's unique affective and behavioral profile.

0.41

CALM: Configuration-Aware Human Intervention Boundaries During Robot Approach

cs.RO cs.HC ·2026-09-07 ·Xinting Gao, Sipu Zhu, Weimin Zhuang
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 22 pages, 12 figures

How robot body configuration shapes human intervention during approach remains underexplored. We conducted a within-participants study with 41 participants, measuring final stopping distance, subjective comfort, and exploratory eye-tracking responses across four humanoid arm configurations and two spatial scales. Full forward arm extension increased stopping distance by approximately 31-36 cm relative to arms-down. Spatial scale primarily affected comfort and pupil responses without a detectable stopping-distance shift. We introduce the Configuration-Aware Limit Model (CALM), which translates stopping-distance distributions into configuration-dependent population-coverage boundaries. Estimated boundaries at 80% coverage ranged from 0.88 to 1.47 m. In an illustrative one-dimensional planning analysis, reconfiguration enabled a 1.10 m approach goal that was unreachable with arms remaining fully extended under the same nominal pointwise 20% intervention-probability constraint. These findings support treating body configuration as a planning variable while distinguishing physical safety, behavioral intervention, and subjective cost.

0.29

HEIR: Harness Egocentric Intent for Human-Robot Interactions

cs.RO ·2026-11-12 ·Yichi Zhang, Bo Wang, Zhenghan Zhu, Yutong Han, Jiayin Zou +9 more
code/data similarity 0.67
Abstract

For robots to assist, serve, and collaborate with humans, they must not only interpret human requests conveyed through language and multimodal intentional cues, but also execute long-horizon tasks that interleave navigation and manipulation. In this paper, we introduce HEIR, a resource for studying how to Harness Egocentric Intent for Human-Robot Interaction. HEIR pairs human speech, measured gaze, and egocentric video with robot observations and teleoperated navigation-manipulation trajectories, while each session preserves successive episodes, with each request fulfilled through multiple execution subtasks. The captured data, together with human-authored annotations, support the study of intent grounding, execution planning, and task completion within a unified interaction setting. To demonstrate the value of HEIR, we conduct extensive offline experiments to evaluate how models benefit from additional human-centric context across these tasks, together with real-robot experiments that assess execution task completion. HEIR thus provides a valuable resource for studying user-centric robot interaction in naturalistic household environments. Our demo and dataset are available online.

0.18

RobotEQ 3.0: Towards Personalized Social Proactive Intelligence in Embodied Agents

cs.HC ·2026-09-29 ·Shufan Zhang, Xinyi Che, Kuofei Fang, Xuehao Wang, Liyi Liu +6 more
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract

Social Proactive Intelligence (SPI) is an emerging research area, aiming to shift embodied agents from reactive assistance toward proactively understanding human needs and executing socially desirable actions. Prior work has largely centered on the average user. However, human expectations are inherently diverse, and prior work overlooks individual nuances. To bridge this gap, we introduce RobotEQ 3.0, a benchmark for Personalized SPI. (Dataset) We first profile participants via a structured questionnaire covering factors that are correlated with human expectations of embodied agents, such as basic demographics and personality traits. Participants then select their preferred actions from a set of candidates. Unlike prior SPI benchmarks that focus on assessing behavioral appropriateness, our task centers on predicting the actions preferred by a specific user, thereby capturing human subjectivity. The resulting dataset establishes explicit links between individual traits and behavioral preferences. (Solution) We observe substantial inter-annotator variance, confirming that user preferences over actions are highly individualized. This motivates our exploration of Personalized SPI, in which user traits serve as additional inputs to predict individual preferences. Experimental results show that incorporating user traits can aid personalized prediction. This work aims to shift the research paradigm from developing agents suited for the average user to designing systems tailored to specific individuals.

0.18

Robots That Take Initiative: A Framework for Building and Evaluating Proactive Robots

cs.RO cs.AI ·2026-09-24 ·Maithili Patel, Sonia Chernova
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Effective robot assistance beyond narrow roles and repetitive tasks requires robots to be proactive - to decide what needs to be done rather than waiting to be told. While proactivity is increasingly explored, it lacks a unified formulation, and work in the domain is typically evaluated offline against static human models that cannot capture the effect of a robot's actions on the environment and the user's own behavior. We introduce a unified formalism for proactive robot assistance, organize it into three levels, and provide a framework to address the highest level of unprompted proactive assistance. We then show that offline evaluation overstates performance in this setting, and contribute a closed-loop evaluation with a human model that adapts to the robot. Finally, we present a method, GAP, that instantiates our framework, learning from passive observation to anticipate user goals and act. Under closed-loop evaluation, prior state-of-the-art methods collapse, in some cases adding more work than they save, while GAP remains robust and substantially outperforms them.

0.22

Exploring Mixed Reality for Engagement in Robotics: A Comparison of Robot Control Methods

cs.HC ·2026-10-12 ·Samantha Edvell, Dinh Tung Le, Gavin Paul
similarity 0.64
Abstract · 10 pages. Submitted to ACRA 2026

This paper presents a Mixed Reality (MR) robotics experience that provides an accessible introduction to interacting with a physical robot. The application combines a TurtleBot with a virtual animal-tending activity and three control methods: Joystick, Waypoint, and Path-Drawing. A mixed-methods user study with 10 participants investigated changes in robotics interest and confidence following the experience and how the control methods influenced engagement, workload, and preference. Confidence increased following the experience, with the exploratory analysis indicating a significant pre--post difference, while the increase in interest was not statistically significant. The control methods produced clear differences in perceived workload and ease of use, with Path-Drawing generally more demanding and difficult to use. Joystick was preferred by eight of ten participants and was associated with better perceived performance and lower frustration. However, no statistically significant differences were detected in the other engagement dimensions, suggesting that the most preferred method was not necessarily more engaging across all aspects of the experience. These findings highlight the importance of considering both usability and engagement when designing how users interact with robots in introductory MR experiences.

0.23

Locomotion Variability and User Experience in Smart Wheelchair Human-Robot Interaction

cs.RO cs.HCeess.SY ·2026-08-11 ·Sean Kille, Adina M. Panchea, Balint Varga, Sören Hohmann
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 15 pages, 7 figures

Human movement is inherently variable, with variability structured according to task relevance: movements are typically more consistent at task-critical points and more flexible elsewhere. In human-robot interaction (HRI), however, model-based assistance strategies commonly assume deterministic human behavior and suppress such variability, potentially altering how interactions are experienced and lowering sense of agency. While movement variability is increasingly recognized as functionally meaningful, its deliberate preservation in assisted interaction, and its consequences for user experience, remain underexplored. In this paper, we empirically investigate how different assistance strategies shape human movement variability, task performance, and subjective interaction experience in a shared control setting. We introduce an autonomy-supportive shared control strategy that preserves users' natural movement structure. This approach is evaluated in a user study in which participants push an intelligent powered wheelchair under three conditions: no assistance, conventional variability-reducing assistance, and variability-preserving assistance. While task-relevant performance remained comparable across assisted modes, preserving natural movement variability led to more favorable interaction experiences. In particular, participants reported significantly higher perceived agency compared to conventional assistance and highest perceived usefulness. These findings suggest that variability-aware assistance can support both performance and user autonomy in physical human-robot collaboration. More broadly, the results highlight the importance of designing assistive robotic systems that respect the embodied structure of human movement rather than treating variability as noise to be neglected or eliminated.

0.10

Toward User-Mediated Self-Repair in Ubiquitous Robots Through Goal-Oriented Agentic AI

cs.AI cs.RO ·2026-08-11 ·Morten Roed Frederiksen
top venue similarity 0.63
Abstract · Preprint submitted version, 8 pages

Ubiquitous robotic systems often lack traditional visual interfaces, necessitating resilient natural language interaction for maintenance and repair tasks. This paper presents a goal oriented agentic AI architecture designed to enable non-expert users to perform technical repairs through situated dialogue. The framework utilizes a multi-layered approach that decouples high-level strategic planning from reactive conversational execution to transform unconstrained human instructions into a structured hierarchy of goals. We conducted a study involving twenty participants to evaluate the system's efficacy using a physical hardware testbed. The architecture achieved a 95\% task completion rate, and participants reported positive self-efficacy following real-time guidance that adapted to conversational diversions and linguistic variations. A comparative analysis with an online baseline revealed that the transition to a physical environment significantly decreased perceived social presence (p=.0005), and trust and competence, (p=.037), while the agentic framework remained robust throughout the interaction. These findings indicate that goal oriented agentic AI can support the sustainability of body-worn technologies by empowering users to perform critical maintenance in ubiquitous contexts.

0.40