CS Paper Radar

Beyond Kinematics: Benchmarking Simulation Fidelity for Muscle-Driven Imitation Learning

Ayah G. Ahmad, Claire E. Borden, Maegan Tucker

cs.LG cs.RO ·submitted 2026-09-18 15:34 UTC · v1
hot direction

Abstract

In this work, we conduct a systematic comparison of two state-of-the-art motion-imitation reinforcement learning (MIRL) pipelines, one built on SCONE/HyFyDy and one built on MuJoCo/MyoSim. HyFyDy emphasizes physiological realism through detailed musculotendon modeling, while MuJoCo prioritizes computational efficiency and scalable policy learning. While recent work has demonstrated that both pipelines reproduce human kinematics with high fidelity, it remains unclear if they accurately capture the underlying neuromuscular behavior that produced the movement. This limitation is particularly important for robotic assistive-device design and control, where outcome measures such as muscle activation patterns and metabolic cost are often used as optimization targets. To conduct a systematic comparison, our work compares both pipelines using a common set of human motion-capture and electromyography (EMG) measurements. The results find that while both pipelines produce similar kinematics with relative accuracy, the muscle activations from HyFyDy are more aligned with the experimental EMG, as supported by the average pooled (RMSE, r) values for muscle activations from HyFyDy and MuJoCo: (0.164, 0.4) and (0.344, 0.11), respectively. While we conclude that the more advanced physiological realism of HyFyDy currently makes it more suitable for musculoskeletal modeling, both require further development to bring physiological realism to GPU-parallelizable simulation environments and advance robotic assistive device design.

Comment
8 pages, 5 figures, 2 tables, submitted to ICRA 2027

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

A generalist policy for muscle-driven control across individual musculoskeletal models

cs.RO ·2026-10-27 ·Bozhao Wang, Yinglei Zhu, Zhengqing Li, Zhiyuan Zhang, Weiming Kang +5 more
similarity 0.71
Abstract · 17 pages, 7 figures. Project website: https://woodater-thu.github.io/MyoAcross/ Bozhao Wang and Yinglei Zhu contributed equally to this work

Differences in musculoskeletal morphology challenge policy reuse across individual models. Here we present MyoAcross, a framework that combines individual musculoskeletal model construction, morphology-conditioned policy learning and virtual model augmentation to enable muscle-driven reference-motion tracking without individual fine-tuning. Across 31 held-out individual models, MyoAcross achieves 99.24% completion and reduces tracking error by 22.60% relative to an unconditioned multilayer perceptron. Policy reuse extends to models of 22 held-out individuals constructed from single-image shape estimates, measured height and body mass, and, with asymmetry augmentation, to models with unilateral lower-limb shortening. Comparisons with measurements from 120 additional individuals show agreement in vertical ground reaction force waveforms and channel-dependent agreement between simulated muscle activations and electromyography. These results establish a common control framework for comparative simulations of movement across individual musculoskeletal models.

0.38

MSK-Bench: Benchmarking Full-Body Musculoskeletal Motor Control Across Tasks, Control Paradigms, and Physiological Metrics

cs.RO ·2026-09-22 ·Mengtao Ou, Zongzheng Zhang, Zhenghao Xiao, Yixuan Pan, Ziwen Zhuang +5 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.70
Abstract · Project page: https://zzongzheng0918.github.io/MSK-Bench/

Musculoskeletal (MSK) humanoids provide a physiologically grounded embodiment for studying full-body motor control, but their high-dimensional muscle actuation, delayed activation dynamics, and redundant muscle--tendon structures make learning substantially harder than torque-driven humanoid control. Existing MSK benchmarks remain fragmented across gait, prosthetics, dexterous hands, or challenge-specific tracks, leaving full-body muscle-actuated control insufficiently evaluated under standardized tasks, methods, and metrics. We introduce MSK-Bench, a benchmark of 22 full-body motor-control tasks organized into three progressively challenging categories: postural stabilization, common locomotor behaviors, and contact-rich environmental interaction. Under unified task protocols and robustness perturbations, MSK-Bench evaluates 5 representative control paradigms, including reward-based RL, agentic reward tuning, latent-action RL, imitation-prior control, and residual adaptation over imitation priors. Beyond task success and reward, MSK-Bench further reports robustness analysis and physiology-oriented diagnostics, including activation cost, joint smoothness, and EMG-envelope similarity. Our empirical study shows that embodiment-aware exploration and structured action representations improve task coverage in high-dimensional muscle spaces, imitation priors enhance reference-compatible stabilization and locomotion but degrade under contact-rich terrain mismatch, and residual adaptation can recover successful behaviors when fixed references fail. We further find that improved task success does not necessarily imply improved physiological agreement, highlighting the importance of evaluating task performance, robustness, and physiological behavior jointly. MSK-Bench provides a task--method--metric testbed for full-body muscle-actuated humanoid control.

0.34

Burden, Bounty, or Bliss? Muscle-Aware Retargeting and Null-Space Exploration for Whole-Body Musculoskeletal Control

cs.RO ·2026-11-07 ·Ruiyang Kong, Takeshi Oishi
benchmark similarity 0.68
Abstract · 9 pages, 4 figures, 4 tables. Submitted to IEEE ICRA 2027

Learning whole-body musculoskeletal control from human motion is important for developing human-like robots, assistive devices, and rehabilitation systems. This task presents two main challenges, namely reference trajectories that are kinematically plausible but difficult to reproduce through muscle-driven dynamics, and a highly redundant 700-dimensional action space in which unstructured exploration can easily disrupt the target motion. In this paper, we propose a motion-to-policy pipeline that exploits muscle redundancy in two complementary stages. First, muscle-aware retargeting (MAR) performs bounded adaptation of kinematic trajectories subject to hard semantic, anatomical, and contact constraints. We motivate the constraint bounds by analyzing how reference-trajectory artifacts affect muscle-driven tracking. Second, null-space exploration (NSE) estimates a one-control-frame mapping from muscle excitations to generalized forces and injects bounded, anatomically structured perturbations along its null space into the actions of a value-guided flow policy. On a 24-clip motion-capture benchmark, MAR and NSE together solve every reference, reach the full horizon with half the samples of the baseline pipeline, and lower joint-center error by 44% without late collapse. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first end-to-end pipeline that transforms monocular video into a trained whole-body imitation policy controlling 700 muscles.

0.13

ImpedanceMimic: Learned Impedance as Action Space for Force-Accurate Motion Imitation

cs.RO cs.GRcs.LG ·2026-11-14 ·Matthias Jammot, Pembe Gizem Özdil
code/data similarity 0.67
Abstract · 39 pages, 13 figures, 28 tables. Project page: https://impedancemimic.github.io/ImpedanceMimic/

Recovering the forces behind a motion is ill-posed: different controllers can reproduce the same movement while generating different contact forces. Physics-based motion imitation resolves this ambiguity through simulation, but relies on fixed-gain proportional-derivative (PD) control. We show that fixed gains impose a trade-off between motion and force tracking, as contact and swing place conflicting demands on joint stiffness and damping. We introduce ImpedanceMimic, a reinforcement-learning policy that modulates per-joint stiffness, damping, and position setpoints from motion and force measurements, but requires only motion at inference. Across 129 participants and six activities, ImpedanceMimic outperforms matched fixed-gain PD under every integration scheme, direct-torque, muscle-actuated and existing imitation controllers in kinematic and force fidelity, approaching a dedicated motion-to-force regressor. By expressing gains as multiples of inertia-scaled priors, a single policy controls subject-specific biomechanical models without explicit anthropometric input and transfers zero-shot to unseen humans and a humanoid robot. The learned impedance forms a low-dimensional representation of motor state, shared across bodies, that generalizes to withheld activities: stiffness scales with load, and damping anticipates unloading.

0.17

RLMuscle: Muscle-Driven Character Animation via Reinforcement Learning

cs.GR ·2026-10-21 ·Chunlei Li, Siyuan Yu, Yang Gao, Shuai Li, Peng Yu +2 more
code/data similarity 0.67
Abstract · 12 pages. Project page: https://chunleili.github.io/project-page-rlmuscle/

Body deformation caused by muscle contraction plays a vital role in the visual realism of character animation, yet in most 3D animation pipelines artists have to manually specify muscle activations, which is time-consuming and gives no guarantee of physical realism. To address this, we propose a new method in which a reinforcement learning (RL) controller discovers per-muscle activations that track reference motions without manual tuning. Existing RL muscle controllers stop at 1D muscles; we go one step further, keeping the 1D model inside the RL control loop as a fast surrogate, and using a 3D volumetric simulation to produce the final deformation. Because both stages share the very same constitutive law, the muscle deformation is produced by the same activations that generated the motion. We further add a measured electromyography (EMG) prior that steers the redundant activation solution toward real human muscle recruitment. To achieve stable, efficient, and realistic simulation, we propose a novel geometric multigrid for Extended Position-Based Dynamics (XPBD) that is built on a coarse tetrahedral cage with barycentric-coordinate prolongation and closes a V-cycle on tetrahedral meshes. Within this GPU-parallelized solver, we inject the same Hill-type force-length law as an energy-based fiber constraint that turns per-fiber activation into realistic muscle contraction and bulging. We demonstrate volumetric muscle simulation on a 194-muscle human body with a diverse set of motions (walk, kick, swim, overhead-squat, etc.), simulating the full-body model at 18 ms per frame on a single RTX 4090. Our work takes a step toward character animation that is not only visually convincing but also biomechanically grounded. The website with code and videos is at https://chunleili.github.io/project-page-rlmuscle/.

0.41

Reflex-Informed Neuromuscular Reinforcement Learning for Muscle-Driven Locomotion

cs.RO cs.GRcs.LG ·2026-09-10 ·Jian Zhou, Xingyu Zhang, Rui Ma, Yu Cao, Shane Xie +1 more
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 28 pages, 13 figures, and 9 tables

Muscle-driven locomotion provides a physically grounded approach to generating realistic human movement. However, achieving both physiological plausibility and adaptability to changes in musculoskeletal capacity and external disturbances remains a fundamental challenge. To address this limitation, we propose a Reflex-Informed Neuromuscular Reinforcement Learning framework for muscle-driven locomotion. Within this framework, a fixed phase-dependent reflex controller serves as the underlying neuromuscular control mechanism, while the reinforcement learning policy produces four biomechanically meaningful residual parameters to modulate key reflex gains and thresholds associated with hip swing, knee support, and ankle propulsion according to the current state. Experimental results demonstrate that the proposed framework generates physiologically plausible locomotion with improved kinematic accuracy and dynamic consistency, as well as better bilateral symmetry and stride-to-stride consistency under nominal walking conditions. The learned policy remains robust under muscle weakness and external perturbations without retraining.

0.47

LocoMuJoCo: A Comprehensive Imitation Learning Benchmark for Whole-Body Control

cs.RO ·2026-11-19 ·Firas Al-Hafez, Davide Tateo, Oleg Kaidanov, Aditya Bhatt, Artur Zelik +2 more
benchmarkcode/datapopular code similarity 0.65
Abstract · 26 pages, 11 figures, 4 tables. Code: https://github.com/robfiras/loco-mujoco

LocoMuJoCo is an open-source benchmark for imitation learning (IL) and reinforcement learning (RL) on whole-body control. The library couples MuJoCo (CPU) with MJX and the MjWarp backend (GPU) under a single API, exposes 9 humanoid, 3 (musculo-)skeletal, and 4 quadruped embodiments, and ships a curated native motion-capture dataset for every humanoid, to which it can also retarget AMASS and LAFAN1. A modular plug-in architecture makes observations, rewards, control modes, terrains, and domain randomization fully interchangeable, while compact JAX implementations of many RL and IL algorithms provide JIT-compiled end-to-end training, and the companion loco-mujoco-real repository provides sim-to-real deployment. We describe the design, the SMPL-to-robot and robot-to-robot retargeting pipeline, and a usage example. LocoMuJoCo is released under MIT at https://github.com/robfiras/loco-mujoco.

0.57

FOCUS: First-Order Control Using Optimal Transport Supervision for Imitation from Observations

cs.LG cs.RO ·2026-10-30 ·João A. Cândido Ramos, Lionel Blondé, Hugues Vinzant, Jacopo Castellini, Alexandros Kalousis
published similarity 0.64
Abstract · Accepted at the NeurIPS 2026 Workshop on Physical Understanding for Decision-Making

Imitation learning from observations must recover behavior from state-only demonstrations without known temporal correspondence. Differentiable simulators provide pathwise policy gradients, but differentiating through long, contact-rich trajectories can make optimization unstable. We introduce FOCUS, which combines local optimal-transport alignment with short-horizon differentiable actor-critic learning. FOCUS matches agent rollout windows to multiple sampled expert segments using a soft best-of-$K$ objective that emphasizes locally compatible matches. The resulting transport-based costs provide differentiable imitation rewards, while a learned critic bootstraps value beyond the rollout horizon. FOCUS requires neither temporally aligned trajectories nor expert-aligned initialization or teacher forcing. Across contact-rich locomotion tasks in DFlex, including a musculoskeletal humanoid controlled by 152 muscle activations, FOCUS improves sample efficiency and training stability over adversarial imitation-from-observation methods and prior differentiable imitation baselines.

0.26