CS Paper Radar

Setting the clock: Evaluating temporal window parameters for coordinated behavior detection

Georgios Panayiotou, Lorenzo Mannocci, Maurizio Tesconi

cs.SI ·submitted 2026-09-18 16:16 UTC · v1

Abstract

Coordinated behavior is a central mechanism of online collective action. On social media platforms, it can support legitimate mobilization, but it can also be exploited in disinformation campaigns, astroturfing, and information operations. Detecting coordinated behavior on social media platforms typically relies on coordination networks, where users are linked when they perform similar actions within shared temporal windows. While the temporal window is central to how coordination is operationalized, it is often treated as an implementation detail rather than as a substantive modeling decision. This paper presents a first analysis of how two key temporal parameters, window length and stride, affect the detection of coordinated communities within information operation campaigns. We find that window length determines which coordination patterns are detectable, while window stride has negligible effect on precision and recall. Our analysis highlights selecting appropriate temporal window parameters as an open methodological challenge requiring careful treatment.

Comment
Accepted as a full paper at the AIDEM Workshop, ECMLPKDD 2026

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Optimal and heuristic strategies for evaluating the influence of coordinated behavior in information cascades and retweet networks

cs.SI cs.CY ·2026-09-21 ·Niccolò Di Marco, Matteo Cinelli, Shinichi Nakano, Andrea Frosini
theory similarity 0.66
Abstract

Coordinated Inauthentic Behavior (CIB) has become a major concern in online social platforms, yet its actual impact on information diffusion remains poorly understood. Existing research has primarily focused on detecting coordinated activity, while comparatively little attention has been devoted to quantifying its influence once detected. In this work, we introduce two complementary frameworks for the post-hoc evaluation of coordinated accounts. First, we formulate the problem on information cascades as a constrained influence maximization problem over directed trees and develop a polynomial-time dynamic programming algorithm that computes the optimal placement of coordinated nodes, providing an upper bound on their achievable influence. Second, motivated by the limited availability of diffusion cascades in real-world platforms, we propose a network-based framework that estimates influence directly from retweet networks using the independent cascade model and compares the observed placement of coordinated accounts against established heuristic baselines. We evaluate both approaches on Twitter/X data from the 2019 UK General Election and on a collection of verified state-backed information operation campaigns spanning multiple countries. While coordinated accounts exhibit limited influence in the UK cascades, the network-based analysis reveals substantial differences across campaigns, with several operations achieving influence comparable to or exceeding that of structurally central seed sets. Finally, by reconstructing cascades from the retweet networks, we show that the two frameworks produce consistent results, suggesting that the observed effects reflect intrinsic structural properties of coordinated activity rather than artifacts of the underlying methodology.

0.28

Why Does Misinformation Propagate Faster? An Algorithmic Perspective on X

cs.SI cs.LGecon.GN ·2026-09-24 ·Pan Li, Shuang Gao
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Misinformation is widely reported to propagate faster on engagement-based platforms, yet prior work largely focused on empirical analysis, without identifying a specific algorithmic mechanism that results in this phenomenon. Thanks to the open-sourcing of X's recommendation algorithms, we conduct what is, to our knowledge, the first component-level study of the recommendation algorithm deployed by a social media platform, which examines how each of its components affects misinformation propagation. Specifically, we identify the engagement fungibility mechanism in the algorithm, where the final recommendation score is constructed as a weighted sum of all predicted user activities. As a result, a tweet can be repeatedly recommended simply because it is predicted to draw many instant reactions (e.g., likes and retweets), even when it is not expected to draw thoughtful responses (e.g., replies and quotes). Since misinformation typically draws a larger share of its engagement from instant reactions, this mechanism enables it to receive more recommendation exposure and to propagate faster. To empirically validate this mechanism, we re-implement X's recommendation algorithm on the USC X 2024 election corpus, and build a calibrated simulation study to analyze the impact of different scoring rules. We find that re-tuning the metric weights has little or even a negative impact on reducing the credibility exposure gap, while those scoring rules that set a precondition of thoughtful engagement for amplification would be able to alleviate the gap significantly, across 46 robustness checks. Our diagnosis, therefore, yields a simple and deployable fix, a reflective-threshold gate that withholds amplification until a tweet is predicted to draw thoughtful engagement, which we find to reallocate exposure away from low-credibility content at no cost to mainstream exposure and with no loss of engagement.

0.23

Birds of a Feather Flock Together: Network-Based Detection of Coordinated Disinformation Campaigns on Telegram

cs.SI cs.CY ·2026-09-22 ·Panteleimon Tsagkarakis, Emmanouil Papadogiannakis, Evangelos Markatos
published similarity 0.64
Abstract

In recent years, disinformation has increasingly proliferated across social networks. The firing of fact-checkers from Meta and the disbanding of Twitter's Trust and Safety Council suggest that this trend will continue to escalate. While disinformation sources (e.g., social network accounts) can sometimes be identified, new accounts emerge daily, making tracking a moving target. In this work, we propose a graph-based methodology to discover previously unknown Telegram accounts that spread disinformation. Starting from a set of verified disinformation groups, we examine their interconnections and identify new accounts that contribute to the dissemination of false narratives. Our approach is language-agnostic, as it relies solely on structural relationships between accounts rather than analyzing their message content. Using this approach, we identify 37 previously unknown disinformation channels (a threefold increase). We demonstrate that Telegram channels display extremely dogmatic behavior with up to 80% of messages being labeled as propaganda. Our findings reveal that misinformation on Telegram spreads within tightly interconnected clusters, in some cases, with over 86K identical messages being shared to multiple channels, suggesting coordinated disinformation campaigns.

0.38

A null model to detect coordinated online behavior integrating evidence from multiple indicators

cs.SI cs.CY ·2026-10-13 ·Filipi Nascimento Silva, Manita Pote, Lake Yin, David Axelrod, Ashwin Balasubramanian +3 more
similarity 0.64
Abstract · 9 pages, 8 figures, 1 table, 28 references

Coordinated online accounts can amplify messages and manipulate attention, but detecting such behavior is challenging due to confounding factors like account activity and item popularity. We propose a statistical null-model framework that assesses behavioral similarity between accounts by comparing observed coordination indicators against activity- and popularity-conditioned reference distributions. By combining evidence across multiple indicators and partners, our method can identify suspicious coordination links more accurately. Evaluations on nine labeled information-operation datasets involving over 152 thousand accounts show that aggregating p-values multiplicatively across indicators and partners yields improved detection performance. While results vary across information operations, this approach offers a generalizable and statistically principled tool for uncovering coordinated online behavior.

0.23

Friends as Sensors: High-Sensitivity Monitoring of Misinformation and Platform Dynamics via the Friendship Paradox

cs.SI cs.CY ·2026-10-12 ·Angermaier Mathias, Lasser Jana, Lewandowsky Stephan, Garcia David
code/data similarity 0.61
Abstract · 33 pages, 7 figures (6 main, 1 supplementary). Includes Supplementary Information. Data: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22895042, code: http…

The friends of a randomly chosen social media user are, on average, better connected than the user, a network property known as the friendship paradox. We use it to monitor misinformation on Twitter/X around the 2024 US election, comparing roughly 27 million tweets from random users with 31 million from the accounts they retweet, which we call sensors. Sensors share news of about the same quality as random users, because news quality follows the political orientation of linked outlets and not the user's position in the network. News links rated by NewsGuard reach sensors a median of 70 minutes earlier, across the quality spectrum. Over the election window, right-leaning content rises about 2.5-fold in visibility, measured as impressions per tweet, among sensors but not among random users. Friendship-paradox sampling therefore cannot separate low-quality from high-quality news, but it detects news early and tracks what a platform makes visible.

0.40

Predicting, Evaluating, and Explaining Top Misinformation Spreaders via Archetypal User Behavior

cs.SI cs.CYcs.LG ·2026-08-17 ·Enrico Verdolotti, Luca Luceri, Silvia Giordano
published similarity 0.59
Abstract · 48 pages. Published version: Online Social Networks and Media 50 (2025) 100336

The spread of misinformation on social networks poses a significant challenge to online communities and society at large. Not all users contribute equally to this phenomenon: a small number of highly effective individuals can exert outsized influence, amplifying false narratives and contributing to significant societal harm. This paper seeks to mitigate the spread of misinformation by enabling proactive interventions, identifying and ranking users according to key behavioral indicators associated with harmful content dissemination. We examine three user archetypes -- amplifiers, super-spreaders, and coordinated accounts -- each characterized by distinct behavioral patterns in the dissemination of misinformation. These are not mutually exclusive, and individual users may exhibit characteristics of multiple archetypes. We develop and evaluate several user ranking models, each aligned with a specific archetype, and find that super-spreader traits consistently dominate the top ranks among the most influential misinformation spreaders. As we move down the ranking, however, the interplay of multiple archetypes becomes more prominent. Additionally, we demonstrate the critical role of temporal dynamics in predictive performance, and introduce methods that reduce data requirements by minimizing the observation window needed for accurate forecasting. Finally, we demonstrate the utility and benefits of explainable AI (XAI) techniques, integrating multiple archetypal traits into a unified model to enhance interpretability and offer deeper insight into the key factors driving misinformation propagation. Our findings provide actionable tools for identifying potentially harmful users and guiding content moderation strategies, enabling platforms to monitor accounts of concern more effectively.

0.70

Information Operations Exploit APIs to Manipulate Social Media

cs.CY ·2026-10-01 ·Manita Pote, Alessandro Flammini, Filippo Menczer
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Research on information operations has focused primarily on the coordinated accounts involved in such campaigns and in the content they promote. Bad actors manage the activity of inauthentic accounts through programmatic interfaces (APIs), but the role of this underlying infrastructure in enabling and uncovering such coordinated behaviors remains largely unexplored. This study investigates how the Twitter (now X) API was used to coordinate influence operations on the platform. Since API access is managed through developer apps, we extract app metadata from 43 operations taken down between 2018 and 2021 and apply three complementary computational approaches to study diverse forms of manipulation. Our analysis reveals several recurring patterns: API-as-a-service infrastructure reused across campaigns, gaming apps performing unauthorized engagement without user consent, spoofed app names to hide activity origins, and synchronized app networks indicating centralized control. Adding app usage as a coordination indicator provides a modest but consistent improvement in detection. These findings suggest that social media APIs play an important role in enabling online manipulation, and that the removal of app-level metadata by Twitter/X has eliminated an important tool for platform transparency and moderation.

0.17

Out-of-Network Attention Dynamics on Bluesky

cs.SI cs.CY ·2026-10-01 ·Andrea Failla, Veronica Mesina, Giulio Rossetti
published similarity 0.59
Abstract · Accepted at Int. Conf. on Complex Networks and their Applications 2026

Personalized social media commonly relies on explicit follow graphs to shape what content users encounter; yet how much attention crosses ties they have not formed remains largely undocumented at scale. We study this question on Bluesky, a large decentralized microblogging platform whose default feed relies on a simple, reverse-chronological content recommender. We analyze 173 million user-author interactions (likes, reposts, replies, and quotes) collected from a near-complete platform dump between February and September 2023. We decompose each interaction by attention-path length (already followed, relayed by a followed account, reachable within two follow-hops, or beyond) and find that 74.5% of interactions reach the user through an account they already follow. Measured by distance in the follow graph rather than by route, 80.6% of interaction lands within two follow hops, far beyond the 22.4% an expected-degree null predicts. We then characterize how exploration varies across users and over tenure. A broad-reaching minority generates three quarters of all exploratory activity, while aggregate declines in exploration with tenure mask three distinct individual trajectories. Finally, attention reaching beyond two hops converts into new follow ties at less than one third the rate of two-hop-local exploratory attention. Together, these results depict a platform where out-of-network exploration is substantial in volume but strongly constrained by network proximity and unlikely to translate into new social ties.

0.26