CS Paper Radar

Abstention and Noise Filtering: Two Missing Primitives of Softmax Attention

Richard Zhe Wang

cs.LG cs.CL ·submitted 2026-09-18 17:03 UTC · v2

Abstract

Softmax attention has two structural gaps. A head cannot abstain, because its weights sum to one, so it outputs something even when nothing is relevant. Nor can it filter what it reads, because its output is a weighted average of value vectors, passing interference as faithfully as signal. We call these missing primitives abstention and noise filtering. Recent studies report that gating the value pathway improves pretraining but attribute the gain to different causes. We show that a value gate partly supplies both primitives, which unifies the reported causes as views of one gain. We give each primitive its own mechanism in matched models of 10M to 350M parameters and measure what each contributes. The gain from gating is almost entirely abstention at 10M, whereas by 350M filtering contributes as much as abstention, so what a study observes depends on its scale. The two benefits are largely additive, with a small overlap. A gate determined by each value alone leaves the attention sink in place, whereas a query-controlled mechanism removes it. Injecting interference into the value reads shows that abstention and filtering protect against it in distinguishable ways. The same patterns appear in pretrained models up to 20B parameters.

Comment
20 pages (8 pages main text plus appendices), 5 figures, 12 tables

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

A Quantum Roadmap for Softmax Attention: Exact Born-Rule Analogs for Softmax Attention on the Probability Simplex

cs.LG quant-ph ·2026-08-11 ·Eric A. F. Reinhardt, Adam J. Hauser
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 27 pages, 10 figures

The attention mechanism forms the foundation of many modern AI models such as the Transformer. In one subclass of problems where attention is used, inputs and outputs are bound to the probability simplex so that all outputs sum to one. In this setting, softmax attention admits an exact, component-by-component quantum realization. Attention scores are Hadamard-test statistics on block-encoded projections of amplitude-encoded inputs. The exponential softmax is the interior of a cosine-squared family generated by Born-rule measurement under an exact bijection, whose boundary expresses sparse attention with exact zeros at finite parameter values. The softmax temperature is a repetition count where post-selected measurement rounds realize discretized inverse temperature exactly. Value aggregation is a deterministic column-loading channel that dilates the column-stochastic value matrix. The gated residual is the preparation angle of a single ancilla, with the additive identity at a mixing angle of $π$/2. Every learnable parameter is a rotation-gate angle. The composed layer is exact in the infinite-shot limit with one measure-and-reload step per attention score; a fully-coherent variant is $ε$-approximate via quantum singular value transformation in the infinite depth limit. The algebraic core is machine-checked in Lean 4.

0.44

Language Models Share a Readout Bottleneck in Working Memory

cs.LG cs.AIcs.CLq-bio.NC ·2026-10-15 ·Dongyu Gong
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) reproduce a human working-memory signature on the N-back task: performance declines as memory load N increases, and errors concentrate on lures, items that repeat the current stimulus at a neighboring but incorrect serial position. We ask whether this shared behavioral signature reflects a shared mechanism. The literature offers two candidate accounts. On a precision account, softmax attention cannot concentrate its weight on the item N positions back, so adjacent items are retrieved instead. On an interference account, attention selects the correct item, but the content of competing items corrupts the decision. We dissociate these accounts in 15 pretrained LLMs from three families (70 million to 14 billion parameters) and in minimal transformers trained from scratch. In all three families, the attention heads that carry the task attend to the target on most missed matches. Linear probes decode near-perfectly whether a matching letter occurred at the target or at a lure position, even on trials where the model false-alarms to the lure, although its own decisions barely distinguish the two. Sharpening attention yields negligible gains, whereas suppressing the letter identity of non-target items improves sensitivity (d') in nearly all model-by-load conditions. In larger models the task is spread over more heads, and removing interference helps more. In minimal transformers, precision limits a single attention layer, but a second layer removes this constraint. The working-memory limit of LLMs therefore lies in reading items out under interference rather than in locating them, consistent with interference accounts of human working memory.

0.15

From Attention Sensitivity to Layer Role: Revisiting Mixed-Precision Quantization of Transformers

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-09-28 ·Nafiseh HosseinpourFardi, Negar Alihadi, Mahmoudreza Babaei, Milad Hosseini, Adrian Weller
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 28 pages, 2 figures, 13 tables. Nafiseh HosseinpourFardi and Negar Alihadi contributed equally

Most post-training quantization pipelines fit each weight matrix to its pretrained counterpart, one matrix at a time. Whether that proxy tracks what an attention block actually computes, or how errors in the Q, K and V projections compound inside the softmax, is rarely checked. We write the objective on the attention output instead, over all three projections at once, and reuse it throughout the pipeline. JAB defines one scalar loss over the joint Q, K, V weights of a block, evaluated against the block's real causally-masked attention output, and uses it twice: to fit the quantized weights (GPTQ warm start, then STE with learnable scales), and to score the block for a multiple-choice knapsack allocation. On attention-only quantization of Mistral-7B this works. At 3 bits JAB recovers 77-90% of the gap between uniform GPTQ and full precision, and its sensitivity estimate tracks an oracle costing 73 forward passes to within a fraction of a point. It stops working once MLP layers enter the allocation. A role-aware offset rule needing no sensitivity estimate at all beats JAB on GPT-2's MLP and on the full Mistral-7B model: with a 3-bit floor it quantizes 96.4% of the weights to 4.5 bits per parameter at 6.933 perplexity, within 4.4% of full precision (6.643) at 3.56x compression, against 7.158 for JAB at the same budget. Which matrix a weight sits in matters more than any sensitivity estimate we computed. Two things came out sideways. Block-local reconstruction is an unreliable proxy for end-to-end perplexity: one run improved a block's own objective 4.6x while perplexity rose 32x, which is why every allocation here is validated end-to-end. And on attention-only quantization, fine-tuning moved weights farther from their pretrained values while pulling attention outputs closer, with net gains. Post-training seems to recover attention behavior, not weights.

0.23

Softmax Attention on Gaussian Mixtures: Linear When It Can, Selective When It Must

cs.LG stat.ML ·2026-10-08 ·Simon Gabet, Etienne Boursier, Claire Boyer
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Softmax attention, at the heart of Transformers, has demonstrated remarkable capabilities. Yet its underlying mechanisms remain only partially understood. Recent theoretical work studies Gaussian prompts, where the infinite-prompt limit reduces softmax attention to a linear map, but also removes the query-dependent selection that distinguishes it from linear attention. This work studies the infinite-prompt limit of softmax attention on Gaussian mixtures, which retain the tractability of Gaussian data while introducing latent structure, multimodality, and nonlinear dependencies. We show that softmax attention can represent and learn, via gradient-based methods, optimal solutions to a range of statistical tasks, including supervised classification and denoising. Our results highlight two complementary capabilities of softmax attention: it can recover linear tasks as effectively as its simpler linear counterpart, while also exploiting query-dependent context selection to solve nonlinear tasks beyond the reach of linear attention.

0.48

Attention Function as an Intrinsic Inductive Bias: How Models' Behavior Diverges in Novel Contexts

cs.LG ·2026-09-30 ·Dong Gyun Kang, Megha Thukral, Kwangsoo Kim
published similarity 0.63
Abstract · Accepted as a full paper (poster) at the NeurIPS 2026 Workshop on Developmental Perspectives on AI (DevAI 2026)

Developmental psychology holds that certain priors are given to infants prior to experience rather than induced from data, and that the influence of such priors is suppressed under strong, well-constrained conditions but reasserts itself under weak ones. We ask whether an analogous principle holds for the Transformer: can the activation function given to attention heads serve as an intrinsic inductive bias? We propose Mixture of Function Attention (MoFA), a parameter-free modification to multi-head attention that fixes a ratio of softmax and sigmoid heads before training. Across five ratios, a 124M-parameter GPT-2 model, and five seeds, we find that this given ratio has little effect in-distribution -- differences between ratios are statistically negligible for moderate mixtures and remain small even at the extremes -- but its influence re-emerges sharply under zero-shot distribution shift across 15 out-of-distribution domains. Perplexity gaps between ratios widen by more than an order of magnitude on several domains, and the best-performing ratio tracks a single axis of domain structure, separating short, informal text (softmax-favoring) from technical, long-form text (sigmoid-favoring), that explains 78.3% of the variance in domain response. This reorganization is visible at the head level: sigmoid heads show an accelerating drop in attention entropy as their ratio increases, while softmax heads respond more modestly, yielding a consistent division of labor between the two head types. Our results suggest that activation choice functions as a given prior whose influence is masked in-distribution and re-emerges out-of-distribution.

0.34

When Can Attention Heads Be Statically Defined?

cs.LG cs.CL ·2026-09-28 ·Weixian Waylon Li, Yintao Tai, Marcio Fonseca, Shay B. Cohen
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Some attention heads learn similar patterns across inputs. Reusing these patterns could reduce training cost by avoiding repeated query-key score computation and softmax. Through controlled pretraining comparisons, we identify Selective Attention Freezing (SAF), which selects heads with low attention-pattern variance and replaces their attention weights with fitted post-softmax means halfway through training. We represent these fixed patterns with absolute-position and relative-distance preferences, reducing storage from quadratic to linear in sequence length. A fused kernel reconstructs the patterns and executes ordinary-attention and replaced heads together. At matched training-token budgets, replacing 25% of attention heads gives 1.056x faster post-replacement optimiser updates at 124M parameters and 4K context, with a 0.77% perplexity increase. At 1B and 8K context, post-replacement updates are 1.068x faster on four GPUs including communication, with a 0.51% perplexity increase. The resulting models also accelerate long-input finetuning and causal prefill. After associative-recall adaptation, the 124M model with 25% replacement generalises to more key-value pairs at a fixed length better than ordinary attention and two pruning controls.

0.20

Linearized 2-Simplicial Attention

cs.AI ·2026-08-10 ·Aritra Das, Dhruman Gupta, Debayan Gupta
similarity 0.62
Abstract

We present a linearized form of 2-simplicial attention by rewriting the trilinear score as an inner product between a composite query and a key, so that the sum over one token axis takes the same form as ordinary softmax attention. We then approximate this sum with positive random features and store the entire past in a fixed-size state, while the second axis stays explicit over a short window of recent tokens. This enables us to achieve linear cost in sequence length combined with a global reach that windowed 2-simplicial attention lacks. We implement it with custom Triton kernels and combine it with Kimi Delta Attention to build a model with no softmax attention at all. Under matched compute, this model achieves the highest mean downstream accuracy among the compared architectures, and at 16k context it improves mean accuracy over a KDA hybrid while lowering LAMBADA perplexity from 715.6 to 602.6.

0.34

Approximating Softmax in Pretrained LLMs: Model Sensitivity and Kernel Acceleration

cs.LG ·2026-09-27 ·Shangzhen Zhu, Muyan Hu, Tomasz Kozlowski
similarity 0.62
Abstract

On NVIDIA Blackwell B200, tensor-core throughput outpaces special-function exponential throughput by more than two orders of magnitude, exposing exponential evaluation in fused attention kernels. A pretrained Transformer, however, may not need it evaluated accurately at every element. We characterize what a pretrained model does need by approximating softmax at inference in ten frozen decoder-only models (0.5B-72B). The number of positions the softmax map assigns probability to and within-row resolution can be cut substantially, yet uniform weighting of the same positions is damaging. Where a fixed resolution budget is placed matters as much as its size, with resolution near the row maximum consistently favored. Perturbations matched on scalar distortion produce model-dependent responses of opposite sign. These findings motivate Rowmax-PoT, a coarse logarithmic weight representation anchored at each row maximum, and Rowmax-H15, its hardware specialization in FlashAttention-4. On B200, the patched FP8 attention forward is 12.4% faster at causal 8K and 25.8% faster at non-causal 8K in host-side call-latency measurements; board energy per forward falls by 8.4% at causal 16K. Measured separately on the BF16 kernel path at 2K, Rowmax-H15 increases perplexity by 0.091-0.492% across five models from three families.

0.20