CS Paper Radar

An exponential lower bound for the bit pigeonhole principle in resolution over parities

Kamil Braun

cs.CC cs.LO ·submitted 2026-09-19 13:32 UTC · v2
theory

Abstract

Resolution over parities, $\mathrm{Res}(\oplus)$, is the characteristic-two version of resolution over linear equations: clauses are disjunctions of affine equations over $\mathbb F_2$. Superpolynomial size lower bounds were previously known only for restricted refutations: tree-like, regular, or of bounded depth. We prove that every DAG-like $\mathrm{Res} (\oplus)$ refutation of the bit pigeonhole principle with $n+1$ pigeons and $n=2^\ell$ holes has more than $\exp(n/(32768\ell^2))=2^{Ω(n/\log^2 n)}$ clauses, for every $\ell\ge32$, with no restriction on regularity or depth. The proof translates an arbitrary refutation with $S$ clauses into a polynomial calculus refutation of degree $O(\log n)$ over $O(S+n^2)$ groups of extension variables in the style of Buss, Impagliazzo, Krajicek, Pudlak, Razborov, and Sgall. One substitution then removes all extension variables at once and leaves a nonzero low-degree polynomial derived from the pigeonhole axioms alone at degree at most $n/2$; a degree lower bound in the style of Razborov, proved through the homology of chessboard complexes, shows that no such derivation exists. The argument also yields a general sufficient condition for $\mathrm{Res}(\oplus)$ size lower bounds. The main theorem, this condition, and all their dependencies are formalized in Lean 4, and every statement links to its formal proof. The proof was developed with substantial AI assistance within an open research framework described in the final section.

Comment
Main results and their dependencies formalized in Lean 4; verification map and reproduction instructions included. 43 pages. v2: exposition revised with a running example proof DAG, worked algebraic examples and an illustrated matching-moment filling; theorem statements and Lean proofs unchanged

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Short Resolution Refutations for CNFs with Bounded Weighted Incidence Treewidth

cs.CC ·2026-10-01 ·Shaowei Cai, Ziqun Li
theory similarity 0.64
Abstract

It is an open problem in proof complexity whether every unsatisfiable CNF formula has an FPT-sized resolution refutation parameterized by incidence treewidth. In this paper, we establish several upper bounds on resolution refutation length related to this problem. Consider an unsatisfiable CNF formula $F$ with $n$ variables, $m$ clauses, maximum clause width $k$, and incidence treewidth $\mathrm{tw}^*(F)$. In this paper, we introduce two variants of incidence treewidth. Their definitions can be stated informally as follows. The first is log-weighted incidence treewidth $\mathrm{tw}_{\log}^*(F)$, which is the treewidth of the weighted incidence graph, in which variables have weight one and each clause has weight equal to the logarithm of its width. The second is partially log-weighted incidence treewidth $\mathrm{tw}^*_{\mathrm{plog}}(F)$, which is a refinement of log-weighted incidence treewidth. In this variant, for a nice tree decomposition of the incidence graph, each clause has weight one along a path selected for that clause and elsewhere has weight equal to the logarithm of one plus the number of its literals whose variables do not appear in any bag on that path, and variables have weight one. For every unsatisfiable CNF formula $F$, we prove the existence of (i) an FPT-sized resolution refutation parameterized by log-weighted incidence treewidth, with width at most $\mathrm{tw}_{\log}^*(F)+k$; (ii) a resolution refutation of length $(n+m)k^{O(\mathrm{tw}^*(F))}$ and width at most $\mathrm{tw}^*(F)+k$; (iii) an FPT-sized resolution refutation parameterized by partially log-weighted incidence treewidth; and (iv) an FPT-sized regular resolution refutation parameterized by log-weighted incidence treewidth. Our main idea is to construct FPT-sized $k$-DNF resolution refutations parameterized by incidence treewidth, and then convert them into resolution refutations.

0.21

A Degree--Size Relation for Resolution over Polynomials

cs.CC cs.LO ·2026-09-30 ·Shuo Pang
similarity 0.62
Abstract · Parameters in Section 8 (Conclusions) made explicit

For every constant-width CNF, we show that linear degree in polynomial calculus (PC) implies exponential size in resolution over constant-degree polynomials, over the same prime field. Applications include exponential lower bounds for CNFs in $\operatorname{Res}(\operatorname{PC}_r/\mathbb{F}_p)$ and hence in $\operatorname{Res}(\oplus_p)$, separations between different moduli, improved lower bounds for $\operatorname{Res}(k)$ up to $k=\varepsilon\log n$, proof-search consequences, and an implication of super-polynomial $AC^0[p]$-Frege bounds from very strong PC degree lower bounds. The proof uses the common-multiplier idea isolated from Braun [arXiv:2609.23015] to construct a Razborov--Smolensky approximation that preserves inferences, without introducing extension variables. The approximation errors are measured by ranks of the multiplication maps induced by the error-witness polynomials, modulo bounded-degree PC consequences.

0.49

The Proof Analysis Problem for Constant-Depth Frege

cs.CC ·2026-11-05 ·Noel Arteche, Susanna F. de Rezende, Erfan Khaniki, Kilian Risse
publishedtheory similarity 0.61
Abstract · An extended abstract of this paper will appear at the 67th IEEE Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science (FOCS 2026)

We give a parallel algorithm for the Proof Analysis Problem of Arteche, Atserias, de Rezende, and Khaniki (FOCS 2025). The problem asks, given a CNF formula $\varphi$ on $n$ variables and a proof $π$ of a size-$s$ Resolution lower bound on $\varphi$, encoded as $\neg \mathrm{Ref}_s(\varphi)$, to extract a satisfying assignment for $\varphi$ when one exists. The original work gave a polynomial-time extraction algorithm for Resolution refutations that enabled a formalization of the Atserias-Müller lower bound (FOCS 2019) in Extended Frege, but it appeared inherently sequential. We devise a new algorithm that performs assignment extraction in low-depth circuit classes. Specifically, we give an assignment extraction algorithm computable by polynomial-size $\mathbf{TC}^0$ circuits and by quasipolynomial-size $\mathbf{AC}^0$ circuits, and we prove the correctness of the latter within quasipolynomial-size $\mathbf{AC}^0$-Frege. This is thanks to a new formalization of the Atserias-Müller lower bound in the relativized theory $\mathsf{T}^4_2(α)$ of bounded arithmetic, which corresponds to depth-$4$ Frege systems. This yields quasipolynomial-size $\mathbf{AC}^0$-Frege proofs for a broad class of Resolution lower bounds, making progress on a question of Pudlák. A key feature of our approach is an improved parameter regime where we get $\mathbf{AC}^0$-Frege formalizations of Resolution lower bounds $\neg \mathrm{Ref}_s(\varphi)$ for all $s$, including $s = n^{O(1)}$. W also show that the Proof Analysis Problem for $\mathbf{AC}^0$-Frege is $\mathbf{NP}$-hard under quasipolynomial-time reductions, which rules out certain Atserias-Müller-type approaches to the hardness of automating constant-depth Frege. Furthermore, automating $\mathbf{AC}^0$-Frege on Resolution lower bound formulas suffices to automate it on all formulas.

0.32

Meta-Mathematics of Algebraic Complexity

cs.CC cs.LO ·2026-10-24 ·Michal Garlik, Svyatoslav Gryaznov, Jiaqi Lu, Rahul Santhanam, Iddo Tzameret
top venue similarity 0.61
Abstract · A preliminary version of this work appeared in the proceedings of ACM-IEEE LICS 2026

We initiate the study of the meta-mathematics of algebraic circuit lower bounds, aiming both to gain insight into the methods sufficient and necessary to prove algebraic circuit lower bounds, and to contribute to the study of bounded arithmetic as a logical foundation for complexity lower bounds. We demonstrate that while algebraic circuit lower bounds are hard for somewhat weak proof systems such as Polynomial Calculus Resolution ($\mathsf{PCR}$), contemporary lower bounds are efficiently provable in proof systems and bounded arithmetic theories corresponding to $\mathsf{NC}^2$, such as $\mathsf{VNC}^2$ and the corresponding class of propositional Frege proofs of quasipolynomial-size. Moreover, going below $\mathsf{VNC}^2$ into algebraic constant-depth reasoning is likely insufficient to efficiently prove already constant-depth algebraic circuit lower bounds. Under an algebraic analogue of the Krajicek--Razborov conjecture, our results suggest that proving superpolynomial lower bounds for general algebraic circuits will require stronger reasoning than that used in the rank-based proofs studied here. Specifically, we show the following.

0.49

The CNF Encoding Complexity of Boolean Functions

cs.CC cs.LO ·2026-11-03 ·Andrew Krapivin, Benjamin Przybocki, Bernardo Subercaseaux
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract · 36 pages, comments are welcome!

We study the minimum number of clauses required to encode a boolean function into a CNF formula with auxiliary variables. Our main result is that if a boolean function can be evaluated in nondeterministic time $t$ (in the RAM model) with $m$ bits of advice such that at most $b$ bits of advice are accessed for each input, then it admits a CNF encoding with $\widetilde{O}(t + \sqrt{mb})$ clauses. This constitutes a nonuniform generalization of Robson's (TCS'91) variant of the Cook--Levin theorem, for which a naïve generalization would yield $\widetilde{O}(t+m)$ clauses; our applications leverage $b = o(m)$ to obtain significantly better bounds. Since preprocessed data structures can be modeled as computation with advice, our result allows us to translate space- and time-efficient data structures to compact CNF encodings. As an application, we derandomize a data structure of Larsen and Williams (SODA'17) to show that every $k$-CNF function on $n$ inputs can be encoded with $n^k/2^{Ω_k(\sqrt{\lg n})}$ clauses. Notably, despite encoding a $k$-CNF function, the encoding itself necessarily contains clauses of unbounded width, since an information-theoretic argument shows that the minimum number of bounded-width clauses to encode such functions is $Ω_k(n^{k}/\lg n)$ in the worst case. In general terms, our results imply that for a wide variety of NP-complete problems, one can reduce to CNF-SAT in a way that results in asymptotically fewer clauses than previously known methods.

0.31

A Fine-Grained Dichotomy for Bounded-Variable Query Evaluation: The Calculus of Relations, a Boolean Modal Logic, and One-Variable Counting Logic

cs.DB cs.CCcs.LO ·2026-10-03 ·Yoshiki Nakamura, Yuya Uezato
publishedtheory similarity 0.60
Abstract · Long version of PODS'27 paper

We study the fine-grained complexity of evaluating Boolean bounded-variable first-order queries over sparse relational structures. For every fixed $k \ge 2$, every relational signature, and every fragment between $k$-variable primitive positive ($\mathrm{PP}^{k}$) and first-order ($\mathrm{FO}^{k}$) logic, we prove, assuming the Sparse MAX-$3$-SAT hypothesis, a dichotomy theorem for evaluation in $O(m^{k-\varepsilon})$ time, where $m$ is the number of tuples in the input structure. The only tractable cases fall into three families: (1) three-variable fragments, (2) two-variable fragments, and (3) fragments over unary signatures. On the hard side, for every fixed $k \ge 4$ and every $\varepsilon > 0$, there is a fixed sentence $\varphi_\varepsilon$ in $\mathrm{PP}^{k}$ over a single binary relation symbol, depending on $\varepsilon$ but not on the input structure, whose evaluation cannot be performed in $O(m^{k-\varepsilon})$ time. For the tractable cases, we show that the evaluation problem can be solved in $2^{O(|\varphi|)} \cdot m^{k-\varepsilon}$ time for some $\varepsilon > 0$. Moreover, every tractable fragment reduces, with a $2^{O(|\varphi|)}$ blowup in formula size under DAG representations, to one of the following query languages: (1) Tarski's calculus of relations, (2) a new Boolean modal logic for sparse model checking, and (3) one-variable counting logic.

0.29

Unconditional Boolean Dynamic Lower Bounds from Disjointness

cs.DS cs.CC ·2026-10-07 ·Young Kun Ko
theory similarity 0.60
Abstract · 48 pages, 3 figures. v2: main result stated for the multiphase problem; appendix extended to further dynamic problems; introduction revised.…

We prove an unconditional $Ω((\log n/\log\log n)^2)$ lower bound on the maximum of the worst-case update time and expected query time for the insert-only version of Patrascu's multiphase Disjointness problem [STOC 2010]. The bound holds in the zero-error cell-probe model with logarithmic word size. Patrascu's reductions transfer it to directed reachability under edge insertions, already on directed acyclic graphs of depth $2$. This improves the $\widetildeΩ(\log^{3/2} n)$ bound of Larsen and Yu [SICOMP 2025] to the quadratic-logarithmic scale previously attained for dynamic range counting and multiphase Inner Product. The bound also transfers to a broad collection of dynamic graph, algebraic, geometric, and string problems. We also obtain a separation between amortized and worst-case time for streaming regular-expression membership. For a simple family of expressions of maximum length $M$ over a polynomial-size alphabet, a deterministic algorithm uses $O(1)$ amortized time per symbol on every input stream, whereas every zero-error cell-probe algorithm with word size $w=Θ(\log M)$ requires $Ω((\log M/\log\log M)^2)$ time on some symbol. The proof adapts Ko's 2.5-round multiphase communication framework [FOCS 2026] from Inner Product to Disjointness. Our main technical observation is that the protocol's verification step allows a one-sided corruption bound to replace the discrepancy property used for Inner Product.

0.24

Top-Down Lower Bounds for All Depths

cs.CC ·2026-09-30 ·Oliver Korten
publishedtheory similarity 0.60
Abstract · 20 pages

We prove that Parity requires $2^{n^{Ω(1)}}$ size De Morgan circuits of constant depth using a new method which is completely "top-down" in the sense of [HJP95]. The proof relies crucially on the core ideas developed in a line of work [HJP95, PPZ99, MW19, GRSS24] which previously established top-down lower bounds for circuits of depth 3 and 4. We first present a proof of a lower bound $\exp(n^{3^{-d}})$. In this case, nearly all of the relevant combinatorial ideas necessary for the proof are already present in some form in [GRSS24]. We then present two extensions of this argument, the first achieving a lower bound $\exp(ε_d n^{1/(2d-2)})$ for some $ε_d>0$ depending only on $d$, and the second achieving the essentially tight lower bound $\exp(ε_d n^{1/(d-1)})$. These improved results each hinge on establishing a key lemma which quantifies the extent to which a high entropy random variable in $\{0,1\}^n$ will look close to uniform after projecting it onto a random small set of coordinates $R \subseteq [n]$.

0.46