CS Paper Radar

Adaptive Differential Evolution and Multistart Search for Noisy QAOA Optimization

Vojtěch Novák, Ivan Zelinka, Swagatam Das, Martin Beseda

cs.NE quant-ph ·submitted 2026-09-19 19:08 UTC · v1
benchmarkhot direction

Abstract

We benchmark classical optimization of a fixed low-depth Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) ansatz across four cost-Hamiltonian families at $N=12$, $p=3$, and $D=6$. Ten optimizers are compared over 25 independent runs under common ceilings of 10\,000 and 30\,000 function evaluations (FEs), first with exact statevector objectives and then with two additive observation-noise levels. Exact objectives favor multistart BFGS and multistart CMA-ES. Under noisy feedback, adaptive population methods become more competitive, but the ranking depends on whether performance is measured by the best exact point visited or by the point selected from noisy observations. A targeted extension over all three pre-screened instances per family confirms this regime change while showing that named adaptive-DE winners are instance dependent: jSO-lite leads low-noise oracle search, iL-SHADE high-noise oracle search, and L-SRTDE high-noise selected solutions in the equal-instance summaries. Bootstrap analysis quantifies a non-negligible high-noise search--selection gap, and a retrospective fixed-budget verification proxy shows that reserving a small measurement budget for final re-evaluation improves selected quality across all ten methods at 30\,000 FEs. A supplementary structure-aware study further shows that QAOA cross-depth restriction and continuous basin refinement are more useful in these conditions than standalone Monte Carlo tree-search selection. Overall, optimizer choice depends jointly on landscape structure, observation noise, and final-point identification.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Optimization Geometry of QAOA and Variational Quantum Algorithms

cs.NE quant-ph ·2026-10-04 ·Vojtěch Novák, Ivan Zelinka, Silvie Illésová, Swagatam Das, Martin Beseda
similarity 0.78
Abstract

Variational quantum algorithms turn choices of Hamiltonian, ansatz, and parameterization into a classical nonconvex optimization problem. We study how this objective function can be visualized and characterized in ways that help explain optimizer behavior. We distinguish two properties of the objective: the number of local minima encountered along sampled directions and the differences in quality among local-search endpoints. We then ask how a local optimizer, represented by BFGS, compares with adaptive differential evolution, represented by jSO. Rather than comparing jSO with a single local run, we allow BFGS multiple starts within the same function-evaluation budget. This gives local search repeated opportunities to explore different basins and provides a stronger baseline for asking when a global evolutionary solver is useful. We study these questions using VQE and QAOA, focusing on how frustra- tion, circuit depth, parameter tying, mixed locality, and nonlinear repa- rameterization change the Hamiltonian expectation-value objective seen by the classical optimizer. Increasing independent circuit depth raises the sampled local-minimum count without making global search more effective. Parameter tying, by contrast, produces both more repeated local structure and much larger differences in quality among local-search endpoints, and in this regime adaptive differential evolution outperforms function-evaluation-matched multistart BFGS. The comparison shows that the number of local minima alone does not determine whether global search is advantageous: the important distinction is whether different basins lead to similarly good solutions or to substantially different objective values. These results provide a practical workflow for connecting model construction, objective- function geometry, empirical diagnostics, and optimizer choice.

0.08

When is global evolutionary search useful for variational quantum algorithms? A landscape-first study

cs.NE quant-ph ·2026-09-13 ·Vojtěch Novák, Ivan Zelinka
benchmark similarity 0.77
Abstract

Variational quantum algorithms recast state preparation as classical nonconvex optimization, but it is often unclear when multistart local search suffices and when population-based global search justifies its evaluation cost. Using a landscape-first design, controlled QAOA experiments identify two mechanisms making local search unreliable: parameter reuse across circuit layers and competition between 2-local and 3-local cost terms. Increasing QAOA depth alone does not replicate this effect. We test these mechanisms across eight unseen spin glasses, fresh $N=10$ and $N=12$ instances, and standard MaxCut, transverse-field Ising, and Heisenberg models. On all eight unseen spin glasses, adaptive differential evolution (DE) achieves lower median error than both multistart BFGS and multistart Powell on the two difficult constructions, whereas the independent-depth control does not. The parameter-reuse effect transfers to MaxCut at both sizes, while standard VQE models remain favorable to local search. A pre-benchmark landscape score combining random-start local outcomes and 1D parameter slices is fixed from confirmation data before evaluating new optimizers. It predicts whether adaptive DE outperforms multistart BFGS by over one spectral-range percentage point on 50 new quantum objectives with 80--86% condition-level accuracy. The clearest indicator of global-search utility is that local search frequently traps in inferior basins, rather than circuit depth or curvature anisotropy. The findings motivate whether quantum circuit complexity can be traded for harder classical optimization when robust global search is available.

0.47

QAOA Inside ADMM: Subproblem Wins Do Not Become Decomposition Wins at Matched Budgets

cs.DC quant-ph ·2026-11-07 ·Mohammad Arif Hossain, Sanim Yousuf Fahim
benchmark similarity 0.69
Abstract

We benchmark the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) as the binary subproblem solver in a two-block alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM) for mixed-binary problems against classical solvers under matched budgets. With 23 optimizer evaluations per subproblem, scoring determines the comparison: on its final readout, the optimized QAOA loses to random search at $n=12$ and 16 binary variables (inconclusive at 20; exploratory and post hoc tests). When credited with its best sample, it wins. In a noiseless 12-qubit simulation, transferred-angle depth-2 QAOA finds the exact optimum of 97.3\% of planted-family subproblems, against 50.6\%--67.4\% for the four strongest local heuristics (100\% against 90.4\%--94.4\% crediting the four best bitstrings) and a not significantly different 96.5\% for semidefinite rounding with local search (SDP+LS). Under our evaluation-counting convention, its time to solution there is a factor of three to five below the local heuristics' but grows with a larger exponent; it is ten times that of SDP+LS and, in seconds, 54 times that of tabu search with restarts. For the benchmark class, an unconstrained binary quadratic problem in disguise, ADMM's binary step is a proximal step on the reduced problem: at unit penalty ADMM re-solves it, and for larger penalties exact solutions increasingly stall. On two families that do not reduce to one, less accurate solvers found the problem optimum more often at unit and larger penalties. No family gave QAOA a better ADMM outcome than the best classical solver and penalty. The benchmark includes a correctness gate and a log of its hypothesis tests.

0.27

Beyond QAOA: A Review of AI and Quantum Computing for Adaptive Combinatorial Optimization

cs.LG quant-phmath.OC ·2026-10-08 ·Hoong Chuin Lau
surveyposition similarity 0.66
Abstract · 36 pages, 5 figures, 7 tables; supplementary evidence matrix included as ancillary file. v2: clarified terminologies, co-optimization defini…

Near-term quantum approaches to combinatorial optimization are limited by qubit counts, circuit fidelity, sampling cost, and the difficulty of encoding constraints, while machine learning is increasingly used to configure and control quantum optimization workflows. We call such workflows adaptive: decisions conventionally fixed in advance, from formulation and penalties to shot budgets, backends, and whether to invoke a quantum processor at all, are made by learned policies that respond to the instance, the progress of the solve, or the hardware. This review examines three paradigms, AI for quantum optimization, quantum for AI-driven optimization, and AI-quantum co-optimization, and organizes the literature by the decision being learned rather than by application. A structured search identified a 119-paper corpus, of which 67 papers form an evidence core coded in detail. The evidence is considerably stronger for AI-assisted quantum optimization than for the reverse direction: learning already reduces quantum evaluations, improves initialization, supports decomposition and penalty control, and mitigates noise, whereas evidence that quantum computation improves learned optimizers remains largely confined to small-scale simulation. Experimental controls are thin: of 52 studies in the three paradigms, 22 include no classical baseline, the quantum contribution is fully isolated in 10 of 24 where an ablation applies, and the median largest experiment uses 16 qubits. We introduce an M0-M5 evidence hierarchy, from simulation to practical quantum advantage, and find no broadly convincing result at the highest level. We argue that scaling is increasingly a systems problem: the question is not only whether a problem fits on a quantum processor, but how classical and quantum resources should be allocated across the optimization process.

0.14

CV-QAOA: Efficient Low-Depth Quantum Optimization of Continuous Variables

cs.DS quant-ph ·2026-10-05 ·Sriram Bharadwaj, Di Luo, Leo Zhou
theory similarity 0.64
Abstract · 40+41 pages, 9 figures

We study a Continuous-Variable Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (CV-QAOA) for high-dimensional continuous optimization. Our formulation extends an earlier CV-QAOA proposal with a variationally optimized initial state and recovers the convergence guarantees of Quantum Hamiltonian Descent (QHD) in the high-depth limit. We prove rigorous performance guarantees of CV-QAOA on several families of cost functions. First, we show $d$-step CV-QAOA minimizes any $d$-dimensional strictly convex quadratic function with $2d$ quantum queries to the cost function. We then analyze a family of nonconvex "Rotated Double Well" (RDW) functions with $2^d$ local minima introduced by arXiv:2311.00811. While prior work showed QHD reaches its global minimum with $\tilde O(d^3)$ queries, we prove that 1-step CV-QAOA solves RDW with just two quantum queries. Although general-purpose classical solvers need superpolynomial time for RDW and structure-awareness can reduce the cost to polynomial time, we show that the 1-step CV-QAOA protocol can be efficiently dequantized, and that a gradient-aligned line search succeeds with $O(d)$ queries, nearly matching the information-theoretic $Ω(d/\log d)$ query lower bound. To move beyond the dequantizable regime, we introduce a ``Rotated Square Well'' (RSW) problem, whose globally flat landscape suppresses useful local gradient information. For this family, we show that an adiabatic evolution simulated by CV-QAOA can reach the global minimum using $d^{o(1)}$ queries. On the other hand, any classical algorithm that learn the hidden rotation in RSW provably requires $Ω(d^2/\log d)$ queries, a bound we nearly match with an explicit $Θ(d^2\log d)$-query classical algorithm.Numerical simulations on deflected corrugated spring and Easom functions illustrate the promising performance of CV-QAOA on more general problems.

0.11

An Empirical Study on Clustering-based Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm for Regression Test Case Selection

cs.SE ·2026-11-06 ·Antonio Trovato, Martin Beseda, Dario Di Nucci
similarity 0.63
Abstract · Manuscript under review at Empirical Software Engineering (EMSE)

Regression testing assesses whether software components that have already been developed and tested continue to work correctly after modifications. Ideally, regression testing re-executes the entire test suite after each modification, but this is infeasible in real-world scenarios because of the computational burden; therefore, optimized approaches, such as Test Case Selection, have been developed. The state of the art in regression testing optimization includes both classical approaches, such as Additional Greedy and DIV-GA, and quantum approaches, such as SelectQA, BootQA, and IGDec-QAOA. However, while the former incur high computational costs, the latter are constrained by the physical limitations of currently available quantum machines. This paper extends the evaluation of QAOA-TCS, our quantum approach for the test case selection problem. We thoroughly evaluate its performance, compare it with state-of-the-art classical and quantum approaches, and assess its robustness to quantum noise. The results show that QAOA-TCS outperforms state-of-the-art multi-objective approaches in most cases and maintains stable performance even under high noise levels. In the single-objective formulation, QAOA-based methods perform comparably. In terms of efficiency, our previous method based on quantum annealing, namely SelectQA, is the most efficient for large problems in the multi-objective formulation, whereas QAOA-TCS offers the best trade-off between effectiveness and efficiency in the single-objective formulation when run on realistic noisy simulators. However, such analysis is constrained by the different computational environments used to run the algorithms.

0.29

Adaptive Policy-Guided Error Mitigation (APGEM): A Unified Learning-Based Framework for Noise Resilience in Quantum Machine Learning

cs.LG quant-ph ·2026-11-10 ·Bisma Majid, Shabir Ahmad Sofi, Mir Mohammad Yousuf
hot direction similarity 0.61
Abstract · 28 pages, 22 figures, 17 tables

Error mitigation stands between variational quantum algorithms and useful results on today's noisy hardware, yet in practice a mitigation method is usually chosen once, by hand, and applied unchanged for the life of an experiment. This is a poor fit for quantum machine learning (QML), where the circuit and the noise drift as training proceeds, so the best strategy in one regime is often wrong in another. We present a generalized form of Adaptive Policy-Guided Error Mitigation (APGEM), which treats the choice of mitigation technique as an online decision made from an algorithm's own feedback. A single contextual-bandit controller observes signals any variational algorithm already produces, such as fidelity, entropy, reward or loss, and gradient behavior, and selects among Zero-Noise Extrapolation, Probabilistic Error Cancellation, Measurement Error Mitigation, Dynamical Decoupling, and circuit optimization per step. Because it depends only on this shared feedback interface, the framework applies unchanged across supervised, unsupervised, reinforcement, and hybrid quantum-classical learning. Evaluated on five paradigms across 80 algorithm-and-noise conditions, adaptive selection reaches 95.5% of an oracle that always picks the best technique and significantly outperforms all six fixed strategies (Friedman $χ^{2}=92.18$, $p\approx1.1\times10^{-17}$; pairwise Wilcoxon $p<4\times10^{-6}$). The learned policy is noise-aware: its favored technique shifts as depolarizing and readout error rise. On noise models from eight real IBM devices, APGEM tracks the oracle almost exactly (99.9% of oracle utility) at a flat cost of roughly $1.3\times10^{4}$ shots from three to eight qubits.

0.19

What a Reporting Convention Hides: A Matched-Budget Audit of Quantum Natural Gradient with an Exactly Computed Metric

cs.LG quant-ph ·2026-10-07 ·Lu Wei, Yufeng Wang, Haibin Ling
similarity 0.61
Abstract · 29 pages, 6 figures, 12 tables. Lu Wei and Yufeng Wang contributed equally

Several published comparisons of variational quantum optimizers time only runs that reach a target loss, or read the verdict at a single target. Either convention could decide whether an optimizer's costlier steps pay off. We measure how much each convention changes verdicts among Adam, simultaneous perturbation stochastic approximation (SPSA) and quantum natural gradient (QNG), on initializations held out from the selection of settings. We compute the exact metric that preconditions QNG, price every step in circuit evaluations and give every method the same budget. In a median pooled over circuit widths, cost families and a sweep of settings with common misses, SPSA needs more than twice Adam's evaluations to reach a loose target. Dropping the censored runs that miss the target hides this gap. On the global-cost family we hold fixed the settings selected for a strict target. QNG then usually reaches the loose target after Adam but the strict target first. QNG's strict-target lead disappears when the metric's simulator price, linear in the number of parameters, is replaced by an assumed hardware count quadratic in that number. We recommend charging every miss the budget and reporting verdicts across targets.

0.27