CS Paper Radar

Expansion Counts under Standard A* Tie-Breaking Strategies on the Final Plateau

Alex Fukunaga

cs.AI ·submitted 2026-09-20 02:05 UTC · v1

Abstract

In the A* search algorithm, the tie-breaking strategies for nodes with the same $f$-value determines which states A* expands on the final $f$-layer. For nine standard tie-breaking strategies, we show that under a consistent heuristic, every pair has positive-cost instances favoring each strategy over the other by an arbitrarily large additive expansion gap. A parameterized unit-cost grid example also gives unbounded expansion-count ratios between low-$h$ with FIFO and LIFO. In unit-cost search with $h > 0$ at non-goals, exact heuristic values near the goal lead to complementary extremal results: low-$h$ minimizes the number of remaining expansions from a common configuration within the perfect region, while high-$h$ maximizes the total number of expansions when every final-plateau state with $h=1$ is a goal predecessor. Finally, with the evaluation function $f_α = g + αh$, when $h>0$ at non-goals, every heuristic weight $0 \leq α<1$ eliminates tie-breaking sensitivity, and all tie-breaking strategies expand the same set of states.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Probabilistic Focal Search: Accelerating Bounded-Suboptimal Search via Lower-Bound Advancement

cs.AI ·2026-09-06 ·Minh Vu Duc, Trung Le Huu, Hà Minh Hoàng, Trung Thanh Nguyen, Phuong Khanh Nguyen +1 more
benchmarktheory similarity 0.58
Abstract

Bounded-suboptimal search seeks a solution within a factor $w$ of optimal while reducing search effort. Focal Search (FS) uses heuristic guidance within FOCAL, the frontier nodes eligible under the threshold $w f_{\min}$, but its deterministic policy may leave $f_{\min}$ unchanged for many expansions. We introduce Probabilistic Focal Search (PFS), which follows the FS guided choice with probability $p$ and expands a minimum-$f$ OPEN node with probability $1-p$. The latter branch encourages the lower bound to advance, enlarging FOCAL and admitting nodes that may lead to feasible solutions. By balancing guidance and lower-bound advancement, this mechanism can reduce time to a bounded solution when progress is limited by delayed FOCAL admission. As a secondary transfer experiment, we apply the same scheduler to Dynamic Potential Search, yielding Probabilistic Dynamic Potential Search (PDPS). We benchmark PFS against FS on N-Puzzle, Pancake Sorting, and the Traveling Salesperson Problem (TSP), and evaluate its anytime extension on the Generalized Covering TSP (GCTSP), using multiple $w$ and $p$ values. Across these benchmarks, the largest gains occur when long $f_{\min}$ plateaus delay useful FOCAL admissions; in such settings, the probabilistic factor may reduce node expansions by about 90\% or more (e.g., on N-Puzzle and TSP). For the anytime algorithm family, Anytime Probabilistic Focal Search (APFS) outperforms all tested algorithms in evaluating anytime methods on GCTSP. We also observe that the benefit is smaller when the deterministic search already advances efficiently (e.g., Pancake Sorting), indicating that the probabilistic factor is most useful when FOCAL admission is a search bottleneck. The PDPS transfer shows that the mechanism also transfers to potential guidance, although its common-success effects remain domain- and bound-dependent.

0.20

A Sublogarithmic Competitive Algorithm for Online Graph Exploration

cs.DS ·2026-11-10 ·Max Klimm
similarity 0.57
Abstract

In online graph exploration, an agent must visit every vertex of an unknown weighted graph and return to its start, learning the incident edges at each vertex it visits. On $n$-vertex graphs, the best known competitive ratio has been $O(\log n)$, achieved by several algorithms, among them the hierarchical depth-first search of Megow, Mehlhorn, and Schweitzer. We give an algorithm with competitive ratio ${(2+o(1))}\ln n/\ln\ln n$ for known~$n$. Like hierarchical depth-first search, it groups the edges into geometric weight classes and searches depth-first between components of lighter edges. Unlike it, the agent tours each component along a minimum spanning tree for the original weights, so only crossings between components pay for rounding, and the base $b$ of the weight class can grow with~$n$. The leading constant $2$ is tight for our choice of base. Without knowing $n$, restarts with increasing size guesses give upper bounds with leading constant $4$ for a fixed schedule and $2$ in expectation for a randomly shifted schedule. If the weights lie in a known range $[1,2^k]$ with $k\ge4$, choosing $b=k/\log_2 k$ gives a competitive ratio of $O(k/\log k)$ without knowing $n$.

0.25

Bidding Games with Rewards: Taming Infinite Configuration Space

cs.GT ·2026-08-31 ·Matan Pinkas
similarity 0.57
Abstract

Bidding games are graph games in which a token is placed on a vertex, each player starts with an initial budget, and a simultaneous auction determines which player moves the token; the players' budgets are then updated accordingly. Motivated by scenarios such as resource-allocation systems in which agents receive periodic rewards (e.g., credits, energy) while competing for control, we introduce and study bidding games with rewards, in which, at each vertex, players may receive additional budget, incentivizing desired behaviors. We focus on reachability discrete poorman bidding games with rewards (DPBGr). The main challenge when compared to discrete bidding games without rewards is that the configuration graph is infinite. To this end we introduce a novel technique to eliminate plays with suboptimal infixes. This enables focusing on a finite part of the infinite configuration graph in order to solve the game via approximation to continuous bidding games with overall complexity in EXP. Finally, we discuss a new type of strategy, usable on a subclass of DPBGr, which guarantee a winning strategy for the reachability player. Membership in this subclass is shown to be in NP.

0.13

Beyond Distance Ordering: Resource Complexity and Universal Optimality of Exact Labeled Directed Shortest Paths

cs.DS cs.CC ·2026-09-04 ·Bin Cai
benchmarktheory similarity 0.57
Abstract · 45 pages, including appendices and references. One endpoint theorem is verified by an exact computer-assisted finite certificate

We study exact single-source shortest paths when the output is only the materialized labeled distance vector ($\mathrm{DIST}$), rather than a distance order. In the full deterministic comparison-addition model, the minimum worst-case number of additions on every fixed directed topology is exactly the maximum number $ρ_{\mathrm{fwd}}$ of forward nonsource endpoint classes over rooted vertex orders; the lower bound permits adaptive control, literals, and arbitrary mixed sums. This arithmetic law aligns with the comparison optimum on DAGs, where the full resource region is an exact rectangle. Cycles destroy that alignment: a two-spoke shared-hub graph has coordinatewise optima $(4,2)$ but requires five comparisons at the two-addition budget. Its $k$-spoke extension forces $k\log_2 k+O(k)$ comparisons at the addition optimum and has an entropy-tight deterministic tradeoff $C_{k+r}^*(H_k)=Θ(k+Λ_{k,r})$, where $Λ_{k,r}=\log_2(k!/[r!(r+1)^{k-r}])$, with leading constant one when $Λ_{k,r}/k\to\infty$. Because the two coordinatewise minima need not belong to one program, these conflicts lead to the same-program benchmark $\operatorname{OPT}_{\mathrm{DIST}}=\inf_A\sup_w(C_A(w)+P_A(w))$. An exact transcript-cone game yields one uniform interpreter whose charged addition-comparison cost equals $\operatorname{OPT}_{\mathrm{DIST}}$ on every topology; its optimal actions are synthesizable in polynomial space but may require exponential time. Finally, an active-core reduction and the current deterministic directed-SSSP bound give an efficient uniform $O\!\bigl(\operatorname{OPT}_{\mathrm{DIST}}\sqrt{\log(2+\operatorname{OPT}_{\mathrm{DIST}})\log\log(4+\operatorname{OPT}_{\mathrm{DIST}})}\bigr)$ charged-operation bound. Thus optimal numerical policies exist uniformly, while efficient constant-competitive navigation remains open.

0.28

Strategyproof Mechanisms for Connecting Impassable Regions

cs.GT ·2026-09-08 ·Hau Chan, Jianan Lin, Chenhao Wang
theory similarity 0.57
Abstract

We study strategyproof mechanisms for building a pathway between two regions of a line segment separated by an obstacle. Each of the $n$ agents has a private location within its region and may use either its original route to a facility or the new pathway, whose traversal cost is a fraction $k\in[0,1)$ of its length. We seek strategyproof (SP) and group-strategyproof (GSP) mechanisms that approximately minimize maximum cost or social cost. After characterizing optimal pathways for both objectives, we establish a tight deterministic maximum-cost approximation ratio of $\frac{2}{1+k}$ and a deterministic social-cost upper bound of $\frac{n}{1+k(n-1)}$, together with complementary lower bounds. Both upper bounds are achieved by GSP mechanisms. We then study randomized mechanisms under strategyproofness in expectation. A power-proportional mechanism achieves a social-cost approximation ratio at most $5$, independent of $n$ and $k$, with a tight guarantee of $3$ for this mechanism when $k=0$. We prove randomized lower bounds of $\frac{3+2k}{2+3k}$ for maximum cost and $\max\big\{1,\frac{285}{263+385k}\big\}$ for social cost, the latter for $n\ge7$. Finally, we improve several bounds for the real-line pathway model of [Chan and Wang, AAMAS 2023]. Our deterministic maximum-cost lower bound of $2$ matches the upper bound obtainable from [Qin, Fang, and Liu, COCOA 2024]. We strengthen the deterministic social-cost lower bound from $\frac32$ to $2$ under SP and to $\max\{2,n-1\}$ under GSP. For randomized social cost, we sharpen the guarantee of Chan and Wang's proportional mechanism from $6$ to $3$ and raise their lower bound from $1.02$ to $\frac{285}{263}\approx1.08365$ for $n\ge7$.

0.19

Exact Locality Gaps for Matchable Semi-Matchings

cs.DS cs.DM ·2026-10-01 ·Marek Gałązka, Hanna Wdowicka
code/data similarity 0.56
Abstract · 11 pages. Verification code and data: https://github.com/mgalazka84/semimatching-locality-gaps

An assignment of tasks to servers can resist every small improvement and still make tasks wait longer than necessary. We determine exactly how inefficient such an assignment can be when each task requires one unit of service and the eligibility constraints permit all tasks to use distinct servers. For every move size $r$ and maximum current server load $K$, we give a closed formula for the worst ratio between locally optimal and globally optimal total completion time. Local optimality here allows every feasible reassignment changing at most $r$ tasks. Every finite-cap bound is attained on a tree where each task has at most two eligible servers. Thus the worst behavior already occurs under simple eligibility constraints. At load cap two, the exact ratio is $1+1/(r+2)$, attained on a path with $r+2$ tasks. Without a load cap, the worst-case supremum is $3/2$ for single-task moves and approximately $1.294503159$ for two-task moves; its excess above one is $1/(r+2)+O(2^{-r}/r)$ as $r$ grows. The proof uses an explicit rational potential on a comparison graph and matching extremal constructions. These results give sharp guarantees for bounded-size local search on matchable semi-matchings, including exact guarantees under degree bounds.

0.30

Bellman Search in Arbitrary Finite Dimension: A Self-Similar Cell Theorem and Effective Computability of Planar Shoreline Search

cs.CG math.MGmath.OC ·2026-08-29 ·Florentin Koch
theory similarity 0.56
Abstract · 23 pages, 1 figure. English revision 8.3

A shoreline-search path starts at the origin and must meet an unknown affine line, without knowing either its normal or its distance. We first establish a self-similar reduction theorem for homogeneous search problems whose historical information is a record profile updated by pointwise maximum. Two quasi-returns of the normalized state delimit a block that renews the required profile by itself; a short connector closes this block into a cell. Every finite-ratio path can therefore be approximated, with arbitrarily small loss, by repetitions of a single cell at all scales. The main chain is then made effective. A finite coding of the state space computably bounds the scale factor and normalized length of a nearly optimal cell. For planar Shoreline search, the support function of the convex hull gives an exact cell functional. A one-sided polygonalization then reduces the problem to a computable number of vertices, after which quantifier elimination decides whether a polygonal cell exists below a rational threshold. It follows that the optimal deterministic planar Shoreline value $C_2^*$ is a computable real: for every rational $ε>0$, an algorithm terminates with a rational interval of width at most $ε$ containing $C_2^*$. Additional results---sliding memory, Bellman transitions, deadlines, geometric filters, and relative equilibria---are presented separately as a toolbox for certified computation and for the study of spiral rigidity; they are not used in the computability proof.

0.61

Exponential Local Search in Bounded-Occurrence MAX-CSP

cs.DS cs.DMmath.CO ·2026-10-12 ·Sophia Heimann, Hung P. Hoang, Stefan Hougardy
similarity 0.56
Abstract

We study the number of improving steps that local search may require for $(2,2,r)$-MCA (Maximum Constraint Assignment), a bounded-occurrence version of MAX-CSP with valued constraints in which every constraint involves at most two variables, every variable occurs in at most two constraints, and every variable takes one of $r$ values. We consider the flip neighborhood, where two assignments are neighbors if they differ in the value of exactly one variable; moving to such a neighbor is called a flip. Local search repeatedly performs improving flips, that is, flips that strictly increase the objective value, until a local optimum is reached. Our main result is that $(2,2,5)$-MCA has the all-exp property: there is an infinite family of instances with initial assignments for which every sequence of improving flips ending in a local optimum has length exponential in the number of variables. Thus, on these instances, local search requires exponentially many steps regardless of which improving flip is chosen at each step. This is the first all-exp result for $(2,2,r)$-MCA for any value of $r$, and our result extends to every $r\ge 5$. In contrast, for $(2,2,2)$-MCA every sequence of improving flips has length at most quadratic in the number of variables~\cite{Kaz2020,KCJ2020}. We give a short, direct proof of this result.

0.47