CS Paper Radar

TicTacBench: Benchmarking Timing Closure Capabilities of Coding Agents

Bowei Wang, Zhigang Fang, Zhijie Yang, Renzhi Chen, Shanshan Li, Lei Wang

cs.AI ·submitted 2026-09-20 05:17 UTC · v1
publishedbenchmark

Abstract

Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have led to the emergence of coding agents capable of performing complex engineering tasks, including register-transfer level (RTL) design and optimization. Existing RTL benchmarks mainly evaluate functional correctness and performance, power, and area (PPA) of the generated RTL designs, leaving agents' ability for \emph{timing closure} under-evaluated. We propose TicTacBench, a benchmark specifically designed to evaluate coding agents' capabilities for RTL-level timing closure under post-place-and-route (post-PnR) evaluation. TicTacBench contains 30 diverse tasks, each provided with a suboptimal RTL design, realistic timing constraints, functional equivalence verification, and timing reports. With over 300 runs of coding agents driven by 8 frontier LLMs, we find that even the best agent can only close 53.3\% of tasks with 7.18\% area-delay product (ADP) degradation and 8.83\% energy-delay-squared product (EDDP) improvement on average. We identify common failure categories that explain why agents fail to close timing. Then we propose TicTacSkill, a new method that guides agents to follow standard timing-closure procedures and improves the Timing Closure Rate by 9\%. These results suggest that while coding agents have made significant progress in RTL design, their timing-closure capability still has substantial room for improvement.

Comment
Accepted at ICCD26

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Batch Before You Time: Decision-Scoped Proxy Execution for Timing-Aware Logic Rewriting

cs.AR ·2026-09-02 ·Pujun Su
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 6 pages, 3 figures

Standard Delay Format (SDF)-annotated switching simulation distinguishes delay-dependent activity among functionally equivalent rewrites, but evaluating every candidate repeats timing, compilation, and replay. A zero-delay proxy can remove timed evaluations, but generating that proxy candidate by candidate can cost more than the timed work it saves. We present Batch Before You Time (BBYT), which compiles all candidates of one rewrite decision into one scoped zero-delay image and either commits a well-separated proxy winner or invokes the unchanged timed chain. Across 12 counterbalanced holdout sequences, BBYT reduces complete candidate-selection time by 18.05% on average; the design-level reductions are 5.84% and 30.25%, with both confidence intervals above zero. On a counterbalanced 8,192-transition C6288 workload, BBYT is 9.24% faster than the same gate executed with candidate-wise proxy launches. In the five-workload corpus, BBYT removes 32.52% of timed candidate evaluations and matches exhaustive timed selection on all 250 evaluated decisions. For on-demand timing-aware rewrite selection, proxy execution and fidelity continuation should use the same decision scope.

0.49

LATCH: LLM-Assisted Timing Closure Harness for Post-Route FPGA Optimisation

cs.AI ·2026-10-12 ·Shu Gu, Matthew Youngman, Yuqin Zhao, Cristian Sestito, Ali Siddique +3 more
code/data similarity 0.63
Abstract · 14 pages, 11 figures, 4 tables. Code: https://github.com/aprilaihub/LATCH

Post-route FPGA timing closure remains expert-dependent and computationally expensive. We present LATCH (LLM-Assisted Timing Closure Harness), a two-layer framework that separates large language model (LLM) orchestration from deterministic FPGA implementation and evaluation. Across sixteen designs and seven LLMs, a single-iteration study compares three agent control granularities - expert-written recipes, direct EDA operations and LLM-constructed procedures - to ask how much control an agent needs per attempt. Functional-pass rates are 98.2%, 71.4% and 17.9%, respectively; yet direct operations give slightly larger 3.4% median Fmax gains when passing, versus 3.2% for recipes. This exposes a trade-off between execution reliability and timing improvement. Informed by this trade-off, a multi-iteration study fixes the action tier at expert recipes to ask how repeated attempts are best organised, comparing a fitted deterministic heuristic with sequential LLM reasoning, branching exploration and knowledge base-guided exploration within 12 checkpoints per run. Branching raises mean maximum-frequency improvement from 10.5% (sequential) to 16.0%, and the knowledge base to 20.3%, improving 15 of 16 designs. Characterisation across 2,421 recipe attempts profiled their gain and validation rates, showing hard-block re-placement gives the largest cumulative mean gain at 41.4MHz.

0.29

Can Agents Design Better Chips with a Higher Level Abstraction?

cs.AI cs.AR ·2026-09-17 ·Zijian Ding, Yang Zou, Yizhou Sun, Jason Cong
publishedbenchmarkcode/data similarity 0.63
Abstract · 7 pages, ICCAD'26 special session

Large Language Model (LLM) agents are increasingly being explored for chip design, but most existing approaches operate directly at RTL. We ask whether agents can design better chips by leveraging higher-level abstractions. We compare Direct RTL Design, Agent-based HLS Design, Post-Compiler HLS Refinement, and Post-HLS RTL Refinement, and combine Agent-based HLS Design with Post-HLS RTL Refinement as Agent-based HLS with RTL Refinement (AHRR). We use FPGAs as a practical, easy-to-deploy platform for end-to-end evaluation, but note that the design-flow tradeoffs we study are largely independent of the target technology. Across a diverse 11-tasks benchmark suite, AHRR achieves a 2.6$\times$ geometric-mean speedup over Direct RTL Design across our benchmark suite. Case studies show that HLS distills design knowledge into abstractions that agents can leverage, while RTL refinement recovers lower-level optimization opportunities. Together, these results make AHRR a promising workflow for agentic chip design. The code and evaluation artifacts are available at https://github.com/ZijD/AHRR.

0.57

ServerBench: How can your coding agents design specialized LLM serving systems?

cs.AI ·2026-11-04 ·Xinrui Zhong, Zhiming Wang, Yongqi Liu, Zhaohui Wang, Shanglin Yang +3 more
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract

Large language model (LLM) coding agents develop software through experimentation, offering an opportunity to design the serving systems supporting their own operation. Effective serving requires coordinating implementation and operating decisions under session dependencies, latency constraints, and correctness requirements. We introduce ServerBench, a benchmark for agentic design of complete, specialized LLM serving systems. Agents experiment against a common objective, dollars per dollar: latency-qualified token value per dollar of GPU cost. Stateful replay preserves session dependencies, and independent verification checks the submitted system. Across 11 coding-agent models and three deployments, Claude Sonnet 5.5 achieves 2.97 dollars per dollar on Gemma E4B, $4.87\times$ the vLLM reference; 22 of 33 runs yield verified systems, and 13 exceed the strongest baseline. Our analysis identifies three findings: high-value designs coordinate capacity improvements with load selection; agents interpret performance feedback through workload-relevant experiments; and reliable delivery requires verification of the execution paths introduced by optimization. Overall, ServerBench supports systematic study of how agents translate service objectives and feedback into effective, verified serving systems for given task specifications.

0.15

FABRICA: Agentic CUDA-to-CSL Translation and Optimization for Wafer-Scale Systems

cs.CE ·2026-08-25 ·Yuebo Luo, Eliu Huerta, Venkatram Vishwanath, Caiwen Ding, Rajeev Thakur +1 more
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Porting GPU kernels across architectures requires architectural remapping, not syntax substitution. CUDA encodes decomposition, locality, and synchronization through threads, blocks, and memory accesses; the Cerebras Software Language (CSL) requires explicit placement, distributed SRAM, fabric communication, event-driven tasks, and host/device contracts. We present FABRICA-Bench, 49 paired CUDA-to-CSL tasks, and FABRICA, an agentic framework combining target knowledge, execution, failure-directed repair, and correctness-gated optimization. On a fixed 28-task Level~1--3 core comparison with Claude Opus 4.8, FABRICA raises success from 6/28 to 26/28; 22 successful programs match or beat their CSL references. Across the 49-task coverage evaluation, 38 tasks produce a correct program; the final three tasks are evaluated over three seeds and pass 8/9 runs. For 27 generated/reference pairs with device-internal timing, geometric-mean speedup is 3.75$\times$ on the SDK simulator and 3.47$\times$ on WSE-3 hardware. With the executable workflow fixed, Claude Opus~4.8 passes 26/28 core tasks while the best open-weight model passes 2/28; retrieved Cerebras knowledge separately raises success from 1/15 to 7/15 on a Level~1--3 panel. These results identify base-model capability, target knowledge, execution feedback, and same-target measurement as central to cross-architecture kernel generation.

0.08

Toward Autonomous RTL and Synthesis Optimization: Benchmarking and Self-Improving Agents

cs.AI cs.AR ·2026-11-10 ·Wenji Fang, Yao Lu, Jinghua Wang, Zhiyao Xie
published similarity 0.62
Abstract · ASP-DAC'27 Invited Paper

Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) and autonomous agents are creating new opportunities for hardware design optimization. This paper examines three connected directions toward autonomous RTL and synthesis optimization: (1) Realistic benchmarking. We discuss reference-based and open-ended RTL optimization benchmarks that evaluate optimization opportunities under realistic EDA workflows. (2) Tool-grounded RTL optimization. We present Dr. RTL, a multi-agent framework that automates critical-path analysis, RTL rewriting, and implementation-level evaluation, while continuously improving through reusable optimization skills. Evaluated on 20 real-world RTL designs, Dr.~RTL achieves average WNS/TNS improvements of 21\%/17\% with a 6\% area reduction over commercial synthesis. (3) Design-specific synthesis optimization. We explore agent-driven synthesis script tuning and the discovery of executable synthesis algorithms across intermediate representations, technology-independent optimization, and technology mapping. Finally, we envision AI-native design automation that jointly explores architectural, RTL, and EDA algorithm design spaces, guided by verification constraints and implementation feedback.

0.40

Context-Aware Precision Scheduling for Small Language Models

cs.LG ·2026-10-11 ·Mukund Athmaram, Manoj Rao, Liang Ma
benchmarkposition similarity 0.62
Abstract

Small language models (SLMs) used as on-device agents must balance accuracy and latency as their context grows. Mixed precision helps manage this tradeoff by assigning different precisions to weight tensors according to their size and sensitivity. However, these choices depend on the operating conditions, so a configuration selected for a short context may no longer provide the best tradeoff at a longer one. We calibrate a timing model from measurements at different precisions and context lengths, and combine it with tensor sensitivities to choose configurations under a latency or accuracy budget. We argue that fewer bits do not always mean faster execution, so our predictor estimates latency from calibrated execution costs rather than weight bytes alone. Under a latency budget, reading the larger key-value (KV) cache leaves less time for weight operations, leading the allocator to select lower precisions. This gives a schedule of tensor changes that can be prepared before execution. Our runtime follows the schedule while retaining the session's KV cache. We evaluate executed schedules on a laptop GPU, including a longer-context schedule with three weight formats and a tool-use benchmark measuring full response time and correctness. Under an accuracy budget, measured error from a quantized KV cache determines the budget left for weights. The allocator can raise or lower weight precision as this estimate changes. These experiments show where context-aware precision helps and where accuracy recovery remains limited.

0.18

Evaluating Inference Compute for Generative AI: A Framework for Enterprise Workloads

cs.AR cs.DCcs.LGcs.PF ·2026-10-05 ·Abbas Raza Ali, Muhammad Ajmal Siddiqui, Moona Zahid
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract

LLM deployment is shifting from single-turn completion to agentic trajectories in which a model plans, calls tools, reads results and reasons at test time before acting. This inverts the economics of inference hardware: chat serving amortises weight reads across large batches, whereas agent trajectories are sequentially dependent, run at effective batch one, and make per-token decode latency (TPOT) the dominant term in task completion time. Using a roofline analysis and a closed-form episode-latency model, we show why this regime favours accelerators that keep weights in on-die SRAM (Cerebras WSE-3/3T, Groq/NVIDIA LPU) or compiler-managed tiered memory (SambaNova SN40L/SN50), and why three vendor ecosystems converged in 2026 on disaggregated prefill/decode serving. We show that per-step reliability compounds exponentially in trajectory length-a 2% per-step failure rate erases a 2x decode advantage for a 20-step agent-so determinism and tail latency are first-order performance variables. We then propose a four-layer evaluation framework (silicon, serving system, agent episode, enterprise) with a metric set built on goodput at an agentic SLO and cost per successful episode, a six-axis benchmark protocol over six task families, a paired-bootstrap statistical design, an attestation protocol for vendor-run benchmarks, and TCO, availability and adoption-timing models with explicit break-even conditions. All performance figures are public and labelled by evidence class; we state seven falsifiable hypotheses and the experiments that test them, and argue that the most likely original result is that token-throughput rankings diverge from cost-per-successful-task rankings on long-horizon work.

0.18